4 ms·
FCC scraps old speed benchmark, says broadband should be at least 100Mbps
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dirkc 3y agoMakes sense, all that bundled JS isn't getting any smaller. You don't want to try and open a news site on a poor backyard 3G connection
- ufocia 3y agoYay, I'll be able to play Fortnite now! Seriously, a backyard 3G connection should still be faster than an indoor 3G connection.
- wccrawford 3y ago"Scraps"? No, they just updated it. Nothing was "scrapped". Typical journalist BS headlines. I was on the fence about whether it should be updated, but 25 down / 3 up really isn't for "advanced" usage. That's really basic these days. So if that's the line, they made the right call. I'm looking forward to the day they get to their 1000 / 500 goal. Having upload as such a small fraction of the download can be a pain sometimes.
- LoganDark 3y ago> Having upload as such a small fraction of the download can be a pain sometimes. I pay for 900 megabits and get 20. Upload, of course. None of the other plans even offer upload speeds this high - so not only does paying for 900 get you only 20, but to get only 20 you have to pay for 900. That's nuts.
- ufocia 3y agoYou're most likely not paying for 900. That's just marketing talking. That's not committed bandwidth. Come to think of it, the asymmetry is probably a way to exploit transit fees.
- LoganDark 3y ago> You're most likely not paying for 900. That's just marketing talking. That's not committed bandwidth. I do get around 900 megabits of download on real actual workloads like downloading from Steam (over 100 MB/s). I believe there's absolutely no uptime commitment though, and they do commonly shut off my internet access for like 5 minutes at 4am, presumably to install some sort of unwanted update on the router that I don't own, because if I try to install a router I do own, they cut the line after a few days of usage. in contrast, I get about 24 megabits of real-world upload speed. That ratio is disgusting. (DL:UL 35+:1)
- LorenDB 3y agoI think the FCC ought to mandate symmetrical gigabit as true broadband. With today's fiber tech, there's no reason ISPs can't deploy a symmetrical connection to anyone, and gigabit is a perfectly reasonable speed. After all, the hardware for it has been around for years now.
- notquiteright 3y agoIt’s not that easy. The federal government is in fact spending over $100 billion in the next decade laying fiber (and that’s only partial subsidies, so the total investment will be even higher) and it still won’t be enough to get fiber everywhere.
- ufocia 3y agoNot sure why the taxpayers are footing the bill.
- notquiteright 3y agoBecause it’s not profitable to build fiber out to many places.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoBased on what happened last time: - the telcos pocketed the money and did very very little actual deployment, and the FCC did nothing - lobbied the FCC to deny Starlink funds when Starlink actually delivered a usable rural service and got them to declare it "not broadband" At least the FCC hasn't been completely useless in mobile broadband. I'm sure if 5G starts approaching usable competition with Cable/Telcos, the FCC will kill it for them.
- ufocia 3y agoIf the FCC had the power to mandate this and they exercised the power its power would likely be curtailed or Internet access would disappear completely, at least temporarily, in certain parts of the US. Infrastructure costs money that companies expect to recoup on a certain schedule (ROI) despite the technology being around for years. Having said this I wouldn't mind at all having a big fat pipe Internet for next to nothing just like everyone else. I was excited to hear about Google's plans to lay fiber "everywhere." More than a decade later, I'm still waiting in my excited state.
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoI was under the impression that asymmetric connections were a trade off that on a technical level allowed more downstream than upstream - have I been wrong in thinking this?
- cloudwalk9 3y agoThat's the case for cable Internet, which I wager is a large plurality of Internet connections in the US. At least Charter for the past few years has been rolling out equipment along their cable network to support more uplink bandwidth for symmetrical service, called "high split" I think. I'm still waiting on my area to get the high split treatment.
- pcl 3y agoURL to their press release: https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-401205A1.txt https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-401205A1.txt The move is from 25/3 to 100/20. That uplink change is a big jump for sure. Nothing in the press release about latency or jitter though. (Corrected uplink; thanks @Thorrez!)
- Thorrez 3y ago100/20, not 100/25
- yurishimo 3y agoGood. It seems the only way to get internet providers to do the right thing is to make it mandatory by law. We tried the carrot and now they should get the stick.
- reassembled 3y agoMeanwhile, to my knowledge, ATT is actively pulling all existing DSL service with the only hard line alternative in many markets being a 1Mbps “UVerse” connection over the same copper phone lines. My 6Mbps DSL was suddenly turned into a 1Mbps UVerse line last year, with no warning. This has been happening to my neighbors as well. In some instances, after a big storm knocked out phone lines, ATT took the opportunity to cancel some folks DSL lines under their new policies. If you go to the ATT DSL page you will see that it is no longer being offered as a service. Fortunately we were able to get Starlink soon after but it’s not a perfect replacement, particularly for gaming, due to the periods of short downtimes we still experience.
- ufocia 3y agoYou're lucky that ATT is offering any wired Internet service in your area. I know highly urbanized ATT areas where they offer no wired service. They pulled DSL and put nothing in its place. Fortunately there is another monopolistic wired Internet provider serving the area, but with little competition the pricing is suboptimal from the consumer perspective.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoUrbanized area should have 5G competitors. They suck, but they exist. Urbanized should have had municipal wifi and even fiber, but regulatory capture in broadband is a bitch. Maybe what is needed is a "local wifi collective" that can serve an apartment building from a single fiber or a fiber-to-directed wifi link to the building and then general wifi/wiring inside the building itself. The fact there is zero innovation on this front shows the power of the regulatory capture by the big two. Nobody even bothers trying anymore, and any politicians that would support competitors have been effectively eliminated from the system.
- duffyjp 3y ago> Standard of 100Mbps down and 20Mbps up Still only 20 up? Moving from 300/10 on cable to 300/300 on fiber has been huge. You can’t realistically use offsite backup on 10 or 20mbps up. Uploading a YouTube video can take an hour. I once sent a dataset to a coworker and it was embarrassing when they’re receiving at 10mbps. Being a tech worker with a stone-age connection…
- _joel 3y agoMost consumers don't do offsite backups (more than icloud syncs of a few photos or whatever, 20Mbps fine for that) and upload lots to youtube, I guess.
- sneak 3y agoMost consumers don’t read books but that doesn’t mean we should get rid of the libraries.
- notquiteright 3y agoThe point of this definition of broadband is to guide FCC subsidies. They’re saying 100/20 is goal for what everyone should have in every single home and business in the country, and that it’s so crucial that the taxpayer should pay for it if need be.
- sneak 3y agoTaxpayers pay for libraries too, despite most not using them. What's the point of the state or taxes if not to push society in a better direction? 20Mbps isn't even a lot.
- notquiteright 3y agoWe’re talking about you saying the FCC should define broadband as requiring gigabit upload speeds minimum.
- 3y ago
- actionfromafar 3y agoGreat, now mandate decent latency, too! (Including maximum jitter. One can dream.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Jedd 3y agoHere in Australia we're often led by technological visionaries. > In 2010, Turnbull called 100Mbps internet "a gigantic torching of taxpayers' money." In 2013 then-Prime Minister Tony Abbott said a download speed of 25Mbps will be "more than enough" for the average Australian household. Malcolm Turnbull and Tony Abbott (both subsequent prime ministers) put serious effort and political capital into ensuring our national (fiber) network was never built properly, setting us back at least 15-20 years (sunk cost on the low-quality deployment we ended up with). Always nice to see we're not alone in poor-planning and top-shelf world-class short-sightedness.
- cushpush 3y ago100Mbps 15 years ago in Australia would have been huge, the return on investment almost instantaneous for that timescale (Say, 14 months)
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion over here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39708957 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39708957