10 ms·
United Airlines tells Boeing to stop building Max 10s and to switch to max 9s
- MR4D 3y agoThis is good. Boeings problems can be slowed down if they stop producing that airplane. They need to simplify and regroup. United just gave them another reason to do so. Let’s hope other airlines follow.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- its_ethan 3y agoThe Max 9's that United has asked them to switch to is the one that was recently grounded for the door plug issue.. I'm not so sure this is the sign that you're assuming it is?
- MR4D 3y agoUnderstood. However, that issue appears to be a process/maintenance issue as opposed to flight certification situation like the 10 has. Finally, killing off the 10 will likely force Boeing to actually build a new plane instead of iterating on a half century old design. Personally I hate the 737. It needs to be put out to pasture and replaced with an aircraft design that represents modern ideas.
- blueelephanttea 3y ago> Finally, killing off the 10 will likely force Boeing to actually build a new plane instead of iterating on a half century old design. AA just ordered a ~100 of them. They are still making the Max10. And the problem that has caused certification issues for Max10 still needs to be fixed for Max9. Just not a big enough issue to ground existing planes.
- mikece 3y agoBoeing's problems could be solved if they cleared all of the McDonnell Douglas accountants and MBAs from upper management and went back to being a company run by engineers who created fantastic aircraft designed by engineers (not focus groups) and on schedules set by the engineers. Sadly it might be too late for that.
- drooopy 3y agoIs that kind of 180 even possible anymore after being "married" to McDonnell Douglas for nearly 30 years?
- mikece 3y agoIt will probably require Chapter 11 at a minimum, which, at the rate things are going, isn't out of the question.
- tcbawo 3y agoIf a Private Equity group decided to buy them out and restructure, it would make a fascinating case study. If some radical restructuring does happen, I hope they bring along a film crew to make a documentary in the process.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- salawat 3y agoJesus. Do you want us all to die? Private Equity might as well be the hand of Death themself. Literally so when they get their hands on hospitals. https://arstechnica.com/health/2024/01/hospitals-slash-staff-services-quality-of-care-when-private-equity-takes-over/ https://arstechnica.com/health/2024/01/hospitals-slash-staff...
- tcbawo 3y agoNot advocating. Very few companies can be overhauled in a significant way while remaining public. Boeing is a strategically important company from an economic and military perspective, so I have to imagine it will be treated as a special case.
- tekla 3y agoBefore all the posters who only read the title and post w/ assumptions as is common in Aviation threads. > United specified that the removal of the MAX 10 from its delivery outlook was due to the unknown certification timeframe for the largest variant of the MAX family. > “We are in the market for A321s, and if we get a deal where the economics work, we’ll do something. If we don’t, we won’t and will wind up with more Max 9s.” The A321neo delivery schedule is late and incredibly backlogged too.
- electroly 3y agoThe Airbus backlog is so comically long it's hard for me to imagine why United would even suggest that they could get A321s. If they're not already in the queue, they're not getting A321s. Is there something I'm missing? Some way for United to jump the Airbus queue?
- gmm1990 3y agoThe mention if its economical so maybe pay someone more than face value further up the line for their planes
- electroly 3y agoAhh, thank you. That was probably obvious to aviation insiders but I hadn't connected the dots.
- RandomBacon 3y agoStartup idea: instead of ticket scalping, plane scalping.
- icegreentea2 3y agoI don't think they believe they realistically have the ability to jump the queue. But they are publicly announcing their displeasure at Boeing. Like this message is literally saying "we are stuck with our second choice". As a vendor, this is a sign that you're really boned. Maybe this order will go through, but you're going to have to work your butt off after this one.
- dig1 3y agoIMHO, two things keep Boeing running afloat: 1) the Airbus production queue is already full for upcoming years, and 2) their military connections and strong lobbying within US airline companies. If there were more competitors in the US, Boeing would have been out of business years ago.
- andix 3y agoAs long as there is no other US plane manufacturer like Boeing, the government will keep them alive somehow.
- speedgoose 3y agoIs it a good time to pitch an aircraft manufacturing startup at Y Combinator?
- flamedoge 3y agoprobably easier to ask Elon to start building airplanes
- nativeit 3y agoYeah, because he’s the beginning and end of prudent reliability.
- andix 3y agoThat was one of my first ideas, because it could actually work out. But it has the potential to become even more problematic than Boeing.
- avgDev 3y agoGreat idea! After all Musk himself he knows more about manufacturing than anyone else.
- randmeerkat 3y ago> probably easier to ask Elon to start building airplanes I’m not sure if this is sarcasm or not, but I had the same thought. I can’t imagine that building an airplane is more complicated than self-landing rockets. He could integrate them with Starlink too so customers on the flight had actual wifi that works.
- fxtentacle 3y ago"United was hoping to swap orders for the MAX 10 for the Airbus A321neo"
- akmarinov 3y agonice win for Europe
- KoolKat23 3y agoAs a passenger, the A321neo is such a nice plane to fly on, second only to the A380.
- unethical_ban 3y agoHow so? Passenger comfort IMO depends on seat width, legroom, headroom, climate control. Secondary would be ease of luggage access, lavatory size/number, ride comfort (resistance to turbulence) and aesthetics. Does the a321neo have better legroom and seating than say, a 737?
- KoolKat23 3y agoFrom my experience, the seats are better designed than those in the likes of the Dreamliner, there likely is more legroom too given their slimline design (obviously can differ a bit on airline customisation). Things like the screen can pivot and aren't fixed like the new Boeing's, climate control and lighting are great (but wouldnt say necessarily a differentiator).overall just a more high quality feel. Resistance to turbulence is also better and best on the a380, Dreamliner for instance bounces around the sky.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- t0mas88 3y agoNot about the article, but... I find it ironic that a pop-up with the title "We value your privacy" makes me accept 1532 partners to sell my data to.
- rho138 3y agoYou will enjoy being the product.
- tivert 3y ago> Not about the article, but... I find it ironic that a pop-up with the title "We value your privacy" makes me accept 1532 partners to sell my data to. Par for the course. I read the other day that a major automakers infotainment system will assure you your driving data will not be shared with third parties without your consent...on the screen where you agree to the off-screen legalese that includes a consent allow them to share your driving data with third parties.
- TimeBearingDown 3y agoWhich one please, allegedly?
- tivert 3y agoThat egregious UI was specifically Honda's (see the last paragraph I quoted), but a lot of automakers are doing shady stuff: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/11/technology/carmakers-driver-tracking-insurance.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/11/technology/carmakers-driv...: > General Motors is not the only automaker sharing driving behavior. Kia, Subaru and Mitsubishi also contribute to the LexisNexis “Telematics Exchange,” a “portal for sharing consumer-approved connected car data with insurers.” As of 2022, the exchange, according to a LexisNexis news release, has “real-world driving behavior” collected “from over 10 million vehicles.” > Verisk also claims to have access to data from millions of vehicles and partnerships with major automakers, including Ford, Honda and Hyundai. > ... > The other automakers all have optional driver-coaching features in their apps — Kia, Mitsubishi and Hyundai have “Driving Score,” while Honda and Acura have “Driver Feedback” — that, when turned on, collect information about people’s mileage, speed, braking and acceleration that is then shared with LexisNexis or Verisk, the companies said in response to questions from The New York Times. > But that would not be evident or obvious to drivers using these features. In fact, before a Honda owner activates Driver Feedback, a screen titled “Respect for your Privacy” assures drivers that “your data will never be shared without your consent.” But it is shared — with Verisk, a fact disclosed in a more than 2,000-word “terms and conditions” screen that a driver needs to click “accept” on. (Honda does mention Verisk in an FAQ on its website and Kia highlights its relationship with LexisNexis Risk Solutions on its website. A Kia spokesman said LexisNexis can’t share driving score data of Kia participants with insurers without additional consent.)
- jihadjihad 3y agoIn other news, the whistleblower who brought to light the quality issues with the Dreamliner died of an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound yesterday [0]. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/12/business/john-barnett-boeing-whistleblower-dead.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/12/business/john-barnett-boe...
- yunwal 3y agoSurprise, they turned the comments off as well, and Barnett’s lawyers are demanding an investigation into his death.
- aufeld 3y agohow much will boeing's recent setbacks impact the consumer's behavior? eg, creating a preference for airlines / routes that utilize airbus products? has this impacted anyone's decision making process when booking a flight?
- anonym29 3y agoKayak already lets you filter by plane type, so conceivably yes.
- alistairSH 3y agoMarginal changes. Most people need to fly the route they need to fly. If they're corporate, they have preferred airlines. If they're consumer, they want the lowest fare for the destination. Plus, even if you can filter by plane type, there's no guarantee that plane type is what shows up at the gate - 737NG and 737Max are roughly interchangeable for many routes. Swapping an Airbus for a Boeing would be very rare, but still not impossible (you just can't re-use the same flight crew).
- akie 3y agoIf I book a flight I will definitely try to avoid flying Boeing. If there's an alternative comparable flight with an Airbus, even if it's a bit more expensive, I will book it instead. I'm sure I'm not the only one who takes Boeing's reputation into account here.
- sojournerc 3y agoCounter-anecdote: for long haul international flights I seek out the B787 dreamliner because of how comfortable it is. The question is ultimately whether it changes broad consumer behavior. No doubt it does for a few, but for most I imagine it simply doesn't weigh as high as cost or convenience
- noxvilleza 3y agoI was flying to Mexico recently (from Germany), and went for a $100 more expensive flight just to avoid taking a Air Canada leg (on a 737 MAX).
- idontwantthis 3y agoWild idea: What would it take for Lockheed Martin to start making passenger jets? Is that remotely possible?
- mym1990 3y agoWeren't they doing this and then got pushed out by Boeing? It seems like the business of making airplanes has an incredibly high cost of entry, tons of regulation, and fairly thin margins. One incident would be all it takes to shut a newcomer down.
- tech2 3y agoI think that whole situation is what eventually meant MD being purchased by Boeing, Lockheed leaving civilian aircraft manufacture, and Rolls Royce being bailed out and semi-nationalised. The DC-10/L-1011 competition was an amazing period of time with some massive impacts in civil aviation, all because two companies fought (and both lost, kinda/sorta) over a segment only large enough for one of them.
- CyberDildonics 3y agoOne incident would be all it takes to shut a newcomer down. Do you have any examples of that happening to a company as big as Lockheed Martin, which has a market capitalization of over 100 billion?
- mym1990 3y agoI meant a brand new builder…Lockheed Martin is obviously not a newcomer to making airplanes.
- CyberDildonics 3y agoThe person you replied to directly said 'what if lockheed martin' started producing planes to compete. You answering 'what is a brand new company screws up' has nothing to do with that.
- picadores 3y agoReintroduce shareholder liability - if you missmanage a company such that it creates liability, you participate in it with more then the shares value?
- adra 3y agoTobacco companies, share prices to the moon! What next do you want politicians unable to trade on privileged insider knowledge? Barbarity!
- smallmancontrov 3y agoSure, but at this point I'd settle for "fees that aren't a tiny fraction of the ill gotten gains."
- konschubert 3y agoThat's a great way to prevent the formation of new companies. The result will be very few, very big companies owning the whole economy. Let's not throw out the baby with the bathwater.
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoThey can build whatever they want, I'm not getting in one.
- breadwinner 3y agoDo you drive a car to work, or to get groceries? If so, is that really safer than getting in a Boeing airplane?
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoI don't drive, I walk to get groceries and take the train to work
- breadwinner 3y agoRailroad deaths totaled 954 in 2022 [1]. Aviation fatalities the same year was 357 [2]. Also, 7,388 pedestrian deaths occurred in 2021. [1] https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/home-and-community/safety-topics/railroad-deaths-and-injuries/ https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/home-and-community/safety-topics... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_accidents_and_incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_accidents_and_inciden...
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoYou realize how silly your argument sounds, right? “Accept unsafe planes because more people get hit by cars when walking around”
- nottorp 3y agoThe article doesn't say they're switching to Max 9 because they care about safety or quality. It says they're switching because Max 10 isn't certified (and probably won't be any time soon, considering recent events). I read that as they would happily get it but they worry the FAA won't allow it. They're happy to order the Max 9 which had the door problem.
- madeofpalk 3y agoMy understanding is that the Max 9 has no inherit door problem, but it had a process/installation that lead to the incident? Boeing has a problem, but not the Max 9?
- mym1990 3y agoI would second this. I believe people are bunching a lot of things together: pilot error, maintenance issues, airplane defects into one big "BOEING SUCKS" billboard.
- nottorp 3y agoYeah blame the dead pilot who had to deal with undocumented behaviour for MCAS. Make what happens in Boeing's factory a 'maintenance issue'. It wasn't a job done by Alaska Airlines was it? As a potential passenger on these planes, why do you go along with the passing the blame game?
- mym1990 3y agoI was referencing the United flight last week that landed in Houston and ran off the taxiway into the grass. Nice of you to show your colors though.
- nottorp 3y agoThis one? https://avherald.com/h?article=515e3618 https://avherald.com/h?article=515e3618 Looks to be pilot error. No one discussing Boeing's fundamental flaws is thinking about that one though, but of the 400+ dead because of MCAS. Which has been attributed to pilot error because "3rd world countries".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tssva 3y agoYesterday American Airlines placed a new order for 85 MAX10s and converted a previous order of 30 MAX8s to the MAX10.
- blueelephanttea 3y agoYeah. It seems like United really needs these planes and is prioritizing converting to an order than they can get sooner. And AA is confident that this type will eventually get certified (so they are ordering them) but don't need them as sooner as United.