4 ms·
Why African startups don't always need to expand across the continent
- Mordisquitos 3y agoIt says something about the myopic obsession with growth and the ignorance of global cultural diversity that is prevalent in Silicon-Valley-ish tech capitalism that such a statement is deemed notable enough to deserve a headline and that the interviewee is expected to justify it. No startup "needs" to expand across anything. A startup is a business in its early stages. A business satisfies a need in given market, and not all markets are the same. A business can cease to grow and yet continue providing value for society, its owners and its employees.
- foldr 3y agoAlso, Nigeria is a huge country (population 230 million). US startups aren't necessarily expected to expand even as far as Canada or Mexico. It's not clear why there should be an analogous expectation on a Nigerian startup.
- Ozzie_osman 3y agoWell no economy in Africa compares in size to the economy of the US by any means, and for our VC-fueled industry, it's more about total addressable market than anything. That said, totally agree with the comment you're replying to. The idea that startups need to expand across "Africa" or "the Middle East", etc, is both a result of VC-fueled startup strategy and ignorance of the diversity of those continents/regions. Hell, even expanding across a single country like India can be drastically more difficult than the US due to differences in laws, language, culture, etc across different states / regions.
- bluGill 3y agoToday. Hopefully those countries will grow their ecconomy. If you can help that you will do well.
- FinnKuhn 3y agoInvestors don't measure potential for companies not by how many potential customers they have, but by the purchasing power of their potential customers.
- foldr 3y agoInvestors are interested in ROI. A Nigerian business will tend to have lower costs as well as lower potential income. It may be a smaller investment than a company that’s targeting the US market, but not necessarily a bad one.
- lupire 3y agoIs Nigerian cloud computing as cheap as Nigerian food? Unless the whole supply chain is local, you're still paying global prices for some things.
- mooreds 3y agoGDP is about 1/3 of Australia. https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/profile/NGA https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/profile/NGA https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/profile/AUS https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/profile/AUS Seems big enough to support a lot of great companies to me!
- asdff 3y agoStartups might poof into smoke in a matter of months while your local plumbing company has been a family business for half a century and has no shortage of work.
- ozim 3y agoEverything you wrote already outlines why nothing about family owned plumbing company is interesting. My father was not a plumber and he had no business like it - as a young person looking to make my impact on world it doesn’t matter. Has no shortage of work but also cannot scale besides couple employees and trusting/trusted customers, word of mouth - as an investor that’s not good for me and I am out. Good for people running those businesses but instead of trying to fight incumbent companies on existing market where they had 50 years headstart - and they will push me out to keep their turf - I have much more opportunity trying to do something new or something I can grow in multiple ecosystems in case it goes poof in one place, where in other place it might blossom.
- alephnerd 3y ago> is prevalent in Silicon-Valley-ish tech capitalism Us VCs and PMs (so called "MBAs") aren't dummies. This article is moreso about the fact that "Africa" is not a unitary market but in reality an extremely diverse market with multiple different markets. The kind of GTM needed to go big in Kenya is entirely different from Nigeria which is different from South Africa. The scene in Nigeria and East Africa reminds me of India and ASEAN in the 1990s-2000s, and ime chatting with some African founders (a couple of whom ended up in YC) the strategies are similar. There are some legal and historical intricacies that cause this difference that I can elaborate on if there is interest.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alephnerd 3y agoThis is a must read article for HNers about the value about localization and points out that "Africa" is not a unitary market but in reality an extremely diverse market with multiple different markets. The kind of GTM needed to go big in Kenya is entirely different from Nigeria which is different from South Africa. The scene in Nigeria and East Africa reminds me of India and ASEAN in the 1990s-2000s, and ime chatting with some African founders (a couple of whom ended up in YC) the strategies are similar. (I can't speak about Françafrique so if anyone can give me insight into that I'd love it!) There are some legal and historical intricacies that cause this difference that I can elaborate on if there is interest (I don't want to write a massive essay no one will read) Edit: finished it below. Sorry it it's incoherent. I realized this could be a book unto itself and editing in the gym is a PITA
- AnthonBerg 3y agoPlease! It would be of great interest. (The reason for the interest is at once trivial and profound – African music saved my life. My heart is there now although I’ve never been there myself.)
- alephnerd 3y agoOn it! Will take a bit of time!
- patcon 3y agoPlease post a new share or self post! and link to it here :) (Just bc the eyes one this comment section might die down by the time you get it written!)
- alephnerd 3y agoI posted a crummy tl;dr below. I realized while writing this, that it could be a substack series about the domino effect of innovation globally, but I can only write so much in a comment section
- 3y ago
- bee_rider 3y ago> For instance, product adoption is slower in countries like Ghana, and scaling a digital savings product in Kenya will be a huge challenge. Does anyone know the “why” behind these statements? (I bet they are obvious statements for the typical “restofworld.org” audience, but maybe the more general HN audience will find the question interesting— at least I hope I’m not unusually oblivious!)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alephnerd 3y agoIn Kenya's case because of a hypercompetitive fintech market. In Ghana because it has a well established fintech infra already through a UPI style system called e-Zwich - https://carnegieendowment.org/2022/09/19/digital-financial-inclusion-and-security-regulation-of-mobile-money-in-ghana-pub-87949 https://carnegieendowment.org/2022/09/19/digital-financial-i...
- rvba 3y agoIsnt this the same thing? Slow product adoption = difficult to get users. Scaling a product = difficult to get users Bootstrapping is hard. Also perhaps different markets are different due to local law and competition. But isnt water wet?
- bee_rider 3y agoCould be local law, competition, or maybe the people are more or less conservative about this kind of stuff in different countries. > Also perhaps different markets are different due to local law and competition. I’m just curious (for no real reason, just curiosity) and want to nail down the “perhaps.” > But isnt water wet? If you ask a chemist or physicist why water is wet you might get an interesting answer!
- alephnerd 3y ago> competition It's this. Ghana and Kenya have some of the most robust fintech industries in Africa.
- Havoc 3y agoI'm more surprised why we don't see more of the opposite - western startups testing their ideas in Africa as a sandbox and then expanding out. Not a huge amount of disposable income there sure, but for the right product its the perfect testing ground. e.g. zipline doing on demand blood deliveries to hospital in Rwanda. I bet their recent US drone authorization was in no small part due to their ability to point to a live operation doing at scale life/death critical deliveries with success. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOWDNBu9DkU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOWDNBu9DkU
- resolutebat 3y agoDoing business in Africa is playing life in hard mode, particularly if you're a startup with no local connections.
- notahacker 3y agoGetting VC-sized returns from medical deliveries in Africa is incredibly difficult compared with building a CRUD app and throwing VC money at sales and marketing to people that speak the same language and use the same web platforms as you and have orders of magnitude more to spend. Some of the interesting tech stuff coming out of Africa like mobile money doesn't translate into a Western environment even if it excels in Africa too.
- alephnerd 3y agoRwanda's success is overstated. They hired an amazing PR and Lobbying team from Racepoint and BTP Advisers to rehabilitate their image since 2010.
- suddenclarity 3y agoRwanda always rubbed me the wrong way since Sweden (among others) is handing them millions in financial aid every year only for them to use the money to be a shirt sponsor for Arsenal FC.
- alephnerd 3y ago
- throwaway920102 3y agoDoes anyone have any advice for someone who's done a bit of solo travel in Europe and Asia and a teensy bit in South America but is considering going to Accra or Kampala or Nairobi or Kigali or Lagos, as far as how to figure out where to go?
- __s 3y agoRecently worked on a site easysencanada specifically aimed at helping students in Senegal study abroad in Canada It's targeting a specific socioeconomic situation which doesn't generalize across Africa: relatively wealthy families wanting their children to study abroad in French while having trouble understanding paperwork & available colleges/universities (the older relatives may speak Wolof primarily)
- alephnerd 3y agoOh whoa! That's pretty cool! Are you going to expand it across Francafrique or are you going to stick to Senegal for now? How does Canada vs France vs Belgium rank among Senegalese at least from a education perspective? I thought the French Canadian unis were weaker in prestige than their France counterparts, but I guess having the ability to get PR in Canada is a massive value add. Would love to compare it with similar products aimed at Indians and Chinese in a similar economic strata who are targeting Canada, Australia, and the UK. Edit: ah, it's education visa consultancy. That makes sense! Yea you'll def do well!
- __s 3y agoI helped with implementing site on the side, so not involved in its operations except as a friend. But I think the business owner aims to expand to more visa consultancy categories instead of other countries As such, I'm also not sure about relative prestige of different countries, but my understanding is there's a lot of demand to study abroad anywhere. Canada in particular tends to have overlooked openings because most people will only focus on Quebec for French studies, but there's plenty of French studies (& francophone population) in northern Ontario, east coast, & even Saskatchewan