5 ms·
Yes that's the documentary, Its a nice one to watch. What I realized about the entire chapter of Greece was that you can't blame the government and corporation
by kamaal 15y ago
Yes that's the documentary, Its a nice one to watch.
What I realized about the entire chapter of Greece was that you can't blame the government and corporations for all the problems in the world.
Sometimes we as individuals need to step back and think of our own financial future. Reckless spending on our behalf without planning for the future are disastrous. Savings and investments are important for our future. And we need to think of it.
There is a point where the government's job ends and ours begins.
- anotherthrow 15y agoTwo points: 1. I wouldn't think for a second that Michael Portillo is a reasonable unbiased analyst here. 2. How do we prevent individuals from spending recklessly? Seems like government is going to have to play a large part in that story. On (2), it's not an issue of blame, and personally I'm not interested so much in who to 'blame' - we're doing economics, not philosophical ethics. Rather it's an issue about what we do about it. Simply telling people to act differently is unlikely to be a sensible solution.
- arethuza 15y ago"How do we prevent individuals from spending recklessly?" How about not bailing out banks that insist on making poor loans?
- anotherthrow 15y agoThat might be a start, but probably only if banks were suitably sized and regulated in the first place which wasn't the case this time. Better bank regulation / breaking up banks going forward seems more sensible.
- josh33 15y agoYou don't need to regulate banks if you prove to them you are not going to bail them out when they are too loose in their lending practices. They'll go out of business or tighten their lending standards. The real problem here is banks the world over have convinced their people and their governments that having debt-financed possessions is the key to happiness and prosperity.
- nickik 15y agoI would look into Hisotry and Economic Theory befor you make such clames. Specially about the size of banks, the US had strong regulations on bank sizes for a long time (I dont know when the stoped exactlly) and that lead to a massiv amount of bank failure in the great depression. About 8000 Banks failed in the US, most of them single branch (this is in a system with a central bank), while you look at canada where you dont have a central bank (until 1935) you have only one bank failure. The History shows that some of the banking system with less regulation (and sometimes not central bank) have shown to be much stronger. This is large subject if you are intressting look for "free banking". The most comprehensive book on the subject is: The Theory of Free Banking: Money Supply under Competitive Note Issue by George Selgin Download here: http://files.libertyfund.org/files/2307/Selgin_1544_EBk_v5.1.pdf http://files.libertyfund.org/files/2307/Selgin_1544_EBk_v5.1... It might be easier to just go to youtube and look for some videos. The most importend thing is that you dont just bail out the banks, it dosn't matter what size they are.
- Dylan16807 15y agoIt sounds fine to me to have small banks failing with FDIC around. People don't lose their money, and someone with better business sense starts a new branch.
- nickik 15y agoI think deposit insurence is great but Im not sure why the state should provide it. Most of the Bankruns happend befor the FDIC (1933). The problem with the FDIC is just that it makes, that people dont run on banks. Bank runs or often 'good' in the sence that banks that are overleveriged get finally taken down. As sooner as banks are taken town the more return you get for every doller in the bank. With the FDIC and the FED banks can go on longer then the should and therfore pay back less when they are finally go down.
- anotherthrow 15y ago>I dont know when the stoped exactlly http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_Act 'Many commentators have stated that the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act’s repeal of the affiliation restrictions of the Glass-Steagall Act was an important cause of the late-2000s financial crisis.' Here in the UK we had something similar with the 'big bang' of bank liberalisation in the 1980s, resulting in the City of London becoming the world's largest financial centre - and subsequent problems. Whilst I'd look into History and Economic Theory, I wouldn't look to Cato Institute fellows for sensible views on this matter.
- megablast 15y agoWhat does one have to do with the other? Bailing out banks does not happen so people can still keep spending recklessly, it comes from the belief that letting banks fail will cause major harm to the financial system.
- arethuza 15y ago"Financial bailouts of lending institutions by governments, central banks or other institutions can encourage risky lending in the future if those that take the risks come to believe that they will not have to carry the full burden of potential losses." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard
- ticks 15y agoIn relation to point one. Everyone is biased no matter how hard they try not to be, at least with Portillo you know what you are getting and can treat it with a pinch of salt.
- Tichy 15y ago2 is a good question. One answer is presumably mandatory payments for social security and health insurance. You can't spend money recklessly anymore that you gave to the taxman.
- randallsquared 15y agoOn the other hand, if you can't save money, spending it recklessly is much more likely. Politicians who choose not to spend money now cannot expect to choose to spend it later (due to the uncertainty of being reelected), which creates a strong incentive to just spend it. It would be a rare politician who could be elected repeatedly while running on a policy of saving money for the next generation's government to spend.
- shrikant 15y ago> 2. How do we prevent individuals from spending recklessly? Seems like government is going to have to play a large part in that story. The Reserve Bank of India (India's equivalent of the Federal Reserve) does this by encouraging saving in small ways. In India, savings accounts are the default for retail individuals, not current/checking accounts. Most banks only permit you to open an interest-free current account as a business account. The small amount of interest earned in a savings account acts as some incentive to keep the money in it. I believe no overdrafts are permitted on savings accounts either, so easy credit in the form of spending more liquidity than you have becomes just a little more inaccessible.