4 ms·
What I want to know is: who wants those data brokers to exist? And if those data brokers became owned by Chinese or Russian entities, would that change the ans
by amelius 3y ago
What I want to know is: who wants those data brokers to exist?
And if those data brokers became owned by Chinese or Russian entities, would that change the answer?
- lillecarl 3y agoEmployers. Not too long ago you could Google my name, the first result was MrKoll and an exclamationmark on my name. You could then pay 10$ and get access to my legal history involving minor possession of drugs and DUI. Now all my relatives know... Yep this is pretty fucked, we also have our taxation calendar available for anyone to look up my declared income. These systems and laws of openness worked great before the Internet, you'd have to call every court in the country to request access to my full legal history, and call the taxation office about my declared income. Now it's just 10$ away from anyone curious
- eecc 3y agoYou get a notification when your data is accessed, and by whom?
- rightbyte 3y agoNo, unless it includes a credit score. These companies are shady and don't follow the law as intended. They would need your permission to store the data in the first place. Hence the journalism "workaround". Proper background checks for criminality are done by the police, who hands the paper to the person the check is done on, and can only be done for roles for which the police are allowed to do those checks for. Like banking and teachers.
- Pinus 3y agoNo. The idea here is that the workings of the public authorities should be open to scrutiny. Hence, all documents (correspondence, working documents, the lot!) are public, except those that are explicitly made secret, and it takes national-security level issues to do that. The authorities are not even allowed to ask who’s asking. The first problem is that even material on individuals, collected by the authorities, becomes public. This generally went unnoticed for a couple of hundred years, as you still had to know which documents there were, go around and ask whichever authority held the documents, and probably pay at cost for copies. Now we have the Internet, which has led to the second problem. Several data brokers have started to request all data there is, and then index, repackage, and sell it on the Internet, drastically lowering the threshold to request all the juicy stuff on anyone. Now, that is obviously against the GDPR, but the law allows anyone to become a journalist, who play by different rules, by saying "I am a journalist!" and paying a token fee. So, to summarize: Openness, intended to keep tabs on those in power, and which has historically been somewhat tamed by practical barriers has, those barriers torn down by the Internet, become uncomfortably open.
- eecc 3y agoOh right, I get it. As an Italian we always spoke with admiration about this transparency regarding tax, but I always thought the request and the requesting party was also annotated and made available. What you describe is fairly blunt and alarming.
- 7734128 3y agoIt certainly shouldn't. It's just public data, that anyone from any nation could both access and provide. I don't mind these services and I think the recent development where they are blamed for enabling the violence is just a stupid distraction. The domestic terrorists we have would certainly still be a problem and would hardly stop their attacks if we got rid of our very useful public data laws. The current politics are working hard on removing all the fundamental data laws of my country, beginning with making massive energy rebates confidential last spring.
- ftrobro 3y agoRegarding electricity tax returns, not making the names public was a very good idea because of course some newspapers had headlines like "Look at how high tax returns some rich bastards got, it's a scandal, they could never use that much electricity just in their private homes!" the day after the anonymized sums of the tax returns were made public. Which just showed the ignorance of those journalists, because private taxes are much higher than corporate taxes so why would anyone want to pay privately for electricity used by a company? Nobody applied for tax returns, the sums were based on how much they had paid in electricity taxes. And companies got the tax returns too, just a few months later. One of those who got high private tax returns came out publicly and explained that his company was of the type "enskild firma" which means that it uses his person number, it's not a limited company. And apparently Skatteverket had treated all companies of that type as if they were private citizens. But of course most people just remember headlines, so if the headline had been "Look at person XX, that rich bastard got this much in tax returns!" you had probably remembered that but not the later explanation that it was his company that got tax returns.
- actionfromafar 3y agoThe idea with this temporary relief was to help home-owners keep their homes warm during the first winter of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Many mechanisms could have worked for this purpose. A fixed amount for instance. Or an upper limit on a tax cut. Remember, the idea was to keep a typical home warm. Instead there was a tax cut with no upper limit. So the affluent heating outdoor pools in the middle of winter also got relief, not just home-owners on the brink of ruin trying to heat their old house. In the big scheme of things, probably not a big deal, but interventions by the state should appear (and be) as fair as possible, lest people will loose faith in the system.
- rightbyte 3y ago> who wants those data brokers to exist? Some employers and recruiting firms, to do background checks. I think they more or less funds the market.
- Pinus 3y agoI’m not sure anybody really wants them to exist (except themselves, obviously). Current law, more or less by accident, allows them to exist, and since this touches on the principle of openness in public administration, which is a bit of a holy cow here, any changes are unthinkable. My guess is that this situation will persist until slightly after it becomes completely unsustainable, at which point everyone will suddenly have been advocating for a change for the last decade.