5 ms·
Market-rate housing will make your city cheaper
- mortify 3y agoThis sounds like the long way to say that increases supply lowers prices. It does address common criticisms of this approach, however. I feel like I'm missing something.
- JohnMakin 3y agoBecause the author's argument is presenting this discussion in a profoundly dishonest and unrealistic way, and glossing over in a single sentence or two very real phenomena like gentrification (here's some cherrypicked studies most readers will never click on - there you go folks, gentrification isn't real!). One example being - this isn't a zero sum game and rental markets don't behave like one. If someone builds an expensive condo, yes this increases supply of housing in the area, but in the event that prices increase all over the place due to cartel-like behavior (spoiler - this happens often), renters don't react by shopping around for a landlord that's beating out the price of his neighbors. For one, getting approved even to be a renter is difficult for many, so this level of flexibility/fluidity is unrealistic from the start, and two, people react to rental increases often by cutting costs in other areas or by doubling up the occupancy of the home (e.g., getting a roommate), because the choice of where one decides to pay rent is far from a perfect or efficient market at all. This issue is far more complicated than "it's supply and demand dummy" and usually this argument is presented by faux YIMBY's who intentionally or not are acting as astroturfs for the developers, who win out big in the end no matter what.
- choilive 3y agoWhy shouldn't developers be economically rewarded for supplying housing in an area that demands a large amount of housing? > renters don't react by shopping around for a landlord that's beating out the price of his neighbors Renters certainly shop around. What makes you think they don't? > approved even to be a renter is difficult for many, and two, people react often by cutting costs in other areas or by doubling up the occupancy of the home (e.g., getting a roommate). Yes, and both of those issues can be solved by increasing the supply of housing. If demand greatly outstrips supply, landlords can be as picky as they want on renters. If theres an excess of supply, they will be a bit looser.
- JohnMakin 3y ago> Renters certainly shop around. What makes you think they don't? I never said they do not. I said that’s not the typical reaction, because moving is very difficult and has a ton of financial and logistical hurdles for most households. “supply and demand, dummy” arguments around the housing market tend to conveniently wave away these costs in the same manner the author waved away gentrification.
- anamax 3y ago> I never said they do not. I said that’s not the typical reaction It doesn't take many shoppers to make a huge difference. > because moving is very difficult There's always a fair number of people new to the area, not to mention people whose situation has changed significantly and there are a lot of people looking for new housing. Note that rent-control takes the latter group off the market. Note that someone taking a "new property" off the market (regardless of reason) is exactly the same as not adding said new property. (Ie, it can't make things worse.)
- JohnMakin 3y ago> It doesn't take many shoppers to make a huge difference. Ok, sure, but when a single landlord buying the new property to do airbnb destroys this entire silly argument right away, that’s a sign to me the argument is working with a flawed premise.
- astrange 3y ago> very real phenomena like gentrification He wrote a famous post years ago about gentrification prevention called "yuppie fishbowl theory". Gentrification is caused by blocking infill development that adds new units. That's what causes existing units to get replaced. > but in the event that prices increase all over the place due to cartel-like behavior (spoiler - this happens often) That doesn't happen, landlords cannot enforce a cartel and are not motivated to. Cartels are enforced in housing /by governments/ - they are what zoning laws are intended to do. And they're the only way it can happen because they have legal force. Upzoning an area is defeating a cartel.
- immibis 3y agoReplacing units is what causes units to get replaced. We can look upstream of that to see why landlords choose to replace units (probably the reason you cited), but we shouldn't miss the trees for the forest either.
- anamax 3y ago> If someone builds an expensive condo, yes this increases supply of housing in the area, but in the event that prices increase all over the place due to cartel-like behavior Umm, no. Adding a new expensive housing to a market does not increase the demand for existing inexpensive housing. It can have the effect of reducing the demand for other expensive housing, as in "why should I pay a lot of money for old?"
- choilive 3y agoUnfortunately yes, because people don't understand basic supply/demand principles. It sounds like common sense/econ 101 (which it is). But the proponents of low-income housing and rent controls don't seem to believe that increasing the supply of market rate housing decreases rents in the long term.
- pixl97 3y agoMost proponents of low-income housing I know of would like to vastly increase density and lower the number of SFH but the vast portion of the market and voters does not want that at all since it would lower their home value.
- jdhendrickson 3y agoand it's miserable to live in.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pixl97 3y agoCool, figure out how to pay for trillions of dollars of sprawling infrastructure then. We in the US haven't figured that one out yet and the bills are coming due.
- brigade 3y agoIncreasing density generally increases existing home values more than not doing that; the land becomes more valuable (for free!) if more houses can be sold on top of it, and that's almost always worth more than having renters nearby. The more common reason people vote against it is because they want their neighborhood to be frozen in time at the precise moment they moved there; that's what they originally chose after all. And they don't want to be forced to look at anything with a FAR above 0.4, and even that much is questionable.
- immibis 3y agoAre you sure they're talking about the long term?
- zachmu 3y agoWhat you're missing is the incredibly vocal activist culture in cities like SF and Seattle, who demand that any new multi-family housing built include below-market-rate units. (These cities also typically extort new developments with expensive "link-up fees" but that's beyond the scope of the supply-and-demand issue). The obvious fact that these requirements make it harder for developments to pencil out and therefore decrease the amount of new units built will never, ever occur to these activists.
- chii 3y agoOr, these activists are actually saboteurs, using the requirement for below-market-rate units as a form of barrier to prevent actual constructions from happening! How can it not be obvious that forcing below-market-rate units into a development will force the developers to suffer losses?
- ianburrell 3y agoLots of cities came up with an arrangement to build low-income housing by having developers build low-income housing. My impression is that this wasn't activists driving it but cities finding an easy solution. The activists are now bought into the solution as way to get low-income housing. This sounds like a good idea because it taxes the ones making money. But the result is that less housing gets built because of the extra costs and it tends to be luxury housing so developer can make money. I also not sure how much a few low-income units increase the diversity of neighborhood. The solution is probably just tax all developers and use the money to build low-income housing. Or even better, tax everyone. Diversity can be better accomplished by building low-income housing throughout the city. Better to mix low-income housing with cheaper market-rate housing.
- m463 3y agoI kind of wonder if it is missing the home-purchase-not-rental part of the equation. If you cannot stop renting, if nobody can, will this have a parasitic effect on society?
- cess11 3y agoThe author forgot to explain why the housing equivalent of a "Lambo" should exist at all, let alone the "Lambo" itself. It's statistics employed to defend harshly hierarchical societies while claiming to care for the disadvantaged.
- zachmu 3y agoIt exists because someone wants it and is willing to pay for it and someone else is willing to sell it to them. What makes you think you have the right to stop either side of that transaction from engaging in it?
- cess11 3y agoI'm not religious, I don't believe in rights as given by gods or nature. I also don't believe either debt or money are necessary for a decent society.
- pixl97 3y agoBecause we have a million different laws preventing people from buying and selling whatever they want. The libertarian utopia that many on HN thinks should exist, doesn't. If the right to stop it didn't exist, there would be far more apartments and dense housing in these places that are zoned SFH.
- refurb 3y agoYour logic is “we ban some things so banning this is fine”. Thats an incredibly shallow argument. It’s so shallow in fact it could be used to argue for the ban of anything.
- pixl97 3y agoI mean looking across all humanity there is very little that has not been banned in one place or another. Banning things seems to be the one thing we're really good at.
- 3y ago
- tmnvix 3y agoIn this whole debate around availability of housing nobody ever seems to think about what has happened to the proportion of dwellings used as a primary residence. Up or down? What would that tell us? Cheap credit, rapid price rises, and AirBnB and the like have created extra demand for 'investments'. Second homes, short term rentals, even good old fashioned land banking. We should pay more attention to what has been happening to the demand side of the supply and demand equation.
- anthonypasq 3y agothis sort of stuff is barely a drop in the bucket, and savvy politicians consistently try and succeed in directing public complaints towards these types of scapegoats and away from the fact they have completely forgone the public interest in exchange for appeasing the de facto "landed gentry" who lucked their way into owning an expensive asset that they dont want to get rid of.
- tmnvix 3y ago> this sort of stuff is barely a drop in the bucket Do you know this or is this your opinion? I know for a fact that in Melbourne the areas that experience the highest capital gains and are most 'in demand' as places to live also have the highest vacancy rates. 15% and higher vacancy rates in some inner city suburbs (as determined by water usage). Not intuitive if you think in terms of 'supply and demand 101'. Think about it in these terms. It used to cost you money to have a second home but since interest rates started a steady decline around 30 years ago the supply of new money that has gone into property means having a second home now makes you money via capital gains (even without generating income via long term rental). The advent of AirBnB and the like also mean owning a second home can be profitable where it once wasn't. Now, given that, surely more people will be doing this now, right? A suburb near me has around 2000 dwellings. About 50 are listed on AirBnB as 'entire homes'. That's 2.5%. A typical vacancy rate is 3% (not as measured above, but provided by real estate agents - i.e. that are available for rent). 2.5% starts looking very significant. And this is just AirBnB. There are other platforms involved. Not to mention land banked properties, second homes not listed for short term rental, etc. In short, the number of underutilised properties is significant and made worse in a booming market. Edit: Further evidence of the existence of underutilised properties. In NZ, when interest rates shot up at the start of 2022, the number of listings for both purchase and rental rose significantly (close to 50%). Where did these properties come from? A similar example could be seen in Ireland post GFC. There was a 'shortage', then financing became difficult and suddenly a surplus of rentals and homes for sale appeared. It was accepted that there was an oversupply and the preceding boom had led to overbuilding. As the market slowly improved over 15 years the surplus disappeared again to the point where rentals are very scarce in Ireland (but short term rentals are now abundant).
- palmfacehn 3y agoFunny to read Noah defending market pricing. I remember him for his court economist takes on the lack of price inflation following the "housing crisis" money supply inflation.