5 ms·
Maersk names first vessel of its large methanol-enabled fleet "Ane Maersk"
- kasperni 3y agoHere are some specs and pictures (The link in the article is wrong) https://brandcentral.maersk.com/d/AWavsgKLBExv/press-area#/press-area/vessel-facts https://brandcentral.maersk.com/d/AWavsgKLBExv/press-area#/p...
- c0nfused 3y agoI have to say that the "fun facts" included here are actually pretty cool. They are exactly the sort of thing one would want to use to explain the whats and whys of the ship to your kid.
- bombcar 3y agoInteresting; that page has typos that the PDF version doesn't, almost like a bad OCR.
- everybodyknows 3y ago>Speed: 21 knots Surprisingly high. Is this typical for container ships? Would it be run slower if carrying non-perishable, low-value cargo?
- dgllghr 3y agoSo if I understand correctly, methanol is a low emission fuel source because the CO2 is taken from the air or from plants that have captured it from the air? But if there isn’t enough supply of methanol now, won’t the gap just be filled by methanol from natural gas? And what incentive is there to change from natural gas to something more sustainable in the future? I’m skeptical that these methanol ships are an improvement.
- analog31 3y agoRight now ethanol is also sourced from methane unless heavily subsidized, so far as I know.
- SoftTalker 3y agoWell it's probably better than bunker oil or whatever petroleum fuel was used before. Battery electric may work at some smaller scales such as local ferries but not for moving 100,000 tons across oceans. The energy density just isn't there. Nuclear would be good but would make the ships a huge piracy/terrorism target. You'd need military escorts for them.
- lukan 3y ago"Battery electric may work at some smaller scales such as local ferries but not for moving 100,000 tons across oceans" It would definitely also work for 100 000 tons, but then a sizable percentage of those 100 000 tons will be battery and not freight. Unless the ship should make stops all the time to recharge, which is expensive as well, so no, batteries are not a economical solution for freight ships. But fuel cells might be a solution https://www.fraunhofer.de/en/press/research-news/2021/march-2021/worlds-first-hightemperature-ammonia-powered-fuel-cell-for-shipping.html https://www.fraunhofer.de/en/press/research-news/2021/march-...
- dv_dt 3y agoRun them on beamed microwave power from space based solar panels
- zdragnar 3y agoI've played SimCity 2000, no thank you.
- lukan 3y agoI suppose it often caused disasters?
- wafflemaker 3y agoFor those who haven't read the very good hard sci-fi near future book Delta-V by Daniel Suarez: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/40859000-delta-v https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/40859000-delta-v Though we only encounter microwave beaming in the sequel, Critical Mass I found the book a very good read, super realistic. 10/10 for realism/science/research and 8/10 for story. It's very optimistic. Nice to read with the war in Ukraine and progressive climate change not filling with optimism.
- vegetablepotpie 3y agoYou can take CO2 from industrial processes that emit it as a byproduct. Carbon fee and dividend would incentivize low carbon fuels by putting a price on carbon. The methanol purchased would not incur a fee. Carbon fee and dividend is employed in Canada and bills have been introduced to the US congress many times since 2009. Shipping companies have an incentive to begin employing low carbon fuels to get ahead of policy changes.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoHmm - why isn't this happening more often? IIUC, you can produce 1 tonne of Methanol for $100-250 from CO2: https://decarbonisationtechnology.com/article/162/conversion-of-co2-to-methanol https://decarbonisationtechnology.com/article/162/conversion... (presumably the cost should be less for waste, since waste is "free"). That would be ~250k BTU per dollar and gasoline is about ~50k BTU per dollar IIUC. OTOH, natural gas is close to 1M BTU per dollar.
- icegreentea2 3y agoThe current methanol source is almost certainly natural gas. There is quite a lot of work in trying to get bio-methanol and other truly low/negative GHG sources online (along with biodiesel, bio-heavy fuels, etc etc). If you're asking for incentives - if the actual cost of materials does not become directly advantageous, then presumably we'll get plain old fashion regulation forcing the issue. In any case, actually having these ships out there in operational service gives additional incentives to whoever is working on bio-methanol to like... actually get going. Edit: Sneaking in an aside. If you were wondering about the naming, and maybe you were ignorant like me. Maersk is majority owned by A.P. Moller Holding. A.P. Moller is one of Maersk's founders.
- KingOfCoders 3y ago"Today we use biofuel from waste streams that are unfit to use for human or animal consumption." https://www.maersk.com/support/faqs/low-carbon-fuels-used-by-maersk-eco-delivery https://www.maersk.com/support/faqs/low-carbon-fuels-used-by...
- plorg 3y agoThat sounds more like biodigesters or landfill gas than the "hydrogen from renewable sources plus CO2 from the combustion of plant sources" described in a cousin comment.
- lazide 3y agoIt can also be exhaust from biofueled turbine power plants, which apparently are a thing in Northern Europe. Typically fed from timber harvest slash, brush, etc. [https://smartcitysweden.com/best-practice/399/swedens-largest-biofuel-heat-and-power-plant/ https://smartcitysweden.com/best-practice/399/swedens-larges...]
- amenhotep 3y agoChips from logging Canadian old growth forests, if you're Drax.
- fulafel 3y agoThe incentive (and driver for more co2 neutral methane production) might be the CO2 pricing on the seas coming up: https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/oil-and-gas/worlds-first-global-co2-charge-inches-closer-at-london-meetings/108776965 https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/oil-and-gas... But yes, the methanol fuel capability is a necessary-but-not-sufficient precondition for low co2 emissions shipping.
- ncallaway 3y ago> the methanol fuel capability is a necessary-but-not-sufficient precondition for low co2 emissions shipping. Would I be (very approximately) correct in thinking of it like the transition to Electric Vehicles, where it is not sufficient in that we then also need to ensure the electricity is generated in a low CO2 emissions manner? But the transition to EVs is a necessary step, because it enables that transition to be possible?
- crote 3y agoYes, but until we invent and scale up a suitable truly CO2-neutral alternative, it's at least a lot better than bunker fuel!
- ogrisel 3y agoHere is another reference that described how Maersk define and source green methanol: https://www.maersk.com/news/articles/2023/06/13/maersk-secures-green-methanol https://www.maersk.com/news/articles/2023/06/13/maersk-secur... The cleanest process combines hydrogen produced from renewable electricity (typically wind or solar) and CO2 captured from the combustion of biomass.
- nottorp 3y agoWell, it's like electric cars. You can charge the battery from solar power or burning coal. But if you shut down the coal plants and go all solar, you don't need to change anything about the existing cars.
- photochemsyn 3y agoThe replacement of high-sulfur bunker-oil fuel (literally the bottom of the barrel in terms of petroleum refining) with methanol is an undeniable win on multiple grounds, such as high air pollution in port cities and along shipping lanes. Methanol is simply a much cleaner-burning fuel, regardless of source. As far as synthetic hydrocarbon production goes, methanol is low-hanging fruit. E.g. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fchem.2018.00446/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fchem.2018.0044... > "Starting from pure CO2 and a separate pure source of H2, rather than a mixture of CO, CO2, and H2 as is the case with syngas, simplifies the chemistry, and therefore also changes the reaction and purification processes from conventional methanol producing industrial plants. At the core of the advantages is that the reaction impurities are essentially limited to only water and dissolved CO2 in the crude methanol."
- mistrial9 3y agoOil industry chemists have decided somehow that methanol from LNG is the next step to delivering their own production materials. Related to this are long-range plans to build the infrastructure of ports, manufacturing and processing facilities to implement it. IMHO they do not intend to ask anyone for permission, they will simply do this with military, and let the politicians deal with fallout.
- rzwitserloot 3y agoNot the CO2 - the C. Technically you don't need the Cs at all, you can just burn H2. However, H2 has all sorts of annoyances; running a car on H2 is difficult. Running a boat on it, not really feasible right now. Your worry about the 'gap' is sensible but (probably) not relevant here. You're asking to do the job of 'produce energy in a sustainable way' and the job of 'use said sustainably produced energy efficiently' in tandem, never raising one without also raising the other on the same day. Not. Possible. This market is already far too complicated. So, instead, you work on one of the 2 edges and trust that the market will fix the other edge. If not immediately, then at least create a stable incentive. For example, right now, solar and wind is generally considered 'cheapest', but that glosses over an important detail: When the sun is out and it's windy, power prices are often __negative__ for it. So cheap, it's negative. That's because so much solar and wind is produced, the demand side hasn't caught up. Power MUST be used IMMEDIATELY, you can't just 'let it go round and round on the power cables', they'd just asplode. If there's a sudden unplanned influx of power then that's bad and thus you get money _back_ if you take more power off the grid in that time. And, the flipside: ON a misty day (no wind, no sun), power is very expensive. Because supply is lower than expected. (Prices go negative because not all solar/wind systems are smart gridded up; if they were, they'd just turn themselves off and stop producing. Which merely reduces the price to 0 instead of negative). Hence, one of the big missing links in this future renewable energy world we're trying to make happen, is an energy _demand_ that can react perfectly to the inherently fluctuating nature of energy _supply_ where the supply is based on solar/wind. One solution is to add a really stable or flexible source on the supply side. This is partly why richer countries still are building gas-based fossil fuel powerplants: Gas plants are easily 'tunable' - you can pretty much just rotate a volume knob and the power output responds pretty quickly. Coal is harder to 'tune', and nuclear is MUCH harder to tune (twiddle the knob now, it has an effect hours from now). Regardless of the tuning, a fossil fuel powerplant, even one that is usually running at nearly zero flow, is something we'd prefer to avoid. So, a better solution is to instead have flexible demand that can respond to fluctuating supply. But that's really hard to do! The solution so far is to let the grid mediate: Folks producing power just shove it on the grid, prices respond to supply, and the hope is that the cheap (or even negative!) arbitrary price drops incentivize the market to come up with ways to use the free power when its there. This is sort of working but the biggest issue is the grid part. It's actually really pricey to build a grid that can deal with massive spikes, and the exact places where you want to build wind and solar (far away where there's plenty of space) is where there is no grid. Because nobody lives there. Methanol offers an enticing way out. Instead of building, say, a wind farm in an urban area (complicated), or a wind farm where there's plenty of space (but no grid connection that can deal with it), you build a wind farm out of the way and hook it up to a methanol factory. You just store the methanol (it's easy to store - liquid and not all that poisonous or volatile), you can even pump it, you can ship it. The amount of research and money flowing into this model of 'make fluctuating renewable energy sources and hook em up to methanol producing things built right next to them' is limited because the demand for it isn't all that high. But it's not all that technically challenging (within reason. My point is, this is WAAY easier than nuclear fusion, for example) - so, create stable demand for it and it's highly likely the market will provide. Hence, it's oversimplified but in broad strokes fair to call methanol 'low emission' even if methanol supply today isn't great.
- credit_guy 3y ago> I’m skeptical that these methanol ships are an improvement. And you should be. The damning fact about methanol is that it has a very low energy density. Per wikipedia [1], one kilogram of diesel has an energy content of 45.6 MJ (megajoules). One kg of methanol has only 19.7 MJ. So, joule for joule, you need 2.3 tons of methanol for each ton of diesel you replace. My guess is that these ships will forever remain "methanol capable", but will continue to run on regular diesel fuel. It's probably some scheme to get some green credits, just like the "flex fuel" cars in the US, which can run on ethanol, but most often don't. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density
- SkyPuncher 3y agoMy impression is energy density matters significantly less with these giant ships.
- credit_guy 3y agoI ran some numbers. This ship can carry 7226 TEU containers; it has a gross tonnage of about 100k tons (93.5k to be precise) [1]. I found that a 5000 TEU carrier has a fuel capacity of 2 million gallons [2]. Since Anna Maersk can carry almost 50% more, its fuel capacity should be larger, but probably by less than 50% because of economies of scale. In any case, replacing diesel with methanol would require at least an additional 3 million gallons, which comes to 10000 tons. That's 10% of the gross tonnage of the ship. I suspect that no ship builder or operator will consider this a negligible amount. [1] https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q83601270 https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q83601270 [2] https://www.aol.com/many-gallons-fuel-does-container-142703880.html https://www.aol.com/many-gallons-fuel-does-container-1427038...
- pfdietz 3y agoI wonder if it would be possible to economically separate and store the CO2 from methanol combustion (on the ship), then deliver it back to a methanol production facility. Alternately, this could enable use of a fossil fuel, with the CO2 delivered to a facility for sequestration, or perhaps even pumped into deep water during an ocean crossing.
- noughtme 3y agoI don’t think fish like CO2. It makes the water more acidic.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe deep ocean is naturally acidic due to the natural carbon pump. Because of this, below a certain depth (typically around 15,000 feet), calcite and aragonite just dissolve (the "carbonate compensation depth") and there is no accumulation in the ooze. The carbon pump involves dead organic matter falling to depth, where it is consumed and oxidized, producing CO2 there.
- Faaak 3y agoCo2 dissolved in water makes it acid, which is bad for plenty of sea life
- pfdietz 3y agoYes, but the deep ocean is where almost all the CO2 we've released is going to end up, eventually. This is just accelerating that process.
- consumer451 3y agoWhy you might not want to accelerate that: > Effects of Ocean Acidification on Marine Phytoplankton https://cmi.princeton.edu/annual-meetings/annual-reports/year-2015/effects-of-ocean-acidification-on-marine-phytoplankton/ https://cmi.princeton.edu/annual-meetings/annual-reports/yea... > Regime shifts and ecological catastrophes in a model of plankton-oxygen dynamics under the climate change https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28456463/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28456463/
- pm90 3y agoIm guessing that container ships don’t need much refueling? If the ship runs into issues I wonder if they have to ground it until they can ship the methanol to it.
- icegreentea2 3y agoIt's a dual fuel ship - it can still run on fuel oil.
- denimnerd42 3y agoso is this methanol in harbor / emissions zones and fuel oil at sea? Does it run on diesel too?
- icegreentea2 3y agoThe main engine can run on fuel oil and methanol/LPG. They claim they can have 40k km of range on methonol. What they actually do in operation is of course different from what they're able to do.
- denimnerd42 3y agoyeah I wonder how the costs compare at current day prices. they aren't going to run methanol if its more expensive.
- bombcar 3y agoThey will if they can get someone to pay the difference; either because of carbon credits or advertising or whatever.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoApparently not; large container ships have a range of 10.000 - 20.000 miles on a single tank of fuel. These things are huge, and I can imagine they don't even need to compromise on storage space for fuel tanks (just like planes have fuel in the wings so their cargo capacity is maximised)
- readyman 3y ago>Fun fact: The vessel can load app 29,000 African elephants. The moment between reading the words "African" and "elephants" was frought.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ThomPete 3y agothis wont work
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoCan you elaborate? This is a very low quality comment as it stands.
- ThomPete 3y agoits not scalable, its too expensive its done for political ESG reasons not economic optimal reasons.
- everybodyknows 3y agoBased on what financial information?
- ThomPete 3y agobased on an understanding of physics, economics and energy policy. This is to get ESG approval not because it makes economic sense, the article itself speaks to why they are doing it. Denmark is extreme about renewables. Also its total excel magic that they get to “green” Dont take my word for it, just follow the claims and see how little of this is anything but ESG strategizing and greenwashing