3 ms·
> "Now-disgraced sci-fi patriarch John W. Campbell..." What did he do?
by Animats 3y ago
> "Now-disgraced sci-fi patriarch John W. Campbell..."
What did he do?
- cwillu 3y ago“An increasingly strong interest in pseudoscience later alienated Campbell from Asimov.[4] In the 1960s, Campbell's controversial essays supporting segregation, and other remarks and writings surrounding slavery and race, served to distance him from many in the science fiction community.”
- User23 3y ago[flagged]
- KittenInABox 3y agoI don't believe Samuel Delany is an open NAMBLA member. He has expressed support for NAMBLA in 2004, and in 2014 admitted to reading a newsletter from them but claims not to have kept up with them for 20 years. These statements are now a decade and two decades old & I don't know what to make of him now these days. If you have more recent info, please let me know. [Also: alleged pedophile? who alleged him of pedophilia? seriously asking]
- cratermoon 3y ago"In 1949, Campbell worked closely with L. Ron Hubbard on the techniques that Hubbard later turned into Dianetics. When Hubbard's therapy failed to find support from the medical community, Campbell published the earliest forms of Dianetics in Astounding." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_W._Campbell#Views https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_W._Campbell#Views
- KittenInABox 3y agoJohn W. Campbell did one of those contrarian intellectual who knee jerked too hard. He advocated that slavery had good sides and that it should've been kept as an institution because the civil war was worse than slavery. Also that slavery was a more natural way of society. Also that the relation of smoking to lung cancer was esoteric (he loved a good cig). Oh and that racial segregation should be maintained because of the inferiority of negroes. You know this kind of personality.
- fractallyte 3y agoHe relished challenging readers' thinking and preconceptions. You can make up your own mind - there's a collection of his Astounding/Analog editorials in this book: https://archive.org/details/collectededitori0000john https://archive.org/details/collectededitori0000john And then there's this, Jeannette Ng's acceptance speech for the John W Campbell Best New Writer Award: https://youtu.be/sQ58zf0vzB0?feature=shared https://youtu.be/sQ58zf0vzB0?feature=shared (She began by calling him "Joseph Campbell", with the audience cheering the rest of her increasingly incoherent speech... Derision from people who really don't understand science fiction.)
- ubermonkey 3y ago>He relished challenging readers' thinking and preconceptions. Yes, on things like (checks notes) segregation. Huh.
- fractallyte 3y agoHe wasn't afraid to dive into the details of topics that many people shun or simply dismiss. He made arguments, and encouraged counter-arguments. Without that, there would be blind consensus, and at worst, societal stagnation. It's his relentless urge to shake things up that made him one of the most prominent figures in science fiction. It's very telling that there wasn't some kind of disagreement with Jeannette Ng's shockingly ignorant outburst, or the delighted applause of her equally ignorant audience.