2 ms·
> ask any competent engineer about the sort of control inputs which are needed to maintain smooth-ish operation of a half-decent system The Taylor Rule system
by pjc50 3y ago
> ask any competent engineer about the sort of control inputs which are needed to maintain smooth-ish operation of a half-decent system
The Taylor Rule system of inflation control actually works extremely well. Being a system with one input and one output variable, classical control theory can be easily applied. But - very importantly - this kind of control system is not immune to external shocks (someone trying to push over your inverted pendulum), has a huge phase lag (months to years), and also does not take into account other side effects (unemployment!). Which is why the Russian invasion of Ukraine triggered a worldwide transient (impulse response) inflation.
https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/basics/72-inflation-targeting.htm https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/basics/72-inflati...
That said, economics has a serious problem with politically motivated bad economics, and the multiple "schools" warring with one another.
- GenerWork 3y ago>Which is why the Russian invasion of Ukraine triggered a worldwide transient (impulse response) inflation. I think the worlds response to Covid (money printing) had a lot more to do with inflation that Russia invading Ukraine.
- disgruntledphd2 3y agoIt's important to distinguish between the US and Europe, when talking about this. From a US perspective, the impact of Russia's invasion of Ukraine on energy prices (and hence inflation) was relatively muted. For Europe, on the other hand, the impact was incredibly large. Additionally, Ukraine supplied huge amounts of grain to EU farmers for livestock, which put a double impact onto food prices in the year following. Finally, the money printing during Covid was wildly different in terms of distributional impacts between the US and Europe, so it's relatively unhelpful to talk about global impacts.
- gilleain 3y ago> other side effects (unemployment!) It was startling to see discussion of interest rates that talked about how increasing unemployment brought down inflation - almost as if it was a good thing to increase unemployment... Sometimes people think of these abstract models of human systems as if the system itself is the important thing, not the humans that make it up. Like considering social systems as 'Darwinian' without considering that 'survival of the fittest' implies 'death of the unfit'.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Taylor Rule system of inflation control actually works extremely well What are you basing this on? The Taylor Rule was suggested as a toy model--that's why a_pi and a_y were set to the magic value of 0.5 without further thought given to it. Its own author abandoned it as computers became advanced enough to run more complicated models.