3 ms·
> there's little point in enforcing a separation between users and root I agree but I don't think that's fundamental. It's pointless on Linux because any attac
by IshKebab 3y ago
> there's little point in enforcing a separation between users and root
I agree but I don't think that's fundamental. It's pointless on Linux because any attacker can simply alias `sudo` to something and wait.
But I can imagine a modern desktop OS where there's a useful admin account. Windows is pretty close. Much better than Linux on that front.
- PlutoIsAPlanet 3y agoEven on a Linux desktop OS with a single user, it's still a security risk as it skips over a last line of defence. If a Chrome bug is found that allows web pages to arbitrary code execution, it can be chained with an exploit like this to infect more than just the user account, potentially, depending on the computer, the firmware itself.
- IshKebab 3y agoSure but most malware doesn't really care about infecting more than the user. The only reason to infect firmware is to gain persistence in the face of OS reinstalls, but those are very rare in general. Only targeted NSA level malware is going to bother with that. For normal botnet/cryptocurrency stealing malware once it has user access it has everything it needs.
- Manouchehri 3y agoIf you're able to throw a 0day at a target, there's nothing stopping you from throwing it again after they reinstall.
- kentonv 3y agoYes, I agree. But I don't think the path forward is to re-establish the security of root. Instead the path forward is to stop granting the full capabilities of the user to every program the user runs. In Android, for example, every app has its own user account. That is meaningful! I wish every desktop app were sandboxed by default, but it requires redesigning so many interfaces that you might as well think of it as a whole new platform. Of course, such a platform basically exists: the web platform. I think everything-is-a-web-site is the realistic way we get to secure desktops. I don't like it but it's hard to imagine anything else getting traction from here.