5 ms·
Reddit CEO defends $193M compensation following backlash from unpaid moderators
- iLoveOncall 3y agoVolunteer work is unpaid, more at 5.
- mananaysiempre 3y agoNot precisely. Both Reddit volunteer work and (the vast majority of) Wikipedia volunteer work is unpaid, but the legal rights you get to everyone else’s (and retain to yours) are different enough that it’s foolish to engage in the former but reasonable to engage in the latter. Not that everyone will want to work on Wikipedia, but at least it’s not a bad idea on its face. (Stack Overflow toyed with going over to the Reddit side, but they have backed off for now.)
- sysstemlord 3y agoSince when does Reddit make $193M yearly profit? It seems a lot has happened since I stopped using Reddit.
- iLoveOncall 3y agoSalaries don't come out of profits. Profits are calculated after employee compensations obviously.
- Folcon 3y agoSure, but there's a sort of nominal expectation that post salaries, especially salaries of that magnitude an entity has some profit. The obvious exception being they had an unprofitable year but have a gigantic pile of money sat in a bank somewhere.
- passwordoops 3y agoSo maybe the CEO compensation should be adjusted accordingly?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> maybe the CEO compensation should be adjusted accordingly? This is outside the domain of unpaid moderators’ unless the CEO’s compensation is threatening the company’s survival. It clearly is not.
- passwordoops 3y ago$193M compensation to lead a business to unprofitability is a problem. Period.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> $193M compensation to lead a business to unprofitability is a problem. Period. The compensation did not lead to unprofitability—it contributed to it. And we have no evidence by which to claim it would have been worse under less-paid management. (Well, with Reddit, we might.) I’m not defending the compensation per se. But arguing everyone at any profitable entity should be paid less until the venture is profitable, irrespective of any other facts, is silly. Particularly when it comes to non-cash compensation.
- pjc50 3y ago> But arguing everyone at any [un?]profitable entity should be paid less until the venture is profitable, irrespective of any other facts, is silly. This is the argument usually made for redundancies: reducing the overall payroll.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> the argument usually made for redundancies: reducing the overall payroll It’s for increasing profits. Redundancies are reduces at profitable and unprofitable firms alike.
- hgomersall 3y agoOk, but when you look at the forecast, and see an expected loss of 90 million, maybe the CEO should say, perhaps if I was paid 90 million less then we will be in profit, and I would still have enough money to retire in excessive luxury.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- giantg2 3y agoClearly there's a group of people of people who are selfish and think so highly of themselves that this sort of logic will never make sense to them. Any company or executive that says they care about the workers, customers, or cause and is making 8+ figures is lying whether they realize it or not. I realize some people will make the argument that the comp needs to be so high to attract top talent. But there's a pool of talented people who would do it for less. Plenty of non-profits or mission-driven companies have lower paided executives.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 3y agoDoesn't sound like the CEOs problem; he isn't there to make personal sacrifices to make the company profitable and I don't think anyone would pretend he is. If anyone should be making that observation it is whoever signs off on his compensation. Although the compensation package won't cash so the situation isn't quite that simple.
- giantg2 3y agoIt can only be viewed as a sacrifice if you believe he legitimately deserves that much money. That money could be used to increase employee comp instead of shareholder value. That's a lot of money for running an unprofitable business. I wish I was so delusional that I thought I deserved 100s of millions for running an unprofitable company.
- pjc50 3y agoDistinction without a difference. If the salary was lower, the profit would be higher. No, the important distinction is "is that coming from cash or stocks". The cash component of salaries goes in the profit&loss account. See https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1713445/000162828024006294/reddits-1q423.htm#i1b9a579e78a34dfa99f7f26daeec195b_40 https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1713445/000162828024... Revenue $804m (!), expenses $944m (!). But I'm having trouble working out which of the expenses breakdown entries has the board salary in. And if it's compensation in stock, does that have to be expensed?
- TheAdamist 3y agoThe CEO is paid $193M, this has nothing to do with any profit reddit makes. Which, they have never made a profit, "Now, Reddit — which is not yet profitable"......"Reddit reported a net loss of $90.8 million in 2023, a narrower loss than the $158.6 million loss it netted in 2022." https://www.cnn.com/2024/02/23/tech/reddit-ipo-filing-business-plan/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2024/02/23/tech/reddit-ipo-filing-busine...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- giantg2 3y agoPretty wild that a CEO can make that sort of money while running an unprofitable business. I can't imagine thinking so much of myself that I would value myself at 100s of millions. I wonder if there's some sort of pathology behind it.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> wonder if there's some sort of pathology behind it That of taking a company public. I get where you’re coming from. But Reddit, given its heritage of leadership, is a weird hill to take a stand on.
- consp 3y ago> "Reddit reported a net loss of $90.8 million in 2023, a narrower loss than the $158.6 million loss it netted in 2022." I know it's naive but cutting the CEO's (and rest of C suite) salary to normal employee levels would fix that loss down to 0.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> cutting the CEO's (and rest of C suite) salary to normal employee levels would fix that loss down to 0 Now do it with cash flow.
- 3y ago
- rightbyte 3y agoAt some point you are the problem if you work for free for a commercial entity. This neo-$whatever belief in that commercial entities can replace community run things can't die off soon enough.
- Radim 3y ago> At some point you are the problem if you work for free for a commercial entity. Sounds harsh, but this is the correct stance. The free labour you provide is not only "your loss". There are second order effects: you effectively make it harder for others to compete with said commercial entity. This includes salaried employees of competing companies whose wages you effectively press down. And even other volunteers and non-profits, because defending and sustaining their project in face of "free inputs, for-profit outputs" competition is that much harder. Community projects die because of this. "Working for free for a commercial entity" is just a bad idea all around. You exploit yourself (whatever, your choice, you may be getting other kicks out of it) and harm others.
- romwell 3y agoYou just provided free content (a brief opinion piece) for publication on a commercial entity (HackerNews, run by YCombinator)... ...which, according to you, is a "bad idea all around", since you exploit yourself and harm others. So, why are you acting against your morals and judgement?
- koolba 3y agoIt’s not necessarily a bad idea if the individualized return is positive. Feeling like a big shot for making a cogent point in a public forum has an unquantifiable non zero worth to the commenter.
- Radim 3y ago> has an unquantifiable non zero worth to the commenter. Yes, that's the "other kicks out of it" above. Already covered. More importantly: > You just provided free content (a brief opinion piece) for publication on a commercial entity (HackerNews, run by YCombinator)... ...which, according to you, is a "bad idea all around", since you exploit yourself and harm others. If HackerNews is indeed a PR branch of some commercial entity, then people posting here for free provide value (which is not to say any of my comments do…) to that entity. Potentially harming alternative forums, whether free or commercial. The point stands. > So, why are you acting against your morals and judgement? Good call. I guess I didn't perceive HN as for-profit. Perhaps OP's "At some point" is now, for me.
- nashashmi 3y agomoderators are not professionals working according to direction. They are doing things as they see fit. And some of them are doing things for their own agenda (G. Maxwell) paid by some shadow org. Fine. The other mods are complaining that they are doing some very noble work and are doing it for free. That's how noble work goes. It is thankless. If any mods want money, I think they should be allowed to pin sponsored threads and use that for referrals. Oh wait! They can do that already. I guess they are trashing on the CEO for not giving them a network of sponsors whose ads they can pin and make special money.
- sesm 3y agoThat’s a good point. In video game related subreddits mods are often employees of the publishing company.
- shp0ngle 3y agoThey can do another blackout since the last one was so successful and achieved all its goals
- Ylpertnodi 3y ago>They can do another blackout since the last one was so successful and achieved all its goals Gotta start somewhere.
- RileyJames 3y agoReddit going public (again) is such a weird and egregious destruction of any value that reddit had left. It’s like Wikipedia going public with the expectation that it would continue to hold any value going forward. The proposition can’t hold true.
- passwordoops 3y agoGotta cash in on the AI hype while you can! I figure the price will track the AI bubble, so probably go up, then crash and burn when investors realize LLMs are good tools, but not $30 a month good to most business clients. But the execs and board will make of quite handsomely by then
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Gotta cash in on the AI hype while you can Reddit is among the most-trafficked websites on the planet. Its value has little to do with AI and everything with attention.
- passwordoops 3y ago2010 called, they want their social graph back: https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/1atb6ac/reddit_has_a_new_ai_training_deal_to_sell_user/ https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/1atb6ac/reddit_has... https://techcrunch.com/2024/02/22/reddit-says-its-made-203m-so-far-licensing-its-data/ https://techcrunch.com/2024/02/22/reddit-says-its-made-203m-... https://www.cnbc.com/2024/03/15/ftc-investigating-reddit-over-ai-data-licensing-practices-ahead-of-ipo.html https://www.cnbc.com/2024/03/15/ftc-investigating-reddit-ove...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> 2010 called, they want their social graph back Attention sells ads. A social graph is something else. About as relevant as yelling about AI potential. Maybe it’s there. But again, a separate argument.
- 3y ago
- hsjsbeebue 3y agoReddit is one of the few places you can build an audience and attract people for free. The trouble is most subs aren’t for profit so the mods don’t benefit. Given the mods money might be good but it might be bad in that you attract people trying to make a buck and ultimately spammers and AI crap.
- pennybanks 3y agowhat would a for profit sub look like? paid entry? a specialized market place that takes commission? wouldnt it just be like fb marketplace if they did create a sub with profit in mind?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hsjsbeebue 3y agoa sub that is the community for a paid product (although that is not reddit like) a sub with sponsorship maybe
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoIt could like like a youtube channel with ads. Some of the revenue from ads shown in that sub go to pay the moderator.
- ionwake 3y agoIts a bit annoying the "you cant use reddit unless you open the native app" moment to short the company, came before it IPO'd. Sorry if this is negative, but like wtf have they been doing to it over the last 10 years. As a plus, the native app IS great. But at what cost bros.
- nmfisher 3y agoReddit mods are quite far down the list of "people I have sympathy for". Arguably (?) they play a role in keeping out spam/off-topic posts, but there's a reason reddit is often referred to as a hivemind. Mods play a big part in that.
- boomboomsubban 3y agoNot being paid plays a role in that. A person willing to spend countless hours on unpaid volunteer work is likely to have some other motivation. The common ones are flexing their ego or being ideologically driven. Some genuinely like the topic they're moderating, but they often get burnt out by how shitty the job is.
- Barrin92 3y agoIsn't this an exceptionally high compensation even among American CEOs? This makes him what, the second highest paid CEO after Sundar, twice as well compensated as Tim Cook? For Reddit estimated at 6 billion? It's not obvious from the article but is this a one time thing stretched out over years?
- Takennickname 3y agoWhich probably means he has no faith in the company's stock or else he would have taken stock options instead of taking it all in cash.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- suddenclarity 3y agoIt's almost all stock with an estimated fictional value. As stated in the article.
- frankjr 3y ago> In anticipation to Reddit's IPO, it was revealed that Huffman’s compensation package for 2023 was worth $193.2 million, which included salary of $341,346, stock awards worth $98.3 million and stock options valued at $93.8 million.
- waitforit 3y agoMany people complain about that number (not necessarily on hackernews, but there are some comments like that already) without realizing that most of that value is based on the stock price and not cash. Depending on how the IPO fares this $193M value can turn into $1M or $1B+ (both extremes and very unlikely to happen). He got around $1.1M in cash. > According to an SEC filing, Huffman got a salary of $341,346 in 2023 and a $792,000 “incentive” bonus. In February, Huffman’s salary was raised to $550,000 with the bulk of his $193 million compensation package tied to stock.
- pavlov 3y agoThe same applies to all public company CEOs. They all get paid mostly in stock. Ultimately it's the other shareholders paying these compensation packages. They may sometimes be well deserved, but discussing and criticizing them is fair too. Sometimes courts do strike down excesses. Elon Musk's $55 billion package was voided by a Delaware court because the Tesla board didn't follow proper procedure. (I.e. not because he didn't create shareholder value — he absolutely did! — but because the process was flawed.)
- epolanski 3y agoStock compensation is arguably way more valuable than cash compensation unless you're leading a sinking ship, taxation is much better and you get more power/votes in the company.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoI'm sure the most active mods would be happy to have shares worth only a mere few hundred thousand dollars? Regardless of the amount it's a particularly egregious example of profiting from other people's hard work.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoBut when the victims are willing and enthusiastic participants, who would complain bitterly if they were barred from contributing their free labor, what are you supposed to do? Their free labor is compensated by something else, probably status or power, obviously, so it's not clear that anyone is being taken advantage of.
- threeseed 3y agoMany of the moderators are very much paid. Some work for the companies that a subreddit may be centred around, others get kickbacks from those looking to promote products and my favourite are the state actors who help to ensure certain viewpoints dominate. But of course Reddit has been happy to turn the other cheek to all of this over the decades. Anything goes so long as it doesn’t end up in the media.
- TrackerFF 3y agoI'm a big user of reddit, but the platform has definitively suffered a bunch of things that could be tied up to their use of free moderation: - Some subreddits are so politically biased, that you really need to know the political leaning prior to using them. Getting locked out of huge subreddits like r/worldnews is easy as pie, if you just write the wrong things on certain topics. - A bunch of subreddits automatically get closed/locked due to lack of moderators. - There are so many different rules to follow. Just posting something in a random sub comes with a 50/50 chance of your post getting removed or shadow-banned. And let's not even start on the straight up enshittification of the platform features. I fully expect reddit to become a completely close-off / walled garden app that follows the worst TikTok practices. As long as I can use old.reddit, I'm happy, but I think we all know that it will disappear one day. As for the compensation...yeah, outrageous comp when the site is feeding off free work. And the usual corporate response from the CEO "The board decides my compensation, and if the website does well then so do I"
- o_____________o 3y ago> There are so many different rules to follow. Just posting something in a random sub comes with a 50/50 chance of your post getting removed or shadow-banned. Reddit has god awful UX/I and makes moderation very difficult. They could help themselves with very simple features like post templates and flows, but instead, every semi-popular subreddit faces a daily onslaught of low effort users posting repetitious garbage. Users will feel frustrated by seeing the garbage, but also launch into righteous complaints about mods if they're moderated. They also make it clear that a post is being held for moderation and then encourage the user to message the moderators directly, so now you have low effort, high volume, and a guaranteed sense of immediate opposition. The real takeaway for me is that at this point, Reddit is popular because it's popular, not because it deserves anything.
- thinkingemote 3y agoReddit has huge value in hidden marketing. Many users, subreddits and moderators are paid by companies. These create a lot of good content! It's not obvious bland marketing it's good and engaging. They work to promote people, products and companies from the boring to the new, the safe to the illicit. It's exactly the same with Musks twitter: getting the power users who are paid to tweet to pay the platform.
- some1else 3y agoMaybe spend a couple bucks on bringing closed captions to video AMAs. I clicked the link to the embed featured in the article, and it's 20 min of unsubtitled speech. https://www.reddit.com/r/RDDT/comments/1bhr6uv/amalmosta_answers_but_make_it_video/ https://www.reddit.com/r/RDDT/comments/1bhr6uv/amalmosta_ans...
- AnonC 3y agoSome 2022 figures below for comparison. This is total compensation (including stocks), not just base salary. Andy Jassy, Amazon: $1.3 million (a big fall from $212 million the year before) Jensen Huang, Nvidia: about $21 million Mark Zuckerberg, Meta: about $26 million Satya Nadella, Microsoft: about $55 million Tim Cook, Apple: about $100 million Sundar Pichai, Alphabet: about $226 million It’s not very surprising to see that a CEO (u/spez) who’s actively driving the company into the ground gets an atrocious pay. I hope all the large investors in the Reddit IPO ‘lose their shirts’. The hype can’t get any louder.
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]