3 ms·
Scanning the exam's questions, I really can't see them as "hard" in the conventional sense. Hard would be a question in math, physics or some other field which
by joe_the_user 15y ago
Scanning the exam's questions, I really can't see them as "hard" in the conventional sense.
Hard would be a question in math, physics or some other field which has a very difficult to discover objective answer. There's no limit to hard here but these essay questions are different. "Should wealth be inheritable?" just doesn't have an objective answer and one's answer could only be judged based on whatever the exam grader thinks is a good answer (well written, clever, whatever). In fact, considering one can choose three out of twenty seven, the exam doesn't seem much harder than some essay exams I've taken that were supposed to be extremely easy (CBest, for example). Some of the essays would be require to marshal facts in a given field (classics or economics) but we can hope the writers have some expertise in something.
I think the only way the questions could be considered hard would be if someone taking it thought they needed to settle one or another of these debatable questions. There you have might the situation where geeks and humanities majors each think the other has "really hard exams"...
Edit: And that's "are there objective probabilities" - an English major could take half an hour to answer without worrying about whether they'd really objectively established their answer. We geeks will stop and aim for an "objective" answer. But while one can establish whatever model one wants in the realm of math, one isn't going to pin down the concept of "objective" and "probability" as used by English speaking humans today.
- aplusbi 15y agoIt sounds like people are [mis-]using the word "hard" to mean "selective".
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pcrh 15y agoSome of the most pressing problems in society don't have answers that fit into the mindset of the more mathematically-minded among us. They are problems nonetheless, for example: should free speech exist? You can't answer that question using science, yet we need people to think about that kind of thing. For what it's worth, the reputation of All Souls College (which does not have students) is strongest in the humanities.
- joe_the_user 15y agoSaying the exam wasn't "hard" as such wasn't intended to slight All Souls College or the humanities. It seems like what makes a question part of the humanities is that many if not most humans have some sort of answer to the question. For that reason, I imagine the humanities might be better served not conjuring up images of super-hard exams only a few can pass.
- pcrh 15y agoFrom the perspective of All Souls, they do want exams that only a few can pass. The goal of this kind of exam is to identify original and insightful thinkers. I presume that it is hoped that those who enter All Souls will make original and long-lasting contributions to their field of endeavor. In the natural sciences, a similar effort is supported by the Howard Hughes Foundation at Janelia Farms, as described here: http://www.nature.com/news/research-at-janelia-life-on-the-farm-1.9373 http://www.nature.com/news/research-at-janelia-life-on-the-f...