4 ms·
Killing the Messenger: My Final Days Working at a Disaster
- metadat 3y agohttps://archive.today/UcKM7 https://archive.today/UcKM7
- instagib 3y agoThe title is interesting and it’s a few minute read. “The messenger” was a news site and the disaster is about seeing the writing on the wall but the job “has dental.“
- TheRealDunkirk 3y agoAnd after 30 years of blogging, it made me finally realize the stark difference of writing for yourself vs writing for an audience. This is a great example of the former.
- paulsutter 3y agoThe major risks when taking a job: - Joining a company that won’t triple revenue this year - Joining a company that isn’t reinventing an industry - Working on pointless CRUD apps that won’t impact the economy If you end up in a role mike these, the best case scenario is that the company shuts down and you’re freed up to work on something that matters
- suriyaG 3y agoI understand you're trying to simplify every other job out there in a crass way. But, - How many companies out there are tripling revenue? If a majority of the companies are tripling their revenue YoY is it healthy or cancerous to the economy? - How many times does an industry "reinvent" itself. - What use are all other software, without CRUD apps pulling money from the "other" economy into software? famously, computing got its foothold, __because__ lotus 123 was utilitarian. What I mean by that is, ultimate utility for all software products come from software interacting with the real world somewhere down the line. it might not be hip or world breaking. But, it is the most important part.
- sverhagen 3y agoMaybe if we got some real serious inflation, could we triple our revenue? /s
- paulsutter 3y agoLotus123 did affect the economy and was a breakthrough. But that was 1983, closer to WWII than to today. No AI, no internet, no cellphones . We have vastly more powerful systems and dev tools now.
- wizzwizz4 3y agoVastly more powerful systems that are slower. Pretty much the only office tasks that are faster are crunching spreadsheets and sending data to a neighbouring office: everything from booting the machine to keying in data to making phone calls takes longer.
- ketzo 3y agoThe thing that’s maybe most grim about this article is how much of a non-story this is. “New-media outlet can’t raise more VC funding, goes bust with no warning, leaves nothing but ashes” — yeah, it’s a Wednesday alright. It’s obviously cliche at this point, but I do really worry about the future of publicly available, long-form writing. Investigative journalism in particular.
- AirMax98 3y agoObviously, I’m sympathetic to the writer and I am aware of the plight of the modern newsroom. What’s surprising here is that this all sounds like something I — as a software developer — have been through with like 70% of the places I’ve ever done contract work at. The stress of external VC cash, the loose interconnectedness of employees, and the vague indifference towards pulling the plug. These are, to me, cultural artifacts specific to software startups. Why does a media company need to run this way? Software is eating the world, but maybe not in ways that are immediately apparent.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anonylizard 3y agoBecause no one other than tech VCs will touch media with a 10 foot pole. And tech VCs aren't going to change their entire investing mindset/philosophy for a deeply unprofitable niche with no chance to hit it big. There's been multiple waves of VCs to invest in traditional media. Out of both economic opportunism, as well as a desire to at least save a bit of the industry that died because of digital advertising. Every single one failed, not one large success. Hiring rooms of journalists to publish articles is very high cost and risk without any economies of scale that software people have.
- nradov 3y agoI'm surprised that any VC firms were even willing to invest in a fairly generic mass-media startup at all. Going forward such organizations will probably have to bootstrap, or operate as non-profits with donations to support public interest reporting, or find a wealthy patron who wants to own a media company as a vanity project. There's just no way that media companies like The Messenger can scale up to generate the type of outsize returns that VC firms have to target.
- poopsmithe 3y agoThe title is very misleading. TL;DR: A film critic reflects on their time at The Messenger, a startup that collapsed unexpectedly, leaving employees in uncertainty about their futures.
- apollo_mojave 3y agoThat last line really resonated with me: "It's the only thing I really know how to do," or something about like that. One of the most terrifying realizations I've had over the past few years is that I've worked myself into a pretty narrow niche, one that I can't probably market outside of a few specialized companies if the need arose. Thankfully I have a law degree, though I let my bar license lapse. But this is one thing I guess I'd say in favor of the modern job-switching economy: your resume doesn't get stale, it shows new things over and over again. There's only so much people like me, who've stayed / plan to stay with one employer over the long-term, can do about things like layoffs. What happens if I lose my job? It is very hard to say. I guess I'd either try and pass my resume around, but at this point it's almost as if changing careers entirely (for a second time! Yikes!) would be just as easy...
- anonylizard 3y agoGeneric white collar jobs are far more vulnerable to AI than niche jobs. Niche jobs are hard to automate: 1. Very little public data to train on. So AI is bad at it. 2. Low savings from automation. So no incentive to spend tons of money to make the AI good, such as medicine. There's always a balance between specialization and genericness. But with AI, I think the balance is heavily tiled to the former. However, one must pay attention to the little ecosystem they specialise in. If it is trending down, there must be decisive moves to shift away early. Most people however choose to be blissfully unaware of the wider scale trends until it hits them like a truck. In the article's case, the author's outcome is sad but fully expected. 1. He's a journalist 2. Worse, he's an hollywood journalist That's a completely economically worthless niche, and there isn't even any 'public good sympathy'. When you go into a worthless niche, all the employers left are the exploitative vulture ones, and thus you get abused again and again. Because no good employer will touch their toe into that industry. Its possible to make a living as a journalist, you just have to specialise in niches that people are willing to pay for. Financial journalism (There's investigative journalism there because readers care and pay for it), industry vertical journals (Banking, tech etc, the information charges like $600 a year). Or be so good you can get into the NYT, etc. What if you don't want to? You just want to report on games, anime, hollywood etc? Then either start a youtube channel, or a substack. Directly confront the audience and their willingness to watch and pay. Its risky and probably going to fail, but there's a very comfortable upside if you make it. Just don't expect someone will hand you a good job in dying niches.
- nradov 3y agoDo people even read movie reviews anymore? There can't possibly be much work for movie critics.
- bombcar 3y agoMovie critics have always been somewhat of a "find one who makes you laugh, and read him". It, like much of journalism's output, is a form of entertainment itself. We like to pretend we read the news to be informed and educated, but it's really just some entertainment before work.
- imiric 3y agoBeing laid off or the company shutting down is bad enough, but what an awful way to handle things. No communication from management, sudden loss of access privileges, and then a blank page with all your work gone. I hope that the people who ran this company get a hit on their reputation that makes anyone think twice about working with them in the future.
- htrp 3y agoThe Athletic worked, so VCs are going for "Athletic for {niche}"
- anamax 3y agoWhat did we tell coal miners and pipeline workers? Yes, I know that those folks didn't tell their own stories, but ...