6 ms·
Inequality is a stupid measure. What matters is absolute poverty. If I have a comfortable standard of living, what do I care if Bill Gates has a million times m
by gadders 15y ago
Inequality is a stupid measure. What matters is absolute poverty. If I have a comfortable standard of living, what do I care if Bill Gates has a million times more money than me?
- njharman 15y agoFYI, we couldn't tax the super rich enough to end poverty let alone give everyone a comfortable living. Income equality is not about solving all problems. It's just trying to rectify one of the most egregious ones.
- baddox 15y agoYou may not care, and I certainly wouldn't care, but the desire for absolute socioeconomic equality is extremely common. There's a word for it: "egalitarianism." Egalitarianism is a fundamental principle behind many political systems, from socialism to modern American liberalism.
- matwood 15y agoIf I have a comfortable standard of living, what do I care if Bill Gates has a million times more money than me? Because people by their nature are jealous. Many people even hate when their friends do better than them for some reason.
- jules 15y agoYou'd think, but as it turns out, inequality has strong negative effects to the point that even the rich in an inequal country do worse than the more poor in a more equal country. TED talk about it: http://www.ted.com/talks/richard_wilkinson.html http://www.ted.com/talks/richard_wilkinson.html
- meej 15y agoI haven't seen either talk, but I am really curious now about why TED would post Wilkinson's talk but not Hanauer's, if they both address the subject income inequality.
- jules 15y agoFrom reading the transcript of Hanauer's, Wilkinson's talk is just way better. He has A LOT of actual data, in fact the whole talk is data, data, data, on obesity, happiness, violence & homocide, lifespan, infant mortality, trust, teenage pregnancy, addiction, child wellbeing, mental illness, highschool dropout, social mobility; all on a country level and on a US state level. He also shows that inequality is the problem and that GNP per capita hardly matters ... while Hanauer's talk is 99% rhetoric. Even though the message is roughly the same, Wilkinson's talk definitely is a lot more objective rather than subjective political assertions, so it's a lot harder to argue that he's simply pushing a political agenda.
- gadders 15y agoIs that an appeal to authority? Just because something is on TED, doesn't make it true. I'm sure you could find studies that disagree with this.
- jules 15y agoThat's not an appeal to authority. It's a link to information. If you manage to find any contradicting studies, please do post them here. That said, his data seems pretty solid, unless he's flat out lying (unlikely). Keep an open mind!
- anon1385 15y agoInequality of wealth means inequality of power. High levels of inequality mean a small number of people have vastly disproportionate power to shape society in their own interest, at the expense of the majority. Now whether or not you think that is a problem depends on whether you care about things like self determination, democracy and social justice.
- philwelch 15y agoRich people don't act as a cabal though. For every Koch there's a Soros. So while individual billionaires do have a lot of power, probably more than they should, it's still very strongly tempered by the mob, so to speak.
- dfc 15y agoYou think there is a one to one ratio between Koch and Soros type billionaires?
- philwelch 15y agoNot exactly, but then again the country is neither as libertarian as Koch would like or as progressive as Soros would like. And frankly, there are things that Koch and Soros probably agree on that aren't the status quo either, so how do you explain that? The fact is, there are as many viewpoints as there are billionaires, and that's what keeps them from forming a cabal. If you want to find someone who can form a cabal to bend the system for private profit, look for a corn farmer.
- dfc 15y agoWhy do corn farmers have more homogenous viewpoints than billionaires?
- MartinCron 15y agoCorn farmers all get their money in the same way. Billionaires? Not so much.
- chime 15y agoBecause he has million times more power than you, power over things you hold near and dear. It is fortunate that Gates/Buffett are using their influence for good but not everyone is doing the same.
- jlarocco 15y agoIf I can buy "power" over somebody then that's the problem, not the income inequality. Furthermore, I don't see how fixing the income inequality fixes the root problem there.
- anon1385 15y ago>I don't see how fixing the income inequality fixes the root problem there. It doesn't, but it might make the lives of millions of people better in the medium term, and possibly result in knock on legislative changes that give more power to working people: repeal of anti-labour laws and so on. Which makes further real change to the system more likely and possible. You will find many far left wing types have little interest in proposals to fiddle with the tax system, for the reasons you describe: it doesn't fix the real problem. And in a funny way it may well be against the interests of the proletariat: it prolongs the slow death of the current system. That doesn't mean the far left doesn't talk about income inequality of course, but they do so with a different aim: to increase awareness among the working class of their exploitation, with eventual revolutionary goals. People have been debating the relative merits of gradual reform/revolutionary change for a long time now…
- roel_v 15y agoYour position is correct, but nonetheless fails to account for human nature. It's all fine and dandy to have a system where, through 100% morally justified means, 1% holds all assets. Then you get an uprising of the other 99% and the whole country/system falls on its face. Morally, I don't agree with income redistribution for the sake of egalitarianism either; but pragmatically, one cannot but acknowledge its importance for the stability of a social system. And in the end, that trumps dogmatism.
- wvenable 15y agoThe issue is that a very small number of very wealthy people are holding onto a very large amount of money. Any money that isn't being used to buy, sell, or invest in something is effectively just taken right out of the economy. Everyone is poorer because this money is "gone" from the system. All this wealth is locked away as a number in a computer.
- Tycho 15y agoIf the money is in bank accounts, then it is contributing to the economy. One of the worst economic problems of recent years has actually been the lack of money just sitting in reserve to give the banks stability.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoI almost agree with this. Of course it's a very small percentage of US wealth that's literally sitting locked up doing nothing. Money in a bank is doing something, being lent out or invested somewhere. There's some wealth that's genuinely locked up, sitting in items that provide no utility for example. Say fine art locked in someone's vault or basement. But it's not all that much as a percentage. Where the bigger problem in recent years has been is all the wealth tied up in what is essentially sophisticated gambling mechanisms in the financial markets. Money tied up in ways that aren't providing any true value to the economy (mumbo jumbo justifications aside). I'd be all for rules that stopped that sort of thing with funds subject to public bailouts. Your own money, your own risk, fine go ahead. Your money but risk assumed by the government? No. No thanks.
- wvenable 15y ago> If the money is in bank accounts, then it is contributing to the economy. It is, but only in the most limited fashion. Money sitting in bank accounts is doing very little to improve unemployment. Buying physical goods would be much better for that. > One of the worst economic problems of recent years has actually been the lack of money just sitting in reserve to give the banks stability. In a way, that's true although I wouldn't frame it that way. The banks could make loans and then sell those loans as investments -- they didn't need any money on hand for that. Increasing deposits, for example, wouldn't change anything.
- eli_gottlieb 15y agoHalf the taxpayers of the United States make less than $32k/year. How's that a comfortable standard of living?
- gadders 15y agoBut if you are saying $32k is not a comfortable standard of living, then that is a statement about absolute poverty. $32k would still not be a comfortable standard whether Bill Gates had earnt $1million or $1billion.
- ClHans 15y agoYou, as an individual, may not care. Unfortunately, historical evidence and social science evidence suggests that (bearing in mind that you as an individual may not care) when income inequality grows too great, other parts of society begin to suffer and eventually break down. This even affects things like the average health outcomes for the people living in the unequal the society. There's a strong correlation that indicates that poorer health outcomes, higher crime, poorer standard of living all go hand in hand with greater income inequality. Again, you may not care, for your own sake, but the country is a fair bit larger than you, and this problem does affect us all, whether we care or not.
- grn 15y agoI'd say it's the other way round: the greater the suffering of a society (poor health outcomes, higher crime etc.) the greater the inequality. Your ability to protect yourself grows with your income. Therefore those who earn less are more likely to loose which widens inequality.