8 ms·
Is Economic Deprivation the Real Cause of the Adolescent Mental Health Crisis?
- buescher 3y agoib4 Betteridge tldr: rich kids are nuttier, nobody knows why, I'm sure you have an opinion
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoBeyond the points made in the linked article I'd say this: there are places in the world where the 2008 financial crisis didn't have nearly as strong as an effect. Notably Canada, a culture very similar to the US https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canada-escaped-worst-of-recession-statscan-1.935579 https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canada-escaped-worst-of-rec... But they still suffer from the same teenage mental health problems at similar rates.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoBut they still suffer the same core problem: housing is out of reach, jobs don't pay enough to live, everything is getting more expensive, wages remain stagnant. Just striking out on your own as a young person is getting more or more unrealistic, and if you're still living with your parents, rightly or wrongly, that amounts to a huge amount of stigma and makes you feel like a failure.
- space_oddity 3y agothe challenges of achieving financial independence are unbearable sometimes
- madsbuch 3y agowhile the Anglo world seem to have some quite severe issues re. housing, that is not the case in the Scandinavian world. housing and jobs are roughly as easy/difficult getting your hands on as for the past generations. We still suffer from the aforementioned issues...
- marginalia_nu 3y agoDunno, at least in Sweden the housing market is a real pain to enter. Rentals are available, at least in smaller citities, but there's a real divider between renting and owning. Unless you've got a family to sponsor you, you're basically SOL until you're in your early 30s and you can finally afford the priviledge to be in over your ears in debt.
- madsbuch 3y agoNot trying to take away from you, that it is difficult. Just saying that it hasn't changed too much over the past 50 years – it was also difficult for the previous generations. At least in Denmark, the situation is better now than it has been earlier, despite the market being heated. You can comfortably buy a house at around 4x annual salary with reasonable savings (~10% down payment).
- marginalia_nu 3y agoSwedish housing prices have increased something like 300% the last 20 years. Salaries have not. In fact, nothing has. This is in part due to interest payments being tax deductible, a measure to help the Swedish housing market bounce back from the housing crash in the mid '90s. The government "forgot" to remove that insane policy even once the market had recovered, since it would be unpopular for everything to be more expensive, even throughout the negative interest rate years they didn't do anything about this. Which means everyone and their grandmother has loans up to their ears, taken back when interests were basically free. ... so now interests have gone up by like 5 percentage points and everyone with a loan is in struggling, that interest subsidy policy is going nowhere in a hurry, meanwhile it still drives up prices and creates an ever-widening gap between those who own and those who can't afford the down payment because the market has seized up entirely since nobody wants to realize the loss of selling their house for less than their mortgage.
- madsbuch 3y agoalso the interest rate has gone down from 20% to close to 0%.the rate is going up again, and we should see the housing market correct itself, but it usually takes a couple of years - in particular, my take is that the interest rate does not go down as long as we expect it to (ie. we don't change the behaviors that are required for the banks to lower the rate). regardless, in Copenhagen you can get a 2 room apartment for 2.5m DKK. if you have a down payment of 200k you can buy this with a salary of roughly 550k a year, which indeed is reasonable as you live in Copenhagen. if you are a couple, then you are at 5m kr where you can start to get houses in the suburb or quite nice apartments. personally I prefer a market with higher interest rates such that the price is not just set as multiples of a median salary.
- acover 3y agoTldr: no. Poor teens actually suffer from depression at a lower rate than richer teens. A reversal from earlier.
- jplusequalt 3y agoHow much of this is due to richer kids having more access to mental health resources? While I wasn't poor growing up, my parents didn't have the means to let me see mental health professionals and as a result I went undiagnosed for 21 years.
- IncreasePosts 3y agoThere's also different reactions to various illnesses across groups. In some subcultures, you might get a special, nicer treatment for having an illness, whereas in others you may viewed as broken and less worthy of respect. The former would probably have some people seeking out a diagnoses for the illness, whereas the latter would have some people intentionally avoiding a diagnosis for the illness.
- airstrike 3y agoWhile we're all playing armchair sociologist-cum-psychologist, I'd say IMHO it boils down to the lack of a compelling future. Which is to say there's a general disillusionment with the state of humanity (as far as values, realizing our full potential, whatever that means, etc.) I'm not saying it's an accurate belief, but that doesn't make it less real to those who subscribe to it. It might explain why rich kids are even more depressed than poor ones. If you're already rich and you hate life, it's harder to dream about a better life. You're "supposed" to be happy already. I "blame" the sudden rise of social media and western society reorienting itself to highly addictive dopamine-hit loops. Before that, the end of the Fairness Doctrine and the subsequent weaponization of mass media. All without an accompanying evolution of cultural, social, moral norms (!= rules) to aid navigation in this brave new world.
- chrisweekly 3y ago(+1, insightful) 100% agreed. Along these same lines, the endlessly demoralizing narrative around climate change is likely another big factor. I think many more people need to read and internalize things like Hannah Ritchie's book "Not the End of the World: How We Can Be the First Generation to Build a Sustainable Planet". Highly recommended.
- jplusequalt 3y ago"How we *CAN* be" is doing a lot of lifting there. Boomers, GenX, and older Millennials all had ample opportunities to do something before we arrived here.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoAbsolutely it is. Why work hard when getting good grades in school and college isn't enough to guarentee the ability to own a home or start a family? China has the same thing with "lay down" culture. We just call them NEETs in the west. Ironically, tradesmen these days are the ones who are KILLING it next to highly paid SWEs. If you don't thrash your body, those jobs will pay you well for life.
- cjbgkagh 3y ago* not the one downvoting you... but I'm not sure if I'm buying the tradespeople killing it meme. It may help if you defined KILLING as some $/hr value. I'm seeing numbers like $45/hr which I would consider the bottom rung for SWE in the US.
- freitzkriesler2 3y ago$45/hr starting is great. Most pro tradesmen that are good I know bill 75-150$/hr. The SWEs that I know who are KILLING it are in the 100-250 hr range but I can guarantee you that a tradesmen in the bay that is good and skilled is pulling that as well. Electricians and plumbers especially make a lot of money if they're licensed and have the experience. Most guys go solo business and have enough booked worked for a life time. This was the consequence of people doscouraging trade work on the 90s and 2000s. These guys are doing very well now.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoI'm not seeing those same numbers, anecdotally it seems people are very excited a $80 hourly rate in SF in a skilled trade that requires a 5 year apprenticeship - which suggest to me that most are not getting that. Though perhaps those doing well don't have time to post on the internet. "I can guarantee you that a tradesmen in the bay that is good and skilled is pulling that as well." - or to rephrase; a similarly skilled tradesperson isn't making more in trades than they would have made as a SWE. In general there is a competency crisis so I'm sure competent tradespeople can and do charge a premium and as things get worse I'm sure the premium they can charge can increase. That said, the US was angling to be a 'knowledge-worker' economy but for some reason, like many western countries, there now seems to be a huge appetite for importing unskilled labor to create a more mixed economy. I believe there will be an effort to push the newly arrived unskilled labor into the skilled tradespeople labor force which would put downward pressure on blue collar salaries. So the current windfall that they are enjoying might yet abate. I think the denigration of blue collar was done so people wouldn't feel as bad about shipping factories overseas to increase corporate profits. The process of financialization and deindustrialization was driven by politicians and bankers and I think culturally the rest of us are were reacting to these realities as opposed to driving them. I think financializing and deindustrializing the economy was a mistake, as is importing large amounts of unskilled labor. I truly would have loved to have seen a larger blue collar middle class.
- Anotheroneagain 3y ago[flagged]
- delusional 3y agoI think there's a non-zero chance that the teen "mental health crisis" is just their generations "hippie culture". Not to say there's any internal similarities between the two, but I don't think we are going to "solve" the crisis as much as wait for the next generation to have some other problem.
- whatever1 3y agoThe social mobility has been decimated in the west and most definitely our kids will have it worse compared to us. It's not easy to be living in a declining environment. Compare it to working for a dying company that does layoffs after layoffs and is eating itself in a downwards spiral. Of course nobody is happy.
- paulpauper 3y agoI think it can also be explained in part by better record keeping and availability of data. It's not unreasonable to assume society has gotten better at assessing and tracking teen mental health today compared to 60+ years ago, when such data did not exist or before concerns about teen mental health were raised. Having more data means it's possible to draw more conclusions. IF you poll people about concerns of alien invasions, suddenly you will get people showing concern about aliens.
- dv_dt 3y agoGiven how poorly privatized healthcare plans cover mental health, getting diagnosed let alone regularly treated for mental health is a luxury for many.
- knallfrosch 3y agoIt's not like that was better 50 years ago. But to think that there's "something wrong" with a specific teen is already down the wrong path. It's like 5 goung to therapy while working for Amazon.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated: The Smartphone Kids Are Not All Right https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39812623 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39812623
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dartos 3y agoIs there ever not an adolescent mental health crisis? I’m a millennial and I remember a lot of talk around depression and anxiety crises when I was in school.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoThe idea that it isn’t two mostly-unrelated issues of screen/information addiction and meaning is baffling to me. I know I’m providing no evidence, but this feels so obvious to me. I’m 27 fwiw. Does anyone else agree with my flippant perspective?
- underlipton 3y agoA related anecdote: For teens a half-generation before mine, for music, it was common to buy CDs (and to have the money to do so). For my generation, it was common to pirate everything (so it was okay that we were all broke). In both cases, there was a sense of "ownership" over one's music collection. If someone wanted to take it away from us, they'd have to break into our house or burn it down or wipe our hard drive or something. What do today's teens have? YouTube and Spotify and SoundCloud. Slightly more expensive than "free", even though affordability has gone down. But what's worse is how easily TPTB can reach into your playlist, your account, the platform as a whole, and erase your music. Just, poof, gone, with no warning. The older ways of building a music collection still exist, of course, but they're not as accessible. Best Buy doesn't even sell physical media anymore; every teen's favorite boom box (their used car) is now prohibitively expensive. Torrenting still exists, but it's outside the mainstream of music consumption; can you even do it on an iPhone? Downloading in general is discouraged by the big platforms, except as a way to keep you engaging with the app if the WiFi goes down. Teens, of course, have existed for millennia without easy access to the latest pop hits. I dunno if cultural expectations have caught up to this regression to the mean, though. Are you uncool if you don't have SOME kind of musical identity? Advertisers sure want you to think so. Your parents probably treat your adolescence as an echo of their own, too, even with the massive changes in just this small corner of teen life. Carbon copy to every other facet as is appropriate. So (in a bit of semantic irony), I buy it. (Also ironically, given the above,) it's a bit of a mirror of Millennial angst wrt home-buying, marriage, etc. It's actually obvious to me, and obvious why Boomers can't see it (or are slow to come to it): they hold all the capital that would otherwise be solving our issue.
- BriggyDwiggs42 3y agoThis is a real phenomenon no doubt, but I don’t think it’s a big factor in current teen unhappiness. In music, most people just have a spotify playlist representing their identity and taste that has never had a song nuked from it before. I’d definitely argue it’s more about insecurity in one’s future and a lack of any purpose to one’s potential employment.
- rufus_foreman 3y ago>> Best Buy doesn't even sell physical media anymore https://www.bestbuy.com/site/vinyl-shop/vinyl-records/cat02001.c?id=cat02001 https://www.bestbuy.com/site/vinyl-shop/vinyl-records/cat020...
- engineer_22 3y agoAdolescence is a period of temporary insanity. Source: firsthand knowledge
- BriggyDwiggs42 3y agoFrom my experience, so is existence.
- space_oddity 3y agoYeah, just with different variables (depending on age)
- foxyv 3y agoWhen I was a kid, there was a shining rainbow at the end of the long slog through High School and College. I just had to not mess things up so bad I became unemployable. My parents were a shining example of this. Then 2008 hit and suddenly, you didn't just have to not mess things up, but you had to have exactly the right skills and mindset to succeed with a whole hell of a lot of luck. Most of my friends ended up with college degrees working as bartenders and waitresses. The amount of opportunities available to the next generation have dwindled compared to what I saw as a kid. Now, you can't expect to survive doing what you love. You can barely survive doing what you hate...
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoI make good money and still regret my youth so much. I didn't socialize or party in college. I'm a poorly-adapted adult who envies young people who are more risk-taking than I've ever been, and envies people my age who had their fun and now are happy to accept the stability I feel stuck in.
- space_oddity 3y ago"...the stability I feel stuck in". Same here.. It's hard to find joy in the life I'm living now.
- throw18376 3y agothe same social limitations that prevented you from partying as a younger person, probably also prevent you from enjoying your nice stable life to the fullest. a lot of old boring people have lives full of fun and rewarding friendships. i'm not trying to rub salt in the wound, i'm just saying if you can improve your social abilities, there's not really a deadline for a rich and fulfilling life. especially since you are financially stable.
- IncreasePosts 3y agoI have an easy fix for you. Quit your job, and take 5 months to ride your bike from Lisbon to Istanbul.
- space_oddity 3y agoThe economic aspect of life has always been, for most people, decisive for understanding the state of mental health
- scns 3y agoOnce read a comment here on HN. It said his/her parents were immigrants in Canada. The mother barely spoke english and worked at a slaughterhouse. They had a house and two cars. Which seems far out of reach for young people nowadays.
- jimbokun 3y agoIt's time to remove Nature from the list of reputable science publications. This blog post demolishes Odgers critique with a simple chart that could have been researched by Odgers with a few minutes work. Instead, she just threw out a politically popular attack without taking any effort to see if it fit the available data. This follows recent trends, of Nature making decisions to publish content in line with their preferred political ideologies, without regard to any scientific evidence.
- throw7 3y agoIt's parenting. Of course then, what is "good" parenting and what is "bad"? Honestly, I don't know how much screen time is "good" vs "bad" or if there is a correct amount. There's only knowing where you came from (knowing who your Mom & Dad are) and that they love you so much. That's simplified and idealized. But those elements can also be proxied if they're not there originally... approximately.
- alienicecream 3y agoNo, there is no crisis, kids are posing like they always have and having anxiety is cool now because the jocks aren't allowed to clown on the nerds anymore and it makes you different, even though everyone is doing it. TV writers knew better than the eggheads a decade ago, watching 22 jump Street would tell you more than this article.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoI'm not an adolescent anymore, but I'm a Gen-Z'er who definitely thinks about these things a lot more than is healthy. Firstly, the age of technology was seen as a godsend for a lot of us to connect more quickly and easily. In the beginning, it seemed great! I remember a lot of mid to late 2000s social media was user-focused. But we know that nowadays the value given to us was clawed back and monetized in an effort to generate returns due to the massive reliance on VC funds. And nothing generates engagement, clicks, and usage more than internet fights. I hate to say it but even just last week I found myself in a Twitter argument that had me checking and scrolling Twitter every 5 minutes. That's not healthy to anyone, but Twitter got more ad views out of me that day than any other day before or since. And because of that, my algorithm is absolutely f*ked and only shows me content that makes me angry so they can drive another internet argument out of me. I know Twitter isn't intentionally doing this, but the algorithm is built to prioritize engagement, and arguing was the most engaging thing I did. Included with this is the proliferation of 24/7 news. My parents only saw the news on newspapers or on TV, which would typically only air it for a few hours a night. If you wanted to avoid the news, it was 100% possible and fairly easy. Nowadays, if you use the internet, you're going to encounter news. And, of course, news sites have to generate income through ads or subscriptions, so create clickbait articles, showing rage bait articles to drive traffic and arguments to further increase ad revenue. I can't even scroll through my friend's Saturday night Instagram stories without seeing someone post bloody bodies from the Gaza/Israel conflict. Lastly, there's a lot of resentment in the younger generation. I'm not even 30 and I've experienced two recessions, a pandemic, wages have stayed stagnant since I started working while rent has tripled in that same timeframe, the city I grew up in is sinking due to climate change. My friends right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are discussed on TV like they don't matter. I guess the concise way to boil it down is: No matter where we look or what we do, we are inundated with anger, rage bait, consume consume consume, if you want to rent a place then work multiple jobs, everything you remember growing up will be gone by the time you're old enough to truly appreciate it, etc. We've internalized that there is no future for us, and it's everyone's fault.
- Devasta 3y agoIn Tech the decade before last vast amounts of effort by some of the smartest people in the world was put into making people click ads; the last decade, blockchain nonsense. The next decade will be on using AI to destroy any last remnants of human connection, all the while we live in the holocene extinction event and the major governments of the world spend their time berating Palestinian children for not using their final breathes to condemn Hamas. Are there reasons to be optimistic? Sure, but to suggest things are going well is to be beholden to some of the weirdest neoliberal freaks you'll ever see on the internet.
- spencerflem 3y ago<3
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"In contrast, the rise of smartphones and social media not only fit the data, but the solutions (no phones at school, keeping kids and younger teens off social media) are low-cost and have few downsides outside of diminished profit for the social media companies." This really makes Odger's position difficult to understand... unless she is getting some sort of kickback/benefit, real or imagined, from not interfering with the profits of the so-called "tech" industry. Whether or not phones and conniving websites run by so-called "tech" companies are the "cause" of problems should not impede anyone from taking steps to lessen the suffering from them. Maybe they only aggravate a condition caused by something else. That they are not the underlying cause should not stop people from seeking immediate relief.
- miki123211 3y agoI feel like every scientist and non-scientist investigating this issue is trying to push their pet theory, which is consistent with their worldview. Are they democrats? It's racism and school shootings. Are they anti big-tech or part of the mainstream media (which is basically the same thing)? It's smartphones. Are they anti-capitalists? It's economic depression. Are they libertarians? It's helicopter parenting and lockdowns. I'm also really surprised that none of these scientists seem to be looking outside the US. We have no school shootings where I live, a very different economic environment, a completely different approach to racism, much less helicopter parenting, far less doomsaying and polarization, and yet we have the same problems. To me, this rules out everything except smartphones and possibly lockdowns, and that's with my pro-covid, pro-big-tech bias.
- vieinfernale 3y agoThere was a dream where a person coming from a good family and heritage, as long as they put in a decent effort in any sufficiently developed country of this world, could afford to buy a house in a major city, could raise a family in a safe environment, could ensure that they and their children received excellent education and could take advantage of a world-class universal healthcare system. The cost of living is extraordinarily high. The housing market exploded. What is there going on for the lives of teenagers exactly? I can gauge that the smarter ones will be locked inside a claustrophobic concrete prison figuring out how to pirate literature, movies, software, music, etc ... produced in a time where humanity was flourishing culturally. For example, classical literature from the 20th century and earlier periods is far more seducing for a teenager trying to create a soul for himself, because they explored societal and existential problems in a much deeper and romanticized way. This high culture still exists, but you have to scavenge through the wasteland that the internet has become. I say this from brazil: this place is completely dead, culturally dead. The educational system here is broken and suffers from the ideological indoctrination. One selects a path at a very early stage in life. If that goes wrong, it is extremely difficult to switch to another job or career path. Almost every industry requires three to five year education degrees. Any alternative career path means having to go back to school and redoing everything. A degree in Mathematics, Physics, or Chemistry is completely devalued, leaving only Medicine, Finance, and Technology as sane career options, so choose your poison. Medicine is bizarrely competitive. Medicine is viewed as a way to make money and the life of the students literally depends on their exam proficiency. Medical school is not a real academic course, it is an over glorified professional polytechnic factory for the mass-production of medical slaves. Not to mention that we have belgium levels of corruption and the society is not homogenous, but some kind of abomination miscegenated. Shared norms and social trust are almost non-existent, replaced with hostility and individualism. Governance is basically impossible. A country where a bunch of people with radically different beliefs, ideologies, religions, and ways of life were shoved into a room and told by the government: Be Nice. Or Else. Does this sound like a happy country who will breed healthy and strong young girls and lads for the future of the nation? The 'High Cultute' here meant you were middle-class reading European literature and watching Hollywood movies fantasizing that the world was going to be one hell of a ride based on the American Dream lifestyle with a mixture of LSD-driven Science-Fiction, Drugs, Sex, and Rock n Roll. Summation: Existentialism; Culture; Educational System; Technological Addiction.
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]
- incomingpain 3y agoEconomics and psychology is remarkable the interactions which exist. Economics can fully explain mass suicide events, mass depression in connection with economic depression. The idea is that economics is technically passive and just measuring what's happening, but can point to a causal event. But it's a very long stretch to suggest the mental health crisis is caused by economics. In my mind the current mental health crisis comes from 4 key sources. 1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2854760/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2854760/ There are about 30 major sources contaminating our drinking water. We are effectively giving low level HRT to everyone in society. With the obvious consequences. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/12/101208125813.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/12/101208125813.h... The sources are unimportant. Just that we must discontinue the idea that our drinking water is clean. 2. Government restrictions on in person social interactions preventing people from having friends. In my jurisdiction, government has effectively eliminated in person social interaction; but it will vary i'm sure. 3. Significant social changes which have obvious consequences. This started probably around 2010, but then gamergate and metoo are kind of your major sparks which started the social wildfire. Record low fertility rates and still dropping. 4. Covid lockdowns. Everyone pointed out how this was a bad idea which would cause a mental health crisis, especially for children. I'll take my downvotes now.