4 ms·
A wealth tax sounds good in theory but no one has ever figured out a way to make it with effectively in practice. What do you do with illiquid assets such as pa
by nradov 3y ago
A wealth tax sounds good in theory but no one has ever figured out a way to make it with effectively in practice. What do you do with illiquid assets such as patents or equity in private companies? Would owners have to pay for independent valuations every year as part of filing taxes? There's just no way to do it at scale. A wealth tax would also tend to cause people to hide their assets in non-productive things like physical precious metals instead of investing in businesses that grow the national economy.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoA sufficiently high land value tax would filter through pretty much everything as a decent wealth tax, and would require no additional work since it’s already continuously appraised. Too low land value taxes incentivize hoarding. Also, copyright should be reduced to 10 years, maybe 20 years at the longest.
- gshubert17 3y agoWould taxation of intellectual property reduce rent-seeking behavior? Any idea how it might be implemented?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoNo, but simply removing the ability to seek rent by removing copyright would.
- ForHackernews 3y agoJust tax the hell out of land: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism Very hard to hide acres of Earth.
- wakawaka28 3y agoVery hard to determine a fair value for those acres too. Everything outside of actual land purchase prices is hypothetical, and not every worthwhile purpose for land produces the same income. We already have high property taxes in some places anyway. Of course I think some kind of tax is necessary but the higher the tax the more this "ownership" resembles a lease.
- ForHackernews 3y ago> the more this "ownership" resembles a lease. ...good? We are all temporary stewards of an Earth we did nothing to earn or create.
- scoofy 3y agoThe best wealth tax is a periodic tax on unrealized capital gains. The fact that Jeff Bezos will likely never pay and capital gains tax on his share of Amazon is insane.
- wakawaka28 3y agoNo it's not insane. Unrealized gains are purely hypothetical and subject to manipulation. Imagine figuring out the value of an income-producing asset, such as a chicken, then taxing the eggs and the chicken itself. That's what people like you are essentially proposing.
- scoofy 3y agoWhen the asset can be marked to market, asking people to pay tax on the value once a decade is reasonable, especially if you offer tax credits for any decline that happens later.
- wakawaka28 3y ago"Marked to market" does not change the situation much. Tax credits won't make up for the basic reality that you're demanding cash that is not necessarily on hand, regardless of the company's situation, with a vague promise of tax credits in the future at a time when the company is likely facing losses anyway. "Once a decade" does not make this idea work either.
- scoofy 3y agoTaxes on marketable securities are, by definition, trivially payable, especially considering the tax-loophole use to literally get around paying capital gains tax is simply to borrow against them.
- wakawaka28 3y agoYou're wrong again. Not everything is marketable, and even if it is you have no right to steal it. Why should a business owner have to gradually give up ownership of his creation just to satisfy some arbitrary tax invented to make poor people feel better about being poor, or feed some arbitrary government apparatus? That's what any wealth tax is, especially when applied to business. Wealth in and of itself should not be taxed, only transactions and fixed assets that need state protection. And the taxes should be carefully measured so as to not penalize people for being successful.
- wakawaka28 3y agoTaxing wealth will make people not seek it. Why try so hard if it can evaporate in a couple of years anyway? Of course illiquid assets are also a major problem with the idea. But the main problem is that taxing wealth for no particular reason disincentivizes production.