7 ms·
What are the "worst" spelling bee pangrams?
- angiosperm 3y agoThe one-liner to solve that SB is grep -v '[^victmze]' /usr/share/dict/words | grep .... | grep e A program to generate all possible NYTM SB puzzles is at https://github.com/ncm/nytm-spelling-bee https://github.com/ncm/nytm-spelling-bee . The alterations to match the online version are trivial. It runs in well under 100 ms on a modern CPU. There are bigger dictionaries packaged, e.g. wamerican-huge.
- mvkel 3y agoJust came here to say: bill mill is an awesome human and I'm glad to see his work appreciated here!
- spyspy 3y agoThe minimum puzzle length for spelling bee is 20 words iirc. The dictionary is also a highly curated list of “common” words. What constitutes a valid word is up to Sam, the NYT editor. It’s designed to make the puzzles doable by the average solver. You’ll notice that a lot of the words in the OP are very esoteric. Source: helped build SB at NYT.
- namanyayg 3y ago> Source: helped build SB at NYT. Wow. Another example of HN at its finest. Great work on the game btw. My gf introduced me to the game and we love it. Though, we play a variation of it against one another in which we open the game on a single screen and whoever finds a pangram first wins.
- angiosperm 3y agoTo share remotely, one player gets halfway to genius, pangram forbidden, and the second player gets over the line. After that you use SB Buddy (no peeking at hints) to get to Queeen Bee. The most annoying missing wordlist words are naphtha and caracal. An objective measure of word-use frequency should determine the words included. Probably super-obscure articles of clerical costume should not be.
- tptacek 3y agoSo you need a 10-letter pangram that generates like 19 4-letter words. :)
- llimllib 3y agoThanks for the insight! There's no actual answer to the question, given that the word list can be set inconsistently, so I had to choose _something_ to go off. The best word list I was able to find is the one hosted by https://www.sbsolver.com/ https://www.sbsolver.com/ , but unfortunately they don't distribute it. I got a somewhat better word list for part 2: https://notes.billmill.org/blog/2024/03/mitzVah_-_the__worst__pangrams_part_2.html https://notes.billmill.org/blog/2024/03/mitzVah_-_the__worst... But it's still imperfect. However a lot of the words I expected to be invalid have actually been in puzzles before, so it's not easy to guess which are going to be good and which aren't. edit: there have been puzzles with as few as 16 words before: https://www.sbsolver.com/stats/count/low https://www.sbsolver.com/stats/count/low edit 2: I modified the program to print puzzles with at least 16 words, and the "worst" puzzles it found with that constraint are: unbEknown, jawbonE, monadnocK, woRkgRoup, daGlock, moonwalK, confLux, buLLhorn, yOkOzuna, Fraught, hogliKe
- spyspy 3y agoThey've loosened up the rules since I left many moons ago, likely to expand number of puzzles without repeats. IIRC we had about 5 years worth at the beginning.
- dmurray 3y agoI think your word list is still considerably too large. Zero chance in my mind that jouk or qajaq, for example, would make it to the NYT wordlist. (I don't think they'd even be accepted in the crossword, which has looser standards, unless there was a very specific theme that called for them). Apart from being obscure, their only use seems to be as non-standard spellings, for juke and kayak respectively. The Spelling Bee doesn't even accept UK spellings. At least 5 of the proposed pangrams wouldn't make the cut, either.
- llimllib 3y agoI agree with you, do you have a better one? I can only work with what I have
- 3y ago
- ddejohn 3y agoVery cool, thanks! I play every morning. There are times when Sam's curation is very frustrating. It would be nice to submit other valid words and have the game verify them as a way to score "bonus" points. Oftentimes I find that there are some baffling omissions and, after the fact, some truly bizarre inclusions. It would be nice to be able to score points based on your own vocabulary while still having the game's score based on whatever common denominator Sam comes up with.
- dsjoerg 3y agoAgreed, I get frustrated a few days a week with curation inclusions and exclusions. DOORYARD, MICROMINI, NONCOM, ROMCOM are in the list and IMO shouldn't be. UNTENDED, MONOTONIC, BOLE are not in the list but IMO deserve to be.
- StefanBatory 3y agoAs a nonnative speaker it's first time ever I've heard word "bole" being used
- gomox 3y agoI still remember my disappointment when I entered HEMOPHAGE and it was deemed "not a valid word".
- angiosperm 3y agonaphtha and caracal.
- dmurray 3y agoAnd naphthalene, which would have been a pangram that day.
- themadturk 3y agoI seem to remember both those words were put forward in the hints page, too!
- banana_giraffe 3y agoThat may be the target, but there have been a handful of Spelling Bees with less than 20 words in the answer list. For instance, March 27, 2023 had 16 answers: > MORTIFY, FORTIFY, FIFTY, FORTY, MOTIF, FIRM, FOOT, FORM, FORT, FROM, IFFY, MIFF, RIFF, RIFT, ROOF, TIFF
- darth_aardvark 3y agoToot, trot, tort, and moot aren't legal?
- ztravis 3y agoFrom the list of words, I think F was the required (central) letter.
- ajkjk 3y agoYou have to use the center letter, whatever it was.
- banana_giraffe 3y agoAs others have pointed out, all words must have the center letter, which was "F" on this day, the outer letters were "I M O R T Y"
- spyspy 3y agoVery possible. The've loosened the rules have a bit since I originally generated the puzzles e.g. they now allow more than one vowel, i+n+g and e+d are allowed in puzzles, possibly more
- angiosperm 3y agothe "ed" and "ing" puzzles are just annoying.
- JadeNB 3y ago> The've loosened the rules have a bit since I originally generated the puzzles e.g. they now allow more than one vowel, …. The original Bees allowed only one vowel? That must have made it really tough to get long Bees!
- tzs 3y agoIs it the same dictionary Letter Boxed uses?
- schoen 3y agoDefinitely not! I play both and Letter Boxed accepts many more words.
- dehrmann 3y ago> What constitutes a valid word is up to Sam, the NYT editor I think the only listed words I'd think would get approved are jukebox, quixotic, and gimmickry.
- basil-rash 3y ago> Every day's puzzle is guaranteed to have at least one pangram. I’m almost certain that wasn’t true for at least one puzzle early this year, but haven’t been able to come up with an exact date.
- banana_giraffe 3y agoThe 2140 or so puzzles I've grabbed over the years all have at least one panagram. > 1: 1642, 2: 364, 3: 90, 4: 24, 7: 2, 5: 12, 6: 5, 8: 1 That 8 panagram day was December 16, 2021
- chockablock 3y agoOfficial rules say otherwise: "Each puzzle includes at least one “pangram,” which uses every letter." https://www.nytimes.com/puzzles/spelling-bee https://www.nytimes.com/puzzles/spelling-bee -> click on 'How to Play'
- tptacek 3y agoI've always assumed they generate the puzzle starting from a pangram.
- JadeNB 3y agohttps://nytbee.com/ https://nytbee.com/ is an excellent source for historical data, if you'd like to try to track it down.
- karagenit 3y agoVery neat. Would it be more efficient to start with every known pangram (~35k) and calculate the score from there instead of scoring every possible set of 7 letters (~8B) and then filtering for pangrams?
- llimllib 3y agoThe problem is that if you do that, you have to test every word (~42k) against every pangram (~16k) to see if it's a subset. I just wrote two quick test programs to find the score of the set of words for every pangrams, and my approach takes 6s vs 15s for your proposed approach: https://gist.github.com/llimllib/cc01daa8be8ced13ddeb6c76cf115fcc https://gist.github.com/llimllib/cc01daa8be8ced13ddeb6c76cf1...
- hlfshell 3y agoI love when people get fascinated by a puzzle and deep dive into it like this. Great article. Similarly I was fascinated by LetterBoxed, another NYT game and took a crack at a solver. https://hlfshell.ai/posts/letter-puzzles/ https://hlfshell.ai/posts/letter-puzzles/
- tkgally 3y agoI’m a fan of LetterBoxed, too. The NYT’s solutions are always two words, which I rarely get on my own. But once, a couple of years ago, I discovered a one-word solution to one day’s puzzle: LEXICOGRAPHY. Very elegant, I thought to myself smugly. I happened to remember that solution a couple of months ago, and I decided to see if I could find others. I am not a programmer, but by asking ChatGPT 4 for help I was able to create a Python program and run it in Google Colab using a large list of English words that I had compiled from various online word lists. Here is the beginning of the resulting list of one-word solutions to LetterBoxed: acetylcholinesterase [a c e] [h i l] [n o r] [s t y] acetylcholinesterases [a c e] [h i l] [n o r] [s t y] achondroplastic [a c d] [h i l] [n o p] [r s t] acknowledgement [a c d] [e g k] [l m n] [o t w] acknowledgment [a c d] [e g k] [l m n] [o t w] The code that ChatGPT 4 wrote for me and the full list of solutions are here: https://gally.net/temp/20240318onewordsolutionstoletterboxed.html https://gally.net/temp/20240318onewordsolutionstoletterboxed...
- tkgally 3y agoWhoops. Looking through that list of words again, I see that some of the puzzle configurations could not yield those solutions, because adjacent letters in the solution are in the same triplet. The configuration for acknowledgment, for example, has a and c in the same triplet, which is not possible in LetterBox. My bad. I’ll take a look at the code again later.
- tkgally 3y agoWith Claude 3 Opus’s help, I think I have fixed the code. The corrected code, which took more than two hours to run in Google Colab, and the resulting list of one-word solutions to LetterBoxed are here: https://gally.net/temp/20240318onewordsolutionstoletterboxed.html https://gally.net/temp/20240318onewordsolutionstoletterboxed...
- philshem 3y agoHere is a TUI player and solver that maybe is of interest: https://github.com/philshem/open-spelling-bee https://github.com/philshem/open-spelling-bee
- angiosperm 3y agoThe one-liner to solve that SB is grep -v '[^victmze]' /usr/share/dict/words | grep .... | grep e A very short program to generate all possible puzzles given a word list is at https://github.com/ncm/nytm-spelling-bee https://github.com/ncm/nytm-spelling-bee .
- jeffbee 3y agoIt is certainly possible on some days to hit the "Solid" score, which is the terminal rank for free users, with only a pangram.
- kjhcvkek77 3y agoAm I missing something or does this not take the center-letter rule into account?
- waiwai933 3y agoPart 2 does
- jjcm 3y agoIronic that `equivoke`, defined as a word or phrase that has multiple meanings, is the word that when shuffled has the fewest meanings.
- nlawalker 3y agoRelated aside: if you like Spelling Bee, try NYT’s new game Strands: https://www.nytimes.com/games/strands https://www.nytimes.com/games/strands It’s in beta right now and so I believe is accessible to everyone. Make sure to read the instructions. I love puzzles but for some reason I’ve never been into word/dictionary games (Spelling Bee; Boggle; Scrabble) but since hearing about Strands via https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2024/03/strands-word-search-game/677656/?gift=Ex_YT3j3w4bpWvzqHtkwO6BVPcqjF0fMIpYafiavsnQ&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2024/03/stran... I’ve played every day.
- frereubu 3y agoThanks for this. Funny that it's not on my Games page (I'm an NYT Games subscriber) unlike, I think, Connections, which was shown on that page with a "beta" flag.
- Agingcoder 3y agoIndeed that’s a very good game. Thanks.
- macintux 3y agoAs an aside, I’ve been frustrated at some of the game list’s omissions. When “ullage” was not in the list, but a week or two later “doggo” was, I considered giving up. Fun game, but frustrating and annoying at times.
- gwern 3y agoThe double-backlink at the bottom is amusing - I recognize this bug from painful experience. OP counted each of the 2 links in the other article as a backlink, and didn't deduplicate. But... if you deduplicate, then you are unable to do true bidirectional backlinks to the original caller. You can't figure out 'which' link in the other article is meant. You need HTML IDs set on each, but they have to be different ID-anchors (obviously, and also because it'd be bad/invalid HTML to have duplicate IDs). So you actually need to track not just the other article but the ID inside the other article, and a way to generate those link IDs to begin with (since you definitely don't want to do it by hand). Gets tricky.
- algas 3y agoYup, here's the problem [0]: def calculate_backlinks( pages: Dict[str, Page], attachments: Dict[str, Attachment] ) -> None: for page in pages.values(): for link in page.links: linked_page = find(pages, attachments, link) if not linked_page: info(f"unable to find link", link, page.title) continue linked_page.backlinks.append(page) No deduplication performed. Since he's parsing the backlinks directly out of the markdown, you don't have to worry about a recursive loop where the backlinks section on one page appears as links in another. A simple solution would be to change the datatype of backlinks from list to set. [0] From OP's static site generator: https://github.com/llimllib/obsidian_notes/blob/main/run.py https://github.com/llimllib/obsidian_notes/blob/main/run.py
- im3w1l 3y agoWrote this which runs basically instantly https://pastebin.com/ax4eTKMr https://pastebin.com/ax4eTKMr I hope I didn't make some embarassing mistake, but it seems to match the results of the code in part 2.
- nkurz 3y agoFor those wondering about the word "quooke", which is listed at the bottom as one of the 6 official solutions, it is the "(obsolete, nonce word) simple past and past participle of quake": https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/quooke https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/quooke Spenser coined it to use in the Faerie Queene in 1590: His horses backe, yet to and fro long shooke, And tottred like two towres, which through a tempest quooke I confess that it's hard for me to get excited about solving puzzles to find obsolete nonce words.
- Ylpertnodi 3y ago>"(obsolete, nonce word)" Note: 'Nonce' is British slang for paedophile, though did you mean 'nonsense'?
- chownie 3y agoNo, "nonce" meaning paedophile is very modern. Until the 1970s nonce meant "appears only once" and referred to figures and terms which never found common use after being coined.
- nkurz 3y agoNo, as 'chownie' says, I was using it in it's original technical sense of a word that is created for the occasion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonce_word https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonce_word Nonce is also used in cryptography for a number that is arbitrary and only used once: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryptographic_nonce https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryptographic_nonce
- llimllib 3y agoquooke is a valid scrabble word that is almost certainly not valid for the spelling bee, however I don't have a very good spelling bee word list. So you might still be interested in the spelling bee, they mostly don't allow words like that. (And thanks for the eytmology!)