5 ms·
Modeling of pulsed plasma rocket shows it should be possible to create one
- allears 3y agoOne pulse per second? Sounds like a bumpy ride.
- krasin 3y agoCombustion engines mitigate that problem by having multiple cylinders. An eight-cylinder car engine runs much smoother than a single-cylinder scooter.
- rpmisms 3y agoAlso flywheels, and I'm not sure what the rocket analogue for that is.
- randallsquared 3y agoGigantic shock absorbers.
- kurthr 3y agoI was going to just say springs, but this is more accurate. Orion (the original nuclear rocket) already had this. I'm not sure if the complexity of the multi-chamber pulsed plasma would make dealing with the vibrations more challenging though.
- adrian_b 3y agoThe rocket analogue of a flywheel is a very heavy rocket, whose large inertia would smooth the changes in its velocity due to propulsion pulses. Nevertheless, this solution is undesirable, because it would limit the acceleration of the rocket to small values. The right solution is that mentioned by the other poster, i.e. to have a large number of pulsed rocket engines, whose pulses should have distinct phases. In this case there should be pairs of engines with synchronized pulses and symmetric positions, to avoid the rotation of the rocket, because the engines can no longer be aligned with its center of inertia.
- db48x 3y agoAn Orion drive actually scales pretty nicely. As I recall, a city 20 miles wide planted on top of a big metal plate was just about the sweet spot. Mostly this works because it is easy to make a bomb with more yield without making the bomb larger.
- api 3y agoMultiple engines, and engines mounted on shock absorbers tuned to dampen out pulses.
- Terr_ 3y agoI have this amusing vision of a rocket ship that resembles a Slinky™ dog, the rear propulsion section connected to the habitable front by an exaggerated spring.
- api 3y agoMore likely you’d have the engines flying out in front on tethers, so like a skier behind a thermonuclear ski boat. Tethers would weigh a lot less than springs. You could also have fully electromagnetic “springs” using powerful superconducting magnets.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DennisP 3y agoNot as bumpy as Project Orion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsion) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propuls...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- api 3y agoThis article doesn’t mention it but this sounds like the fissile material also undergoes fission either as plasma or as part of what makes it plasma, making this like an “inboard” externally driven version of Project Orion (the bomb pogo stick idea, which on paper is workable). This, Orion, and the nuclear salt water rocket seem like three actual “torch ship” engines that could theoretically be built with current technology. Nothing as loony as the Epstein Drive from The Expanse or the antimatter rockets from Avatar but able to get around the solar system way faster than any chemical rocket.
- credit_guy 3y agoInteresting concept, but plenty of red flags. The idea is to have achieve fission criticality in a projectile of uranium fired inside a gun of uranium. The system is designed so that the gun is always subcritical, while the projectile is supercritical, because there's some moderator inside the projectile. The authors claim they simulated the neutron economy of the system using the MCNS6 software, a soft created by the Los Alamos National Lab [1]. The idea is certainly cool, and I wish so much for it to be feasible. But the paper has so many red flags. The main red flag is this: according to the paper, the projectile completely vaporizes when it is 11 centimeters inside the gun. The effective multiplicative factor K_eff (the ratio of the number of neutrons in a new generation vs the old) is calculated to be about 1.1. Anything above 1 is super-critical, meaning the number of fission events increases exponentially with each generation. The paper mentions that they used the software MCNP to estimate this factor, but it does not mention how they treated the change of phase. When the projectile reaches the temperature they describe (11600 K), the mean velocity of the hydrogen ions is about 16 times higher than the mean velocity of the uranium atoms, so basically all the hydrogen is gone. The amount of moderator just went from a certain number to zero. What exactly happened to K_eff? It must go down, but how much? More precisely, the K_eff must be a function of how much the vaporized projectile has expanded, and how little of the original hydrogen is still around. Nothing like this is hinted. My point is that the computation is highly complex, but the way the paper presents it reads like a high school science project. Another big red flag is this: there's no discussion of the neutron economy inside the barrel. We are just told the barrel is subcritical, but even so, it is subject to a huge bombardment of neutrons from the supercritical projectile. Those neutrons will trigger fission events in the barrel. If you shoot 1 projectile per second, this is bound to have quite a bit of an effect, quite soon. Fission is enormously energetic. And yet another red flag: why was this paper published in Acta Astronautica, and not in a nuclear physics of nuclear engineering journal? The application is indeed to rockets, but the meat of the paper is the nuclear fission. One would be much more comfortable to hear the paper was peer-reviewed by nuclear scientists. As a point of reference, the latest issue of this journal [2] has 49 articles, and only one is nuclear related. That one has the title "Direct fusion drive based on centrifugal mirror confinement". In other words, "pie in the astronautical sky". Unfortunately, this pulsed plasma rocket sounds about as feasible as the direct fusion drive rocket. [1] https://mcnp.lanl.gov/ https://mcnp.lanl.gov/ [2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/acta-astronautica/vol/219/suppl/C https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/acta-astronautica/vol/...