7 ms·
When new hires get paid more, top performers resign first
- erehweb 3y agoSounds plausible. The obvious Q though is - were the researchers able to identify a causal effect? Or could it be that the highly-paid new hire is a sign of the market being hot, so the top performers are able to get new better offers? i.e. would they have left even without the new hire?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- itsdrewmiller 3y agoAgreed they don’t really address threats to validity (HBR almost never does). Another objection - they claim that adjusting salary sooner rather than later has a big effect on turnover, but do they control for the general effect that getting a raise or not affects turnover rate, independent of whether someone was hired at a higher salary?
- s3tt3mbr1n1 3y agoI’m in the unique situation where I’m hiring my replacement after having made a promotion. I know they will make (substantially) more than me. How would I negotiate a matching or superior salary?
- bevekspldnw 3y agoCompeting offer. Go interview.
- thot_experiment 3y agoLeave.
- rjbwork 3y agoUnfortunately this is the answer. The bean counters do not give a shit about your experience or value. They just need warm bodies. They know the friction of leaving a company is high so they'll intentionally make you feel like a sucker until you finally quit, getting more years and months out of you for a lower rate than you deserve. When you finally do leave, they'll pat themselves on the back for retaining you for so long at a depressed wage.
- hallway_monitor 3y agoI guess the problem with bean counters is they don't know how to count our beans. The low performers look exactly the same as the high performers to them. So they make foolish decisions.
- ThrowawayR2 3y agoLeave? Into what is anecdotally the worst job market for developers since 2008 and maybe even the dotcom bust?
- eastbound 3y agoI don’t understand this remark. It’s still incredibly hard to find engineers here in Europe (I’m hiring at 5x the minimum wage, to give an idea). Where are the swathes of unemployed people that you are describing? Are a quarter of American IT professionals unemployed?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vundercind 3y agoOffer to step back into that position because taking the promotion will reduce your pay to under the going rate for the position you’re leaving.
- jedberg 3y agoEveryone else is telling you to leave or try a power play, but food for thought -- you may actually be less valuable now in your new role because you aren't experienced in it. If you just moved from IC to manager, you might be a pretty new manager. It's normal for managers to have reports that make more than them. Just because you manage them doesn't make you more valuable. I'm not saying this is the case for you in particular, but it might be, so something to consider before playing hardball.
- s3tt3mbr1n1 3y agoThat’s very insightful and the argument I would expect if I were to start discussions about salary. How would you counter this? I would also say I’m more qualified for the job than those that are applying now, so I’m not sure if this really is applicable to me.
- anal_reactor 3y ago> How would you counter this? "I asked for a promotion, not for a complete career switch".
- slim 3y agomaybe it's no the right time to negotiate your salary ? given there is competition for your job position and your competency is not proven. why not wait till next year ?
- Jcampuzano2 3y agoYou just got a promotion, so now you're in a better position to make more money by leveraging the new level/status at another company. Leave or get a competing offer to use as leverage if you really like your company.
- bboygravity 3y agoRead a book or watch some Youtube videos about negotiating (in general)?
- s3tt3mbr1n1 3y agoAnything you would recommend, specifically for salary negotiations?
- mooreds 3y agoJosh Doody's stuff is pretty good: https://fearlesssalarynegotiation.com/ https://fearlesssalarynegotiation.com/
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoCambell's "Start with NO" is a great book to read.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bevekspldnw 3y agoUsed to be a high performer at Big Tech. Found out a coworker with less experience at the same level had $200k/year more in comp. I didn’t care about the money, I care about being taken for a fool. There were additional factors, but I left and started my own company within three months and nobody in my old team has anywhere close to my experience.
- mupuff1234 3y agoWas it the result of them getting lucky with timing the RSU grant or was it just their original offer?
- bevekspldnw 3y agoI got fucked on my offer. Something of a phyrric victory for HR - lost a high performer and gained a competitor over a rounding error in the budget.
- bmitc 3y agoNot only is it an example of the idiotic decision making processes that companies use that are not effective in the long run, it demonstrates how they are happy to pit employees against one another. It is awkward for a person to know that they make substantially more than coworkers. It forms a feeling of guilt and other negative feelings. But what are they supposed to do? Negotiate lower salaries when starting or after working for a while? And it's definitely frustrating knowing other coworkers with the same or less experience and responsibilities as you make a whole lot more. It forms feelings of jealousy, not feeling valued, self worth, and other negative feelings. And all of this is caused by the company simply not caring about actually employing and managing humans. And it's always been insane to me that companies will let an experienced person leave because they won't raise their salary and then immediately put out a job requisition at a salary that would have kept the experienced person. It makes no sense, and yet, this happens constantly.
- peteradio 3y agoThe social order is fundamentally nepotistic. Family/Tribe/Caste matters more than experience/performance within the managerial bubble. Keeping the actual workers down helps to keep them desperate to put food on the table, but you better perform well enough to float the non-workers. Deloitte/Wipro/Infosys/et.al know how to play this game very well to discourage anyone not in the tribe from advancing.
- duxup 3y agoIn the late 90s I worked at a place that recognized the issue where they were having problems bringing people onboard so they offered more. But in our department they also did a yearly "adjustment" across the board to make sure they avoided paradoxical issue of new guy / longtime hire guy unexpected pay disparity. In that case the new guy getting paid more or close to the same was a largely non-issue as you knew you'd get adjusted. It was arguably good news for you.
- tombert 3y agoCan someone who understands economics better than me explain how the workforce can "shrink" in 2024? The number of people isn't going to dramatically decrease, are just a ton of people retiring? Or does this imply that there's going to be a reduction in the number of available jobs?
- kdfjgbdfkjgb 3y agoif you click on the word shink in the article, it takes you to another article that explains boomers are retiring and they are a larger generation than the younger ones who will replace them.
- rjbwork 3y agoIn the industrialized world, the fertility rate is almost universally below replacement rate, and has been for a long time. So, as boomers are retiring, there are not as many people replacing them.
- hallway_monitor 3y ago[flagged]
- rjbwork 3y agoI understand, I just don't care. It's the economic elites who don't seem to understand that they need a next generation to exploit and that the proletariat cannot be squeezed indefinitely. Eventually we look around and say "fuck this, I'm not wrenching sentience from the void to live in this morass".
- tombert 3y agoI live in the US, have a decent-paying job, but I don't have any kids, and I got a vasectomy so it seems unlikely that I will have any kids. If something happens by accident (e.g. the vas deferens heals), my wife and I would almost certainly keep it and we'd be parents, but I don't think that's terribly likely. I actually do really like kids, I like my nieces and nephew, but the problem is that the value proposition for having kids is not terribly high. They're expensive, and time consuming, and honestly kind of a liability. It's especially hard for women, because pregnancy takes you out of the workforce for a long time, and women are still (however unfairly) typically the "primary caretaker" for the child. Since your 20's are generally the optimal time to grow your career, it's an extremely high opportunity cost to have a child. I've never wanted to have my own kids. My wife and I have agreed to take care of our nieces and nephew if something happens to their parents, but I don't think I'd be a terribly good parent, and I would prefer to avoid screwing up another human.
- jedberg 3y agoThis is one of the reasons I loved Netflix. Each year they would say "to get new people in the door with your level experience, we had to offer them $XXX. Therefore we are raising you to $XXX." Some years I got 25%+ raises. Netflix understood this like no one else.
- bluSCALE4 3y agoMakes me happy that at least someone out there is experiencing pay fairness.
- testfoobar 3y agoWould the 25% raise be composed primarily of salary or stock?
- ivalm 3y agoNetflix is just salary
- mmxmb 3y agoNetflix doesn’t do stock comp.
- i_am_a_peasant 3y agoapparently for some people they do lol
- jpalawaga 3y agohistorically they've had an options program that you could optionally participate in, with your salary. the rumblings i've heard seems to imply they'll be rolling out an RSU system in the future as they continue to destroy the unique corporate culture they had.
- i_am_a_peasant 3y ago
- ALittleLight 3y agoMakes sense. New hire gets paid a lot, everyone updates on what they should be getting paid, top performers have the best chance of getting jobs elsewhere and they now know they should be getting paid more. Seems like this consideration makes hiring new people much more expensive. Either you pay everyone (or just top performers) more or pay the new hires less and likely attract a lower tier of new hire which has its own cost. Employees should do more to share their pay so everyone knows how much everyone else is getting paid. I mostly think there should be a law mandating this - every employer with more than 100 employees must publish summary statistics on wages at every job category. I recall reading that CEO pay skyrocketed after a law intended to reduce CEO pay required that CEO compensation had to be disclosed. It had the opposite effect and CEOs started to make much more. Seems like we should apply that same thing to the average worker.
- vundercind 3y agoBasically anything companies don’t want workers to be able to do is good for the workers and bad for the companies. They don’t want us sharing pay. They don’t want to have to post comp ranges in job postings—they don’t want it to be easy for us to compare job postings. That means it’s a safe bet that both of those tend to increase worker comp.
- Jcampuzano2 3y agoWell no shit. If I'm currently a top performer and we hire new workers at a higher pay rate than me, if I have to wait to get a raise because of BS corporate bureaucracy then the company should know from the second they say no I have my foot halfway out the door. Funnily enough at many companies the second you actually threaten to leave, that corporate BS suddenly isn't an issue. But trust has already been lost. Exactly as mentioned in the article but what should be basic common-sense. Why would I continue to work as hard as I do being a known top performer just for somebody who is new and has no history to get paid more than me. But of course some of this may actually be exactly what some companies want in this backwards world, get rid of top performers who expect a pay raise in favor of those who don't expect one anytime soon like new employees. Set the expectation to new employees to not expect raises, etc.
- theshrike79 3y ago> at many companies the second you actually threaten to leave, that corporate BS suddenly isn't an issue Not "many" - "every company". Unless you're an useless cog in the machine, you can always leverage a raise by saying you got a better offer somewhere else. In very rare cases it pays to take the raise from the old company though, your name is already on a List, so better start looking for other jobs anyway.
- fnord77 3y agoCovid really pulled the veil back on "BS corporate bureaucracy". So many bureaucratic sacred cows went out the window.
- Groxx 3y ago>Interestingly, even employees who aren’t actively looking for a new job may become more aware of shifting market prices when a new hire joins at a higher salary, sparking concerns that they may be being taken advantage of. Because being paid less to do more means they are being taken advantage of. That's blindingly obvious. It's just that it was thrust in their face by the new hire occurring.
- hinkley 3y agoIt’s not obvious to narcissists or little feudal lords, though I may be repeating myself. Give a man a little power…
- saghm 3y agoYeah, I'm struggling to understand how this could be noted as "interesting". "Wow, my employees think they should be paid for the work they're doing _without_ having to threaten me about leaving to get a raise? What a revelation!"
- dragon-hn 3y agoI just had a very valuable teammate quit this week from lack of salary progression. New-ish grads are making more than him for much lesser jobs. The business refused to do even a token salary increase because of the ‘economic climate’ Now a critical project won’t happen on time, which will cost the company many magnitudes more in revenue than it would have cost them with a token increase. Oops.
- bell-cot 3y agoBut, viewed on a small-enough scale, the managers did get their way. And "small" is usually quite descriptive of managers.
- tayo42 3y agoAre you all extremely underpaid or something? Or how are new grads getting so much in a down market? I'm decently experienced saw lots of relatively low paying jobs in general
- Zambyte 3y agoWhat market is down?
- suzakus 3y agoThe regular software engineering market is very rough to get jobs in right now, particularly at lower levels of experience
- mooreds 3y agoAgreed. This is in line with experience of friends (Metro Denver, USA). Even senior folks are having a harder time than in the past few years.
- vundercind 3y agoLow to mid experience and trying to land FAANG-alike or finance jobs, I think. The “merely” 1.5-3x median household income comp range sure seems to have remained healthy, even for newbies.
- golergka 3y agoIf you're willing to attract new hires with more pay, your competitors are willing too.
- turtlebits 3y agoThis is why you don't stay at a company for more than X years - IME, it's probably around the 3 year mark? I once received > 2x comp after leaving a company I had been at for 6 years.
- geraldwhen 3y agoSome companies pay fine. I’m not going to find 250k for how easy my work is jumping ship.
- austin-cheney 3y agoWith higher pay plus less experience comes entitlement. It’s the attitude of I shouldn’t have to do x, y, or z. Usually it’s because they can’t do those things and in full fear mode vomit some bullshit excuses. That, more than anything else, is why I’m in another line of work full of former programmers who are eager to do something else.
- Gasp0de 3y agoWhat line of work is that?
- jpgvm 3y agoProbably wood working, seems to be where all the burnt out programmers end up.
- karaterobot 3y agoI can think of half a dozen former programmers I know who now do things like finish carpentry, furniture building, luthierie, and other fiddley wood stuff, and it's been a private joke with friends. I didn't know it was such a widespread phenomenon though!
- lukan 3y agoOr teachers.
- lexh 3y agoWhat line of work is full of former programmers?
- sys_64738 3y agoNowadays, that's the unemployment line.
- adolph 3y agoI have a periodic thought exercise of a counterfactual where our culture had developed in a way that paid early career people relatively more than now and vice versa for late career. The concept behind it is that interest compounds and beyond basic competence it can be difficult to tell the relative value of experience versus eagerness and top performers with/without the supportive environment in which they operate.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoOn top of that in terms of your life outside of work, some of your biggests costs are up front in your life. Education, childcare, housing, paying into retirement plans through it all, etc. When you are in your 50s-60s with your kids moved out, your healthcare later in life to be subsidized by the government, your home payed off, your student loans long gone, your retirement portfolio built out, with another 20 years lets say on average of life left in you, what do you even need a raise for?
- kstrauser 3y agoWhat broke me was seeing new employees get the same option grants as those of us who’d been there before our product launched. We took on all the risk and the years of startup salary to build the thing, and new people walk in with the same ownership? What the hell. I couldn’t forgive that.
- Saulivar 3y agoThere was an article at Forbes that said employees who stay with the company for more than 2 years are underpaid by as much as 50%. So why do they stay for so long? Humans are resistant to change. Speaking of myself, when I was working as a programmer, finding a new job meant going through endless interviews with leetcode tests even though I had 15 years experience. Turns out it was Joel Spolsky who invented that practice. I'm sure most programmers want to strangle that guy. Lol. As for me, I became a contractor. All my underpaid overtime turned into a paid one. Plus my contracts lasted a lot longer than my full time jobs. But even that what I later found out is what they call "trading hours for dollars". In order to really succeed I need to start my own business. Which required me to learn "direct response marketing and copywriting". Because being an Engineer I sucked at selling, finding hungry markets for my products, creating products and selling them by the millions. Once I figured that out, it's like a new world opened up to me. Turns out you can make as much money as you want. Unlimited amounts. It's up to you how much you want to make. I wish I would've figured that out earlier.
- thisiszilff 3y ago> Which required me to learn "direct response marketing and copywriting". How’d you go about getting good at these things?
- jmholla 3y agoNot an answer to your question, more bolstering your comment, hoping someone else will come along and be encouraged to answer. Trying to learn about this on the internet is a nauseating series of blogspam. Edit: Although, this particular article doesn't seem so bad: https://mirasee.com/blog/direct-response-copywriting/ https://mirasee.com/blog/direct-response-copywriting/
- ore0s 3y agoAny recent books you suggest on "direct response marketing and copywriting"? I've tried to read "how to win friends and influence people" "ogilvy on advertising" "traction" but haven't taken actions yet.
- 3y ago
- stagger87 3y agoRecently experienced an excellent colleague ask for a raise to $X, get rejected, leave, the replacement was hired for more than $X, the replacement complained about the workload being too much, and so we hired another body to cover the original developer leaving, again for more than $X. Absolute madness.
- sys_64738 3y agoWord of mouth means that the attrition will forewarn those who have the same thought process.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoObligatory MonkeyUser: https://www.monkeyuser.com/2020/new-hire/187-new-hire.png https://www.monkeyuser.com/2020/new-hire/187-new-hire.png
- throwaway194832 3y agoThis is happening to me in real time. New hire will have higher job title than me and more pay but will be taking over my work. 2 people on the team already put in their notices.
- from-nibly 3y agoProgramming as theory building has been the rock that explains how stupid companies are with how they turn retaining employees into a financial game. https://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~remzi/Naur.pdf https://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~remzi/Naur.pdf Your employees ARE your company. Every time you lose an employee you are cutting a chunk out of your company. Sometimes this is good. But if you lose a top performer its like losing your kidneys. You are going to be on dialasis for a long time. ...this metaphore makes me think about how insane it would be for a person to look at their organs as a financial puzzle to solve. Like what if dialasis was less expensive than not selling your kidneys.
- Havoc 3y agoWell duh - when something is/feels wrong those with options bail first. Not exactly rocket science
- slibhb 3y agoDefine "pay equity" please. Does that mean everyone in the same role gets paid the same? Everyone with the same seniority gets paid the same? Something else? Sure, some people are getting paid too little and others too much. But the concept of "equity" has no place here. It suggests that you "deserve" to paid equally. But equal to whom? And based on what? A new hire can be more valuable than a veteran. Two people in the same role can contribute different amounts.
- alexchamberlain 3y agoI don't understand how this practice is legal; don't we all have laws on equal pay for equal work?
- allthecybers 3y agoI've been rated in top tier/exceeds status for the last two years as a Senior level tech employee at a FAANG. This is after working up from entry level at hire, and promoting two times. Despite high performance and successful delivery of large projects, my base salary* has increased less than 3% in three years. Every single year, the company has come up with an excuse to not raise base salaries. It typically relates to economic intangibles, stock performance, or whatever corporate alphabet soup they choose. People hired halfway through my tenure got hired on with substantially higher base salaries, some who are a level below me. I really enjoy the work I do, but I just can't sustain less than 3% income growth over the course of the next three years. That's why I am looking elsewhere, not because I want to, but because I have to. Some roles I'm seeing below Senior level have starting salaries 50% higher than mine. *I am aware of the concept of total compensation and I do get company stock, but you can't pay bills month-to-month on funds that are six months away from being available, and you aren't sure whether you'll see a 6% upside or 6% downturn.
- JohnFen 3y ago> I am aware of the concept of total compensation I'm with you on this. When I'm evaluating an offer, the only part of the total compensation package that I really pay any attention to is salary because the rest is too uncertain.
- altdataseller 3y agoFor those wondering why companies do this, I wrote a post on this awhile back https://bloomberry.com/why-new-hires-often-get-paid-more-than-existing-employees/ https://bloomberry.com/why-new-hires-often-get-paid-more-tha...
- snotrockets 3y agoAnd in other news: elephants are quite big, the sun is hot, water is wet.
- mancerayder 3y agoCan someone tell tech hiring on Wall Street? Financial companies seem to suffer from salary rot, a seasonal affliction appearing towards and after Comp Day. New hires get paid more. Sometimes a lot. Salaries are geared to stay at or just above inflation while more risk is taken by the employee due to bonus turning after a few years not into "bonus" but "missing piece of salary".
- gabriella4151 3y ago[dead]
- c_o_n_v_e_x 3y agoHow often are you supposed to "mark to market?" Quarterly? What happens when the markets drop? Will employees accept seeing their comp drop? I suppose you could offer some base level of compensation + have some market adjusted component? Having the entire salary marked to market creates uncertainty in annual compensation. Or you give employees options on how frequently they want their salaries to be re-evaluated but that comes with the potential of going down?
- sandspar 3y agoHBR is great at cranking out Just So stories like this. "Shucks, who could have guessed that the leadership style I learned in my 2010's American Northeastern university MBA is scientifically proven to be the best leadership style in all of human history?"
- GaryNumanVevo 3y agoYearly I'd interview with other companies, get an offer or two, and use those to negotiate mid-year raises / RSU bumps. Turns out this is quite lucrative, I don't have to change jobs, or worry about trying to get promoted.
- christinealfred 3y ago[dead]
- calvinxander08 3y ago[dead]
- galina700 3y ago[dead]
- galina700 3y ago[dead]
- p91paul 3y agoIn other news, it has recently been discovered that water is wet.