5 ms·
I suspect that nobody thought of a 2 wheel design because nobody thought it would be stable. The hinge between the front and back wheel is crucial. Even today,
by WalterBright 3y ago
I suspect that nobody thought of a 2 wheel design because nobody thought it would be stable. The hinge between the front and back wheel is crucial. Even today, few bicyclists understand how a bicycle is able to turn and remain upright.
None of the early designs seemed to have any brakes, making them quite impractical.
Without modern steel and machined parts, a bicycle of wood and iron would simply be too heavy.
- digdugdirk 3y agoThis. Also, horses are the original self-driving transportation, and anyone with the means to buy some newfangled technology like the early bicycle. It's been a hundred years and we're still not better in that regard than the finest of equine hybrid technology, so can you imagine the landed gentry giving that up to... Exert themselves to travel to town? (Queue 'bicycle as feminist icon' comments below)
- pimlottc 3y agoThat should be “cue”
- rob74 3y agoYup... before the industrial revolution, those who could have theoretically afforded a bicycle (and had a need to transport only themselves to somewhere else) could also afford a horse, while all the others not only couldn't afford a bicycle, but also had no need for one. Peasants barely left their village, and if they did, it was to deliver some produce, either to their landlord or to the market, and for that a bicycle wouldn't have helped...
- bawolff 3y ago> landed gentry giving that up to... Exert themselves to travel to town? Landed gentry often love showing off their wealth in ecentric ways, so yes i could imagine that.
- fbdab103 3y agoMaybe there would have been an opportunity for a three-wheel recumbent bike to be developed first? Seems like a lot of easier engineering if you can take stability as a given and just worry about the driver supplying direction and power.
- saalweachter 3y agoEh, doesn't work well with the factors that led to the penny-farthing. The penny-farthing was a direct drive on the front wheel - no chain. It had you positioned on top of the wheel to get as much traction as possible. A primitive recumbent trike would tend towards the same design, like a child's trike, with no chain and a direct drive on the front wheel. And because you'd get terrible traction, with so little weight, you'd be dead in the water until the machining was available to engineer a chain system to connect pedals in front of the cyclist with wheels underneath. I don't think there's any penny-and-two-farthings intermediate to make the recumbent trike work before that.
- loeg 3y ago> None of the early designs seemed to have any brakes, making them quite impractical. None of them were freehub designs, so you could always backpedal to slow down. It's definitely more work than a real brake, but it's not nothing.
- NegativeLatency 3y agoIf they even had pedals
- loeg 3y agoThere's always the "Ted Shred" (braking by applying your foot to the rear wheel).
- giraffe_lady 3y agoCan't rule out the possibility that victorians were whipping sick skids. My fixie brothers & sisters through time.
- loeg 3y ago49x19 is life!
- School-Cotton 3y ago> Even today, few bicyclists understand how a bicycle is able to turn and remain upright. I’d go so far as to say no cyclist understands. AFAIK there’s no simple physical explanation.
- Smoosh 3y agoFortnine recently made a video (motorcycles, but still applicable) which I think aids in understanding the issues and debunks some incorrect ideas. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSZiKrtJ7Y0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSZiKrtJ7Y0
- aaronharnly 3y agoThank you, great video.
- beryilma 3y agoMotorcycles and bicycles turn with the same principle: countersteering. When I started riding motorcycles, I bought a well-known motorcycling book. It had a whole chapter on countersteering because there are even today many seasoned motorcyclists who don't believe or understand that you turn using countersteering.
- kqr 3y agoYou're answering the wrong question. The question is not "how does the rider initiate a lean" which is usually through countersteering. The actual question is "Why, when you give a bicycle a good shove, does it stay upright on its own, continually changing its direction to balance itself?"
- barrkel 3y agoThe counter steering answer to that question is rake, the fact that the steering axis hits the ground in front of the contact patch if the front tire, so that when a bike is leaned over it self-steers into the turn (the contact patch torques the wheel around the steering axis) and countersteers itself upright. It's well known in motorbikes that the amount of rake is what makes a bike more stable vs more responsive to steering. Some folks lower the front of the bike - tighten the triple tree lower on the forks - to increase responsiveness on otherwise more boring bikes. Of course there's more to it all, gyroscopic effects and so on, but this is the countersteering perspective.
- jmopp 3y agoThe bicycles that were made from wood and iron gave an extremely stiff ride and were called boneshakers.
- Ekaros 3y agoAt time when roads were not what they are these days. Lot of their improvement before cars became from bicycles.
- Lio 3y agoThere's a good book about that very subject, The Roads Were Not Made For Cars[1]. https://roadswerenotbuiltforcars.com/ https://roadswerenotbuiltforcars.com/
- kgabis 3y agoI think pneumatic tires are the single most important invention when it comes to making bicycles comfortable and allowing smaller wheel sizes.
- soperj 3y agoPeople have made stable bike frames out of bamboo.
- amelius 3y agoNobody would think walking is as stable as we know it is (try to put e.g. a Star Wars action figure in standing position on a table, it is not so easy and not very stable). There's more to it than just Newtonian mechanics.