3 ms·
Consumers would be helped more if these large companies are broken up. We could have so much more competition if Apple was divided into software, hardware and
by amelius 3y ago
Consumers would be helped more if these large companies are broken up.
We could have so much more competition if Apple was divided into software, hardware and services companies.
And these companies (except perhaps the services company) would be more pro-consumer, making stuff that we actually want instead of stuff that Apple wants us to have (and vendor-locks us in).
It is also a bit ridiculous that some of the best CPUs out there are available only for consumer products.
- threeseed 3y agoThis comment is pretty ignorant of the history of computing. Apple tried to allow competition in their ecosystem. And all that happened is that vendors like Power Computing went straight for Apple's most profitable markets and nearly bankrupted the company. The only reason Apple is successful is because people like the console-esque experience of having one vendor do everything.
- asadotzler 3y agoYou cannot make that final claim because there are plenty of alternative scenarios never tried that could have allowed Apple to be successful by other means. Also, your 90s era anecdote is mostly meaningless today, certainly not demonstrative that licensing couldn't work, just that Apple failed to make it work with their one potentially poor attempt 30 years ago.
- aurareturn 3y agoIt’s about choice. I want a tightly integrated experience on my iPhone and Mac. I don’t want regulators as designers. iPhone and Macs own a small fraction of their markets around the world. Clearly there are alternatives and you don’t need to choose an iPhone or a Mac.
- simion314 3y ago>It’s about choice. I want a tightly integrated experience on my iPhone and Mac. I don’t want regulators as designers. if you are from outside EU then you are fine for now, you will not have this freedoms. If you are from EU then keep calm, nobody will force you to use a better application or service then the default ones from Apple. Side loading was available on Android and facebook Messenger and whatsapp are still on the official store despite all the FUD from Apple extremist fanboys, you can continue sitting inside the Apple walls.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoEven so Apple shouldn't be able to use its position to disadvantage users. I believe being able to run whatever software you want on the hardware you buy is a basic right. If you want to forgo that, fine, but you should have the choice. The fact that they have a small market share is not relevant when they have many millions of users. This kind of thing leads to oligopolies that disadvantage consumers, which is what we have with phone app stores on Android and iPhone.
- burnerthrow008 3y ago> I believe being able to run whatever software you want on the hardware you buy is a basic right. If you want to forgo that, fine, but you should have the choice. Ok, so then why do you support the EU denying me that choice?
- amelius 3y ago> It’s about choice. I want a tightly integrated experience on my iPhone and Mac. If it's about choice, then Apple performs very poorly at it. Apple is great if your requirements are average. A large minority of people still have to look elsewhere.
- burnerthrow008 3y agoApple performs poorly at giving you choice by... making something different to everyone else? Do you understand what choice means?
- amelius 3y agoYes locking products down means less freedom and less choice. And this is made worse by Apple buying up their supply chain and precious slots at semiconductor foundries. Not everybody is an average consumer looking for average products. But these products are using precious resources and outcompete more generally useful products just by market volume. Apple is behind the hardware version of Eternal September. First the internet got spoiled by the masses, and now our hardware too.
- aurareturn 3y agoIt works for me. If it didn’t, I would switch to Google’s Android, Samsung’s Android, Xiaomi’s Android, Windows, Linux, etc.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoI don't think that's necessarily the answer. Often these things arise out of market failure. For instance Apple couldn't sell its ARM processors even if it wanted to because ARM's licence agreement with Apple forbids it. The problem is that the market for CPUs lacks choice. Hopefully RISC-V will alleviate that, eventually.
- nottorp 3y ago> For instance Apple couldn't sell its ARM processors even if it wanted to because ARM's licence agreement with Apple forbids it. First time i hear that. Isn't Apple a founding member and can do whatever it wants?
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoNo they sold their ARM stock decades ago, they have no special rights. They bought an architectural licence, but those always come with limitations, or you just don't get one. See Qualcomm's litigation against ARM.
- nottorp 3y agoOkay, but hell will still freeze over before Apple sells even a resistor they make to a 3rd party. Let alone a CPU.