7 ms·
Richard Serra, minimalist sculptor whose steel creations awed viewers, has died
- windowshopping 3y agoI for one have never heard of this artist. Sometimes I feel like there's a world of contemporary art that exists entirely apart from the layers of society I am exposed to.
- browningstreet 3y agoThis was a fairly prominent moment in his raise to the “mainstream”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tilted_Arc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tilted_Arc
- twoodfin 3y agoEveryone’s taste is their own thing, but if you haven’t exposed yourself to the world of contemporary art, I’d highly recommend giving it a try if only to see how it bounces off you. In my experience, great modern art creates an indelible impression that puts to shame all but the most thoughtful artifacts of our (largely “disposable by design”) popular culture. I distinctly recall wandering through one of Serra’s oxidized marvels at the Bilbao Guggenheim, just before becoming mesmerized by Ragnar Kjartansson’s “The Visitors”—now 9 years ago. It’s the penetration into memory and the deeper layers of the subconscious that really distinguishes the best contemporary artists and works.
- eichin 3y agoI had to dig a bit, but MIT's "Transparent Horizons" (local description: "is neither") turns out to be Louise Nevelson's work, and "The Great Sail" is a Calder; turns out MIT didn't end up with any of Serra's work in the Big Hunk Of Metal genre. (On the other hand, unlike Serra, as far as I know none of Nevelson or Calder's installations actually killed anyone...)
- fumeux_fume 3y agoI went to a public university and walked pass/thru/around one of his works nearly every day on my way to classes for four years. It’s actually not a world as far removed as you might think.
- acjohnson55 3y agoIt's unfortunate that you're downvoted, because I can relate. I knew nothing of the contemporary art world until I found myself working at an art marketplace and media startup. For a few years, I was immersed in it. When I left, I wrote in my farewell note that I felt like I gained a whole new layer of perception of my surroundings. I connected with art installations. I sought out galleries and museums when traveling. This is how I became acquainted with Richard Serra's work. His pieces are so monumental and immersive that when you encounter his work elsewhere, you immediately know it, whether or not you remember his name. So I don't blame you for not feeling a connection. But you might find it worthwhile to invest in learning about the art world. If you're interested, IMO, the single best thing you can do is go on the little scheduled guided tours at museums. The docents (volunteer guides) are great at making the art relatable.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Serra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Serra
- 0x6A75616E 3y agoThose are some interesting pieces. It'd be fun to create a game where players need to guess between "Art Installation or Random Pile of Trash"
- ordu 3y agoOne cannot guess with post-modernism. Classicism has fixed standards of beauty, you can measure them looking at a piece of an art and grade them. The follow ups like Renaissance art tried different standards of beauty, but the idea was the same: you measure level of art looking at the art. But post-modernism had shown then you can make a pile of trash and it might work like an art installation. The really interesting question is if any pile of trash can serve as an art installation? Or maybe you need a pile with some special characteristics? If so then what are those characteristics?
- optionalsquid 3y agoMy first thought was artworks like those of Tim Noble and Sue Webster: Literal piles of garbage in several cases, but also much more than that. https://www.artworksforchange.org/portfolio/tim-noble-and-sue-webster/ https://www.artworksforchange.org/portfolio/tim-noble-and-su...
- 082349872349872 3y ago> what are those characteristics? That's easy: does the particular pile of trash generate any interesting discussion? (for the category-heads: what functors are there into or out of the pile of trash?) EDIT: we have AI generated art; do we have AI art critics yet?
- cutemonster 3y ago> does the particular pile of trash generate any interesting discussion? Then, trash created by a celebrity, is art? Because knowing that that person did that ugly thing, generates discussions (like "wow what did s/he think!? Is that the best they can do?")
- aabhay 3y agoSad to see the other comments are so contemptuous. When you see one of his pieces in person, you will gain an immediate appreciation for what he was trying to do. Essentially Richard Serra’s iron sculptures were playing with the architecture of the spaces they were placed in. Turning an open plaza into a twisty maze and so forth. As far as art is concerned, one of my favorite people, and I’m glad he did what he did.
- llm_trw 3y ago>Sad to see the other comments are so contemptuous. There are literally no comments in this thread which are negative. I have no idea why those who control the art world feel the need to present themselves as marginalized.
- aabhay 3y agoYes. I pull the strings on the art world and have complete control over everything but this comment thread.
- paganel 3y agoNot contemptuous , but this guy’s “art” is the type of thing that has helped alienate the common man and drove him into whichever political hands rejected these neoliberal-inspired creations. Also, props to Serra for doing some “art” stuff for Qatar in the 2010s, the money was probably very good (which brings me to my above point).
- outop 3y agoPretty sure the existence of art made from large pieces of steel isn't the thing that "helped alienate the common man".
- paganel 3y agoAlienating art has been a staple of many past social revolutions, the “made up of steel” thing (like in this case) is just a secondary issue. But I get this guy’s appeal and I also get why his audience wouldn’t want to see it that way, it is what is, nothing that the two of us can do about it other than trying to talk over an over-increasing socio-economic wall.
- frostburg 3y agoMy favourite of his pieces is Open Field Vertical Elevations, which incidentally was erected in the fields outside the residence of a collector who also recently passed, near where I live in the middle of nowhere, Tuscany. In person, viewed while immersed in its necessary context of landscape, it is visually powerful and moving. It is also a link to the greater world outside our narrow vales and to a cultural history of patronage of the arts. I understand that the attitudes here are mostly skeptical of contemporary art, but it really goes too far in most cases. Serra wasn't Hirst.
- failrate 3y agoThese sculptures are awesome. Literally. Walking next to one is a literally awe inspiring experience. They just seem so big and imposing standing next to one.
- ok_dad 3y agoIt makes sense he grew up in a shipyard town, big ships are imposing like his art. I’m not sure it was nearly formative, but I feel like he must have been going for something similar to walking through a shipyard, with all of the large ships but also the buildings and equipment and cargo are huge!
- ajmurmann 3y agoThe Guggenheim museum in Bilbao has an entire wing dedicated to a giant Richard Serra installation that's one with the architectural space it's in. For anyone visiting the Basque country, I cannot recommend visiting the exhibit strongly enough.
- bamboozled 3y agoSaw it once, it was incredible. I didn’t really know what it was when I first walked into the room and kind of got sucked into it.
- Daub 3y agoThis is a simple yet effective description of the unmediated art experience. At the end of the day, art is about standing-in-front-of, and experiencing, THINGS.
- relativeadv 3y agoAnd if Spain is too far for some American southerners, there are a couple of Serra pieces in the Chattanooga, TN sculpture park. I was surprised to run into them while I lived there.
- gyomu 3y agoThe installation he had at SFMoMa, in the side entrance, was really great. The space now just feels naked without it.
- augustocallejas 3y agoIn 2002, Caltech students rejected one of his pieces, which would have been installed on the Beckman Lawn: https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2002-may-22-me-caltech22-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2002-may-22-me-calte... https://campuspubs.library.caltech.edu/1826/1/2002_05_20_103_27.pdf https://campuspubs.library.caltech.edu/1826/1/2002_05_20_103...
- stock_toaster 3y ago> For a week, I considered chartreuse seriously.
- huytersd 3y agoThese are so large. How do you even go about bending such large sheets of steel in unconventional ways.
- tedd4u 3y agoBig machines: "… we use very large machines first used to build battleships in the Second World War. People really hadn't explored the potential for what steel could be in terms of its variabilities and elasticity. It's only recently been explored by a few people." From: https://www.moma.org/audio/playlist/236/3052 https://www.moma.org/audio/playlist/236/3052
- vonnik 3y agoSF native. Brother of defense attorney Tony Serra who defended Shrimp Boy and the Ghost Ship guy. Agree with comment below that his works are best appreciated by walking in their shadow.
- asveikau 3y agoThe old James Woods film True believer is based on Tony Serra.
- gdubs 3y agoSerra's work is just one of those things that completely changed my world. I don't know how old I was, but walking through his pieces made me realize that art could be larger than life. Truly a giant of the 20th century.
- coisasdavida 3y agoMy visit to his stuff in Bilbao was amazing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ignormies 3y agoStumbled upon 'Fulcrum' yesterday near Liverpool Station in London without knowing anything about it. Incredibly impressive piece of art that made me stop and admire it for a few minutes. Watching the relatively minuscule people shuffle by at the base of the _enormous_ sheets of twisted steel was fascinating. Yesterday I knew nothing about the artist but the moment I saw this article title I thought, "wait that piece had to have been this guy." I'm going to have to seek out more of his work.
- Oarch 3y agoIt's reasonably hidden, lots of redevelopment work going on around that sculpture at the moment. Hopefully the setting improved a bit.
- Daub 3y agoNo one here has talked about the number of lives that Serra's work has claimed/ruined. So far: one death and two serious injuries. Details here: https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/shortcuts/2018/aug/21/a-menace-to-life-and-limb-the-artworks-that-have-injured-and-killed https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/shortcuts/2018/aug/... From this link: > Richard Serra’s steel sculptures feel the most dangerous of all. They tower over you, surround you, menace you. The danger is not illusory. Serra’s rolled steel is dangerous, especially for workers who have to install it. In 1971, a contractor called Raymond Johnson was killed during the installation of a Serra sculpture. In 1988, two workers were seriously injured while deinstalling one of his pieces. We were taught to hate his work at school. Big, heavy, industrial... 'big willy' art I remember one lecturer calling it. However, I always liked his work, largely as a result of seeing it in person at the Tate Modern. I could feel the literal eight of his work as I walked through it: heavy sheets of metal balanced against each other. Peril was part of the price of admission. The death/injuries victims were all art technicians: people tasked with installing the work. I used to work with such people, and their job is a fascinating one. I remember helping to scan a building with ground scanning radar in order to determine if it was strong enough to hold Anselm Kiefer's library of huge lead books: https://www.wikiart.org/en/anselm-kiefer/the-high-priestess-zweistromland-1989 https://www.wikiart.org/en/anselm-kiefer/the-high-priestess-... It took a team of four men and a forklift truck just to turn the pages of these books.
- CPLX 3y agoI’m not sure it’s fair to describe something as “dangerous” and as having “killed” people when you’re talking about technicians hired to safely move or install something. By that definition pretty much any object is “dangerous.”
- kibwen 3y agoRight, in order to fairly describe this man's artworks as any more dangerous than average based on their entire functional lifecycle we'd need to evaluate, for example, how many people were killed while producing the marble blocks used by sculptors such as Michaelangelo, or how many people died as a side effect of exposure to toxic compounds (e.g. cinnabar (red), cobalt (blue), lead (white)) while producing pigments for painters such as Rembrandt.
- ripe 3y agoLove the article. I knew nothing about this artist, but after reading this, I am curious to see his works. Gives lots of details including pictures. The article does talk about the hazards of installing these giant steel sculptures and that workers have died and been injured.
- da-bacon 3y agoMy favorite Serra story is when he was hired to build a sculpture by Caltech. In typical fashion he decided he wanted to build a giant wall across one of the few remaining wide open green spaces on campus, the lawn adjacent to Beckman. In a nod to Caltech he called it “Vectors”. The students were not happy. This was great lawn to just lay out, play frisbee, etc. A few days after this blew up in the student news, a large wall showed up right in front of the main coffee shop, the Red Door. That was a nice space with beautiful trees and tables (ah, the Southern California weather). The wall was right in the middle of this and blocked off the thoroughfare. The wall was called “Eigenvectors” and that word was painted on it, along with a ton of other linear algebra formulas. I remember walking by and going “holy shit is that the Moore-Penrose inverse?!” In the end the students won, the sculpture was never built.
- Daub 3y agoThanks for the story,. I love Serra's work, but I'm glad this piece was never built. For artists of his generation, the thoughts/feelings of the Hoi polloi were of little regard. A space was their stage, dam the little people.
- cutemonster 3y agoSeems he got to build one eigenvector at least - the last photo in the article, the Tilted Arc. Across a public square, everyone needs to walk around the eigenvector. I had a reaction similar to that of the students But beautiful small figures :-)
- fsckboy 3y ago> the thoughts/feelings of the Hoi polloi were of little regard pedantic language note: "hoi" means "the" in greek. So, the thoughts/feelings of hoi polloi can be ignored just like that.
- salomon812 3y agoI was a undergrad senior at Caltech during that time, and as luck would have it, I was taking an art history course. Caltech humanities courses tended to have visiting professors that would come for a single night a week. I mentioned to my professor that I did not think Serra's piece should be considered art and it turned into a debate that spanned several weeks. At first, I was worried I was taking a harsh stance but the professor was so excited that Caltech students took an interest in art and we happily debated for a while. I told her I hated Serra's Tilted Arc but conceded I did like his Sea Level and The Matter of Time. While I was not one of the students that put up Eigenvectors, I would have gladly helped if I realized they were doing it. I argued to my professor that Eigenvectors was art because it stood for something and my professor could not have been happier about the situation. Another protest piece that occurred was dumping a bunch of indoor and outdoor furniture on the very lawn that was going to host Vectors and then placing a sign on it that read something along the lines of "Invoice: Qty 1 art installation. Price: $1,000,000" in protest of the amount Caltech was going to pay Serra. If I recall, while the students won, Caltech never admitted it was due to the outcry. The official statement argued that a geological report of the area deemed it unsuitable for such a heavy art piece. I just looked online and it looks like they ripped up the entire lawn in a last few years to create another building and parking lot.
- erickhill 3y agoI've always admired his large outdoor work "Wake" at the Olympic Sculpture Park in Seattle. I have very fond memories of my kids peeking around the massive, wave-like walls of steel.