7 ms·
IRS has launched its free tax filing service, Direct File, in 12 states
- stevekemp 3y agoThis is basically a duplicate of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39686585 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39686585
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoNot basically, it is. OP wasting our time, not helping ppl out
- bookofjoe 3y agoSee also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39598391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39598391
- mikece 3y agoWell shoot: if it requires cooperation from my state (Kansas) then I'll probably be in the 50th State to get the service.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- manicennui 3y agoDon't worry, there are always Alabama and Mississippi.
- flybrand 3y agoGov’t rollout of IT - just like any large roll out of IT - remains a mess. The recent work w FAFSA is a good example. https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2024/03/11/how-new-fafsa-problems-began/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2024/03/11/how-new-...
- resource_waste 3y agohealthcare.gov turned out alright for the most part. Negatives: There is still an unavoidable 20 clicks to select your health insurance, there is no way to get some .csv output or even chart to compare plans. Everything is clicking clicking clicking. Most people probably don't need to compare 200+ plans, but by not having the UX the insurance companies win. Positives: Everything is explained in understandable terms. I don't think its possible to mess things up. I know billion dollar websites are prob a bad idea, but if we can create over a billion in savings/GDP growth, it should be a no-brainer to invest in stuff like this.
- thfuran 3y agoI'd rather see most of that billion invested in fixing the processes that led to a billion dollar website being a possibility.
- cogman10 3y agoStop having the government use private contractors and instead employ critical infrastructure IT development inhouse. It's not as if the government doesn't have experience employing software developers. When you introduce a private company into the mix you get a perverse incentive to jack up the price as much as said private company can get away with. And since uncle sam has an infinitely deep pocket book, you can imagine how easy delays and budget ballooning can be. I'd much rather the government waste $1 million on 10 lazy devs that are hard to fire (because, government) then have them spend $1 billion dollars on garbage rushed work that probably cost the implementing contractors $30k to actually produce (So much of the initial work was simply outsourced) and who knows how much to go back and fix.
- beej71 3y agoI've only used healthcare.gov once, and that was a couple years ago. It seemed to work quite well. Then I took an unexpected job and had to pay all of it back, but that's another story. :-)
- whiterknight 3y ago
- esbranson 3y agoYou have to give up your privacy to even login to IRS.gov because to use ID.me one must: * Consent to the collection, use, and sharing of their personal information to third parties (i.e. data brokers). * Agree to binding arbitration and a waiver of class action rights. * Agree to limits on liability for any indirect, punitive, special, exemplary, incidental, or consequential damages. * Consent to arbitrary termination of the account at any time for any reason. Login.gov (https://login.gov/ https://login.gov/) is the obvious choice for a login service. Enough excuses.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoReproducing toomuchtodo’s excellent rebuttal [0] in the sibling thread where you posted the same thing: Login.gov does not provide a sufficient level of identity assurance (IAL2 [1]) to serve as the IDP for this pilot and IRS functions in general (ID.me liveness check and facial recognition). IRS is working with Login.gov to upgrade Login.gov to deprecate ID.me for this purpose [2] [3]. Would it make sense to not proceed with this pilot until this was ready? Certainly not; Login.gov will catch up and meet IRS in the future as Direct File expands next filing season. Very similar to when Social Security Administration (ssa.gov) transitioned from ID.me and their internal IDP to Login.gov. (Login.gov partners with USPS to perform in person identity proofing for those who cannot perform remote proofing via a mobile device) [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39691325 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39691325 [1] https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3-Implementation-Resources/63A/ial2remote/ https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3-Implementation-Resources/63A... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30430851 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30430851 [3] https://fedscoop.com/irs-to-adopt-login-gov-as-user-authentication-tool/ https://fedscoop.com/irs-to-adopt-login-gov-as-user-authenti...
- generalizations 3y agoSeems like what you said can be summed up as: - Yes, the privacy infractions listed by esbranson are accurate. - But we don't have an alternative right now. - But something better is coming! It's totally right around the corner!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoIt makes sense that it’s limited by tax situation but why the limit on amount of income? Surely the math for $1499 interest is no different than $1501 interest.
- beej71 3y agoI was thinking this too. Maybe it's just a way to safely limit damage if something went wrong with the system in these early trials...?
- bbarn 3y agoBecause most audits are done on income over that level. Also, this is definitely the "MVP" version of this, and I would venture people with incomes totaling more than 250K have at least one other thing "not supported yet" and it makes for an easy filter.
- dcre 3y agoSeems obvious it's a way of capping the complexity of the filings. Have to draw lines somehow. Dollar amounts are pretty clear.
- PopAlongKid 3y ago> the math for $1499 interest is no different than $1501 interest. This particular limit must be because once over $1,500 of interest, a Schedule B must be included with Form 1040, adding complexity they had to leave out of scope for now. In general, the higher the AGI, the more complexity as various phase-outs start kicking in, requiring more forms or worksheets.
- MarkSweep 3y agoThere are a couple of forms that you only have to file if your income is $200k or higher. 8959 (extra Medicare tax) and 8960 (net investment income tax) are examples. Child comments point out the schedule b for interest over $1500. So it higher income returns are more complicated.
- inquirerGeneral 3y ago[dead]
- beej71 3y agoOregon rolled out their system this year, and I think it worked really well. The only thing it could have done better is some kind of integration with the federal return, since as it is, you have to manually enter the W2 and 1040 data, but that's not much hardship. Potentially error-prone, though. I know they're working to improve it for next year.
- p3opl3 3y agoThe fact that this was not a thing until recently is mind blowing to me as someone who lives in the U.K. Doing your taxes is so easy here - takes me 30 mins max, all online and there is even a mobile app to set reminders and give you updates on any rebates or messages. Dam...
- eropple 3y agoSuch is the price of a lot of lobbying from those who stood (and still stand) to profit from capturing the audience.
- PopAlongKid 3y agoThat's some of it, but not the biggest part. The main reason is the complexity of our tax laws in the U.S.
- alanjdev 3y agoAs someone in the US, there have been numerous free options for filing your taxes for a long time (even officially endorsed ones), and for most people without complex tax situations, it is indeed quite simple and only takes a few minutes. The people who complain about taxes in the US either have uncommon situations, didn't understand the tax implications of an employment arrangement prior to tax season (e.g. became an independent contractor without realizing their responsibilities), or are simply unaware of the free and easy options that have existed for a long time.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoDependent care credit forms, interest/dividend income forms, independent contractor forms, student loan/home mortgage interest deduction forms, medical expense deduction forms. And that is excluding state tax return, which most have to do too. A sizable group of American tax filers, maybe even most, cannot do their taxes in a few minutes.
- p3opl3 3y agoI've heard you have to have some sort of registered person do or sign of your tax returns or something ridiculous like this. Something about an entire industry of tax return specialists or something that exist purely for taxes to be done correctly. Of course the US is massive so it might be some random state maybe or something. Honestly I see America like a collection of large countries as groups of states almost. They are so different in so many ways.
- xeromal 3y agoThese are duped dang. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39686585 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39686585
- internetter 3y agoThe IRS should just acquire FreeTaxUSA
- jermaustin1 3y agoCan the US government "acquire" a company? Contract that company to handle it, sure, but actually BUY the company?
- Tokkemon 3y agoWorked for Amtrak didn't it? Well, "worked" to an extent.
- ARandumGuy 3y agoA better example would be Conrail, the US owned railroad that took over the Penn Central. Although in this case Penn Central was completely bankrupt, and I'm not sure if the US government actually paid anything to Penn Central's shareholders.
- stkni 3y agoI'm genuinely baffled by this, why are the tax filing options in the US so fragmented? Here in the UK there are probably some situations in which you can't use the online, government provided, free service. But I'm going to stick my neck out and say they're fairly niche. Having lived in the US I know things get complex when you start mixing in state taxes, but this is federal taxes right? Or wrong?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThe US is very diffuse in taxing power. The federal government only has the power to implement procedures related to federal taxes. But the state/county/city and even other amalgamations of governments such as “metropolitan”, “transit”, or other special case governments have the ability to tax and their own jurisdiction for implementing how to collect it. In my opinion, the complexity is at a point that it is a drag on national productivity. And on top of that, it enables lots of corruption where anyone can simply claim plausible deniability and pay a small fine well worth the low probability of being punished.
- cogman10 3y agoFederal taxes tend to be even harder than state taxes. There's usually more that goes into whether or not you qualify for exemptions and what sort of deductible you should take. But the reason it's a mess is really really simple, lobbying. Tax prep companies have lobbied against a government solution for a long time now. Requiring everyone to spend $100, $200, or more per year is their subscription model and they like it that way.
- elevatedastalt 3y agoFederal Taxes tend to be easier than state taxes. First of all, there is no nonsense of partial residencies to consider, which gets even more messy when you and your spouse have spent time in two different states. Additionally some states (I am looking at you CA and NY) are absolutely rabid when it comes to coming after you for what they deem is their share. They will keep hounding you for years after you have moved away from the state. NY in particular enforces a withholding on additional income that's more than the maximum state tax rate, which effectively means that they get millions of dollars of interest-free loans from their taxpayers. Plus community property laws make calculations even more messy.
- jermaustin1 3y agoWith all these limitations, why didn't they just reintroduce the 1040-EZ as an online form with increased income limits and a couple of extra fields?
- kjkjadksj 3y agoThere’s an entire segment of the legislature that tries to claw back bones tossed for the common person every day they show up to work. So many things can be fixed with a pen stroke, not just taxes. We already have a universal healthcare system, for example, you only get to use it if you live to 65 though (and ironically join the most costly age pool to insure).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sithlord 3y agoWhats with arbitrary monetary limits?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xyzelement 3y agoI am excited that there is possibly a viable alternative to filing that can emerge over time (I am generally a TurboTax user, trying H&R Block this year) - but I also wanted to address the "why are taxes so complicated in the US" comment that unimaginatively pop up in all such threads. At its core, most people in the US can file taxes very simply and for free. A typical guy or gal who works a normal job and doesn't own complex investments, gives to charity reasonably but not extravagantly, etc. can file 1040EZ on-line or on paper, and the equivalent state version, for free in a few minutes. I've done this in the first few years of my career. Layered on that is a bit of "complexity" that occurs when you engage in activity that the government seeks to reward or discourage. EG if you start a business, or partake in equity, make more complicated types of investments, hire people, donate large (relative to your income) - then your tax work gets proportionally more complex. According to the IRS, almost 90% of filers take the standard deduction - so you can take that as a rough proxy that only 10% of filers deal with more complex situations. The fact that state taxes further complicate the situation is a small price to pay for the diversity of lifestyle that the US offers (kind of like the complexity of Unix is worth it for the freedom over the simple interface of IOS for many people.) I live in NY which is a very high tax state and therefore has complexities that are worth navigating if you're in that more complicated 10%. We could have chosen to live in a lower tax state and face a very different tax code (but also very different lifestyle in other ways) but I am happy to take on the complexity for the freedom of the choice. And as I said, for most people the state tax is a very straight forward calc/file. There are some HIDEOUS situations, I got a taste of that when I worked in Connecticut but lived in NYC (which has its own tax on top of NY state) but that's so rare and again, the edge cases are worth the main case.
- ein0p 3y agoThe tax system is one of the most infuriating aspects of living in the US. For most people IRS _already knows_ how much you owe and why. If you make a mistake on your taxes and underpay they’ll send you a stern letter, and if you overpay they’ll send you a check (this happened to me once, though the refund was only several hundred dollars). But they make you waste time and money on “filing taxes” instead of just sending you some automated paperwork to approve or contest. Why?
- explorigin 3y agoTo give you the opportunity to pay taxes on money you made under the table (or get benefits from non-tracked donations you made charities). There are things they don't know about.
- ein0p 3y agoHence the “contest” part. You’re still going to have that opportunity, if you want it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- billy99k 3y agoThis sounds great, on the surface. However, the default will maximize the money to the IRS and minimize the money returned to you.