4 ms·
A simple blood test can detect colorectal cancer early, study finds
- billy99k 3y agoI've been getting colonoscopies since I was 35 (every 5 years). It's actually not that bad. With the drugs they use now, you don't remember or feel a thing.
- susiecambria 3y agoI agree that the colonoscopy itself is not that bad. Endoscopies are not bad, either. What's bad is the prep and that's where work is needed. Though this year I did find that using zinc oxide makes all the difference. Spread it on, drink, use more cream/ointment after each visit to the bathroom.
- theGnuMe 3y agoSweet. What is the concordance with cologuard and this blood test?
- melling 3y agoAn inexpensive test that could be done annually would be great. There has been a recent debate over the effectiveness of colonoscopies. “Colonoscopies may not be as effective as thought, study suggests. Doctors disagree.” https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/need-colonoscopy-new-study-colon-cancer-screening-effectiveness-rcna51515 https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/need-colonoscopy-... Chadwick Boseman died from colon cancer before he reached the recommended age for a colonoscopy.
- verall 3y ago> In fact, the results were actually quite good for the people in the study who got the colonoscopies — a 31% reduction in colon cancer risk and a 50% reduction in risk of dying from it, experts said. > “In order for a colonoscopy to be effective, you have to have it done,” said Dr. Robin Mendelsohn Huh? So the study found that being randomly selected to be invited for a colonoscopy doesn't improve your risk of dying from colon cancer, but if you bother to get the colonoscopy, it reduces risk by 50%? Maybe they previously though it would decrease risk by more than 50%.
- ahi 3y agoWe've gotten pretty damn good at curing colorectal cancer (not including QOL). The 5 year survival rate for even Stage 3 (locally advanced with nearby lymph nodes) is around 70%. Stage 4 (other organ involvement) is still basically a death sentence, but most people are in their doctor's office long before then. All this to say, there is going to be diminishing returns for any new treatment or early diagnosis.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoJust need to cut to the chase and build a vaccine for it. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9384853/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9384853/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10383643/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10383643/ https://www.mskcc.org/news/vaccine-targeting-kras-in-pancreatic-and-colorectal-cancer-shows-promise https://www.mskcc.org/news/vaccine-targeting-kras-in-pancrea...
- unsupp0rted 3y agoI’ve been having colonoscopies since my mid-20s. It’s only a mild inconvenience to do it every 1~n years. There are risks that come with sedation, of course, and a non-zero risk of perforation. But overall it’s barely a blip on my radar compared to what a cancer patient goes through.
- spondylosaurus 3y agoThe prep isn't too fun, but yeah, one day of clear liquids is infinitely more bearable than three rounds of chemo would be. And the risks from sedation/bleeding/etc. have to be far lower than the risks of excision surgery or -ectomy for advanced cancer.
- Vecr 3y agoYou've got to multiply that with the probabilities in various somewhat complicated ways, but a simple approximation is to multiply the probability of death by a certain kind of cancer by the expected loss of dying of that cancer at the expected age to die from that cancer. Yes, it's subjective. No, that's not fixable, and in my opinion it's not a problem.
- jfengel 3y agoI had it once, and I wouldn't call it a "mild inconvenience". It was basically two days for me, one to sit at home dealing with the laxatives, and another recovering from the sedation. It wasn't excruciating, and it's sure as hell better than cancer. But I'm glad I don't need to do it again for another decade.
- burnerburnito 3y agoYou can actually schedule it so that you simply pull an all-nighter while taking the laxatives. That way you'll be cleared out by the time of the colonoscopy but only really just spend 1 day dealing with the colonoscopy prep and procedure. (You'll still easily want to sleep normally after)
- TheLML 3y ago
- ahi 3y agoGeneral advice is first scope at 45, or if family history, 10 years prior to their onset. I was recently diagnosed at 40, so I wished my son a very happy 30th birthday in advance. He didn't find it funny. Good news that he will be able to get tested regularly long before he has to open my gift.