4 ms·
When I say fixing I primarily mean government fixing. But thanks for insulting my ability to read because I used the wrong synonym (fixing/control). Therefore
by Dylan16807 3y ago
When I say fixing I primarily mean government fixing. But thanks for insulting my ability to read because I used the wrong synonym (fixing/control).
Therefore I will ignore price gouging laws because that's a form of the above but also if reasonable they won't apply to a person selling their own single allocation.
> In this scenario, eventually no amount of money can buy food. You could be the richest person on earth, willing to spend every last cent you have, but you're still not eating if you happen to come late to the party.
If you come after everyone eats for the day then that's not a shortage by my reckoning. Price works just fine as long as you're not insisting on being served between meals.
It's not like you can expect to buy a house in less than a day no matter your budget.
So I still don't see a big difference here between 90 meals and 90 houses for 100 people. There's always a price that will get you one.
- randomdata 3y ago> So I still don't see a big difference here between 90 meals and 90 houses for 100 people. The difference is that once the meals are consumed, that's it. 91st in line can't buy food no matter what. No amount of money is going to produce the 91st meal. As such, when food stocks are tight, you cannot rely on price to determine the buyer. You have to resort to some other mechanism. Given the limited information you provided, it would appear that you chose a first-come, first-served mechanism. On the other hand, 91st in line for a house, if he has enough money, will buy a house from someone in the first 90 who got there first. There is always a house for sale. They don't disappear (freak disasters excepted). They are not consumable items. Even during the tightest inventory periods we've ever witnessed, there were still many houses available for sale. Price can continue to determine the buyer here. Those who cannot afford them leave the market. Economically, this is not a 90 houses for 100 people situation. If there are 90 houses, then only 90 people will remain in the market. The other 10 are priced out. Those 10 are not market participants, they are simply dreamers. Dreamers don't count. Socially, there can be a 90 houses for 100 people situation. I get you are wishing you could use shortage here, but what are you communicating? Everything with a price attached has more people dreaming of ownership than there are units available. That's why there is a price attached. That's literally what price is for – to reduce the number of potential buyers until the number of buyers matches the number of units available for sale, with price increasing until that is satisfied. Basic supply and demand. When using shortage to include dreamers, everything is in shortage, always. What is the point in drawing particular attention to something that is always the case? It's pointless. You are not saying anything. Nothing has been communicated.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> consumed 90 meals per day. > if he has enough money, will buy a house from someone in the first 90 who got there first Which takes longer than waiting for the next day. You're making a distinction that doesn't really exist. > The other 10 are priced out. Those 10 are not market participants, they are simply dreamers. I can only laugh at this. If people give up, then it's not a shortage? You claim my definition makes everything a shortage, because you ignore the other rules I would apply because you think they're too subjective. But your definition makes nothing a shortage.
- randomdata 3y ago> If people give up, then it's not a shortage? No...? That doesn't make any sense. People also have to give up when there is a shortage. Some people giving up is a constant here. I am sorry to report that the world does not have infinite resources. Economics is a thing only because we have to manage allocation of the limited resources. If you want to take that angle, the mechanism by which they give up is what is significant. If they give up to a price-based mechanism, then you have what is considered a normally functioning market. But if price is unable to rise and thereby they have to give up to some other mechanism, then you have what is considered a shortage. > You claim my definition makes everything a shortage Frankly, I have no idea what your definition is. I stated that if you want to consider dreamers participants in the market then everything that comes with a cost is in shortage. Obviously. That's why there is a price. If we had the resources to allow everyone to have everything they could ever dream up, everything would be free. Any time you see a price of more than free – even just 1¢ - you know there are people wanting more of something than there are of those somethings available. If it is that this does align with your definition – which I'm guessing is why you called it your definition – what are you communicating by exclaiming 'shortage', exactly? It doesn't say anything.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> If they give up to a price-based mechanism, then you have what is considered a normally functioning market. But if price is unable to rise and thereby they have to give up to some other mechanism, then you have what is considered a shortage. In that case I can take just about any situation that has a "shortage", then reintroduce prices. Did I just solve the shortage? Assume I haven't changed production or consumption at all. For example, if there's a lottery then simply allow resale after the lottery runs. > Frankly, I have no idea what your definition is. I stated that if you want to consider dreamers participants in the market then everything that comes with a cost is in shortage. We can establish a ballpark for what a sensible price is for most things. Don't worry about the exact number right now. If every house costs $1-10, there is not a shortage. If every house costs $1B-10B, there is a shortage. I think over 90% of people you ask would agree with those two statements.