21 ms·
UV-K5 is the most hackable handheld ham radio yet
- noodlesUK 3y agoOne thing that I picked up on the spec sheet there which you shouldn't really have in a ham radio is a scrambler. I don't know if they really mean something like DTS/CTCSS which isn't actually encryption, but the word encryption shows up in the user manual, though this might just be a troubled translation. I'm curious if anyone who has one of these has any further clarity on what exactly that feature is.
- thrtythreeforty 3y agoIt's "voice inversion" [1] which conceptually is just flipping the baseband signal's spectrum around a mutually-agreed upon frequency, which serves as the key. The resulting audio is difficult to understand. The UV-K5 is only capable of selecting a single key frequency; more clever schemes will have some sort of rolling code/hopping. This is separate from CTCSS/DCS which this radio also supports, and is not a method for obscuring meaning. You are correct that it is illegal to use on ham frequencies (which can't obscure meaning), but I wanna say it's legal to use on FRS. Of course, this radio is not type-certified for FRS, so technically that would also be illegal (although many people don't care so much about type-certification for FRS). You are correct, it has no completely legal use on this particular radio. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voice_inversion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voice_inversion
- thereddaikon 3y agoIt could be a mistranslation and just refer to DTS/CTCSS. The cpu isn't powerful enough to implement real AES encryption and the datasheet doesn't mention a hardware crypto module. It could be an inversion scrambler, that's not difficult to implement in software and even if it doesn't have that stock someone could implement it. But scramblers have limited utility now. They are really only useful to annoy others, they are trivial to defeat. Undocumented encryption capabilities are also not unheard of with Chinese made ham radios either. Seems the FCC really only cares when people make a menace of themselves and draw their attention.
- AnarchismIsCool 3y agoPeople should be able to have encryption if they want it. The rules are absolutely unenforceable either way and there isn't actually any drawback. I'm a ham but most hams like to freak out about it because they think it'll cause companies to suddenly start using ham bands with impunity. The reality is, we need to enforce the existing rules about IDing in the clear periodically and then send whatever you want after that. You already can't decode most of the common digital modes without significant effort because they rely on proprietary vocoders so it's not like encryption would change anything. Cue hams being angry:
- threemux 3y agoTo be fair there are a large number of people that think the AMBE vocoders should be removed from the ham bands too. Personally I don't think they run afoul of the rules since the intent is not to obscure meaning. I think encryption is a terrible idea for amateur radio not because of companies doing things (they have ample land mobile allocations), but because it would be filled with cryptoshit scams in no time at all. I know of at least one RF-based cryptocurrency already. I'd also be worried about high speed traders on the HF bands since they're already trying to get licenses in the shortwave broadcast bands as it is. Not to mention I've yet to hear of a legit use case for encryption in the amateur bands that isn't served just as well by other licensed (and licensed-by-rule) services.
- AnarchismIsCool 3y agoMy belief is that the core purpose of ham radio is experimentation, so playing with modern protocols, modulation schemes and techniques is really important for it to remain relevant in the future. It can't forever exist as an HF/VHF AM/FM service forever. The future is AES/RSA, DSSS/CSS, internet access, and mobile mesh systems. All that said, if we went to allowing it with a cleartext ID, how do you think the crypto scams would defeat that in a scalable way?
- wiml 3y agoPeople can use encryption all they want. They just have to do it in some part of the spectrum that wasn't explicitly set aside for more "open" kinds of communication. Use the ISM bands, or get a license for commercial spectrum. It's really not a big restriction.
- ShakataGaNai 3y agohttps://youtu.be/1dt6ykstvOo?si=itGvWonj4MPQaSrq&t=384 https://youtu.be/1dt6ykstvOo?si=itGvWonj4MPQaSrq&t=384 Mentions that it's a basic scrambler. I doubt a $30 radio has a chip powerful enough for real-time (proper) encryption.
- briandw 3y agoThe website and manual mention "10 groups of scrambled voice encryption". They don't specify what this is actually doing. I've always wondered what it would take to make a really good encrypted coms system using one of these. However my understanding is that encrypted transmission on HAM is illegal.
- thereddaikon 3y agoUsing encryption on ham bands is illegal yes. You can use it on commercial bands if you buy a license from the FCC and ISM (common 2.4ghz/5Ghz) is mostly fair game as well. The practical reality is people are probably getting away with abusing it because the FCC is not omniscient and has limited resources. For an individual to draw the ire of the FCC they need to make a nuisance of themselves. Occasionally you hear of people getting arrested for using illegal cell jammers and the like. I can't recall hearing of someone getting caught using encryption. For something like this to really get a crackdown you would need a watershed event like RC aircraft had with cheap drones. The point where very capable hardware became extremely cheap and accessible to people who know nothing about the hobby. The RC aircraft community effectively self policed for decades because the bar for entry was high enough that anyone getting involved had to engage with the community. Drones changed that. And the FAA had to step in and regulate. I think we are getting close with cheap Chinese radios. But even Baofengs still require programming and educating yourself. Devices like the flipper zero are far more damaging. Even though they are limited in their capabilities, they make it trivial for the user to make a nuisance of themselves in ways that are hard to ignore. Its probably a matter of time until a cheap radio hits Amazon that does everything for you and permits non hobbyists to ruin everything. Imagine something as capable as a HackRF but as easy to use as an iPhone. Then we have problems.
- reaperman 3y agoAssuming there was aggressive enforcement against it, could someone “get away” with encrypted transmission sent in low-power alongside high-power unencrypted transmissions? Like would a well-encrypted stream look indistinguishable to a bit of noise from a low-quality transceiver?
- sparrish 3y agoIt's not terribly useful yet but I like where we're headed. Needs a beefier CPU and more memory. I'm going to buy a few more to help signal to manufacturers that this is the right direction.
- topspin 3y ago> Needs a beefier CPU and more memory The MCU is $0.21 at quantity on Alibaba. Make it a whole $0.50 and they'd really have something. Kind of a shame.
- cjk2 3y agoPretty cool but is the TX / LPF still shitty? The cheaper radios usually are a real miss on this front.
- marssaxman 3y agoSounds excellent! I suppose I'll buy one.
- trelane 3y agoFor USD28? Oh yeah. :)
- Rebelgecko 3y agoIs there a legit way to use these without a Ham license? I sometimes ski in areas with bad cell service and it would be neat to have an alternative. I've seen portable CB radios but they're on the pricier side
- trelane 3y agoYou can always listen. It's transmitting that requires a license. Possibly also the modding as well.
- trelane 3y agoIt's probably pretty easy for anyone here to get Technician, and probably General. I'd expect a large number could get Extra, and probably in one sitting. So you're right, you could use ham radio, but it does require a license, but it's probably not hard to get. Also, if you've an emergency, technically whatever you need to do to get help is fine. But it had better be a life and death emergency. Especially if you end up taking over the radio to a government agency, e.g. FAA or DoD.
- kstrauser 3y ago> It's probably pretty easy for anyone here to get Technician, and probably General. Yep. If you're reading this, you probably have the technical background to pass the Technician exam pretty easily. A big chunk of the exam is stuff you learned in the physics class you probably had to take along the way. The rest is largely about specific regulations, like the power limit at this frequency is X, and don't build a tower more than Y tall within Z of airport. If you can remember "frequency * wavelength = speed of light" and "watts = volts * amps", you could probably get a passing score on the technical part of it without studying in advance.
- MandieD 3y agoMost of the rest of the Technician exam is what is the absolute minimum you need to know about Part 97 to avoid disrupting your neighbors' radio reception and/or keep the FCC from knocking on your door.
- geerlingguy 3y agoAnd... I just bought one. It's under the threshold for impulse buy to fuel the hobby. Hopefully it doesn't sit in the box for too long, I would love to hack away at it and see what else it can do. I would love more manufacturers to open up the firmware on devices like these. Leave default safeguards in place from the factory, but allow tinkering. Cheap, hackable stuff helps get new people interested in radio, especially if it can be managed using tools people might already be familiar with like WebSerial.
- AnarchismIsCool 3y agoPeople stress about the safeguards too much. If you run around trying to jam gps, airband, or cellular you'll get your pp slapped pretty hard. If you go off and experiment with random other stuff without making too much noise, literally nobody cares.
- dogleash 3y agoyea, it's possible to loose perspective on how much people can just go out and do in life, and how after-the-fact most of the systems that prevent it are. It seems like there is a predisposition to that perspective shift for people who spend all day working on little boxes that are the one area of society where relentless permissions and control are ruthlessly and untiringly micromanaged to high heaven. There's a lot of fatalism that after the fact remedies are impossible if something was done with a computer, even when the actions in question are performed by known parties that comply with legal bounds.
- wkat4242 3y agoIt's not just about getting caught. Many of us hams try to cause as little interference to others as a matter of honour and pride in our hobby.
- kps 3y agoI just ordered one too, just because of the hackability. (I will likely never transmit with it, since I already have a radio with a better radio.)
- crims0n 3y agoReally impressed with the custom firmware people are developing for this radio. The one I am on now is written by egzumer and even comes with a spectrum analyzer. Unfortunately, the radio itself is about what you would expect from a $30 import. The frontend easily overloads, and the harmonics on transmit are way outside what the FCC permits. Still, as a gateway into ham radio, it is one hell of a value proposition.
- topspin 3y ago> way outside what the FCC permits Confirmed. And yet it has an FCC ID from early 2023... https://fcc.report/FCC-ID/XBPUV-K5 https://fcc.report/FCC-ID/XBPUV-K5
- drmpeg 3y agoThe FCC doesn't test the transmitter. The device is only tested to comply with Part 15 unintentional radiation rules (just like any other consumer electronics device).
- jcrawfordor 3y agoHave you been able to perform testing? I think the quality of these Chinese radios has actually improved quite a bit over the years, and the reports I see of testing UV-K5s shows them within FCC limits (well within for 2M, closer to the limit for 70cm). The situation is much worse if you transmit outside of those bands, but, well, that's not really what it's designed for anyway. You have to be cautious with harmonics reports on these radios because a lot of people seem to try to evaluate them with an SDR... and they are pretty much guaranteed to overload the SDR's front end and cause all kinds of intermodulation that people mistake for emissions of the radio. I wish ARRL still put more testing pieces in QST because it's hard to know what to make of the testing reports you see online. People end up finding all kinds of different results, and I'm sure there's variation between units, but it also seems like there's a big aspect of... random internet people unsurprisingly having inconsistent test setups.
- transcriptase 3y ago
- kloch 3y agoSomeone told me once that Beofang uses the open source DSD (digital speech decoder) package in their scanners/radios. Can anyone confirm this?
- stavros 3y agoI was about to buy one of these (of course), when I noticed that the K6 exists. Which one is the best one to buy to hack around with?
- thrtythreeforty 3y agoThe K6 has a USB-C port for charging. Of course, they bungled it and it doesn't have the CC resistors to trigger PD chargers, so you need an A-to-C cable, or some soldering skillz. Other than that, they are reported to be identical hardware.
- thesh4d0w 3y agoMy K5 also has a usb-c port for charging. AFAIK they are identical except for slightly different housing.
- _JamesA_ 3y agoAre you sure about that? I just ordered the UV-K5 from Amazon sold by Quansheng and it is labeled as having USB C charging. There's also a third party seller with an item description of "UV-K6 UV-K5(8)". That listing seems fishy. I don't see a "UV-K6" listed on the Quansheng web site [1]. EDIT: After more research it looks like the UV-K5(8) is also known as the UV-K6 [2]. I'm curious which model I receive. [1]: http://en.qsfj.com/products/?series=3 http://en.qsfj.com/products/?series=3 [2]: https://hagensieker.com/2024/03/12/quansheng-uv-k6-radio-review/ https://hagensieker.com/2024/03/12/quansheng-uv-k6-radio-rev...
- smarx007 3y agoUV-K5(8) is legit: http://en.qsfj.com/products/3268 http://en.qsfj.com/products/3268
- RockRobotRock 3y agoYes it has a usb-c port on it which you can charge with a type-a to type-c cable. The problem is that it violates the spec by omitting the resistor and you can't charge it with a c to c cable. That's where the frustration comes from.
- ericye16 3y agoJust checking: using a modded handset on ham frequencies with a ham license would still be perfectly legal, as long as you still abide by power/no-encoding rules right?
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoProvided you are broadcasting within bands you have license for, under the power limits for that band/license, and it's not encrypted... yea, you're good. Historically the FCC hasn't care about modding radios, until people start doing illegal shit with them... like broadcasting FM on AM Airband freq's
- gglitch 3y agoMy understanding is that the purpose of amateur licensing is to facilitate and encourage experimentation and learning, up to and including people building their own hardware; that's why the rules are about how your machine affects the world.
- kstrauser 3y agoThat's exactly right. I'm licensed by the FCC to build my own radio from a bucket of spare parts if I want to, and I can do whatever I want with it as long as I stay inside their rules. The RF I generate is what I'm responsible for. How I get there is up to me.
- ubj 3y agoThis looks interesting. A common complaint about the Baofengs is that they transmit significant unwanted harmonics outside the intended frequency. Do these radios have this issue as well? I'm very excited about the prospect of more radios that can be easily programmed with mainstream languages such as Python / Rust / C++. Hopefully this becomes a stronger trend going forward.
- justin66 3y ago> Like Baofeng’s 5R, Quansheng’s K5 as a radio transceiver is fine. In other words, its output is so dirty the FCC would ban it if they were paying attention?
- nimbius 3y ago"for over a decade, Baofeng has been the name in Chinese handhelds." well, its certainly A name...as an amateur extra and a VEC, i tried...i really tried to love these radios. - my first baofeng couldnt hit the repeater across the street from me. - my second baofeng arrived with a flashlight i couldnt turn off, and died an hour later. - my final baofeng (a gift) died during a contest and couldnt even hit a reference repeater. thankfully i was only really using it for a flashlight in a camping tent. ...but i cant. these things are hot garbage for preppers and gun nuts.
- sitzkrieg 3y agoive an bf-f8hp that outperforms kenwood ht everytime i compare, with stock antenna and all. shrug
- xnyan 3y agoApparently the newer ones are significantly improved. https://forums.radioreference.com/threads/baofeng-spectral-purity-imd-testing.461065/ https://forums.radioreference.com/threads/baofeng-spectral-p...
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoFWIW the Baofeng radio I tested, a BF-F8HP circa 2017, was (barely) compliant with Part 97 spurious emission requirements.
- chriscjcj 3y agoYour assertions are applicable to early UV-5R models. However, some have demonstrated that more modern iterations have made substantial improvements. https://forums.radioreference.com/threads/baofeng-spectral-purity-imd-testing.461065/ https://forums.radioreference.com/threads/baofeng-spectral-p...
- teeray 3y agoI wonder if DMR, D-Star, or Fusion can get added to this
- tjohns 3y agoAlmost certainly not. The usual challenges here are: 1. The codec is computationally expensive (at least by embedded-device standards). Often this is handled by a dedicated ASIC. 2. The waveform needed for DMR (TDMA 4-FSK) or D-STAR (narrowband GMSK) isn't something this radio's hardware is built to generate. The RF chip in the UV-K5 is a BK4819, which does have some limited F2D+F1W FSK data capability. Anecdotally it sounds like it's limited to 2-FSK though. You might be able to get APRS text messaging / AX.25 packet radio working. I'm still waiting for somebody to build a truly hackable SDR-based HT that can be programmed with custom waveforms.
- mfro 3y agoAPRS is doable with custom firmware. I use this custom version of the egzumer firmware https://github.com/kamilsss655/uv-k5-firmware-custom https://github.com/kamilsss655/uv-k5-firmware-custom but I don't believe it makes any changes to APRS functionality compared to the repo it's forked from. I believe I also came across a repo with a dedicated APRS firmware being worked on but can't find it at this time.
- alexalx666 3y agoIt's kinda sad that the state of art moved to China, Bao what? Give me a Kenwood or something
- CraigJPerry 3y agoHave you seen the price of the new kenwood th-75? I just sold my th-d74 to a chap in Moldova of all places and that was a really fun handy for all the extra toys on it but I will NOT be getting the 75!
- fourteenfour 3y ago~$750 for anyone else who was wondering.
- vbezhenar 3y agoIs it hackable?
- CraigJPerry 3y agoI don’t think so. By default the feature set is pretty comprehensive though: RX coverage from 100khz through 512mhz with native ssb, cw filter, am and of course nfm & wfm. GPS plus various features on top of that like track logging. Dstar. A packet TNC built in. It exposed IF over usb for use with an SDR. I used it for satellite work a lot of the time (since tx was limited to vhf & uhf), it didn’t have full duplex like the 2 generations prior kenwood which I forget the model number of.
- amatecha 3y agoLong before people were modding these I got one for $20 CAD from Aliexpress. The speaker only works intermittently, requiring me to push on the case to get it to work (I guess there's a weak solder joint or something). I contacted the seller and of course just got infinite runaround. Either way, "buyer beware", these things are insanely cheap for a reason. Basically a dollar-store HT. :P
- sedatk 3y agoJust buy it on Amazon for $10 more, and you're good to go.
- mschuster91 3y agoAll that adds is fast shipping because someone with an alphabet soup brand name upfronted a bit of money to get a container load of them shipped from China to an Amazon warehouse.
- sedatk 3y agoIt adds no-hassle returns.
- amatecha 3y agoUh, on Amazon Canada, the Quansheng UV-K5 is being sold for $125.99 heh
- transcriptase 3y agoOrder straight from Aliexpress. You can get one for around ~$30 CAD all in depending on the day. And believe it or not the shipping only takes a couple weeks.
- amatecha 3y agoThat's exactly what I did! Thus my original post lol.. I was refuting the parent post's suggestion to "just buy it on Amazon" as if the Amazon return policy is worth paying $100 extra for a $20 radio haha
- mikewarot 3y agoI had to look around to find a datasheet[1] for the BK4819 which is the heart of this rig, but it appears that there are I/Q outputs on receive, and possibly I/Q inputs on transmit internally, so it's an SDR, and not limited to FM only. The low output power will likely restrict it to line of site, but it's an interesting substrate on which to work. [1] https://touchardinforeseau.servehttp.com/f4kmn/f4kmn/FRANCAIS/AVANCE/MATERIELS/UV_K5/1703012255BK4819.PDF https://touchardinforeseau.servehttp.com/f4kmn/f4kmn/FRANCAI...
- lxgr 3y agoIsn't UHF/VHF (edit: pretty much) always line-of-sight? Edit: Can the downvotes please explain where I'm wrong? It's a genuine question!
- rfthrowaway2 3y agoTropospheric ducting is a thing... [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tropospheric_propagation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tropospheric_propagation
- lxgr 3y agoSure, but is that a thing you'd be able to (and want to) do using a small handheld radio? It's not like HF where ionospheric reflections are pretty much the biggest appeal of the band.
- rfthrowaway2 3y agoPlenty of use-cases, unsure what you're arguing against. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmNo1TX1E3Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmNo1TX1E3Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hn7_CZurV7Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hn7_CZurV7Y https://www.reddit.com/r/amateurradio/comments/jcvv5g/did_some_2m_dxing_on_my_5_watt_handheld_friday/ https://www.reddit.com/r/amateurradio/comments/jcvv5g/did_so...
- 3y ago
- lormayna 3y agoLooking forward that someone will port FT8 to this devices. At the moment you need a phone or a PC to tx/rx in FT8.
- sitzkrieg 3y agothis is what im looking forward to, too. ive even started making some hardware around digital modes so this might make a cheaper frontend + filter investment lol
- gh02t 3y agoDoes it have the hardware? Per the article the CPU and available flash memory are super limited.
- ianburrell 3y agoFT8 would be pointless. FT8 uses SSB which this can't do. Doing FT8 on FM is a waste of bandwidth and low-signal. FT8 is usually done on HF since that has long-distance propagation and it is important to pick out tiny signals. People do FT8 on VHF but they use radios with SSB. The radio probably doesn't have the processing power for FT8. A Raspberry Pi 3 was struggling for me. Also, a big part of FT8 is choosing what to send and who to respond to, need a good display for that.
- crotho 3y ago[dead]
- lormayna 3y agoIt seems that there is a firmware doing SSB (I don't understand if it's real SSB or something emulated). Anyway, the radio chip of UV-K5 is able to manage distinct I-Q signal, so it just a matter of implementing SSB via software.
- ianburrell 3y agoSSB requires more sophisticated frontend than FM because the channel is smaller and reuqires less noise. There are HF radios that use a simple signal generator, but then need a complicated frontend to be able to received anything. The cheap SDR HF radios are $500 when SDR VHF handhelds are cheap like this one.
- le-mark 3y agoThis may not fit here but I’m going to ask if anyone knows; has anyone been using starlink phased array antenna s for point to point microwave communication? What would be fruitful search words for google to find out more? Thanks!
- raphman 3y agoI don't have any personal knowledge, but you might want to ask Oleg Kutkov - he has been reverse-engineering and repairing Starlink antennas for some time. https://olegkutkov.me/ https://olegkutkov.me/ https://twitter.com/olegkutkov https://twitter.com/olegkutkov
- semi-extrinsic 3y agoNot answering your question directly, but curious why you want to take on the significant endeavour to hack up something like this, when you can just buy e.g. a pair of Ubiquiti airFiber 5 and get 1 Gbps with >100km range?
- FourOnTheFloor 3y agoHow do they make it work on frequencies beyond its range? The diagram puts its range below the aviation band.
- _spduchamp 3y agoThese are listed $24 (Canadian) on aliexpress, with free shipping. How is that possible? I just can't get my head around how these can be so inexpensive. Wouldn't the materials cost more? Like really, can someone help explain the economics of how this works?
- chpatrick 3y agoElectronics are actually really cheap.
- AnarchismIsCool 3y agoThere are basically two main chips in there, one handles most of the RF chain, the other drives the display and handles button pushes. Both likely cost under a dollar each at volume. The vast majority of the other components are tiny passives that cost less than a cent each and are just for filtering and impedance matching. In terms of development costs, there is definitely skill in component selection and packaging, but generally speaking the main PCB could have been designed by a lot of EE grads. If you spend some time looking at it, in terms of sophistication it's barely a couple steps above a happy meal toy, but since nobody wants to make quality flexible use radios, this is what everyone ends up buying to experiment with.
- jhoechtl 3y agoIs Chinese software required? It might be just a booster rocket for Chinese spyware.
- squarefoot 3y agoAccording to the article, the radio can be reflashed using a browser, but if any suspicious software was needed for reflashing, it could anyway be run in a VM after setting the USB/serial port as pass through. To program frequencies and modes then one can use Chirp, which is Open source. https://chirpmyradio.com/projects/chirp/wiki/Home https://chirpmyradio.com/projects/chirp/wiki/Home
- rasz 3y agoYou have been conditioned by US corporations. Apple consumer electronic prices, TI microcontroller prices, Qualcomm/TI radio chip prices, Intel FPGA prices etc.
- Lwrless 3y agoI was surprised to see that it only costs around $14 in China, so I instantly ordered one. It would nicely fill the gap in VHF bands that are not supported by my Tecsun PL-365.
- eternityforest 3y agoWhat the community manages to do is amazing... but I still wonder why all these hackable devices use such low power chips. So many things on the market are basically just computers with specialized IO, but most of the firmware and MCUs don't reach the full potential of the rest of the hardware. A few extra dollars could add literally hundreds of features if they wanted.
- Sodman 3y agoThe product page linked at the top of the article boasts about voice encryption as a feature, but that's still very much illegal on ham radio bands in the US, right? Or is it just referring to CTCSS/DCS?
- jkingsman 3y agoThey do mean scrambling, and yes that's illegal on ham bands. CTCSS/DCS isn't encryption/scrambing, just in band signalling. You can listen to CTCSS/DCS with any radio even if they don't support it.
- wkat4242 3y agoToo bad this is not a DMR radio. Some other custom firmwares have been made for other radios, like the GD77: https://www.opengd77.com/ https://www.opengd77.com/ and the MD380 and similar: https://md380.org/ https://md380.org/ But as far as I know they are still just mods on the original firmware. And DMR is kinda a must-have now for hams. Analog activity is negligible now on the VHF/UHF bands, at least where I am. The "best" Chinese DMR radio seems to be the D878UVII but it's extremely expensive ($200 or more). By the way the Retevis RA79 seems to be the same radio. It's cheaper here on Amazon so I think I'll try that. Also, "Retevis" means "Ass fish" in my language so that's definitely a plus for me!