11 ms·
Why are so many people being hit with £5 fines for 'counterfeit' stamps?
- throwanem 3y agoPutting sub-postmasters in prison for someone else's theft looks pretty played out at this point, so I suppose this must be the new grift.
- nextos 3y ago"It is unclear at what point these ‘counterfeit’ stamps have entered circulation, and their source — or whether they are genuine and Royal Mail’s scanning technology is at fault." Given the precedents from the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Post_Office_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Post_Office_scandal, I think the second option is plausible. My experience in the UK is that dysfunctional organizations try to hide issues by bullying their own customers.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIt’s a scandal engine that occasionally delivers mail. No accountability, no repercussions.
- matthewmacleod 3y agoRoyal Mail and the Post Office are two separate organisations.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI am aware. It seems, regardless of institution, that no one at these levels of UK public good can take responsibility. It is as if the apathy has been institutionalized in a declining nation state. Where and how do find someone who cares and the authority to do something about it? If you told me yet another UK institution had systemic issues (NHS?), I would not be surprised, and that is very sad. It should not be this hard to do better. Right? Or am I just an ignorant Yankee?
- RobotToaster 3y agoRoyal mail has been a privately owned corporation for some years now.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIgnorant Yankee behind the times it is. Much shame. Appreciate being corrected.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bombcar 3y ago[flagged]
- lostlogin 3y agoNo, the mail service isn’t protecting paedophiles as far as I know.
- Loughla 3y ago[flagged]
- andy81 3y ago> Pissed that my taxes were subsidizing their bullshit Accurate
- pard68 3y agoWell I (an American) agree with your sentiment, it appears that the British royalty don't actually rely on tax money, but instead they keep 25% of the money that the royaly estate /makes/ and the other 75% goes to the British treasury. But I might be wrong. https://www.bbc.com/news/explainers-57559653 https://www.bbc.com/news/explainers-57559653
- Dalewyn 3y agoAlso an American and I like the British (and also Japanese) royals. Benevolent monarchs are a cornerstone of serenity and sanity. And yes, I realize the irony as an American. I think on average Americans like the British royal family more than Britons do?
- oarsinsync 3y ago> Benevolent monarchs… The British royal family has veto power over parliament. They use this power to rewrite laws. Lots of this is well documented, but poorly publicised.
- devnullbrain 3y ago>that occasionally delivers mail Roughly once every two weeks, here.
- bombcar 3y agoOr it could be a bug in the printing, there have been cases before where things were accidentally duplicated that shouldn't have been. https://www.mycurrencycollection.com/blog/1-2013-new-york-duplicate-serial-number-mistake https://www.mycurrencycollection.com/blog/1-2013-new-york-du...
- nikdoof 3y agoIn the past six months I've had four letters returned to me because they went through the sort/scanner upside down and used the sender address on the CN22 as the destination address. I'd put money on it being a failure of technology.
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y agoTry putting the CN22 on the back instead.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quitit 3y ago>My experience in the UK is that dysfunctional organizations try to hide issues by bullying their own customers. I noticed this from Royal Mail. I reached out to them multiple times regarding a scam carried out using one of their tracked products from an eBay purchase and they said there was nothing they could do about it. But there was something they could do, and it was already going on completely silently in the background. I later received a letter from Royal Mail stating that the delivery did in fact not take place, and with that I was able to claim a refund from eBay. However my interactions with Royal Mail were not reasonable: 1. They did not disclose that the matter would be looked into, instead they stated unequivocally that it would not and there was no way to escalate the matter. This meant that my plans were altered on account of assuming that the funds were lost. 2. They were unwilling to provide any official statement to eBay regarding the limited "tracking" available for their own product, and naturally eBay won't accept second-hand statements. If they were slightly flexible this would have resolved the dispute promptly - and I doubt I was the first person to fall victim to this scam, so some communication between eBay and Royal Mail would seem reasonable. 3. They gave no notice that they found in my favour and would be sending me a letter as evidence. I only received that mail by chance as I happened to book the same accomodation in a later visit, and this luckily coincided with that letter's arrival. The unhelpfulness, stonewalling and opaque investigation seem entirely designed to cover for their own shortcomings. They would have had location data for the signed delivery, and they would have immediately had visibility that this didn't match my address.
- renewiltord 3y agoThese guys can't get anything right. I'd assume by default that their software is broken.
- chrisjj 3y agoThe real breakage is further up the chain ...
- Ajay-p 3y agoIt is strange that a person would receive a fine for receiving a letter with a "counterfeit" stamp. That would make for a very nasty revenge operation - send your worst enemy letters with counterfeit stamps to cause them to incur a five pound fine.
- ct0 3y agosame goes for bad checks, the person cashing it pays a returned check fee!
- HackerLemon 3y agoYou don't have to pay it. It's only payable if you want to receive the letter.
- Leynos 3y agoThe problem is that there is no way of knowing what the letter is. All you get is a slip through your door saying an item of mail is waiting for you and has a £5 fee to pay. If you're like me, you pay the fee, fearful that it might be something important.
- datascienced 3y agoYeah it could be a speeding fine caused by a faulty detector after all!
- dnh44 3y agoAt my local depot they allow you to see what the item is before you decide to pay or not.
- toast0 3y agoFrom the article, sounds like the recipient can pay the fine and get the mail, or not pay the fine and not get the mail. Maybe it'll get returned to sender, for insufficient postage? Maybe it'll be destroyed?
- jonatron 3y agoIt's impossible to say if this was detecting counterfeits, or incorrectly flagged counterfeits, without more information. I'd like to point to my recent experience trying to buy a mask from Amazon: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39844229 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39844229
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- delichon 3y agoIf this is really about a fine for counterfeiting a stamp, isn't £5 astonishingly low? In the US that's a serious federal felony with up to five years in prison. https://puryearlaw.com/2015/12/27/federal-counterfeit-postage-charges/ https://puryearlaw.com/2015/12/27/federal-counterfeit-postag...
- chrisjj 3y agoIt is not. "Fine" is misreporting.
- jcrawfordor 3y agoThe term "fine" seems confusing here. If you look at the form sticker, it seems apparent that £5 is just the on-delivery postage rate for an unpaid item. Different postal services handle this differently, but it's not unusual that a mailpiece that's lacking sufficient postage will be delivered to the recipient if they pay the postage, and it's also not unusual to make that a higher rate to account for the extra work involved in notifying the recipient and collecting it. Under some postal systems you can do this totally intentionally by marking a mailpiece COD. Maybe Royal Mail really does call this a fine, but it seems like it's just a typical higher "postage due" rate, thus the still rather nominal amount. Paying is optional for the recipient, they could just ignore the notification and it won't be delivered. The use of this approach for counterfeit seems sort of unwise considering the accusation involved in counterfeit postage, the USPS returns the piece to the sender in that case. But the items on the sticker make me think that Royal Mail has a general bent towards offering delivery no matter what. USPS would also return to sender if there's no postage at all, assuming the piece doesn't indicate the postage should be paid by the recipient. But you can see that the £5 sticker here is the same one used in that case. Sometimes the situation is complicated by postal policy, for example UPU policy for international mail tends to strongly prefer attempting to deliver a mailpiece over returning it, so "postage due" stickers seem more common on international mail (particularly since the international rates can be confusing and it's easier to accidentally underpay).
- adamm255 3y agoThe issue is, the recipient is paying the fine. I send you a letter with a fake stamp, you pay. The £5 is an inconvenience, something you’d pay while tutting “what is the world coming to”. The sender is none the wiser. 7.3bn letters delivered in 22-23 (https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0032/272795/post-monitoring-report-2022-23.pdf https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0032/272795/...) If 0.01% of that are tagged as counterfeit, that’s £3,650,000 in fines.
- adamm255 3y agoRoyal Mail needs to be slapped with a massive Freedom of Information request. We need to see how many fines have been paid. We had one of these a year and a half ago, similar story. Seemed BS back then, so this could be a big problem.
- matthewmacleod 3y agoRoyal Mail, as a private (well… public) company, is not subject to FOIA requests.
- lmm 3y agoThey're a creature of the state, you can't practically opt out of Royal Mail. If they're not subject to FOIA then they need to be.
- adamm255 3y agoAlso the legislation splitting the Post Office from Royal Mail and privatising it happening in 2011/12 just looks even more shady in light of all the Post Office stuff.
- adamm255 3y agoWell… that’s convenient. The more you know. Isn’t privatisation great!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RobotToaster 3y agoWhile it would be completely unsurprising if this is yet another royal mail cockup, there's been loads of suspiciously cheap stamps all over places like ebay, so it's possible people are just getting scammed.
- andrewaylett 3y agoThe stamps have "unique" codes, but a genuine counterfeit must still have a code -- and to be useful it must duplicate the code on a real stamp. If the counterfeit gets used first, the stamp is marked as spent, and when the unlucky purchaser of the real stamp tries to use it, they're told theirs is "counterfeit" because it's flagged as "used" in the database?
- chrisjj 3y agoThat would be dumb. Nothing prevents attempted reuse of a genuine stamp.
- taylorfinley 3y agoSorry, what about that would be dumb? Attempted reuse is exactly what would be prevented by scanning the barcode and seeing it had already been used. This is exactly why gift cards have scratch-off material covering their secret keys, otherwise folks would just take a picture of the next card in the stack, wait for it to be funded, and then use it before the recipient does. edit: And would you look at that, you can buy stamp sheets on Amazon.co.uk, and users have helpfully submitted a bunch of photos with barcodes visible.
- chrisjj 3y ago> Sorry, what about that would be dumb? Reused barcode does not mean counterfeit. > Attempted reuse is exactly what would be prevented by scanning the barcode and seeing it had already been used. Sure, but the alleged crime here is not attempted reuse. It is counterfeiting - as shown in the pic of the Royal Mail fee request label.
- chrisjj 3y agoJust to be clear, nothing from Royal Mail here suggests they suspect reuse. And the fact it did not tick the reuse box suggests it does not.
- taylorfinley 3y ago
- libpcap 3y ago[flagged]
- seabass-labrax 3y agoHere's an excellent blog post explaining the anti-forgery features of Royal Mail stamps: http://www.jolschimke.de/briefmarken-und-ganzsachen/erste-gefaelschte-matrixcodes.html#Artikel-englisch http://www.jolschimke.de/briefmarken-und-ganzsachen/erste-ge... What strikes me most is how crude the imitation stamps are - most aren't even trying to emulate the genuine printing techniques. It's all quantity over quality, trying to minimise the cost of producing counterfeit stamps whilst hoping to sell bulk loads of them to naive (or unscrupulous) customers. It sounds like the biggest problem is the conflict of interest that the Royal Mail has, since they currently get to keep the fine payments as revenue. They have no direct incentive to stop the sale of counterfeit stamps, let alone deal with a tiny proportion of false-positives from their scanning machines. Perhaps the answer is for the Royal Mail to be required to forfeit the revenue from fake postage fines, but be absolved of the responsibility to deliver these letters. Therefore, false positives in detection would simply be losses for their reputation, and they can decide, as a private company, whether or not this is an issue for their shareholders. Personally, I would go the other way, requiring that the Royal Mail always deliver letters with fake stamps without issuing fines, but have proper independent investigations into both the origin of the alleged fakes and the reliability of the scanning machines. This isn't going to happen without an Act of Parliament, unfortunately.
- pavel_lishin 3y ago> What strikes me most is how crude the imitation stamps are - most aren't even trying to emulate the genuine printing techniques. Of course. Their goal isn't to fool the post office; it's to be just good enough to sell to buyers.
- alibarber 3y agoRather like how a person can lose their bitcoin stash by accidentally sharing a picture of a private key, can stamps now be 'destroyed' by printing out reproductions of the barcode onto bits of paper and depositing them in postboxes?
- Linda231 3y ago[dead]
- martinald 3y agoThink the comments are missing the point it a bit - it was Royal Mail _themselves_ who provided these "counterfeit" stamps.
- michaelmrose 3y agoI like the theory someone else offered of other people "using up" the numbers o pre-existing stamps which would be feasible if the numbers were predictable.
- datascienced 3y agoWhat, another “computer says no; you is criminal” connected with Royal Mail?
- edward28 3y agoWhy let a pesky human get in the way of justice.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoIn Soviet Britain, the computer is always right, data is always perfect, and software bugs don't exist... and privately prosecute you.
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- dhosek 3y agoWhat caught my attention was that the first-class mail rate in the UK is £1.35 which is about $1.70 at current exchange rates. In contrast, in the US a first-class stamp is $0.68 (I buy forever stamps in bulk so I was surprised to discover it had gotten that high). The USPS really is a bargain.
- vinay427 3y agoYes, Royal Mail tends to be far more expensive than USPS for letters and smaller parcels, including internationally (e.g. UK to US costs far more than US to UK), but they have relatively reasonable pricing on medium-sized parcels in my experience. It definitely is apparent which is the private company based on their pricing schemes, even besides the more consumer-facing UK Post Office locations that are almost entirely franchised and often operate as a small convenience store, etc.
- NeoTar 3y agoThe prices have been increasing above inflation for years, but especially in the last few years - e.g. in 2001 a first class stamp cost 0.27 GBP (0.49 in 2024), and even in 2019 in was 0.70 GBP (0.86 in 2024).
- lb1lf 3y agoIn fairness, though, mail volume must have plummeted as email and electronic invoicing became a thing. My receiving a letter by actual mail now usually means I have forgotten to set up e-invoicing for a service I subscribe to. Yet, most of the infrastructure required to handle the (vastly reduced) volume of mail remains. (I would be surprised if an increasing amount of packages being shipped due to online shopping offsets the reduction in letters mailed)
- M2Ys4U 3y agoRoyal Mail was also privatised in 2013, which goes a long way to explaining the price hike.
- Chris_Newton 3y agoI don’t know whether I should post this as it may be an ongoing case, but not so long ago I sent off my old stamps to the official “swap out” service to have them replaced by the new barcoded ones. A few days later, I did indeed receive equivalent new stamps back — in an envelope that had clearly been tampered with, being roughly cut open all down one side and having the paperwork accompanying the stamps obviously bent and having been pushed back in awkwardly. I immediately contacted Royal Mail via their online system and noted the problem and my concern that this could mean the stamps had been replaced with fakes before reaching me. I asked if there was any way I could verify that they were legitimate before I used them. A few days later, I received a bizarre email back from someone at Royal Mail, saying they were sorry to hear that I wasn’t happy with their response (what response?!) and can certainly understand my frustration but we are not able to progress any further (than what?!), along with various other words that seemed designed to try to appease me while not actually saying anything of substance, and a recommendation to contact some other part of Royal Mail, which I may yet do. It was a surreal experience, but having been prompted to do it by seeing several reports of people who’d sent their stamps in and either never received the replacements or had problems with them, and having received such an obviously tampered delivery, with the entire process from collecting the stamps from my local post box to delivering the replacements to my home being under the control of Royal Mail, I can’t say I was particularly reassured by the response so far. I haven’t yet tried to send anything using the new stamps…
- 2-3-7-43-1807 3y agowell ... it's the royal mail which happens to be identical to the royal mail from the post office scandal. that's about the reassurance you got to expect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Post_Office_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Post_Office_scandal
- 1letterunixname 3y agoI was just about to write this. If you can't make money by criminalizing the service providers, find new ways to criminalize the act of sending a letter on the demand side. Brilliant! ;@] Perhaps: 1. Deregulation and privatization don't work well for some critical services. The BPO should be re-regulated as a government department. 2. Abolish private criminal prosecution, as only the CPS should be allowed to bring criminal indictments.
- rvba 3y agoFew things come to my mind: 1) There is a general batch of stamps and also a second batch, that is used to exchange "old" for "new" stamps. The second batch either contains duplicate numbers, or is not activated in the post system at all -> so those get marked as counterfeit 2) The barcode system has no error correction -> the scanners just read the codes "as is", without any sort of error correction / verification if they were read correctly. The incorrect numbers (wrong reading) are then marked as counterfeit 3) Incorrect readings vs some generic "list of stamps that were used" -> fake (?) duplicates marked by the system.
- PHGamer 3y agowhy do we need to track stamps. seriously.
- kazinator 3y ago> penalty for those who receive (and accept) mail posted using one Insane! Britain imitating Monty Python.
- switch007 3y agoI'm curious if this started/accelerated when they switched to only accepting super special stamps that only their super special machine can determine whether they're genuine and unused? That would sure be a coincidence. The fee was increased recently too I believe This definitely needs investigating properly and determining if we have another Post Office-like scandal on our hands.
- jlarcombe 3y agofrom my own experience, yes it did (never before the change and twice since)
- 2-3-7-43-1807 3y agoknew an artist (Germany) who would paint beautiful fantasy stamps for letters. not a crime and it often went through.
- matthewmorgan 3y agoI'm amazed how they managed to bring in barcoded stamps without a peep from anyone about privacy. Sending a letter anonymously is now impossible.
- pxeger1 3y agoWell that’s not really true. It’s not like cash is deanonynising because of the serial numbers. You can still get stamps on a grey market or send someone else to get them for you, and I’m sure they’re sold in lots of places that don’t have CCTV. The postmark would always have identified the approximate source location, it’s just a bit more precise now.
- kevinventullo 3y agoIt’s not like cash is deanonynising because of the serial numbers. Aren’t there cases where bank robbers were caught after the fact using knowledge of the serial numbers of the stolen bills?
- graemep 3y agoYou can keep your privacy, but most people will not bother. Most people will buy stamps with a card (or phone) payment so there is a complete chain of identify. The aim is mass surveillance so a few people going to the trouble of avoiding it is not a problem. True, it is meta data (not letter contents) but we know that is pretty powerful by itself. I do mean it is the aim - they never really explained what the real advantages of doing it for, and I suspect there is pressure from the security services who are accustomed to seeing most communications (or at least most meta data) to seal what they see as a hole in data collection.
- tim333 3y agoUsing cash to buy them is not hard and the odds of anyone going through the CCTV is low unless you are going to post anthrax to the PM or something. I imagine the main reason to do it was to make it harder to use fake stamps, although there may be some tracking going on.
- fifteen1506 3y agoI think most people are missing the point here. Why, for Christ's sake, is the onus of verifying the stamps put on the customers? The Royal Mail created the problem. Don't give them money. Otherwise bureaucracy and Kafkaesque issues will increase in the private and public sector. PS: not from UK
- Jochim 3y agoThis happened to me. My employer sent me a card and it was marked counterfeit. I raised a complaint and was basically told to go fuck myself.
- Theodores 3y agoSeveral years ago I bought a box of small toy Easter chicks and sent them in lots of envelopes over a period of a few weeks to my mother, as if they were 'migrating', getting workmates to write the labels and send them so they would have different postmark towns. The idea was for them to be anonymous. Some had several chicks in the envelopes. They kept arriving at my mother's and provided much amusement, with all but one of them arriving. I also played silly games to keep the postman on his toes, sometimes leaving out the postcode (zip) or putting other typos in the address. After the migration I visited my mum and she had the chicks everywhere, quite a collection. Then, about three weeks later, she had one of those cards meaning she would need to visit the depot. So she went, saw the envelope and knew what it was. In this envelope the chick was standing up rather than laying flat, to make the envelope too large for standard letter rate, hence the fine. She paid up. After hearing this tale I realised I had dodged about 57 bullets, for any of the envelopes could have ended up too large for the letter rate. At the time the post was affordable, with it not costing £1.25 a letter. The stunt would have easily cost me £100 had I wished to repeat it this year. I would have also run the gauntlet of the fake-forged-stamp malarkey, with it randomly costing my mother £5 just because the Post Office deemed their own stamps-with-QR-codes fraudulent. It looks like I won't be using the post for a while, which is a pity.
- robk 3y agoWell after the first time you just ignore the post cards wouldn't you? Easy way to handle returns too for sellers who can't cancel an order.
- ryukoposting 3y agoI'll defer to Occam's Razor and say that the Mail probably has a machine that's a bit buggy or imperfect. The US Postal Service processed 116 billion parcels in 2023[1]. If they had counterfeit stamp detectors that gave false positives 0.0001% of the time, that's still 116,000 bogus fines per year. And the engineers might have no way to reproduce the glitch, because it's so improbable. [1]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/320234/mail-volume-of-the-usps/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/320234/mail-volume-of-th...
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 3y agoIt's not a fine - you are not going to jail for not paying it.
- karaterobot 3y agoWhat's interesting to me is that the meaning of 'counterfeit' is being shifted. Counterfeit does not mean actually counterfeit, it means 'we couldn't process this stamp', which is a different thing altogether. I guess that either the Royal Mail's system is failing to read the bar code correctly, or it's encountering a bar code it's already seen before, and assuming it must be malicious. But in the latter case, there's no basis for saying the second use of the code is the counterfeit and not the first. That is, apart from doing actual forensic analysis on the stamp, which my guess is they are not doing—not in every case at least. If someone called me a counterfeiter, or even just said I was benefiting from counterfeiting, I'd be pretty angry. Especially if I found out they were accusing me without any evidence, without doing any diligence beforehand, and possibly as a consequence of their own error.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoI think you're nailing it--some black hat has figured out the encoding and is making fake stamps. Same as gift card draining.
- antifa 3y agoWouldn't surprise me if the "encoding" was just unencrypted UUIDs.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoThat would mean there's no encoding to crack, but it could still be going on if it's an inside job. Someone has access somewhere in the production process, notes valid codes. Could be a camera hidden somewhere.
- cyanydeez 3y agoReally sounds more like Mafia interdiction of good stamps and replacement
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wkat4242 3y agoIf this is really such a huge problem, the solution seems simple: simply let every mailbox scan the stamp before accepting the letter. For parcels this is being done already at the drop off point. The mailbox could verify the stamp barcode and refuse it if it's invalid, or require a simple contactless payment when no stamp (or an invalid one) is present. Problem solved. It would also be handy because you don't need to keep stamps in stock for that once off time you need to post something. Of course this tech hasn't existed for most of the life of the postal system but it does now. So why not do that? Fining the recipient who had nothing to do with the alleged crime in question is a bit disingenious. It's something that was unavoidable in the past but not now.