6 ms·
The jobs being replaced by AI – an analysis of 5M freelancing jobs
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- __loam 3y agoReally interesting trends. I was surprised to see that graphic design jobs not only got more in demand but also paid more. Also interesting to see that people seem to be more interested in integration than developing new ml tech. Kind of makes me think the right time to get into ml was 5 years ago.
- rmbyrro 3y ago> people seem to be more interested in integration than developing new ml tech Isn't this true for every tech, though? And a natural fact of life? Think of databases. There's many times more jobs for "integrating" a DB into a project than developing new DB tech. Same for infra, frontend, backend, mobile, embedded, etc...
- __loam 3y agoGood point.
- computerdork 3y agoreally surprised myself. Seems like AI could design some very credible websites and marketing material... but maybe it takes more to integrate all those images together into a cohesive look?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- prepend 3y agoI would think AI helps graphic design jobs as it take a graphic designer to properly use AI and it just speeds them up. In that you still need photoshop skills to pick resolutions, palettes, final touchups, etc etc. So graphic designers will be able to do jobs faster and more frequently. Just like I expect that AI won’t eliminate programmers, just make them more productive. I mean someone still has to tell ChatGPT what to program and test it and it’s not like the project manager will be able to do this. It reminds me of when “easier” programming languages like ColdFusion and ASP made web apps easier, it didn’t eliminate jobs but created more.
- RalfWausE 3y agoIts a sure sign a technology is USED. Think about the relation of Forths to things written in Forth...
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoI'm a bit tired here so maybe it is there and I'm not seeing it but of course it doesn't say anything that the Graphic Design jobs increased by 8% unless we know what the rate was of jobs on offer was between the various periods was, probably to compare with graphic design job growth during previous years. Same applies to other categories of course.
- Rastonbury 3y agoYeah agreed, there was quite a lot of layoffs during the same period too, would have liked to see it normalised or compared against the overall labour market which still wouldn't be perfect because so industry and skill levels might've been hotter and colder but it makes the argument for causality stronger
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoVideo editing, number and price going up? Any ideas why? Since you would think these are also being replaced like writers. My gut idea, is that a ton more people that would only do a podcast, or still slides, are taking the AI video tools and adding video. That a ton of people that would not have even attempted video, are able to get over the hurdle and produce some pretty good video using AI tools. Maybe there is thus an uptick in jobs because the barrier to entry is reduced, so more people want video. And now that more people 'want' video, they start, but need help.
- orbital-decay 3y agoReplaced by what? Current tools are not built up to the purpose, they are mostly toys built by ML folks, not tools to get things done. There's a lot of talk but no walk. The only wildly successful application I know of is segmentation and automatic keying, which is actual magic and saves a lot of tedious work. Once they stop ignoring the domain knowledge, the entry barrier and complexity will only go up, as it happened to 3D CGI back then.
- CTDOCodebases 3y agoPeople are becoming less and less inclined to read I think. I found myself watching a video on YouTube today that was just a guy telling a joke while totally unrelated but pleasant visuals were being displayed. Half way though I thought to myself "Is this a genre?". I think you are right. If you have a piece of content whether that be text or audio it makes sense to turn it into a video. You are gaining a new audience and the video platforms have large audiences that are being force fed content.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoExactly. Coincidentally. just saw that google was releasing new tools to do this exact type of thing. simple video snippets for presentations.
- GiorgioG 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blowski 3y agoHN guidelines: > Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work.
- billllll 3y agoCurious how much of this is due to factors other than AI. The data is correlated, but at least for me, I'm not convinced of causation. Also, I'm kind of surprised at the customer service numbers. Chatbots existed before ChatGPT. Are LLMs more effective than the previous solutions at decreasing escalation to humans? Or could it be other factors like the economy at large causing companies to make do with less customer service?
- Ctyra 3y agoAnecdotally, yes, LLMs are more effective at decreasing escalations to humans.
- billllll 3y agoMore than existing chatbots? Curious what anecdotes you have, whether it be on the customer-side or the service-side.
- chrsw 3y agoI believe my employer is preparing to replace many or most of their human customer service representatives with LLMs or some form of AI. They haven't said this is their plan but based on several things like the new software and tools they've recently switched to, the fact that all customer services reps have been fully remote since the start of COVID and the volume of calls they can't currently handle in various geographies. I'm just speculating but this is my expectation, and the transition may take many years.
- _xivi 3y ago> I'm kind of surprised at the customer service numbers. Chatbots existed before ChatGPT. Interesting, what makes you skeptical about LLMs' efficiency in customer service? It's not like classic chatbots were doing a phenomenal job I don't see why your run of the mill LLM would fail to do a better job.
- PodgieTar 3y agoI opened a support ticket with my Bank, BUNQ, recently. It was 'resolved' by an AI Agent. It simply spat out what I said to it, and said "We can now proceed with this request." It took about 5 more days to receive any answer. I pay 10 euros a month for Bunq. It's piss poor.
- letsgostats 3y agoNow can you make one for jobs being replaced by H1B. Would love to see a detailed analysis about that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Animats 3y agoSummary: Writing, down a lot. Translation and customer service down a little. If it's on a freelancing site, it's very low end customer service. LLMs for customer service still appear to suck.[1] [1] https://futurism.com/the-byte/businesses-discovering-ai-sucks https://futurism.com/the-byte/businesses-discovering-ai-suck...
- nicbou 3y agoLLMs for writing also suck. It might just be that the people using them don't value writing thst much. LLMs for translation, on the other hand, are incredible. They are a game changer in immigration, where immigrants constantly need to read and write credible messages in a language they don't speak. They can't do certified translations for bureaucratic matters, but they are great for everything else, and much faster than hiring a translator.
- nextworddev 3y agoHow much of immigration in Berlin is just a matter of filing forms versus some convoluted system such as North America?
- ugh123 3y agoImmigration in the US has always been about filing firms. Then more forms. Then wait 10-15 years
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nicbou 3y agoForms plus a ton of waiting and unpredictability. The filling isn't such a big deal. The delays are.
- nextworddev 3y ago
- wmal 3y agoThe article is based only on the stats of a single freelancing site. It may be big, but it still represents only a sample of the overall market data. We do not know how big the sample is and whether it represented the same percentage of the overall market size at the beginning and end of the reported period. Only the first conclusion listed mentions Upwork. The rest sounds like it reports a general market trend. The author says the data was provided by a company called Revealera, but doesn’t disclose he is a co-founder. It doesn’t affect the quality of the data by itself but I’m always careful to make conclusions from data presented this way. I visited a couple of new job ads on Upwork and I found that: 1. The „hire rate” of clients is usually between 0 and 70%. 2. Upwork has an AI solution for clients that makes it very easy to post a new job. Meaning it is easier than ever to think about an idea, post a new „job” and forget about it, never hiring anyone.
- bdcravens 3y agoMany of the issues with Upwork came well before AI posting: - thinking they can get Facebook built for $300 and/or sticker shock when they select "US only" freelancers - being overwhelmed with low-quality/spammy responses (agencies copy-and-pasting, etc) - frustration with communication barriers (whether language or time zone) - the need to pre-pay $X to hire someone
- raincole 3y agoI've tried to hire artists from Upwork. Anecdotally the experience sucked. I made it clear it's for sprite sheet game assets, but it quickly got flooded by applicants who clearly never have never drawn sprite sheets. Event worse, about 15% of portfolios had stolen artwork. (I've been around for long enough to spot obvious stolen art, but I'm not a human google image search so the real rate might be much higher than 15%) I ended up contacting an artist that I found on itch.io directly.
- ametrau 3y agoWarning: you absolutely have to only allow certain countries to apply for jobs. The site works if you block India especially for most things.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated more recently: How AI is disrupting the demand for software engineers: data from 20M jobs https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39679170 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39679170
- polycaster 3y agoWhich is flagged for good reasons…
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sinuhe69 3y agoYou can smell the BS in such claims from miles away. 20 million jobs, really? Did they really take the trouble to analyse 20 million jobs, or did they just take a big number to make a mouthful? In reality, the authors did not even have 100 samples of some options. And that was based entirely on voluntary responses. What about controlling for other variables such as economic development or the effect of Section 174? Nope. What did the authors do about selection bias? Nothing. How about drilling down to a single example to see where AI has really replaced a coder? I doubt it. What we are currently seeing is a poker game with huge stake. As Musk himself said, you have to spend billions every year, just to stay at the table. With such a massive investment but no certain outcome, hype and BS is spewed everywhere.
- janalsncm 3y agoMy assessment of Midjourney, Stable Diffusion and DallE are that they are good if you don’t have anything specific in mind and your subject isn’t something which has specific components. (Try creating an accurate chess board. I have never been successful.) So for many situations where we want something that is consistently good, graphic design skills are still necessary imo.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI have a decent time if I use in painting with enough hand drawn scaffolding. I think the best uses of these technologies is adding complexity to a drawing you’ve already created. Anything else doesn’t impose enough constraint to get control if you have a specific idea in mind.
- echelon 3y agoThis is about to improve across the board from a product perspective. To get a feel for this, try Krea or ControlNet or ComfyUI. You can precisely control the scene layout.
- janalsncm 3y agoIf you can link a chessboard created using those tools with all of the pieces in the correct starting positions and with the board in the correct orientation, I would believe you.
- cageface 3y agoI've seen enough of their output now that I can recognize it immediately and I interpret as a signal of low effort and low quality. It's a glorified placeholder. Art is supposed to express or communicate something. Typing in a prompt doesn't really express much.
- bamboozled 3y agoNot sure if this is just my imagination but I think I might have experienced the same phenomena, on Instagram, I can look at an image of a person and very often guess that it's AI generated, even though it's a very realistic looking image.
- 6510 3y agoI haven't found (or searched) much use for AI but it did give me a wonderful new sense that I can only describe vaguely as the opposite of lifelessness. Robot writings and speech have now managed to capture everything that was noticeably missing in the previous effort which leaves it lacking only where we don't consciously notice it. This dead voice is hilarious, after listening to its videos for 20 minutes or so it becomes unbearable. It is like my subconscious is signalling me the real data is missing. Before this I wasn't able to filter out the fine bouquet of emotions expressed.
- azinman2 3y agoNot very good economic works. There’s no attempt to look at other correlating factors that could be teased out. It’s interesting to note about upwork trends but you can’t assume it has anything to do with chatgpt. A much more in depth and rigorous look would be required.
- hatenberg 3y agoThere’s a much better study by Prof Qiao from NUS and her team on the same corpus of data. https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04180 https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04180
- Animats 3y agoNVidia just announced an AI-simulated nurse, to give healthcare advice. Really.[1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yg0m8eR7k24 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yg0m8eR7k24
- bamboozled 3y agoReal nurses do a 1000x more things than give advice. Not sure if you've ever stayed in hospital, but man, what a job these people do.
- snowfield 3y agoGiven that we also have a huge shortage of nurses they're probably just thankful to not have to answer every single question everyone has all the time It's the one AI application that is not going to replace any jobs
- bamboozled 3y agoThis is the simplistic view, but it might also create more confusion and therefore more questions too.
- huuhee3 3y agoLooking forward to Nvidia announcing AI that can drive to old people's house, carry them to shower, wash them, give them food, and ensure they take their medicine. Robotics still suck, and that's what will seriously limit impact of AI for now.
- pydry 3y agoI'd rather have an AI CEO. There's a lower chance they'll kill someone when they fuck up.
- PodgieTar 3y agoWow Hippocratic AI. You can tell it's safe, because they named it as safe.
- ilaksh 3y agoI've been getting most of my work from Upwork in the period since generative AI started to take off. I can clarify something about the number of ML jobs. 90% of my clients are convinced or nearly convinced that they cannot fulfill their chat agent requirements without fine-tuning a new LLM. I do have at least one job in my profile that involved fine tuning. That may explain why some of the clients hired me. But one thing to note is that I do not claim to be a machine learning engineer because I'm not. I say I'm a software engineer with a recent focus on generative AI. 0% of the clients actually need to fine-tune an LLM in order to fulfill their requirements. What they need is any LLM close to the state of the art, temperature 0, and a good system prompt. Maybe some function/tool calling and RAG. The one guy that I did fine-tuning for, he kept telling me to feed small documents into qLoRA without generating a dataset, just the raw document. I did it over and over and kept showing him it didn't work. But it did sort of pick up patterns (not useful knowledge) from larger documents, so he kept telling me to try it with the smaller documents. Eventually, I showed him how perfectly RAG worked for his larger documents like a manual. But he still kept telling me to run the small documents through. It was ridiculous. I also ended up creating a tool to generate QA pairs from raw documents to create a real dataset. Did not get to fully test that because he wasn't interested. Anyway, the SOTA LLMs are general purpose. Fine-tuning an LLM would be like phase 3 of a project that is designed to make it faster or cheaper or work 10% better. It is actually hard to make that effort pay off because LLM pricing can be very competitive. Machine learning knowledge is not required for fine-tuning LLMs anyway. You need to understand what format the dataset goes in. And that is very similar to prompt engineering which is also just a few straightforward concepts that in no way require any degree to understand. Just decent writing skills really.
- snowfield 3y agoDoes fine tuning datasets need to be structured a specific way or can you take unstructured data?
- geoduck14 3y agoYou need to structure it in the form of "if the user says X, you say Y." For example: if the user asks "where do I find red pants," say "we don't sell red pants, but paint can be found here" The OP gave a quick example. You can take raw docs and generate a Q/A data set from it, and train on that. Generating the Q/A data set could be as simple as: taking the raw PDF, asking the LLM "what questions can I ask about this doc," and the feeding that into the fine tuning. BUT, and this is important, you need need a human to look at the generated Q/A and make sure it is correct. Key in this. Don't forget: you can't beat a human deciding what is the "right" facts and responses that you want your LLM to produce
- einpoklum 3y agoWhy is that freelance site representative of jobs in general? And more importantly: It seems the author did not make any attempt to isolate their variables. i.e. if something happened after ChatGPT was released - it must be the effect of ChatGPT. It's not like there are a zillion other factor affects the availability of different jobs, right?
- stockboss 3y agoi can attest to the fact that AI in its current form is still incapable of replacing even low-level artists. in my current business, i required a bunch of cartoon/comic images and i tried really hard using various AI tools to generate something based on my description, and none of it was usable. i then spent $5 on Fiverr to hire a comic artist in Indonesia to do it, and within 24 hours I got a really wonderful deliverable back. i will continue to use cheap artists in developing countries for my graphics. AI just doesn't cut it - yet.
- PodgieTar 3y agoThe only place I've found a use for AI art is in powerpoints, where the general vibe of an image is often sufficient. Anything requiring specificity is.. out.
- wildrhythms 3y agoI don't know, something about that is offputting to me. When I put pictures in my presentation they are things that I relate to in some way; not just some passive eye candy. The assumption that I need visual drivel to hold my attention is condescending to me.
- PodgieTar 3y agoI actually completely agree with you on this. I work as a Solutions Architect, one of the salesy kind. The presentations I care about, that I put time into, I will use high quality stock images. One of my recently presentations about GenAI didn't use a single Gen AI image. But, from experience, on the more businessy side. People do like them. They flash on the screen for like 20seconds, they look pretty high quality, and are usually adapted to whatever business we're trying to smooch up to. But they all have this horrible, gaudy, high contrasty and glossy look to them that I think is tacky.
- mitjam 3y agoIn IT infrastructure outsourcing, running the old infrastructure unchanged but cheaper is sometimes called „mess for less“. Now, we can also generate new mess for less.
- uptownJimmy 3y ago"One is that these generative AI tools are already good enough to replace many writing tasks, whether it’s writing an article, or a social media post." Good enough to what? Give me a headache when I try to read any of the articles that Google coughs up when I search almost anything these days? The auto-generated pap that passes for "good enough" is literally a tsunami of near-meaningless word-porridge that is burying the Web in nonsense. Might as well shove large chunks of lorem ipsum into your "articles" or "social media posts".
- senko 3y agoNot just jobs. I recently hired on Upwork and used prompt injection to make the AI autoreply scripts identify themselves by writing "I am a bot" as the first sentence of the job application. I expected maybe one or two. Almost half of the applicants self-identified as bots. Hilarious and eye-opening.