5 ms·
Nuclear's role in a net-zero world
- bananapub 3y ago[flagged]
- bluefirebrand 3y agoIt's important not to dismiss good ideas just because you dislike the people saying them If more nuclear gets us away from Fossil Fuels faster it's a good thing
- bananapub 3y agonot sure what you're replying to? of course one shouldn't "dismiss good ideas just because you dislike the people saying them", but if your country doesn't already have a nuclear industry then it's too late to get to net zero with nuclear. of course you can plan for using it later, but you can't get distracted by it now or fall victim to scams by well-funded and malicious groups.
- theshackleford 3y ago> If more nuclear gets us away from Fossil Fuels faster it's a good thing His point is that in Australia, it won’t. And it doesn’t matter how much evidence you put in front of these people to show them that. You can’t even tell them it’s costly because they reject even that provable fact. Renewables plus firming is orders of magnitude cheaper and faster than any form of nuclear ever will be in AU and getting cheaper every day to boot. To which the response will simply be “nuuhh uhhh”. https://www.csiro.au/en/research/technology-space/energy/Energy-data-modelling/GenCost https://www.csiro.au/en/research/technology-space/energy/Ene...
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAt least in the case of Australia, they’ll arrive at 100% renewables between 2030-2035 based on current deployment trajectories without any nuclear. All of Australia has 18.4GW of coal generation capacity remaining (per ElectricityMaps.com). To replace this with solar, wind, and batteries will be trivial (China deployed 217GW of solar last year [2023], for comparison). There is already 40GW of batteries in their pipeline. https://www.unsw.edu.au/newsroom/news/2023/12/coal-will-be-all-but-gone-by-2034-under-australias-latest-energy https://www.unsw.edu.au/newsroom/news/2023/12/coal-will-be-a... https://aemo.com.au/energy-systems/major-publications/integrated-system-plan-isp https://aemo.com.au/energy-systems/major-publications/integr... https://www.woodmac.com/press-releases/australia-leads-global-market-for-battery-energy-storage-systems/ https://www.woodmac.com/press-releases/australia-leads-globa...
- Swizec 3y agoIf more nuclear takes 20+ years to build while we can get wind farms online next month, is it really faster? I love nuclear but have to admit it’s dead until we figure out how to build these things faster. You can get 10MW of wind built in 2 months. A nuclear plant gives you 1000MW (1GW). You need to build that in less than 50 months (4 years) to compete with wind. And wind can already deliver incremental value for most of those 50 months so lead times aren’t a problem. When’s the last time anyone built a nuclear plant in 4 years?
- robertlagrant 3y agoJust comparing MW when wind is blowing is never going to be useful or result in a productive discussion. You need compare nuclear with other useful, base load generation methods in terms of build cost/time/CO2 per MW.
- Swizec 3y agoI believe the numbers I quoted are averages, not only when the wind is blowing. Source: https://www.ewea.org/wind-energy-basics/faq/ https://www.ewea.org/wind-energy-basics/faq/ Here’s a better number: https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/how-many-homes-can-average-wind-turbine-power https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/how-many-homes-can-average-wind-tu... > At a 42% capacity factor (i.e., the average among recently built wind turbines in the United States, per the 2021 edition of the U.S. Department of Energy’s Land-Based Wind Market Report), that average turbine would generate over 843,000 kWh (843MWh) per month—enough for more than 940 average U.S. homes For comparison, an actual nuclear reactor in practical use produced 4,697,675 MWh in 2017. That’s the equivalent of 5572 of those wind turbines. That’s a lot of wind turbines. But if we can build 278 wind turbines per year and it takes 20 years to build a new reactor. They’re even. USA currently builds 3000 turbines per year. https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/how-many-wind-turbines-are-installed-us-each-year https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/how-many-wind-turbines-are-install... So I think even with 42% capacity, wind is winning. We’d need to build 10 reactors per 20 years (1 every 2 years) for nuclear to beat wind.
- russell_h 3y ago
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoHe didn't say he dislikes them. He said they were people who were provably lying about the very existence of the problem that they now claim nuclear will fix (in 2 decades, at great expense).
- smallmancontrov 3y agoAny political cause larger than a certain size will have someone stinky in the big tent. There are stinkers in the renewables tent too, does that mean we should boycott solar panels? Of course not. Same here. See also: think of the children.
- ggm 3y agoThis is not "some" -the majority of Australian nuclear backers are the mining sector, the established mining lobby, and the right wing. The socialist case for nuclear exists ("electricity plus soviet power == communism"), but is not being made. Here's a leading hint: the main campaign page in Australia for the pro nuclear push is the Murdoch press. The political party leading the push is the conservative party, and it is being led by the right wing conservative leadership against the wishes of the middle ground and soft-left side of the party. You aren't wrong that any movement has some stink: this movement is lead by the nose.
- defrost 3y agoIt's a completely fair assessment of the current political embrace of nuclear power in Australia - it's being pushed more and more by Murdoch, his papers and Sky arms, and the most Vogon of the Australian political landscape, and they very much have a blind to climate realities "this is the fix" agenda. The great problem with that is it drowns out any chance for any considered debate on the future of Australia's energy mix - there is an engineering case for a small percentage ( <10% ) of nuclear generation in parts of the Australian grid.
- ggm 3y agoWhilst I personally would have no problem with lifting the bans, state and federal, I would personally have a problem with the subsidies required to make commercial builds come out of the woodwork. Nuclear in OZ is estimated at ~$300+ compared to $150+ for firmed renewables as a "unit cost" and we can be confident of the renewables cost because it's been experienced while the Nuclear one is speculative and as has been pointed out in this HN thread, highly subject to cost overruns in legal and construction delays (the size of the unit isn't the point, the difference in the outcome in terms of charges to be recovered from the system is) If in the future SMR prove economically viable and we can save on transmission line builds to have some serving major cities, I'd be fine. I would have no problem living near one, or near ANSTO's lucas heights facility. The current "go nuke" campaign in the Oz has nothing to do with energy, and a lot to do with increasing shareholder value and in objectifying the labor/green parties as "anti technology" and even "anti working class" if you define the working class as engineers and miners, not hairdressers and farmers
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smallmancontrov 3y agoon another sidenote, it's important to be extremely cynical about people claiming that all nuclear is being pushed to the exclusion of other things. This straw man is made of straw. I'm glad that after 40 years renewables are finally viable as a nuclear alternative... but if we just hadn't stopped building nuclear and continued building at the same pace (no learning curves assumed) we would already be done decarbonizing the grid! It takes some really special thinking to call that a grift. Instead, we are just starting to decarbonize, and with 100 gigatons of extra CO2 in the atmosphere from US emissions alone. I am glad we are un-stuck, but gee, I have a really hard time chalking up the concerted effort to kill nuclear and keep it dead as a "win."
- jemmyw 3y agoI don't know much about the politics of this in Australia, but at you have uranium exports already, wouldn't it be an ideal country to build nuclear power?
- Full_Clark 3y agoCoal and gas are major domestic industries and major export earners for Australia, so for a very long time it was a) political suicide to do anything that undermined them and b) simply way too expensive to bring nuclear power into the baseload mix compared to fossil-fuel plants. So the government wasn't going to subsidize it and private industry couldn't make a decent ROI on it. A decade ago Australia repealed its emissions trading scheme, which would have made nuclear much more competitive economically. If the politics at the time were different, and a strong carbon market brough nuclear power into the conversation then, some large plants might be nearing completion this decade. They'd be a reasonable chance to make a serious contribution to decarbonizing Australia's energy mix. But it's only in 2022 that the Australian population elected a government that took climate change seriously. With the timing of the net-zero pledges the new government has put in place, it seems like it's just far too late to put nuclear into the mix without paying hefty premiums for speed of completion. Finally, Australia is physically very large but the population is relatively small. Less than one-twelfth of the US population, less than half of the UK or France's population. It might simply be too small of an economy to establish a domestic nuclear engineering industry and training pipeline. If that's true, it'd be a very tough sell telling people it's time to pay extra on their power bill or taxes to stand up a nuclear industry from scratch ... and most of that money will go to foreign companies and immigrant SMEs.
- bananapub 3y ago> you have uranium exports already nope! Australia is big into mining - dig a hole, put the contents of the hole on a ship to a country that puts more effort into things, cash the cheques. actually doing things with the contents of the whole is a lot of work and requires whole industries full of expertise and training pipelines and industrial policy, so it's easier to just dig holes->ship contents of holes. even owning the mining companies is not a popular hobby - much better to sell out to a big foreign company and take the cash, then they can worry about even the hole digging. if you've ever heard of the Resource Curse, Australia is one of the rare Rich Western Country victims of it - it's all too easy, and so everything else gets left by the wayside. and then the mining industry is rich, so has lots of lobbyists and pet politicians who cement it's power - even easy things like a Mining Super Profit Tax that would have just cut some of the profits that got sent overseas to fund developing other parts of the economy got scaremongered by a huge mining industry lobbying push and never happened. we are very very fucked if mining stops being easy and/or profitable. > wouldn't it be an ideal country to build nuclear power? nope! a few reasons: - it's a small population - less than a tenth the population of the US. having a nuclear power industry has enormous fixed costs. you need a web of companies that work on the various bits, you need universities and apprenticeships churning out experts, you need absolutely fucking enormous government subsidies, and you need to do that for decades. - Australian politicians are - partly because of the above - very used to not working hard, so trying to convince people that they need to pay even more for electricity to subsidise a new nuclear power industry - and like mining above, that's almost entirely going to be going to foreign companies. - renewables are absolutely fucking easy and cheap and quick. Australia is the size of western europe or nearly as big as the main bit of the USA, so you can just deploy thousands of square kilometers of solar panels or wind, across multiple timezones, across multiple climactic regions, etc. nonetheless, people whinge about this, including actual real federal ministers claiming that wind turbines on farms are "eyesores". - it's too late - even countries that have nuclear reactors take decades to build them, so starting now, even with political will and competence, would take, say, twenty years to turn the first one on. Australia needs to be net zero before then. so if people want to argue about deploying nuclear power in Australia, then go for it, but it needs to 1) not delay actual work now, which will mass deployment of renewables and storage and 2) it needs a plan to compete with renewables costs in 2050. saying "oh hey, let's do nuclear, it'll cost way more and won't be here until your grandkids are born, also you'll be subsidising it" is a very very poor sales pitch.
- yongjik 3y agoThe flip-side is of course Germany, globally praised for being the shiny beacon of green energy policy, while emitting almost twice as much CO2 as neighboring nuclear-happy France (per capita). In the end, I think we should remember what is the most important: CO2 emission. Other things are secondary.
- Isle_of_View 3y agoThe Germans, due to their long history of massive earthquakes and destructive tsunamis, have, in their usual rational manner, shut down their nuclear power stations and instead rely on soft coal and importing power from coal powered Poland and nuclear powered France.
- ctrw 3y agoWhat a world to live in, where the right wing is the one which pays attention to reality and the left ignores it. A bit like the fact that immigration in Australia is now the main reason the RBA is driving interest rates into territory that will create a ressession because the government has set impossible to sustain immigration targets and told us as much: https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/migration-surge-adds-to-inflation-pressure-for-rba-20231030-p5eg2e https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/migration-surge-adds-to-i... Or that Australia has been in a per capita ressession and the only reason why the economy has grown in the last 9 months has been immigration: https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.abc.net.au/article/103553062 https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.abc.net.au/article/10355306... But you're a racist if you pay attention.
- defrost 3y ago> people pushing nuclear to the exclusion of other things Which is absolutely not happening here- the forecast balance being discussed in TFA is nuclear as a 10% foundation of largely renewable future. On another sidenote, it's important to be extremely cynical about people re-framing pragmatic discussions about low level nuclear usage as "nuclear to the exclusion of other things". Australia currently has vast amounts of renewables, and has a future that will see generation of exported renewable power for SE Asia .. and yet there is a place in Australia for base nuclear power to replace a small part of base gas and coal - and that's the opinion of someone who's accepted AGW models since the early 1980s and rarely votes for the Australian right.
- roenxi 3y agoThat is overly cynical. It was a genuine effort to get the nuclear industry going in Australia; the Liberals have been angling towards it for a while. * Australia is one of the most anti-nuclear-power countries in the world. At this point we're one of the few advanced countries left that doesn't have a nuclear reactor connected to the power grid. We're behind the curve on this and we should be looking at building up local experience in nuclear power. * The right wing of Australia has been cautiously pro-nuclear since the Howard government and do little probes from time to time to see if the left have calmed down about advanced technology enough to build one yet. * There is a lot of overlap between people who think the climate change people are not genuine and the pro-nuclear people ... but that is because the pro nuclear people have been pointing out the obvious solution from 1980 to 2020 to air pollution issues has been nuclear power and the green parties are one of the most vocal lobbies against it. There are obvious financial risks to nuclear power, but Australia should at least enter the 20th century and have it on the table as an option. Our current policy is stupid. > tl;dr at least some parts of the pro-nuclear-power lobby is actually just trying to end efforts to minimise climate change damage. That is ridiculous; there is no such group. Australia doesn't even cause any climate change damage to minimise - accepting that as the goal, our contribution to global emissions rounds to zero, and we have no leadership on any useful technologies because our manufacturing sector has been knocked out of competition (arguably our terrible energy policies were one of the big contributors to this, although wages were a decisive factor).
- schneems 3y agoWhether pro or anti nuclear, one paper I feel every engineer should read is “Do Artifacts have Politics” that asks the question “divorced from creator or user intent, do inventions/technologies/artifacts contain and/or promote a political will”. Here’s a link https://faculty.cc.gatech.edu/~beki/cs4001/Winner.pdf https://faculty.cc.gatech.edu/~beki/cs4001/Winner.pdf (hint, the answer is “yes” but the journey is more important than the destination). It’s a surprisingly easy read too. More like a long blog post than a dry paper. One of the examples in there is nuclear technologies, which is what brings this up for me.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI submitted a thread for the paper you recommended: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39811287 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39811287
- coxmi 3y agoGreat paper, thanks for posting. It reminded me of a lot of themes present in my design education, of political downstream effects created by apparently neutral technical decisions, and therefore the inherent responsibility of creators when putting something into the world. Not just standard economic externalities but consequences for human interaction. A nice flashback to university, so thanks!
- Terr_ 3y agoI'm trying to imagine artifacts that demonstrate/embed a set of politics and values in a blatant way (i.e. appalling the reader) just to prove the point that such things are possible. For example, a whip specially-designed for the convenience of some humans to inflict coercive pain on others who can't fight back. Or for a more sci-fi bent, imagine an array of mass-produced devices which can reduce a planetary ecosystem into decaying goo while simultaneously reporting on buried ore veins. It tells you something about the likely values and activities of those who would create and use it.
- makeitdouble 3y agoThis indeed felt like a excelent overview of many deeper wells that engineers are bound to have to dive into. That could be the best explaination of why we fundamentally don't solve social issues with purely technical solutions, they're always intertwined. Robert Mose is mentionned midway, so I'd point out that the 99 percent invisible podcast is currently doing a book club on "The Power Broker" [0]. A lot of the issues touched here are inherently design issues, and I think the whole podcast would be a feast for anyone interested. [0] https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/power-broker-01-robert-caro/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/power-broker-01-rober...
- codefeenix 3y agoWhy not title this "Nuclear's role in the world" because NetZero is still a company that does stuff. Also, why the apostrophe?
- karaterobot 3y ago"Net zero" is pretty much the accepted term for the concept of balancing out emissions with reductions. The U.N.[1] uses it, the E.U.[2] uses it, the U.S.[3] uses it. The ISP lost that one! [1] https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/net-zero-coalition https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/net-zero-coalition [2] https://climate.ec.europa.eu/eu-action/climate-strategies-targets/2050-long-term-strategy_en https://climate.ec.europa.eu/eu-action/climate-strategies-ta... [3] https://www.sustainability.gov/federalsustainabilityplan/emissions.html https://www.sustainability.gov/federalsustainabilityplan/emi...
- trhway 3y agoTo me nuclear is like those big iron servers of 90's losing to the horizontally scaled "datacenters" of solar panels and wind generators. Generic economics, physics, network and other considerations, when all the domain specific peculiarities are abstracted away, seem to be very similar.
- Retric 3y ago> It takes up a lot less land than renewables Except, Wind and geothermal are more space efficient than nuclear when you look at the actual land use of current nuclear reactors. In theory it doesn’t need much space so several GW could sit on a few hundred acres. Yet, Wolf Creek Generating Station is only 1.2 GW on 9,818 acres that’s worse than many solar projects. Which seems to be the general issue with the Nuclear industry. In theory you can say all these wonderful things, but in practice people are looking at decades of results when they are choosing to invest or not. Nuclear doesn’t need technological breakthroughs from cutting edge research, that just leads to more delays and boondoggles. What it actually needs is efficiently run projects on time and under budget.
- stavros 3y agoThis seems off, how about this one, with 7 GW on 1,000 acres? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashiwazaki-Kariwa_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashiwazaki-Kariwa_Nuclear_Pow... Or 6.5 GW on 2,300 acres? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Nuclear_Generating_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Nuclear_Generating_Stati... 4 GW, 3,000 acres: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palo_Verde_Nuclear_Generating_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palo_Verde_Nuclear_Generating_... Kind of odd that you'd cherry-pick the lowest wattage per acre reactor to make an example out of.
- Retric 3y ago‘Seems off’ is an odd way of dismissing an actual example. In theory it wins every time, in the real world it doesn’t. So sure, nuclear sometimes uses less land than solar nobody is seriously doubting it, the issue is it isn’t guaranteed and wind and geothermal are both vastly better from a land use perspective. Those 15 MW wind turbines don’t prevent people from farming beneath them, good luck doing anything that productive with land that close to a nuclear reactor.
- stavros 3y agoRight, but then your argument goes from "nuclear isn't more space-efficient than solar" to "in some rare cases, it's almost as bad as solar". Anyway, we probably need both, and we definitely need to stop burning fossil fuels, so let's not disparage one in favor of the other.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoThere is no discussion of power without knowing the: 1) current state of LCOE costs of different power generation methods 2) future LCOE evolution/drop in the relevant power generation methods "Without nuclear, advocates say, we would need to build far more wind and solar power plants to ensure reliable supplies, doubling or tripling costs over power networks that include nuclear." Look, if you look at last years Lazard's LCOE report, incumbent nuclear is 5x to 6x as expensive as wind and solar. So, uh, yeah, its cheaper to overproduce capacity than build nuclear. That's from point 1: the CURRENT state of LCOE. For "new nuclear" to enter the equation in current regulatory politics and costs, it won't power up any new plants for about 10 years. The second point about LCOE comes into play: solar/wind are STILL DROPPING in cost, and almost more significantly, grid storage will probably see the sodium-ion battery and perhaps the sodium-sulfur battery in that time, dropping storage costs by at least 50%, perhaps 80-90%. Solar cells will likely see some multijunction silicon-perovskite cell come into production, and possibly a full perovskite cell, in addition to increased economies of scale. I would predict in 10 years the cost of a solar cell is effectively 1/3 to 1/5 of current day prices (inflation adjusted yada yada). Wind will likely be less revolutionary, but I suspect it will drop still another 50-70% in 10 years. Meanwhile, this is for nuke plants 10 years out, that really don't have new gen designs ready to go. I will be kind and say plants we started funding now are only 4x as expensive as current solar/wind. But by the time they get built, they will probably be 10x as expensive. I'm sorry, I love nuclear power, it is so cool. But the nuclear industry needed to solve its problems about 20-40 years ago. It's leadership could have embraced global warming decades ago, but the leadership of nuclear is staunchly conservative, owing to a seething resentment of regulation and government oversight. I believe there exists, possibly a LFTR, a scalable, cheap, safe, near-zero waste reactor design that can be deployed as industrial power generation and perhaps competitive grid power, when combined with regulatory reforms in the goverment. But that design and reforms needed to happen about 25 years ago. Now nuclear needs to hold onto its existing plants, research new reactors (US National Labs have started new nuclear research including LFTRs, again, about 25 years too late), and prepare for when solar/wind stabilize in costs such that a price can be targeted with a true new generation design. As for grid leveling, old gen nuclear doesn't switch on or off fast enough (LFTR can, maybe pebble bed can too), but it could do "three days of storms" generation. But it still isn't as useful as say natural gas turbine for that (which obviously releases carbon). Alas the LFTR/MSR design is still unproven for a long term industrial standpoint, and has numerous materials issues. China has an MSR up supposedly for a year or two. It is true that regulatory barriers, NIMBY, and other politics increase costs and delay projects in nuclear, but this is also a convenient boogeyman for them to point to. If only the "magic regulatory framework" existed to let nuclear projects freely be built then... costs would still be higher than everything but coal. The LWR just isn't competitive, and I suspect any non-breeding design that can't also transmute waste to usable fuel (LFTR can supposedly do this, I think some other breeder reactors can as well). Because waste solid fuel is either expensive to transport and "dispose" at Yucca and is a whole entire extra bunch of NIMBYism and regulatory oversight, or difficult to reform/reprocess into new fuel. LWR only works on a small portion of Uranium ore, and even when the rods are formed from that fissile Uranium, only a fraction of the fuel is used until the transmuted byproducts of fission spoil the rod. LFTR has on-line reprocessing of its liquid fuel for extraction of the fission byproducts, so there is ... kind of ... 100% fuel use, and ... kind of ... no waste to transport. I don't want to handwave away (because I don't know the full extent of) all the chemistry and processing needed to handle that (and there are holding tanks for waste that needs to "cool" over months or years). Other things I would dispute: solar land use is not a big problem. For one, there is this thing called roofs, and there are a lot of them. There are also lots of parking lots, roads, etc that no one wrings their hands over. Rooftop solar is a lot more expensive than grid solar (and I think it is a scam that it is that much more expensive) but... it would STILL be cheaper than nuclear to put rooftop solar on houses and equip them with their own storage than build new nuclear plants. Such a program would vastly increase civil resilience to disasters and reduce the need for as much "smart grid" development. With the failure of NuScale, which all of a sudden is the people "not doing it right" for the industry, the actual viability of next gen nuclear took a big hit, and with it basically the last hope of nuclear being a part of the next 20 years of power generation outside of "keeping the current ones on". If the nuclear industry had a usable SMR design about 10 years ago specifically for industrial application, nuclear would be in a healthy place. And of course, nuclear needs to compete with the ultimately scalable power source: solar and to a lesser extent wind. Now, I am no Nuclear Engineering PhD-wielding expert, but I've been professing this opinion for a while on here, mostly in hopes of a constructive counterargument or hope for "new nuclear", but ... basically crickets. Which leads me to conclude that nuclear is just shilling these puff pieces to desperately keep the lights on or keep governments investing in whatever new projects there are. And to emphasize, governments should keep up heavy research into new designs for nuclear: there are simply far too many powers-of-ten in energy density involved here.