3 ms·
I see more of a shift to open core. Many large orgs just say no to viral licenses, and in choosing AGPL, you put blockers to adoption. Open core releases some
by verdverm 3y ago
I see more of a shift to open core.
Many large orgs just say no to viral licenses, and in choosing AGPL, you put blockers to adoption.
Open core releases some of the project under permissive license, and keeps some private or under a permissions license.
We are all still trying to figure out how we can have sustainable open source where people can be paid to work on it full time
- wmf 3y agoThe shift to open core was ten years ago. Open core failed and is being replaced with pseudo open source.
- verdverm 3y agoOpen core only became a word people said 10 years ago, it's on the rise as a business model from what I can tell. Do you have suggestions for alternative funding/support models? What is open core being replaced by from your perspective?
- wmf 3y agoOpen core is being replaced by "selling exceptions" to AGPL/SSPL/BUSL/FSL. See MongoDB, Elastic, Hashicorp, Redis, etc. Personally I prefer the Adam Jacob trademark business model but it's not that proven and it can't be retrofitted.
- pininja 3y agohttps://medium.com/@adamhjk/introducing-the-community-compact-431c61ab978f https://medium.com/@adamhjk/introducing-the-community-compac... for folks wondering what Adam’s buisness model is about
- verdverm 3y agoOP, OpenSearch, OpenTofu all seem to indicate the jury is still out on this one. I still see many smaller projects using open core. Three I started using recently ( llama-index, langfuse, qdrant ) are in this category. There is certainly a difference between AGPL and BUSL style licenses. One of the new projects I'm using as some of their code with a BUSL style, but still open core primarily
- lukaszwojtow 3y agoIf AGPL blocks adoption then "large orgs" can buy commercial license (assuming software is dual-licensed).
- verdverm 3y agoThey can, but the issue is how much effort does that require for a random dev in the org to go through to try out a project? It's not a technical blocker, it's a psychological blocker
- lukaszwojtow 3y agoI get it. If there are alternatives that overall would be better (including their technical merits and how easy it is to introduce them to a commercial company) then use them. No one is forced to buy dual-license.
- sakjur 3y agoIf you’re happy with paying a few maintainers, a support staff, and some salespeople the cash flow necessary for being a successful endeavor is a whole lot different than if you’ve raised $350 million. Maybe the problem lies more with overreaching and trying to cash out?
- verdverm 3y agoFor sure, there is a problem in startup culture that looks down upon lifestyle companies. Devtools and developer focused products often get caught up in this. At the same time, founders take money to build their idea into something more than they could do with a small team. An big companies are risk averse, having a small staff or being susceptible to "hit by a bus" failure is often a deal breaker
- sakjur 3y agoThat’s very true. Business is very much a balancing act in that sense. Sometimes raising money is the reason you succeed, but it can equally well be why you fail (especially if you’d be happy running a smaller company but take on investors that want you to be hungrier).