10 ms·
NASA engineers make progress toward understanding Voyager 1 issue
- smackeyacky 3y agoI don’t want to personify it but it’s like a last plea from space asking for help billions of kilometres from home. I hope the nasa engineers can either patch it up or quietly put it to sleep.
- Vecr 3y agoThere's no suffering issue, there's zero point in turning it off. The only thing you'd do is re-allocate DSN resources at some point if someone else really needs them.
- sph 3y agoIs Voyager 1 in hibernation mode because the RTG is not producing as much power, or is it because most components have failed, but could in theory still be powered on? I do not know how long an RTG lasts for.
- tokai 3y agoFrom wikipedia: "generate approximately 157 Watts of electrical power initially – halving every 87.7 years" It should still have power. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MHW-RTG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MHW-RTG
- anotherhue 3y agoThe thermo couples also degrade so halve the power again. Biggest issue is keeping the fuel warm so the antenna can stay aligned. https://www.itsquieterfilm.com/ https://www.itsquieterfilm.com/
- nullhole 3y agoCalled a “poke” by the team, the command is meant to gently prompt the FDS to try different sequences in its software package in case the issue could be resolved by going around a corrupted section. The apparent foresight of the original programmers is impressive though maybe not too surprising given the conditions they expected. I'd be curious to know if anyone has any book recommendations on software design for space missions; I suspect there would be some lessons in there around testing and reliability that could inform more day-to-day stuff.
- isolli 3y agoI can't recommend a book, but I watched this video a while ago, and I found it riveting: "Light Years Ahead | The 1969 Apollo Guidance Computer" [0] > Robert Wills introduces the amazing hardware and software that made up the Apollo Guidance Computer, walks you through the landing procedure step-by-step, and talks about the pioneering design principles that were used to make the landing software robust against any failure. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B1J2RMorJXM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B1J2RMorJXM
- araker 3y agoThanks for sharing, this is a great talk.
- isolli 3y agoI also read this a while ago [1]: "The Voyager’s computer system was very impressive as well. Knowing the craft would be on its own much of the time, with the lag between command and response from Earth growing longer the farther the craft went into space, engineers developed a self-repairing computer system. The computer has multiple modules that compare the data they receive and the output instructions they decide on. If one module differs from the others, it's assumed to be faulty and is eliminated from the system, replaced by one of the backup modules. It was tested shortly after launch, when a delay in boom deployment was misread as a malfunction. The problem was corrected successfully." [1] https://science.howstuffworks.com/voyager.htm https://science.howstuffworks.com/voyager.htm
- shagie 3y agoSome of the fault protection and failover procedures: https://voyager.gsfc.nasa.gov/Library/DeepCommo_Chapter3--141029.pdf https://voyager.gsfc.nasa.gov/Library/DeepCommo_Chapter3--14... Page 74-75 > 3.7.3 Spacecraft Fault Protection > The CCS has five fault-protection algorithms (FPAs) stored in memory, as summarized in Table 3-9. The two algorithms most directly related to the telecommunications system are named RF Loss and Command Loss [19]. > 3.7.3.1 RF Loss. RF Loss provides a means for the spacecraft to automatically recover from an S- or X-band exciter or power amplifier degradation or failure affecting the unit’s RF output. The CCS monitors the output RF power at four points in the RFS: the S-band exciter and S-band power amplifier and the X- band exciter and X-TWTA. If the output RF power from one or more powered- on units drops below a threshold level, the algorithm will attempt to correct the problem by switching to the redundant unit. > 3.7.3.2 Command Loss. Command Loss provides a means for the spacecraft to automatically respond to an onboard failure resulting in the inability to receive or recognize ground commands. If a period of time set in the flight software goes by without the spacecraft recognizing a valid uplinked command, the Command Loss timer expires. The algorithm responds to the presumed spacecraft failure28 and attempts to correct that failure by systematically switching to redundant hardware elements until a valid command is received. Command Loss will be executed four consecutive times if command reception is not successful. After four unsuccessful executions, the CCS will disable Command Loss and activate a set of sequences of commands named the backup mission load (BML) and described below. > 3.7.3.3 Backup Mission Load. In the event of permanent loss of command reception capability, a BML command sequence stored onboard each spacecraft is programmed to continue controlling the spacecraft and achieving fundamental VIM objectives. The BML will begin execution two weeks after the first execution of Command Loss and continue until the spacecraft stops operating. It will transmit cruise science and engineering telemetry, store science observations on the tape recorder, and downlink playbacks regularly.
- piokoch 3y agoVoyager 1/2 is a pick of human achievements in XX century. A piece of hardware run by the computer having a power that today car keys have is flying for over 40 years in the space, outside Solar system, delivering priceless information. People do not realize how amazing engineering it must be. One can watch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Farthest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Farthest to appreciate fully what all those great man did and are still doing.
- anotherhue 3y agoThere's a second film that's a little more recent, was on Prime video last I looked. https://www.itsquieterfilm.com/ https://www.itsquieterfilm.com/
- nickburns 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_NASA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_NASA
- detourdog 3y agoThe inverse is also true. This demonstrates how underwhelming current engineering is.
- queuebert 3y agoOr maybe hardware overkill. I have a soft spot for small, dedicated computers like the Apollo Guidance Computer that have physical buttons and simple functionality. The DDIs on jet fighters are another example.
- detourdog 3y agoFrom my perspective microprocessor grew up around the general purpose computing model. Now the microprocessor power has far outpaced the the actual human needs the focus on general purpose is inefficient. I see efficiencies to be gained in the overall integration of very task specific computers in common network.
- 3y ago
- ndiddy 3y ago> But an engineer with the agency’s Deep Space Network, which operates the radio antennas that communicate with both Voyagers and other spacecraft traveling to the Moon and beyond, was able to decode the new signal and found that it contains a readout of the entire FDS memory. The FDS memory includes its code, or instructions for what to do, as well as variables, or values used in the code that can change based on commands or the spacecraft’s status. It also contains science or engineering data for downlink. Does this mean that someone could set up an antenna and get a copy of the Voyager software? Might be cool to see.
- sidewndr46 3y agoYes. It would also need to be enormous and use the same type of supercooled receiver.
- CamperBob2 3y agoIt's possible to receive signals from some spacecraft with reasonable amateur-level antennas, but not this one, sadly. You'd be lucky to get a photon every day or two.
- colechristensen 3y agoYou would need a dish measured in tens of meters across. When you were done you’d have a decent radio telescope.
- malfist 3y agoTechnically yes. But currently you need a 70 meter (230 foot) dish to hear/talk to it. To talk back to voyager, DSS43 uses 75kw to transmit, so you might have to have a commercial account with your local power company.
- shagie 3y ago> Does this mean that someone could set up an antenna and get a copy of the Voyager software? Might be cool to see. DSN NOW is neat to watch - and sometimes you see VGR1 and its related data https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html And since no one is talking with it, I'm going to find a screen shot. https://space.stackexchange.com/q/17430 https://space.stackexchange.com/q/17430 The DATA feed (at 159 baud - bits per second) is being received at -157.95 dBm ... seven years ago. 1.6 x 10^-22 kW. This is getting into the realm where noise will dominate the signal. https://www.seti.org/detecting-voyager-1-ata https://www.seti.org/detecting-voyager-1-ata > The above assumes a receiver temperature of 120 Kelvin at 8.4 GHz. The receiver temperature could have also been measured using the quasar observation, but the 120 Kelvin figure is not far from reality given previous measurements. The Allen Telescope Array is probably the 'cheapest' way to detect the signal. > The telescope comprises 42 fully-steerable 6.1m-diameter telescopes, of which ~20 are fitted with wideband cryogenically cooled feeds. For comparison, liquid nitrogen is 77 Kelvin. They were able to detect the signal - but in that diagonal chart, note how difficult it is to see the diagonal from the visual noise. That is only detecting the signal - not decoding it.
- subract 3y agoFor those interested in learning more about the challenges in keeping the probes alive, the 2022 documentary It's Quieter in the Twilight follows the small, incredibly dedicated team working the project. Free to stream on Prime. The simple fact that many of the original engineers are no longer alive presents significant challenges in and of itself.
- ojosilva 3y agoI came to say the same, and post this link to the trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vJT8AW0wYw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vJT8AW0wYw
- noelwelsh 3y agoThose ancient Sun machines take me back a bit!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- loloquwowndueo 3y ago[flagged]
- abfan1127 3y agoSome things are not free, even if you "have prime"... so if you have it already, then the cost is already paid... but that's a lot of words. perhaps "included with price of admission"
- dizhn 3y agoThey usually say "included in your prime membership".
- enlightens 3y agoPrime also has some shows you have to pay individually for above and beyond the subscription cost. This particular one is no extra cost, "free", once you have a subscription.
- jgalt212 3y agohopefully not a Killer Poke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killer_poke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killer_poke
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoWow. Some good news for once. Hope it's something they can repair/mitigate.
- tapoxi 3y agoIs the Voyager's software or data stream documented anywhere? I'm a little disappointed by the high level descriptions we get back. I'd love to know what its actually sending.
- crispyambulance 3y agoNASA does have a data portal (https://data.nasa.gov/ https://data.nasa.gov/). There's datasets relating to voyager, but just checking right now, I get '403 errors on those.
- tivert 3y ago> Is the Voyager's software or data stream documented anywhere? I'm a little disappointed by the high level descriptions we get back. I'd love to know what its actually sending. This has a chapter on the Voyager computer system, it's a lot more technical than typical, but I don't think it gets to the detail of the literal programs or data stream: https://web.archive.org/web/20190714113800/https://history.nasa.gov/computers/contents.html https://web.archive.org/web/20190714113800/https://history.n... I don't know why NASA took down this nice HTML version. The live link now just redirects to a scanned PDF. I read NASA has a lot less documentation about Voyager than you'd think, and apparently they don't have a ground-based simulator or anything like that (which they have for later probes).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Some more discussion on the official post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39701473 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39701473
- dang 3y agoComments moved thither. Thanks! Edit: so many of those comments have to deal with the contents of this particular article (which does add more background) so I think we need to move them back. Let's keep the less baity title from the other post, though.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vlovich123 3y ago> The availability of skills is also an issue. Many of the engineers who worked on the project - Voyager 1 launched in 1977 - are no longer around, and the team that remains is faced with trawling through reams of decades-old documents to deal with unanticipated issues arising today At least part of the problem is that we don't regularly send long distance probes. Of course, even with that maintaining a relevant skill set to maintain a 50+ year old technology from over 100 AU seems difficult. I think having it be a single team's life's work is probably our limit to keeping it alive. Our next best window for sending out another group of probes is 2152 and hopefully it'll become cheap enough to send out a bunch of them with even higher resolution imagery & maybe actually hit all the planets this time. Unfortunately, it's likely no one reading this will be alive to see that happen.
- jamiek88 3y agoLikely? I’d say certain! If not then some wonderful healthcare breakthroughs will have happened and wouldn’t that be great? I’d love to see us image exoplanets for example. I’ve often thought about a ‘relativistic chamber’. Some device that is in space looping at an appreciable fraction of light speed. Enter the box. Exit a year later and it’s 200 years passed down on earth. Have a mosey around, back in the box! Have a mooch, back in the box! And so on.
- TremendousJudge 3y agohttps://xkcd.com/989/ https://xkcd.com/989/
- ribosometronome 3y agoIt's a shame we probably live too early for cryogenic freezing to work, either.
- brabel 3y agoIn reality, they would wake up to find themselves in a landfill as everyone just forgot what those funny boxes were for and got rid of them.
- ck2 3y agoMy favorite thought about the Voyager (and Pioneer) probes is that someday, thousands of years from now, humans will launch a ship or drone that will past by it in only a few days (if we last that long, odds are way down). Another far more hilarious thought is I am glad they chose the Voyager probe for the first Star Trek movie and not Pioneer (hint: the letters dropped in the "mystery name")
- ruune 3y agoThat's an incredibly interesting thing in my opinion. Even if we send colony ships now, the odds of them arriving to a planet thousands years later that is already inhabited by humans or human descendents because our technology evolved over that time it non zero. Combined with relative time it gets even more weirder, because an almost-lightspeed ship we'd send could be surpassed by something much more advanced in a matter of days (spaceship time). So when do we send ships? I think there's a Kurzgesagt video about this somewhere
- Vecr 3y agoAs soon as possible, because you don't know you'll last that long. You do need to use resources wisely though.
- ck2 3y agoThat concept for tic-tac sized probes reaching 10% of the speed of light via laser power transfer seems remotely plausible in a few hundreds years but personally I don't think humans are making it off this planet. We are running out of runway with overpopulation, overheating, overpollution, toxic everything and cutthroat politics will only allow space investment for weapons when there's no money for food and health. Even if there was a near-future miracle invention for cheap plentiful power, it would be turned into a weapon of war far before space use. Beyond the power requirement, accelerating mass near the speed of light is beyond our comprehension, we can't even deal with radiation in space forget hitting dust that fast.
- krallja 3y agoThe mystery name for Pioneer could be "one" or "Pion" or "neer".
- DarmokJalad1701 3y agoI remember listening to a podcast where someone mentioned that there was a VM that they used for testing the flight software for Voyager -- possibly open source. Unfortunately, I do not remember what podcast it was.
- tetris11 3y agoHere's a nice CPUshack link detailing the CPUs that we have in space: https://www.cpushack.com/space-craft-cpu.html https://www.cpushack.com/space-craft-cpu.html
- tetris11 3y ago> The availability of skills is also an issue. Many of the engineers who worked on the project - Voyager 1 launched in 1977 - are no longer around, Can you just imagine that? You wrote software in your 30s, and then 50 years later your grandchildren have to come visit you in the old folks home to ask you: "Grandad, why did you write this goto statement at line 1892? Our AI think it might have to do with avoiding a hardware issue?" to which you then reply, "my dear, even if you asked me one year after I wrote it, I would not be able to tell you."
- zoeysmithe 3y agoMy understanding is that its very well documented, but the funding isn't there to do much with it. I mean most of the team behind things like the Atari computers, Acorn, Commodore, early Apples, etc are retired but we can emulate them and understand these things on a very technical level. I know this isn't a great analogy, but ultimately age of the project or the age of the original team members isn't the bottleneck. I sometimes see retro projects on hack-a-day done by people who could be the grandchildren of the original designers of those vintage chips and OS's. They probably know more about that chip or OS than the original people do just due to them being out of the game for so long. The same way people regularly lose to fifth graders in tests because they dont recall 5th grade science and civics. If anything your scenario might be the opposite! Grandpa might be asking his granddaughter how those registers worked or how to emulate his OS from 1982. I remember reading about the team that maintains the Voyagers. Its a skeleton crew using legacy equipment to keep the communication going with the assumption the next decade, or even earlier, is going to be it. NASA has the same problem the private sector has. Capitalism rewards things that will generate profit/prestige, not legacy cost centers, and NASA is not immune from that dynamic as NASA employees and managers want to maximize their income and prestige too. So the people maintaining or bug fixing old products are often lowest on the prestige, pay, recruiting, and profit spectrum than those chasing new things. They get the skeleton crew funding and can't do novel things, even if technically possible because of lack of staff and buy-in. Passion projects make for feel-good documentaries like 'It's Quieter in the Twilight' but ultimately if society isn't vested in these teams, their hands will always be tied.
- 3y ago
- dr-detroit 3y ago[dead]
- wolverine876 3y ago> A command from Earth takes 22.5 hours to reach the probe Voyager 1 is closing in on being the first human-made object to travel 1 light day. V1 has traveled ~22.5 light hours in ~46.5 years [0], and assuming that average rate of 2.07 years/light hour [1] it will reach 1 light day in around 3.1 years. Does anyone know its potential to have sufficent power to measuring anything and transmit at that point? [0] https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/status/ https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/status/ [1] Notes on Voyager's average rate: Remember that V1 did not travel in a straight line or at a constant rate from Earth through its planetary explorations, so the average rate now is probably higher than that simple calculation. Also, if we are looking at distance and speed relative to Earth, and Earth's orbit around the Sun would cause some variation throughout the year. Could Earth's relative orbital positions at V1's launch decades ago and when V1 approaches 1 light day in three years significantly affect V1's distance from Earth? Earth's orbital diameter is roughly 300 million km; V1 travels at ~61,000 km/hr relative to the Sun [0], so the worst case would add ~4,900 hours or ~205 days. (Those are some quick calculations and I have to run to a meeting, so I hope there are no glaring errors!) Also, I assume the Sun's movement relative to Voyager 1 has been constant since its launch.
- rebolek 3y agocalling Voyagers V1 and V2 seems little bit strange...
- palijer 3y agoWhen the news of the breakage first spread I hacked together a fun shell alias to take the current distance of v1 or V2, calculate out the roundtrip signal time, then inject a sleep() before your command ran. The idea of troubleshooting a computer system with that sort of delay must make them incredibly creative.
- consumer451 3y agoThere is a new (2020) interesting "sun diver solar sail" proposal which could get all the way to Voyager 1 in two to three years. Article: https://www.universetoday.com/148241/want-the-fastest-solar-sail-drop-it-into-the-sun-first/ https://www.universetoday.com/148241/want-the-fastest-solar-... Paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2009.12659.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2009.12659.pdf Interview with paper’s author: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-E83lC-eN0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-E83lC-eN0
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- strangattractor 3y agoPresident Biden recently announced that software should be using memory safe languages. The command sent to Voyager - poke - is a command to directly set a memory location with a value - totally not memory safe:)
- oasisaimlessly 3y agoBiden administration outlaws gdb More news at 11
- ciunix 3y agoI hope the communication will be established again and correctly with the farest device made by mankind. Voyager is giving us a lot of important information about what we have in the near around.
- tcgv 3y ago> The time lag is a problem. A command from Earth takes 22.5 hours to reach the probe, and the same period is needed again for a response. This means a 45-hour wait to see what a given command might have done. Astonishing!
- IAmGraydon 3y agoI can hardly imagine how frustrating that scenario would be. Think about how rapidly you hack away at the terminal, and imagine that every time you hit “enter”, it takes 45 hours to find out if it worked. You would only be able to issue 194 commands in an entire year.
- peddling-brink 3y agoImagine that each command is rigorously studied by multiple people and an incorrect entry may be a news generating event.
- layer8 3y agoI know some CI pipelines that are only barely faster. ;)