5 ms·
From anxiety to cancer, the evidence against ultra-processed food piles up
- h2odragon 3y ago"evidence piles up" well of course it does. Who is paying for studies to show the benefits of processed foods? The time individuals don't have to spend preparing their meals, the energy they don't buy and the fuel they don't burn to cook these items; surely those social and environmental factors should be added to the balance, when we weigh the costs and benefits? Imagine someone does start studies to publicize the benefits of industrial foods. Imagine the NPR headlines about "Science for Sale" and how the industry is buying propaganda.
- wk_end 3y agoI guarantee the industrial-food-complex is paying scientists to identify potential benefits of ultra-processed food.
- stakhanov 3y ago> I guarantee the industrial-food-complex is paying scientists to identify potential benefits of ultra-processed food. I just don't think that this particular mode of "money corrupts science" is happening much. I mean the kind of thing where a big industry facing an image problem would say: Hey, let's bribe some scientists to do bogus studies, and use the "findings" as ammo in a public relations war. Maybe that kind of thing was happening when the tobacco industry was lobbying against regulation. But nowadays, I'm having a hard time believing that. Because, nowadays, science is the weakest it's ever been in history (going back, maybe to the middle ages, where it might have been even worse), as a method of actually changing minds. So public relations wars would be fought differently, in a way that didn't involve science much. Second, I think it doesn't jibe with the personality structures of most scientists, as far as their motivations go. They've already decided for themselves that money is not all that high on their hierarchy of motivations, otherwise they wouldn't be scientists. What I think is happening instead is that money is an instrument that corrupts science in a direction of confirmation bias. Essentially you have to ask yourself: What happens if scientist X tells us about their research on YouTube? Would that person be able to build a successful following? -- Even if that scientist despises YouTube, there is a ton of institutional pressure on scientists these days to communicate their work publicly, so to a first approximation, thinking of the "YouTube court of public opinion on science" to decide a scientists' career fate, is an approximation that's not too far off the mark. "Ultra-processed foods are bad for you" is currently very much the way the wind is blowing. Any scientist who claimed otherwise would be seriously sticking their necks out with regard to the institutional context they're embedded in. Any scientist who goes an YouTube and tells people "my research shows that ultra-processed foods are bad for you and, oh by the way, here is a food product I really recommend" can become world-famous and rich. You do the math.
- qgin 3y agohttps://www.scientificamerican.com/article/food-industry-backed-research-gives-results-funders-want-new-analysis-shows/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/food-industry-bac...
- seanhandley 3y agoCompanies like Coca Cola overplay the benefits of exercise as the solution to health problems so they can continue to sell ultra processed "food" with an extremely healthy profit margin. UPF isn't food. It's "edible food-like substances" and it exists to make money, not to keep you in good health through your life.
- qgin 3y agoIt's why nearly every soda vending machine has a sticker like this: "Balance what you EAT, DRINK, and DO" https://www.bevindustry.com/articles/89678-aba-addresses-obesity-crisis-through-balance-calories-initiative https://www.bevindustry.com/articles/89678-aba-addresses-obe...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- qgin 3y agoI'm not sure I believe that companies making ultra processed foods are victims of a catch-22 where they are unable to reveal the truth of how healthy their ultra processed food is because of the social shame that would come from funding a study.
- ipython 3y agoThat was an npr headline. https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-point-blame-at-fat https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074...
- maxcoder4 3y agoI can't identify your point. Studies that show harms/benefits of processed food are good, because they let us make decisions based on facts (as opposed to emotions). Of course there are tradeoffs involved.
- segasaturn 3y agoMy correlation vs causation sense is kicking in here - people eating "ultra processed food" (whatever that means) in the U.S. are usually going to be lower income people who can't afford a fancy Whole Foods diet, or don't have the time to prepare those foods. People who are poor and short on time are probably also more likely to have stress/anxiety and poor health. Skimming through the article there's no mention of controlling for those factors. Lastly, Amazon sponsors NPR and owns Whole Foods. No footnote mentioning the conflict of interest in this article? :)
- curiousllama 3y agoYea, the paper makes clear it's a associative meta-analysis, and the conclusion is basically "we should figure out what the mechanism is" Plus, even if it is causal, it's not really new information: we know high-salt, high-calorie, nutrient-deficient foods (which ultraprocessed foods tend to be) DO causally drive the negative health outcomes described in the paper. So like, this is basically a study that goes "yup, all the small studies are still saying this know-to-be-bad thing is still bad, despite recent interventions - let's go figure out if there's more mechanisms we missed here, or if it's just a matter of more interventions/individual choice at this point"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dfxm12 3y agoI disagree. We can only buy what's being offered. You joke about not knowing what ultra processed means, well, most consumers probably don't know orange juice from orange drink, the difference between chocolate candy and dark chocolate, etc. The question is, why is that stuff even available for sale if it is so bad? Even whole foods sells a lot of ultra processed stuff, believe it or not. I wish I could go to a store and be confident that the bottle of orange stuff I pick up is just freshly squeezed orange juice and not... something else. That's just not the world we live in though.
- mchanson 3y agoI often find the definition of ultra processed difficult. I put pea protein powder in my smoothies. That is certainly ultra processed however it has good macro nutrients and is not empty calories. I understand the concept of “empty calories”, but ultra processed seems like a blend of that and how the food was made.
- passwordoops 3y agoI'm sure "ultra processed" is a term concocted by the industry to cause a muddying of the waters leading to discussions of semantics over specifics.
- antif 3y ago> certainly ultra processed Pardon, but where's the ultra processing? Isn't pea protein just dried peas in a blender? I figured ultra processed was reserved for things like ascorbic acid, pectin, and xanthan gum.
- float4 3y agoMost people buy pea protein isolate. This is a more complex product where the protein has actually been separated from the remainder of the peas. (Not sure if it would qualify as ultra processed though.)
- antif 3y agoYou're right on the isolate.. Just found this video showing how they're separating the starch and fiber from pea protein. https://youtu.be/wbX_w0ZIunM https://youtu.be/wbX_w0ZIunM
- TylerE 3y agoYou’re literally pulverizing the peas. That’s pretty extreme processing compared to, say, steaming some veggies
- gruez 3y ago
- miketery 3y agoMcDonald’s is a solid part of my diet (mostly double cheese and sometimes chicken sandwich, never sodas). I’m in best health I’ve ever been. The gold standard is large scale human randomized control trials (RCT). All of it shows that calorie balance (with sufficient protein), and strength training is all you need for a healthy system. Everything else is cope or people trying to sell you snake oil. Go lift and count your macros. Do this for 30 days you’ll see night and day results if you’re just starting out.
- klyrs 3y ago> Go lift and count your macros. Do this for 30 days you’ll see night and day results if you’re just starting out. You're talking about your muscles, which tells us nothing about symptoms such as cancer and anxiety. Your anecdote doesn't even approach the questions raised in the study.
- zer00eyz 3y ago>> count your macros Hes also talking about a whole diet. Making sure that he gets everything he needs and in the right proportion. He's getting exercise. This is miles away from "I only eat processed food" that some people have moved too. Some without even realizing how much processed food they are eating.
- klyrs 3y agoNonetheless, you can count macros and lift to your heart's content but if your diet includes lead paint chips your physical and mental health will ultimately suffer. I'm not saying that ultraprocessed foods are as bad as lead paint chips, just that this line of reasoning falls short of addressing the concerns raised in studies on ultraprocessed foods.
- zer00eyz 3y agoI like how you picked lead paint and not doom scrolling on your phone while sitting on the couch instead off going out and getting exercise and being social. God forbid our own industry hold up a mirror and admit we might be part of the problem.
- amanj41 3y agoA concern I've had with past studies has been the dosage of processed foods. It's better to avoid them altogether, but I haven't seen many seeking to find limits on how one can safely have X percent of their diet be from ultra-processed foods and still be healthy. It seems like the biggest correlation between overall health and processed food intake is that processed foods are calorie dense and lead to weight gain. If excess calories are coming from sugars and unhealthy fats, and one is consuming large amounts of bad additives, that will surely lead to bad outcomes. What I would like to see is isocaloric studies, where individuals get plenty of fiber, micronutrients and a good macronutritional balance from "healthy" foods, but are also allowed some reasonable percentage of their daily intake to be processed. Maybe it's the guilt of feeling like I'm a weaker person for being addicted to having desserts or chips on a regular basis, but I also feel like they are pleasures of modern life that are worth enjoying in moderation. I mainly strive to eat healthy for all my core meals, and allow myself ultra-processed snacks, while not gaining weight.
- mfer 3y agoThere are guidelines for how much saturated fat, sugar, and other things to have in your diet per day (on average). These are based on many health studies over time. I try to stay at or below the numbers on average and I do treat myself sometimes. But, I can't very much because it would lead to overeating things that would drive up my cholesterol and cause other bad things. Have to eat lots of fruit and vegetables. A problem is that most people eating ultra processed foods blow those category numbers away. I was looking at the label on some food this week. One serving size, which is about half of what an American would usually eat, was over half the saturated fat and sugar someone should have per day. For people who eat processed food for most meals, it's easy to go many times these numbers which has a lot of long term consequences.
- kbf 3y agoI have Crohn’s disease and while there’s still a lot that isn’t understood, it’s clear that it’s linked to highly processed food. Crohn’s is more prevalent in western populations and it’s rising in places that are adopting western diets. There are studies showing that patients who don’t see results from medication can still achieve remission through a strict Mediterranean diet. Obesity is a huge problem and the spotlight on it is warranted, but it’s also a very simple issue to understand and deal with. The effects of ultra processed foods are more complex and far less understood.
- stakhanov 3y agoHN is really on a roll lately, with the ultra-processed food stuff. [1,2] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39711527 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39711527 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39675111 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39675111
- HPsquared 3y agoStressed people eat processed food. Stress causes health problems.
- seanhandley 3y agoProcessed food isn't the same as ultra processed. This is specifically about the NOVA classification of foods.
- iwanttocomment 3y agoYet the NOVA classifications are inherently contradictory. "Processed foods" involve salt, sugar or oil added to unprocessed or minimally processed foods. Many premium ice creams are merely milk and cream (considered unprocessed or minimally processed), sugar and salt. Yet all ice creams are considered ultra-processed. Take that, ice cream! Fruits in sugar syrup are considered "processed", yet sweetened juices are considered "ultra-processed". Huh? Salted nuts are considered "processed" foods. Yet "salty packaged snacks" which would include salted nuts, are considered "ultra processed". Do I have to roast and salt the nuts myself? Where is the processing here? Is the package the problem? Soups are considered "group 2" foods, which are unprocessed or minimally processed foods combined with oil, sugar or salt, but canned soups are considered ultra-processed. Yeah, OK. Like, you can kind of see what they're going for, but when you start looking at all the edge cases, it devolves into lunacy. The actual mechanisms of ultra-processing need to be defined, not these examples which simply don't hold.
- reverius42 3y ago> Is the package the problem? It very well might be.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- seanhandley 3y agoA good way to think of UPF is that it's "pre-chewed" food, due to the highly refined nature of it. The food matrix (structure) is destroyed, which fundamentally changes how your body metabolises it, bearing in mind this is a system evolved over millions of years to break down a mixture of whole foods in stages. It's not even about the macronutrients - it's completely mismatched to our physiology. The nutrients are quickly absorbed due to the lack of structure so you get big blood sugar spikes and dips, making it hard to manage appetite (invariably leading to over-eating). UPF is generally low fibre, so the microbiome is starved. It often contains emulsifiers which have the effect of a detergent in the gut lining, further damaging the microbiome. It shouldn't be called "food". It's industrially produced pseudo-food with increasingly convincing evidence that it's contributing significantly to heart disease, diabetes, mental health issues, etc.
- kevinrpope 3y agoGenuine question: do you have any links you could share regarding the "emulsifiers as detergent" claim? I assume this mainly refers to chemical emulsifiers and not those that are naturally-occuring (like in eggs or garlic).
- throwaway2562 3y agoThis is a great example of how bad nutrition data is, and why meta studies are to be treated with caution. They took 45 studies, but 90% of them were either low or very low quality. ‘Overall, using the GRADE framework, 22 pooled analyses were rated as low quality, with 19 rated as very low quality and four rated as moderate quality.‘
- lainga 3y agoHow do these low-quality studies come about? Who is paying for them?
- chiefalchemist 3y agoThese foods tend to be consumed because of convenience (read: to save time). But is it necessary to save time because they don't have time to spare (e.g., works 2+ jobs) and are under stress. Along the same lines, if a person is time-challenged, then I would imagine odds are they don't have time to exercise either. I avoid ultra-processed foods. But I'm curious if the lifestyle (?) such foods cater to might also contribute to the health issues (i.e., anxiety, cancer, etc.)
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoI can highly recommend the book Ultra-processed People by Chris van Tulleken about what UPF does (and doesn't) do with our bodies. And if you don't want to read the book, here's a ~1h video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QOTBreQaIk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QOTBreQaIk talking about UPF. You don't even need to watch it, just listening is enough to make you think twice about buying many different kinds of food.