7 ms·
Well BBC ran a show last night. And it did show the some reasons why Greece is such trouble today. It turns out people spent like crazy, far beyond their means
by kamaal 15y ago
Well BBC ran a show last night. And it did show the some reasons why Greece is such trouble today.
It turns out people spent like crazy, far beyond their means. Things like electricians driving Porsche's and High End Mercedes cars. All of it imported from Germany. When a nation full of people with government included involves in such spending it is but other wise natural that they price for it later on.
The anchor did explain that it wasn't just weak institutions and bad government policies. It was reckless lifestyle spending on part of Greeks. It seems many Greeks now want to sell of their costly cars, which are now believed to sell for less than half the price they bought it. So what happens? If they are unable to pay the loans and Bank take the cars. Banks still get only ~50% of what they lent. Its step by step collapse of a whole system.
In many ways, the institutions, like Banks are responsible too, for lending out money like that- unchecked. But the whole system is to be blamed. People, Government and everybody else involved.
On the other hand they also showed, Germany and how they manage their economy.
Now lets look at it, Greeks might work harder than Germans. That is no indication of why Greece is such crisis today. Apart from working and earning you also need to manage your money well. Why spend more than what you can earn?
Also scenes in Greece were heart warming, difficult to believe its 21st century Europe. Its almost like a third world country. People begging on streets, sleeping on footpaths, Eating from what is distributed. Couples relying on free clinics for minimal healthcare. As I said, only the Infrastructure looked grand. Otherwise it looked like a third world country.
- arethuza 15y ago"Its almost like a third world country" If it looks like a third world country, then where did all the money go? Presumably the majority of people aren't driving around in Porsches?
- jussij 15y ago> where did all the money go They spent the money. It's no difference to running up a big credit card debt, but at some point you have to pay it back. What went wrong for Greece was it maxed out it's government credit card and none of the banks would let them up their credit limit. Now the goverment doesn't have a lot of money comming in but it still has a massive debt. That debt has to be payed back or else they have to default (i.e. go bankrupt).
- arethuza 15y agoWell, for sake of argument, if it all went on buying Porsches and Mercedes then it's pretty easy to tell where the money went....
- kamaal 15y agoRight, It went to Germany. But you can't hold them responsible for this mess. Germany is a export based country, they are also more productive than the Greeks. They have managed their money well. The only thing is that the Euro facilitated such things more easily. But Germany can't be blamed for it. Imagine you go to a supermarket and buy like crazy. You know you don't have a way of paying it back, but you keep buying. Soon you run out of your credit limit of buying more. Soon you are in a situation where you owe the bank a lot of money and have no money of retuning it back. Who is to be blamed, can you blame the supermarket for selling stuff? Or the bank for lending you money? Or you for not knowing when to stop?
- arethuza 15y agoPersonally, I would give the majority of the blame to the banks (say 60%) and the rest to the borrower. The reason for this is that, in my experience, banks have got a lot less careful about who they lend money to (at least when it comes to personal lending).
- kahawe 15y ago> It went to Germany. The last numbers I read for Greece's imports from Germany were very small, in the low one-digit range. So I am not sure this is valid to say "it went to Germany" although at the beginning of the crisis this was a picture the Greek newspapers were all too happy to paint: the wealthy, greedy Germans who got fat and rich off of all those Greeks buying so much from them...
- jussij 15y agoMost of the money was used for general government spending. Governments earn money with taxes, fees etc and spend money on infrastructure, health, pensions, education, public servants etc. Now the problem with Greece is not unlike what is also happening in the US today. The money the Greek government spent was always more than the money they earned. To cover the difference they just printed Greek Bonds and sold these to European banks to cover the shortfall. Where things went wrong for Greece is not long ago they printed another round of Greek Bonds only to find none of the banks would buy them. So overnight the Greek government runs out of money and is broke. Now they need German/French EU handouts to cover this shortfall but the Germans/Frenchs won't give them money uless they agree to big spending cuts. Hence the current impass.
- zerostar07 15y agoIt's definitely not a third world country. Despite the crisis, greeks still have good free healthcare and education and crime is still low. Don't know for how long though. The thing with the Porsches is a hyperbole, but it's also true that Greeks have become avid spenders in the past decade. There is this Nielsen report that showed that in 2008 Greece was number 1(!) in (designer) brand awareness worldwide: http://pl.nielsen.com/site/documents/ConsumersandDesignerBrands.April2008.pdf http://pl.nielsen.com/site/documents/ConsumersandDesignerBra... . Not a healthy sign for a country that produces almost none of those expensive products. Most of this money went to vitalize local markets that had no future, such as construction (building very expensive houses in a country that already has one of the highest home-ownership rates in europe), food/entertainment and retail. Very little was spent on investing, mainly because tight regulations make it hard to take business risks.
- josephcooney 15y agoThe phrase "third world" has nothing to do with economic conditions, and everything to do with allegiance to a particular policito-economic block. Thanks to the work of the allies (and particularly the brits) during the closing parts of WW2 Greece is aligned with NATO after WW2. After the collapse of the soviet union I don't know that it makes much sense to talk about 1st, 2nd and 3rd world countries any more.
- kqr2 15y agoAre you referring to this documentary? Michael Portillo's Great Euro Crisis From http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01hllyd http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01hllyd Self-confessed Eurosceptic Michael Portillo visits debt-stricken Greece. He believes that the euro crisis must have shaken the Greeks' faith in Europe's single currency and wonders if there'll be a desire to revert to the free-floating drachma. In Athens he meets everyone from a destitute young family to the former finance minister and the outgoing Prime Minister, and is surprised by some of their answers. Meanwhile in Germany, Europe's economic powerhouse, Michael encounters the taxpayers who are paying most towards Greece's mammoth financial bailout while having to watch angry Athenians burning the German flag. With tensions rising in the Eurozone, is this the moment it becomes more united, or will it be pulled apart?
- kamaal 15y agoYes that's the documentary, Its a nice one to watch. What I realized about the entire chapter of Greece was that you can't blame the government and corporations for all the problems in the world. Sometimes we as individuals need to step back and think of our own financial future. Reckless spending on our behalf without planning for the future are disastrous. Savings and investments are important for our future. And we need to think of it. There is a point where the government's job ends and ours begins.
- anotherthrow 15y agoTwo points: 1. I wouldn't think for a second that Michael Portillo is a reasonable unbiased analyst here. 2. How do we prevent individuals from spending recklessly? Seems like government is going to have to play a large part in that story. On (2), it's not an issue of blame, and personally I'm not interested so much in who to 'blame' - we're doing economics, not philosophical ethics. Rather it's an issue about what we do about it. Simply telling people to act differently is unlikely to be a sensible solution.
- arethuza 15y ago"How do we prevent individuals from spending recklessly?" How about not bailing out banks that insist on making poor loans?
- smcl 15y agoI don't think that's why these stats are interesting. There seems to be a stereotype of lazy Greeks being bailed out by hard-working Germans. These OECD stats (which I originally checked out after an episode of Radio Open Source featuring economist Mark Blyth) show that this is just another example of an ugly, incorrect stereotype.
- kamaal 15y agoAlthough I agree that its wrong to say All Greeks are lazy, Its also true that they didn't manage their money well. Now I'm not too much of an economist. But I would be annoyed if my money is used to bail out somebody for mistakes they made.
- smcl 15y agoGerman banks have substantial exposure in Greece and other troubled Eurozone countries, through bonds/loans. Those bailouts (and we're getting a little vague here) are often used to service these debts, allowing said banks to report a profit and pretend their investments were sound in the first place. Interesting that we rarely look at who lent Greece such vast quantities in the first place.
- factorial 15y agoBy "we" you are referring to the mainstream media, and those are in the business to deflect criticism from those alleged pillars of society like the big banks. Just think of how the "sovereignty crisis" came about: governments bail out the banks, and take no their debt. The next thing you know is that the CEOs of the big banks blame governments for their inability to handle money.
- diminish 15y agoI agree; let us not forget that due to EU, Greeks got looser borrowing from banks, and they bought German products. Last time I was in Romania for a business trip, I saw a similar picture. Goods flow from Western Europe to Romania together with easy credit. That spoils people quickly.
- lispm 15y agoThe number of Greek electricians driving Porsche is not very high. Also the German exports to Greece are also not that big (from both sides). In reality Greece imports from all over the place. It also imports a lot of energy sources. It has a huge military with costly imports (parts from that also from Germany). Also the money does not come especially from Germany. If you look at the banks, they are from France, Italy, Germany, US, etc. Avoiding paying tax is a sport - especially for some of the very rich families in Greece. There are several other reasons. There are a lot of people in Greece who work hard and a lot of people who don't work that hard. There is a huge and relatively unproductive government sector for example. How many hours people work is really not that important. In Germany people may work fewer hours, but the work is much more focused. After the necessary working hours many workers actually go home. In many other countries workers spend more time at to workplace without being productive. Also there are large parts of the industry which have lots of robots. For example in car manufacturing you find 10000+ robots working. You would find that level of automation only in a few places on this planet. Not so much in Greece.
- kqr2 15y agoSubstitute electrician for farmer... From http://www.athensnews.gr/portal/9/49503 http://www.athensnews.gr/portal/9/49503 : Larisa, which has about 250,000 inhabitants, is the capital of the agricultural region of Thessaly in central Greece. Larissa “is the talk of the town in Stuttgart, the cradle of the German automobile industry, and, particularly, in the Porsche headquarters there”, since it “tops the list, world-wide, for the per-capita ownership of Porsche Cayennes”.
- batista 15y agoWell BBC ran a show last night. And it did show the some reasons why Greece is such trouble today. It turns out people spent like crazy, far beyond their means. Things like electricians driving Porsche's and High End Mercedes cars. All of it imported from Germany. When a nation full of people with government included involves in such spending it is but other wise natural that they price for it later on. If BBC did run such a show, then, as a Greek, I can tell you it was bollocks. In fact, in you check the private (homes + enterprises) debt for Greece as compared to the GNP you will see that it is quite small, actually one of the smallest in the western Europe. Plus, even for this private debt, the majority is in the form of housing loans (= to buy a house). So, no "electricians driving Porsches". Well, you could find one or two maybe. But I doubt you could find five of them. Now, state spending is another story altogether. I will get in more detail when I can.
- muyuu 15y agoHeh it cracked me up too. "Well BBC ran a show last night" therefore it must be true and I can now give you all my expert opinion in the matter. Private debt is much higher in the UK than in Greece, both in relative and in absolute terms. Public debt is probably second in line to Greece, it's a close race with Italy and maybe some smaller Eastern countries. I wonder if the BBC covered that last night.
- kamaal 15y agoFine, I never said borrowing was wrong. I said borrowing without having means to pay back is wrong. You almost make it look as though Greece did nothing wrong in borrowing, but now Germany and alike are committing a huge sin in not bailing them out. UK, Italy and all those countries you mentioned might definitely have the same debt. But the situation there is different because those people have a way of paying their loans back. I am not expert in economics but I know, spending more than earning(Or what you can earn) is not healthy for any economy.
- muyuu 15y agoGermany has massive part on it by enforcing such shockingly low borrowing rates across the Eurozone. It completely destroyed countries with immature Real Estate landscapes, countries used to high inflation rates that collectively shot themselves in the foot. Germany and France took no hostages when they were stagnating and failed to meet EU requirements. They gave absolutely no regard to these countries and now they are paying for it. They will either way, because that's their main market, Europe. Because it's not just Greece that's over-borrowed, it's most of the eurozone including Italy, France, Spain, Belgium, Netherlands, ... basically most of the Eurozone by GDP.
- rmc 15y agoWhy spend more than what you can earn? Because you can generate more wealth than the interest costs you, and hence everyone can get wealthier. Government and people and companies have been borrowing money to spend on things for ages.
- nickik 15y agoThat is quite right and works for buissnesses, sometimes. Buissnesses are part of the market and they have competition. Government is a hole other thing, Government can creat wealth too, matters differ on how often that happens. Specially in the last 10 year (or longer) most government didn't seam to be much of investing there money smartly.
- hetman 15y agoI think there's a big difference in investing money in things that will generate more money, and spending it on luxuries that will only depreciate in value. I expect the parent was referring to the latter not the former.
- yequalsx 15y agoWhen a market is flooded with easy, cheap money distortions occur. Witness the housing excesses in the U.S. prior to 2008. This is a phenomenon of human nature. Excess credit inevitably leads to too many bad loans.
- cafard 15y agoThis stuff is cyclical. The deregulation of S&L rates in the 1980s led to huge problems.
- nickik 15y agoI have studyed this stuff quite a bit. The deregulatian probebly had some effect but compaired with the effect the easy money had it was not that imprtend. There where other things like that the taxcode favers buying instead of renting. Asian saving lowered long term lones ..... Most importendly Fanny Mea and Fredy Mac could borrow cheap money from the Fed and went below equillibrium prices for a long time.
- sunir 15y agoBusiness cycles and political (mis)intervention in the market are orthogonal concepts.
- damncabbage 15y agoIt also doesn't help that tax evasion is almost a national sport.