4 ms·
Why Europe is dismantling its dams
- Aardwolf 3y agoI think dams are also used to control the water flow and prevent floods, how to solve that instead?
- samus 3y agoIt's a give and take. Historically, the danger from flooding actually increased because the floodplains next to the riverside were mostly eliminated. They would provide flexibility for the river to meander and to expand in times of heavy rain and would have to be restored as part of a dam removal. They also provide biodiversity and help keep the river water clean. Dams are also a hazard when there is a lot of rain because you eventually have to open it or risk failure. As the dam gets older it tends to silt up and its integrity becomes less trustworthy, even less water fits in. This requires necessitating expensive maintenance to remedy. Getting rid of it might be cheaper in the long run.
- ender341341 3y agoCan't speak for the ones in this article but they're doing similar in the pacific northwest and many of the dams where built to locally control flooding, but other newer dams further upstream ended up handling the flood prevention better over what were previously multiple dams so there's lots of old dams that have effectively sat unused & blocking fish & wildlife on the river while also providing no benefit.
- bell-cot 3y agoEvery dam is different...but if a dam has a small reservoir capacity (perhaps partly due to lack of maintenance - so what looks like water behind the dam is mostly accumulated silt), a narrow range of control (the water level is not much different between "flood gates fully closed" and "flood gates fully open", local-only manual controls (vs. pushing a button at National Flood Control HQ), and other issues - then it's actually of little use for those.
- slaymaker1907 3y agoYeah, let's get rid of one of the most effective sources of green energy that works around the clock! The environmental concerns around dams are legitimate, but they need to be balanced against the consequences of how those energy sources will be replaced. There are also mitigation strategies that can be done instead, like the fish ladders that were mentioned in passing, to help mitigate the environmental impact. Edit: I see climate change isn't even mentioned which is an enormous red flag when talking about hydro power.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Ekaros 3y agoI don't think any dams that produce meaningful amount of energy are going to be removed any time soon. These are the ones that used to power mills and like. So we are talking about way under 1MW in power each.
- Gibbon1 3y agoThey are removing all the old dams on the Klamath River. Company that ended up owning them considers them a white elephant because the revenue from power isn't enough to pay for needed refurbishment, operating costs, and insurance.
- sumtechguy 3y agoThis is the real reason most of these are removed. No one wants a 100+ year old dam that need several million dollars worth of work and the ROI is negative. So they remove them and everyone is happy. Most of the ones that are removed are well past their use by sticker date.
- bobthepanda 3y agoEven according to the owners, the Klamath River dams represent less than 2% of the power generated by that electric company. https://www.opb.org/article/2022/11/18/klamath-river-dam-removal-southern-oregon-dams-northern-california-drought/ https://www.opb.org/article/2022/11/18/klamath-river-dam-rem...
- DarkNova6 3y agoIronically and historically it has been mostly the Green party which was against building new dams, as they disturb natural ecosystems.
- rmccue 3y agoThe Australian Greens (one of the earliest Green parties) were founded basically off the back of opposition to dams in Tasmania: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franklin_Dam_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franklin_Dam_controversy
- voisin 3y agoWhy do you find this ironic? Doesn’t this follow logically: Greens don’t want new dams due to environmental impact and now dams are been dismantled due to the negative impact on the environment.
- DarkNova6 3y agoBecause nowadays green(s) are more associated with the fight against Climate change.
- outside1234 3y agoHopefully they replace them with Coal in Germany
- Someone 3y agoEurope isn’t the only one. The USA is doing it, too, for more or less the same reasons. https://www.americanrivers.org/2024/02/saying-adios-to-80-dams-in-2023/ https://www.americanrivers.org/2024/02/saying-adios-to-80-da...: “As many have heard by now, 2023 was a major milestone year for dam removal in the U.S., with the initiation of the largest dam removal project in the country on the Klamath River in California. However, you may not have heard about the 79 other dams that were removed, reconnecting 1,160 upstream river miles. These projects reestablished migration corridors, made natural and human communities more resilient to climate change, improved access to habitat to promote biodiversity, eliminated safety hazards and maintenance costs, enhanced access to rivers for local communities, reestablished natural processes for healthy rivers, and many other benefits.”
- mordae 3y agoSo, what about pumped storage?
- Ekaros 3y agoNo meaningful height differential. Which is one component increasing energy storage capacity linearly.
- masklinn 3y agoIf wildlife is involved these are almost certainly small run-of-the-river dams. For pumped hydro you need significant elevation differentials, a pretty good vertical, and lakes at both the top and bottom. Sites suitable for pumped hydro are really not common, and the financial investment and utility means they wouldn't be getting dismantled.
- lencastre 3y agoSure, let all that precious untapped potential energy and source of fresh water go to the sea. When the yearly 1000 year dry season comes,… then you can thank your Nestle shares. Hydro power is so misunderstood.
- AdamJacobMuller 3y agoWhile I broadly agree with you, most of the dam removal projects I see in the US are tiny dams which have little to no potential for use as fresh water sources and generate tiny amounts of electricity. I'm strongly in favor of replacing the lost capacity with much larger dams though which have the ability to hold non-trivial amounts of water and have the ability to generate significant amounts of power. Relatively speaking, the ecological impacts are disproportionately large for what we gain with smaller dams.
- bobthepanda 3y agoI actually wouldn't consider dams very good for climate change resilience either. They get affected by drought, which is increasing due to climate change.
- kibwen 3y agoWhy on Earth is this submission flagged?
- blikdak 3y agoA dam is many things; is it for generating electricity? Is it political or ideological? Does it give a geographical advantage? Is it extortionate? Is it for drinking water? Is it beavers? This thing doesn't explain what it thinks a dam is.