9 ms·
Things I Learned from René Girard
- olesya1979 3y ago[dead]
- jrvarela56 3y agotl;dr at the end of the article: 1. People are driven to imitate others, but hate to admit it 2. Imitation is the basis of most businesses, but it's always disguised because customers are ashamed of their mimetic desires. 3. We need to expose these disguises, because the drive to imitate leads to rivalry and conflict. 4. Mimetic rivalries are the source of blood feuds and reciprocal violence —which are traditionally resolved by the sacrifice of a scapegoat. 5. The scapegoat combines opposites— and is often both victim & hero, sacred & profane, guilty & innocent. 6. The persecution of scapegoats is a uniting force behind many institutions and practices, but participants cannot admit this because it delegitimizes their efforts. 7. Humans fail to perceive their own scapegoats-so persecution continues while everybody absolves themselves of individual guilt. 8. Our most violent impulses are stirred up by similarity, not difference. 9. Enemies resemble each other, because of mimetic rivalry, but this is another secret that cannot be mentioned. Our enemy is always portrayed as our opposite. 10. Artistic idioms often originate in imitation and ritualized sacrifice. 11. We want to protect victims, and are right to do so; but we need to avoid super-victimology, in which this only leads to targeting and punishing new scapegoats. 12. We can only escape the endless cycles of reciprocal violence by rising above our desire for vengeance and working instead to delegitimize the urge to punish and scapegoat.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- soufron 3y agoPeople can't admit imitation. It's unconscious.
- sdwr 3y agoI love the scapegoat concept, it solves problems in at least 3 ways: - resolves pressure that builds up due to social paradoxes (don't like you but have to pretend to, have desires but can't admit to them) - reminds everyone that it could be worse, normal problems are no big deal compared to actual violence - and promotes bonding over a shared enemy
- agumonkey 3y agoI wish I could find some curated readings about the sociology of shared enemy and all the usual social reflexes that lead bad states.
- 082349872349872 3y agoNot exactly curated, but Durant & Durant The Story of Civilization (1935-1975) is 11 volumes containing several bright spots interspersed with an awful lot of people being awful to each other. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Story_of_Civilization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Story_of_Civilization People are people, so why should it be They often treat each other so awfully
- agumonkey 3y agothanks a lot, and fine choice of quote
- 082349872349872 3y agoyou're welcome. (if you'd like, have a 1927/1984 mashup: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ctqMIkrqCj8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ctqMIkrqCj8 )
- Biologist123 3y agoI’ve wondered if the democratic process is really a civilized form of scape-goating. Elections are a pressure valve, meaning incumbent parties are ejected from office and fresh faces brought in, albeit often with little change in the policies that caused pressures to build.
- an_aparallel 3y agoGirardian philosophy was one of the most profound theories i'd come across when i first heard it. I really need to dig into Girard's actual books - i've only heard of him through third parties.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoI like how Rene Girard spoke about Jesus. The good Samaritan for example. Jesus literally talks about how a person from a completely different ethnicity which hates Jews is taking care of a Jewish man. His message was absolute love and radical forgiveness. If we really take Jesus' message it would mean no borders, no wars, just pure love for each other. Anybody who doesn't understand that is not a real Christian.
- leobg 3y agoYou may find Tolstoy interesting. “What I believe” is the book.
- 082349872349872 3y agoalso the short story Холстомер ("Strider")
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoI love it. Turn the other cheek in the face of death. Incredible ideas but we mangle it. Hence we are not in the kingdom yet.
- leobg 3y agoI may have mixed it up with “The Kingdom of God Is Within You”. Some of the big ideas in there: 1. Nonviolence as a Principle: Tolstoy concludes that the core of Jesus’ teachings is nonviolent resistance to evil. This was a radical idea at the time, influencing figures like Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr. later on. 2. Rejection of the State and All Violence: He argues that all forms of violence, including state-sanctioned violence (like police and military), are fundamentally opposed to Christian teachings. 3. Critique of the Church: Tolstoy is critical of the institutionalized church, asserting it has strayed far from Jesus’ original teachings. He believes the church supports violence and coercion, contrary to the principles of Christianity. 4. Personal Morality Over Legal Systems: He suggests that true Christian ethics are based on personal morality and conscience rather than legal systems or government decrees. 5. The Kingdom of God Is Within: Tolstoy interprets the Kingdom of God not as a physical location or afterlife promise, but as a state of being one can achieve by living in accordance with Jesus’ teachings. 6. Universal Love and Brotherhood: He emphasizes the idea of universal love and brotherhood, extending beyond one’s community or nation, challenging prevailing notions of nationalism and tribalism. 7. Civil Disobedience: Tolstoy advocates for civil disobedience as a means of opposing unjust laws and government actions, prefiguring many 20th-century movements for social change. 8. Simplicity and Asceticism: He also extols the virtues of a simple, ascetic lifestyle, free from the pursuit of wealth and material excess.
- mif 3y agoSimilar to the imitation problem, I’ve read somewhere that it’s not greed what drives people to accumulate things (wealth etc.) but envy. You don’t want more for the sake of getting more, you simply want more than your neighbor. It’s all relative. And difficult to break the cycle. Possibly links to point 8.
- 082349872349872 3y agoThat would explain why so few people seem to have finite greed. Edit: compare Tolstoy, "How Much Land Does a Man Need?" (1886)
- leobg 3y agoI think that’s a Buffett quote: “It’s not greed that drives the world. It’s envy.”
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoBut isn't competition more derived from paranoia and fear than envy?
- mif 3y agoI wouldn’t think so. Envy is this funny feeling we hardly ever admit ourselves but which is part of being human. It happens to everyone no matter where they are in the hierarchy. Or, as Bertrand Russell puts it: „Beggars do not envy millionaires. They envy other beggars who are more successful.“
- 082349872349872 3y agoleading to the well-known analogy of the crabs pulling each other back into the pot
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mo_42 3y agoAre there works that test Girard's theories? Is there some evidence?
- 082349872349872 3y agoevidence for 8 and 9: homoousios vs homoiousios. northern ireland. football hooligans. etc. in fiction: Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of X, {star,plain}-bellied Sneetches I had thought Covid would've been a uniting scapegoat, but no, the hairless apes had to make it all about themselves.
- downut 3y agoThis [1] cured me of Girard. Read that and then read the rest of the comments here. Don't worry, it's very well written and quite funny. Also provides an implicit side view of Silicon Valley culture. [1] https://arcade.stanford.edu/rofl/deceit-desire-and-literature-professor-why-girardians-exist https://arcade.stanford.edu/rofl/deceit-desire-and-literatur...
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoYeah. The ability to torture your citations until they say what you want does not make them evidence for your theory. (Seriously, I second downut - read the reference before you decide you agree with Girard.) And if he's doing that to the foundational texts of Christianity, that makes me inclined to view his statements about Christianity very skeptically, for all he claims that he is consistent with Christianity and supporting Christianity.
- BenFeldman1930 3y agoIs Landy envious of Girard? With Landy having just 1 (one) wikipedia article to his name, and Girard 36 (thirty-six)? Who knows. Thanks for the reference.
- ajkjk 3y agoThey're more like interpretative theories than scientific theories. Different kind of thing. Their validity is in that they seem to pattern-match to a lot of experience, so the only test is really "do they ring true?"; there's not a sense in which they would be scientifically testable. (well- I should say, this is how I feel about how the high-level impression of Girard's ideas, like the notion of mimetic desire in this article. I haven't read him so I dunno about his actual takes; maybe they're more concrete and therefore falsifiable. For instance the actually detailed scapegoat theory, which I have heard about elsewhere, seems obviously silly to me.)
- somedude895 3y ago> 8. Our most violent impulses are stirred up by similarity, not difference. For example, hatred of immigrants (and their hatred of the locals) is amplified when both live in the same neighborhood and the barriers that previously existed have been removed. There are hundreds of other examples, but they all derive from the other refusing to remain the other, and instead showing up on our street, in our country club, at our doorstep, or somewhere else where they start to resemble us. This doesn't make any sense. Physical proximity and similarity are very different things. The correct analogy would be if immigrants assimilated, and that led to resentment by the local population.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 082349872349872 3y agoI'd bet Girard probably reads a bit differently to Gioia's exegesis. EDIT: but maybe not? see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39849487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39849487 for someone else's commentary; I'm reading Girard himself before I pass judgement. (fun fact: in the original Astérix, Idéfix is the dog's name)
- yowayb 3y agoImitation’s apotheosis is AI
- RandomLensman 3y ago"Mimetic desire" in businesses isn't hidden, it is actively thought after ("best practices", learning from winners etc.) - nothing shameful there as people want copy successful things and don't have trouble saying so. Also, institutional isomorphisms are not a new observation or area of study.
- ajkjk 3y agoI don't think that's what mimetic desire refers to. It's not the imitation of the practices, it's the imitation of the goals. Not so much the goal "to succeed in business" as "to look like a person who is succeeding in business", though, and that's in large part why so many people seem so mediocre at it.
- RandomLensman 3y agoI'd say at least some of the goals of businesses are pretty universally shared anyway.
- lifeline82 3y ago[dead]
- JyB 3y agoReading his mimetic theory was a real mind blower and one of those moments that redefines your understanding of the world. The way he seamlessly was able to describe it in so many layers and perspectives is fascinating. From a biological/evolutionary pov, to human sacrifice and scapegoating, to the birth of the 'sacred' and religions, to Christianism, and to so many facets of our modern society and human behaviour.
- throw5323446 3y ago> 8. Our most violent impulses are stirred up by similarity, not difference. For example, hatred of immigrants (and their hatred of the locals) is amplified when both live in the same neighborhood and the barriers that previously existed have been removed Aren't people living far from immigrants the biggest xenophobic group? Cities are much more progressive on immigration issues despite having more of a mix, directly contradicting that theory.
- 082349872349872 3y agoMy rule of thumb for political prediction in the States is: how far away is the jurisdiction from the largest city in its watershed?
- pjc50 3y agoThe most xenophobic group appear to be people who don't have any dissimilar people in their social group or immediate surroundings, but occasionally see one on TV or go to the Big City and get upset about it. It was definitely found during Brexit that places with fewer immigrants were most pro-Brexit.
- 082349872349872 3y ago"Relatives Acting Like They’ll Be Assaulted By Deranged Clown The Instant They Set Foot In Gotham City" https://www.theonion.com/relatives-acting-like-they-ll-be-assaulted-by-deranged-1851359203 https://www.theonion.com/relatives-acting-like-they-ll-be-as... What I really like about YouTube is that for any given polity you can watch slick stuff on state channels and get the official line, and you can also watch "home videos" of normal people doing normal people stuff to get some idea of the day to day. The Texan making chili is just a few clicks away from the Caucasian making shashlik.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoOne factor may be that people who are very xenophobic tend to actively avoid living in areas with a lot of immigrants.
- deleted 3y ago
- scandox 3y agoAs an Ad Exec in a meeting I was at once put it Monkey See Monkey Do. For every theorist there are a whole bunch of practitioners.
- soufron 3y agoI read Violence and the Sacred when I was 8... it changed my life forever.
- istultus 3y agoI think Girard passes muster in that the theory is often useful, in conjunction with others - that is, it passes the "Condorcet barrier of utility" and one can use it as part of a toolbox to explicate certain human behaviors. Taking it as a unified theory doesn't work, just as any -ism taken alone to explain the whole damn thing doesn't work and is often counterproductive. For example - and I would be grateful if someone with knowledge of Girard would explain it - how does one bridge the Underwear Gnomes reasoning of say #12 in the blog: Step 1 - We point out how we all act out of mimicry Step 2 - ??? Step 3 - We "escape the endless cycles of reciprocal violence by rising above our desire for vengeance and working instead to delegitimize the urge to punish and scapegoat."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 082349872349872 3y agoI would put that as: Step 1 - We point out how we all act out of mimicry* Step 2 - We delegitimise the urge to punish and scapegoat (thus rising above our desire for vengeance) Step 3 - We escape the endless cycles (Samsara?) of reciprocal violence Exercise: how soon might the last pandemic have been over if people had been more interested in eliminating viral propagation and less interested in punishing and scapegoating each other? * "You're all different" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QereR0CViMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QereR0CViMY
- slibhb 3y agoIn Girard's model of mimetic desire, there are three parts: the subject, the object, and the model. The subject sees that the model has the object and comes to desire it. There's something deeply true about this. But often, the thing you end up desiring is not an object. For example, you might observe someone else's happy relationship and want a happy relationship for yourself. But you don't necessarily want their partner. Or you might see that someone else enjoys their job and you might want a job that you enjoy...but you don't necessarily want their job. Seen from this perspective, mimetic desire doesn't necessarily lead to conflict.
- HuShifang 3y agoAs an outsider to the "tech" scene, who did a PhD generals field on modern European intellectual history (which included a dollop of recent continental philosophy), it's endlessly fascinating to me how people in tech have fixated upon Girard. While a few of his ilk do come up in standard reading lists, he (generally) doesn't -- he is far more prominent vis-a-vis his peers in this discourse than in his "native" one. I suspect that this owes to path dependency and his metaphysics' compatibility with the industry's participants' socio-intellectual priors (so to speak).
- 082349872349872 3y agoI'd guess it's because anoraks/botanics/intellos/Geeks/geeks are pretty familiar with low-subculture-on-the-totem-pole becoming a unifying scapegoat, so it's an appealing idée fixe. (or is that merely recapitulating what you just said?) On the other hand, I've been in the tech scene for nearly 4 decades, and this discussion is the first time I've encountered Girard (at least that I remember).
- tithe 3y agoFor those who want to "stay a while", Jonathon Bi did a discussion series on Girard's Mimetic Theory: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL_xn3B6eWvGsILrh5v5nq0rMp6OjuBOo9 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL_xn3B6eWvGsILrh5v5nq...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 082349872349872 3y agoskip to the end for the tl;dr
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]