9 ms·
Cloudflare loses 22% of its domains in Freenom .tk shutdown
- albertfredrick 3y ago[flagged]
- thangngoc89 3y agoUnrelated to the article but seeing .tk brings back many memories. As a kid without a bank account let's alone an international credit card (VISA/Mastercard), dot.tk is the only way to put a website online with your name. I created countless of websites with .tk for classmates, school and families.
- miki123211 3y agoWhat are kids using these days? Serious question, Heroku and .tk were such amazing services if you weren't old enough to get a credit card.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- captn3m0 3y agoI used .co.nr alongside .tk for a while, before moving to .co.cc, and then finally managing a way to buy my domain.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoI think I had co.nr too! I just dont remember if it was like .tk or if it was one of those webhosts.
- jszymborski 3y agoI definitely had a .co.nr domain before a .tk. I think I also remember (I was likely 13, so its been a while) that they had an "English" test question on the sign up form that read something like "A Britney Spears is a:" and one of the options was "Hamburger". Looking back this could have been to slow robots down, but I distinctly remember one if the terms being you speak and host English content. Another service I used a lot was " dominosfree" which had a bunch of .gs domains that looked like CC-tlds. I used .ca.gs a lot.
- tamimio 3y agoAh, co.cc, the tld that was full of php reverse shells!
- creatonez 3y ago.co.nr was strange because it put your page inside of an iframe and required advertisement of the service.
- captn3m0 3y agoYeah, the cloaking was annoying - navigation across pages wouldn’t update the URL.
- 101008 3y agoSame here. .tk was the only one back then that allowed you to have your own domain name without subdomains. My memory is that: 1. freeserver.com/~userna <- This was the first URl you could have, sometimes with something inside another directory (freeserver.com/users/u/~usernam). 2. username.freeserver.com <- This wasn't that bad but it didn't look professional. Tripod used to do this. 3. username.fs.com <-- A service with a short domain that provided free subdomains. This was similar to 2 but shorter. Some of them allowed you to chose the domian part. 4. username.tk <-- Among all the free options, this was the best one by far. Then we grew up a bit and started paying domains :')
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoFriend of mine had a .tk domain for a while, last one he used was a .aa.am domain for his Minecraft server, lol.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoIm trying to remember I think it was 8m.com or something like that? Which also let you have stuff like username.8m.com its probably gone now. I also miss tripod, not sure if its still around how it used to be. Angelfire comes to mind too.
- moltar 3y agoOh ya. I had my first website on 8m.com still available in the archives!! Best days!
- davchana 3y agoThose sites are still up, the control panel is at freeservers.com my Site davinder.8m.net is still up after 22 years. I chose .net because it was cooler than .com :)
- giancarlostoro 3y agoHah! Thats awesome, I don’t recall any of the names I used to be honest, its been too many years.
- syuil 3y agoOh man, this brings back memories from high school! .tk was a blessing for us.
- DaSHacka 3y agoSame here! I remember registering a .tk domain for a school project I was working on at the time, my friends were all so impressed when I showed them it was available as a website they could visit in their browser
- lnxg33k1 3y agoIn italy we had 3000.it https://web.archive.org/web/20010331143129/http://www.klimanet.3000.it/ https://web.archive.org/web/20010331143129/http://www.kliman... SPOILER: I didn’t become a webdesigner
- UnlockedSecrets 3y agoBut did you become a webmaster?
- rightbyte 3y ago"Copyright © by klimato ® All Right Reserved" Heh. I remember thinking '©' and '®' being cool letters. I put it on every page since it looked pro. I guess you didn't actually register the "brand"?
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI believe you don't have to do anything to claim copyright, other than make it yourself. One vague legal source I just read says that adding the copyright symbol and notice means you may be entitled to more damages if someone infringes on your copyright though.
- 3y ago
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y agoGod. I’d forgotten all about .tk until reading this comment. What an amazing time.
- tamimio 3y agoI remember flexing on my friends that the google site I had got a proper name with .tk!
- xeromal 3y agoI remember in the early 90s telling Mom that I built my own website. Mom was like noway that's impossible. I can't remember exactly where it was but it was like zoogatyler1.go.com or something. I think it was owned by Disney? I must have been around 7 or 8 but I remember being so excited. I think it was more of a homepage than anything. I started delving into those .tk sites when I was around 11 or 12 probably.
- stef25 3y agoI launched one on a compuserve domain (I think) around the same time. Built it with FrontPage Express that came for free on a cd with a magazine my dad bought. Day after I launched it I had like 20 emails from random people with questions & comments about the site, crazy. Build it and they will come was def a thing. Later on in the UK I put a site on a madasafish domain.
- atum47 3y agoI used to host my websites wherever and then having a redirect to it. Two I remember was pagina.de/dr.enima (roughly translates to site of dr.enigma, my nickname back then) and i.am/supermatrix - a website dedicated to the movie the matrix which I love. I think both of those pages were hosted in geocities and had pretty long urls...
- atum47 3y agoIf i recall correctly, i use frames with size 0 on the top and 100% on the bottom, making that annoying banner invisible
- wnevets 3y agoI remember switching to cjb.net because you could get free wildcard email accounts for your domain.
- a1o 3y agoNow that is a name I haven't heard in a long time. I had a Dragon Ball Z website using that domain, feels so long ago.
- p3rls 3y agoIt's interesting seeing it parallels the problems with .tks today-- I remember using cjb.net to make my own LOVE@AOL websites and phish AOL users telling them that a crush liked their account. Easiest money a 12 year old ever made.
- xyst 3y agosame - I remember hosting a small web server from a crappy pc at my parents house and using a .tk to serve the site. Probably not the smartest thing to do at the time since I may have opened up all ports on the router to get it to work, lol. No https. No security. No moderation. Copy and pasted some html from a site that I thought was cool, search and replaced text to make it my own. It was kind of like a microblog before twitter, fb, ig, blogspot, tumblr.
- accrual 3y agoMy favorite was .uni.cc, I had a couple of those free domains back in the day.
- dpacmittal 3y agoDid you also use 000webhost.com with .tk domains like me?
- mmsimanga 3y agoIn South Africa you could get a za.net domain for free. They stopped new registrations quite some time back as the spam era of the internet was getting started. I still have my domain and use it for all sorts of different things. From email to experiments. Name server changes are still done through email.
- rldjbpin 3y agoi share a similar story but today we don't seem to have any alternatives. it is a shame really but i wonder if there is something else that does not involve freenom today.
- chomp 3y agoThank god, .tk caused so many headaches for us, truly a cesspit of a tld. The rate of fraud and abuse on our platform was staggeringly high from it, it was close 99%.
- jackblemming 3y agoYou think that fraud is just going to go away because .tk is gone?
- jamespo 3y agoprobably not, but very little of value has been lost
- _mlbt 3y agoI would disagree, I remember as a kid in the late 90s being able to host a website on one of the free hosting providers and then pairing it with a free domain name just made the whole thing that much more special. $10 or so a year for a paid domain name isn't a ton of money, but it can be for a kid with no credit cards and parents that aren't convinced as to why you "need" a domain name.
- bombcar 3y agoThe problem is that "free for kids" is also "free for scammers" and it's hard to square that circle.
- kdmccormick 3y agoWould be really cool if public schools provided a free domain and basic hosting for any interested middle/high school student.
- cube00 3y agoGood luck considering we can't even pay teachers properly.
- estebarb 3y agoOh, that is why I wasn't able to renew some domains I have used for 10+ years. I'm not even able to upgrade to paid domain. I don't think it will help reducing malware/scams/phishing. But it will hurt students and young people that want to start in en development and aren't able to pay for a domain.
- wizzwizz4 3y agoWe still have https://nic.eu.org/ https://nic.eu.org/ and https://freedns.afraid.org/ https://freedns.afraid.org/ .
- 8organicbits 3y agoThere's a couple more options too: https://free.wdh.gg/#/?id=domains https://free.wdh.gg/#/?id=domains
- iopq 3y agoI applied for a domain at nic.eu.org in 2023 and I have never gotten a response
- dazld 3y agoFor students, a few of the GitHub Education Student Pack partners offer free domains for a year. https://www.name.com/partner/github-students https://www.name.com/partner/github-students https://get.tech/github-student-developer-pack https://get.tech/github-student-developer-pack https://nc.me/ https://nc.me/
- _mlbt 3y agoAnother prominent .tk domain is for the Tcl programming language (tcl.tk) and I just checked, that is one of the paid .tk domains that are still up.
- overstay8930 3y agoWhy do orgs feel the need to use these whacky TLDs I’m still of the fence with rust using .rs in important places which is fundamentally in control of the Serbian government. You’re going to have to trust the Serbian government with signing .rs DNSSSEC at minimum and I don’t.
- _mlbt 3y agoIn TCL’s case it’s a fun play on Tcl/Tk, which is how it is often referred to when including its famous GUI toolkit.
- Fnoord 3y agoRemnant of a time when the Internet was new and geeks would buy all kind of fun domains with odd TLDs.
- bdcravens 3y ago"new"? I don't remember seeing many of the "odd TLDs" for sale until the web had been around 10-15 years.
- Fnoord 3y agoNot the TLDs themselves the creative use of them. I started on the Internet in the (mid) 90s. Back then, it was already common among security conscious folks. A bit later, end 90s, you could buy a shell account for a couple of USD per month. You could run a BNC on it, or IRC client. It had various IPv4 with reverse DNS, this was called vhost. For example, you could end up with I.pwned.the.whole.eu.org and plays where TLD was part of word. Goatse.cx for example reads 'goatsex', Slashdot.org reads 'slashdotdotorg' or 'httpcolonslashslashslashdotdotorg', the founder of first Dutch consumer ISP Xs4all Rop Gonggrijp had gonggri.jp for ages (guess his email address). There are countless of examples.
- toddmorey 3y agoI get .tk was popular because it was free and you do need a home for your website that’s portable across providers (not like a .netlify.app sub). But like we learned from .af, any of these TLDs technically meant for a country need to be considered ephemeral. You are sort of borrowing it without explicit (or lasting) permission.
- samtho 3y ago> You are sort of borrowing it without explicit (or lasting) permission. To be fair, this is true of all domains. The broader concern with ccTLDs is this borrowing dynamic layered with whatever geopolitical situation the country is in, how stable the administering authority is with respect to the current regime, or just the political forces at work within the country that may lead to changes or requirements for the ccTLD within the country are registered. There is often a concern of DNS infrastructure and local bandwidth considerations for the data center in which the root nameservers are housed, assuming they are not outsourcing that.
- CydeWeys 3y agoIt's not true of gTLDs though. You actually own those domains, and they can't be taken away from you (barring extreme circumstances) so long as you pay the registration fees every year. But domains on ccTLDs can be taken away from you by the government at any time for any reason.
- genewitch 3y agoI gotta say i find it extremely hard to believe that one can "own" a domain. This sounds like hand-waving. We don't own software, we barely own computers (to do with what we want), we don't own media. Is this like "one can own land" but really that's asterisked with Eminent Domain (no pun intended)?
- CydeWeys 3y agoReal estate is a pretty good analogy for this, actually. You own domains on gTLDs in the same way that you can own property, but you have to pay your annual property taxes (domain registration fees) else you can lose it. But owning a domain on a ccTLD is more like renting property in a jurisdiction that doesn't have rent control; at any point the actual owner can simply say you're not allowed to use it anymore, and tough luck. Look at what happened to British .eu registrants, for example. Also you can own all sorts of intangible things, so it's really not that foreign of a concept. You can own parts of the RF spectrum in your country, or mineral rights to a specific piece of land, or you can own a piece of intellectual property or a patent. Domain names are just another flavor of intangible property ownership.
- overstay8930 3y agoThe people complaining that Cloudflare hosts these criminals would be the first ones complaining that Cloudflare has too much power when taking down websites it doesn’t like. You can’t win with these people, I personally think this is the best outcome and shows our systems work (albeit slowly). Sure it took a while, but now there doesn’t have to be a precedent of Cloudflare acting as the internet police more than it has to.
- lolinder 3y ago> You can’t win with these people This is the classic fallacy of assuming that because you see comments of type A and comments of type B on the same forum that means they're the same people. They're usually not. A more accurate way to phrase this is "you can't win with ... people". Whatever you do will end up ticking off some subset of the population.
- mypastself 3y ago“These people” is presumably a set of people quick to find fault in anything a corporation does, which could be a superset of those two groups. Not sure what kind of fallacy that’s supposed to be.
- __s 3y agointersection, not superset
- kortilla 3y agoThose people are in the noise and nobody cares what they think once they realize they just criticize for the sake of it. That doesn’t change that people seem to think the top upvoted comments being contradictory from day to day represents some kind of inconsistency in the views of the commenters on this site.
- mathgradthrow 3y agoYour evidence for the non-emptiness of this set of people is the fallacy above
- thih9 3y agoThe article presents this as a loss - but cloudflare has a free tier, do we know if these were paid accounts? If cloudflare weren’t going to convert these users then this could be a gain.
- PokestarFan 3y agoIf the users were using free domains instead of paying for a domain do you think they'd use paid cloudflare? The cost of a domain is so much lower than the cost of Cloudflare.
- thih9 3y agoI don’t know and that’s why I’m asking. Not paying for a domain is not a reason enough to expect not paying for cloudflare - these are different services. Also note that even not paying for cloudflare is not enough - I asked whether cloudflare intended to convert that segment.
- sltkr 3y agoI could at least imagine a scenario along the lines of: penniless college student creates a site at a .tk domain. Later, the student gets a job so he is no longer penniless, and meanwhile, his site actually becomes popular, so he signs up for cloudflare, maybe even registers a .com domain, but keeps the .tk domain alive because that's where most his traffic is coming from. Not sure how common that is. But I don't think it's a given that all sites hosted on .tk domains are unwilling to pay, especially not if you consider that they must be somewhat popular if they need a CDN. (The sort of personal homepage that most of us had back in the 90s would never need a CDN because it would get 5 hits per week.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoIs there any other connection to Cloudflare? I thought maybe they were using the .cf domain for their own stuff or something. ;)
- bastawhiz 3y ago> The affected domains represent a big loss for Cloudflare, with .tk, .cf and .gq previously accounting for 23.1% of all domains hosted on its platform – and nearly all of these have now gone. I'm not sure in what way this is a "loss". I doubt cloudflare is losing money (or revenue) here. Especially if many of these domains are spammy, it seems like this is probably not much of anything for them.
- jacurtis 3y agoThis was my thought while reading this. Overall I think this is a net-win for CloudFlare. I suspect that exactly 0.00% of the 12.6 million domains they just "lost" were paying customers. Considering the people didn't want to pay for a domain, they probably weren't paying for a CDN either. I'm sure Cloudflare will be able to wipe away their tears of this loss using the extra dollar bills they have from reducing their bandwidth costs.
- ncruces 3y agoI had a free website on .tk When it because moderately successful, they didn't renew, and then wanted 50€/year.
- nicrtt 3y agoAhhh, the memories :) Understandable, but a loss all the same. I'll never forget how proud I felt as a kid when I first had a URL I could give to people.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dancemethis 3y agoTangentially, Cloudflare REALLY needs to start supporting transferring .moe domains already.
- znpy 3y agoUh… if anybody has a legitimate .tk domain, how does one keep it alive?
- qingcharles 3y agoI used to pay for mine. They were sold through resellers if you wanted to keep it. One advantage of .tk is that they supported emoji domains.
- znpy 3y agoWhich resellers?
- qingcharles 3y agoI bought mine through infomaniak.com.
- znpy 3y agoI'm trying to move a legitimate domain to them but I'm getting this error: Entity reference not found [Object does not exist] Has something similar happened to you ?
- qingcharles 3y agoAre you trying to move a .tk? I don't know if anyone can accept a .tk now -- the whole situation with that TLD is a clusterfuck now :( I can't renew the one I had.
- jacurtis 3y agoI'm sure CloudFlare is just reeling from this "loss" of 12.3 Million unpaid customers. I hope the CEO doesn't drink too much tequila tonight during the celebrations
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoMy friends and I used cjb.net for our anime website
- mastazi 3y agoIs it safe to assume that these were overwhelmingly on Cloudflare's free tier? I don't expect that someone who gets a domain for free is going to pay for hosting; if that's the case I don't see this as a big loss for Cloudflare, or am I missing something?
- creatonez 3y agoI would guess the same, that these are not Cloudflare customers but rather domains that happened to be configured on Cloudflare. CF probably just increased their profit margin a little by no longer handling all those free users.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- rurban 3y agoYeah, I've lost my cannes-ratings.tk around that time without any explanation. Lucky I decided to finally pay for the .org a year before.