8 ms·
Giant sequoias are a rapidly growing feature of the UK landscape
- hbossy 3y ago>The tallest tree they found measured about 180 feet tall (54.87 meters)—giant compared with most native UK species, but dwarfed by their American counterparts. I wonder if that have anything to do with communicating vessels effect. The really big ones grow in the mountains, so I imagine it's easier to pump water that high if trees roots can "climb" the slope next to trunk.
- Angostura 3y agoWell, the oldest Sequoia in the UK are 160 years old. The article says they keep up their rapid growth throughout their potential lifespan of 3,000 years - so they are babies.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoGeneral Sherman is 2200 years old for example. Which is pretty incredible
- huytersd 3y agoCrazy to think that this thing was just sitting there, two centuries old, when Jesus was doing stuff in the Middle East.
- noir_lord 3y agoThere are trees that where growing when the Egyptians built the pyramids. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methuselah_(pine_tree) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methuselah_(pine_tree) Human lifespans are a flash in the pan compared to some organisms. Sadly one of those flashes in the pan cut down the tree that was older than Methuselah (at the time, Methuselah is now older).
- jobigoud 3y agoIt feels strange and almost arrogant to "name" the tree with the name of a human figure with our lifespan less than a mere century.
- timdiggerm 3y agoGive them time; they're young trees yet.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThis isnt really a factor. The slope may change ground level a few feet actross the roots, but even then it would reduce height on the uphill side and increase it on the downhill side
- pvaldes 3y ago"[Each Sequoiadendron tree] can potentially pull an average of 85 kilograms of carbon out of the atmosphere per year". I will try to remind this phrase, specially the per year part.
- Fricken 3y agoAverage Per capita annual emissions for UK residents is 5.22 metric tons, according to Google.
- nvdk 3y agoSo about 65 trees needed per resident, that might still be doable? edit: nope, of course being a large tree it also needs a lot of land.
- sequoiamwah 3y ago65?
- nvdk 3y agofixed, ty!
- pvaldes 3y agoLike public parks maybe?
- pjc50 3y agoOr about one air passenger trip to Europe. ("just plant trees" is not a viable solution to climate change unless you can plant a very large number of trees which live to maturity)
- enriquto 3y ago> unless you can plant a very large number of trees which live to maturity and what, then? When plants die, their matter is decomposed by fungi and all their carbon is released back into the atmosphere (unless the dead plant matter is buried). The act of planting trees, in itself, is carbon neutral. Not good, not bad, just irrelevant to the presence of carbon: the carbon is still in the cycle of life within the biosphere. To reverse the burning of fossil fuels, all that new carbon that we introduced into the biosphere needs to be buried back to where it came from. For example, by cutting trees and burying their wood in sealed mines several kilometers underground.
- science4sail 3y ago> We found that UK redwoods are well adapted to the UK and able to capture a large amount of carbon dioxide. Are the UK's giant sequoias predominately naturally-grown or human-planted? If the trees successfully adapt their reproduction cycle to the UK, then I imagine that they could become a new invasive (albeit easy-to-cull) species.
- Sybs 3y agoThey are all planted by people, they cannot reproduce in the UK because they need wildfires and more sun.
- DrBazza 3y agoBBC version of same article - https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68518623 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-68518623 > An estimated 500,000 trees are in the UK compared to 80,000 in California. > To assess how these towering giants are adapting to their UK home, scientists selected a sample of nearly 5,000 trees to study at Wakehurst, Benmore Botanic Garden in Argyllshire, Scotland and Havering Country Park in Essex. > However, while the trees are doing well in the UK, there's little chance of them taking over our native forests any time soon - they're not reproducing here as they need very specific conditions to take seed. I'm curious about the final statement - the article goes to great lengths to emphasize the similarity in conditions, so I wonder what would be missing that would prevent sequoias from reproducing. And to quote a phrase 'life, uh, finds a way'.
- pjc50 3y agoInteresting. I've seen the ones at Wakehurst, a lot were lost during the 1987 hurricane. I wouldn't worry about rogue trees, pretty much all UK forest is to some extent "curated", even the historic old growth places. And they're not exactly hard to see.
- dbingham 3y agoThey require wild fires to reproduce: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sequoiadendron_giganteum https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sequoiadendron_giganteum
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lukan 3y ago"the seeds only being able to grow successfully in full sun and in mineral-rich soils, free from competing vegetation. Although the seeds can germinate in moist needle humus in the spring, these seedlings will die as the duff dries in the summer. They therefore require periodic wildfire to clear competing vegetation and soil humus before successful regeneration can occur" (Wikipedia) They need fire and sun. (And maybe also cold winters). Britain does not have that.
- m-i-l 3y agoThere are pictures and locations of many at https://www.redwoodworld.co.uk/ https://www.redwoodworld.co.uk/ . See also HN discussion of redwoodworld.co.uk at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28047458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28047458 . (Not affiliated, but I did submit details of my local sequoias).
- julian_t 3y agoIt's missing my local one here in Surrey, where someone has one growing in their rather small front garden. Such a huge tree in such a small space - I wonder which one came first. Anyway, thanks for making me aware of this, I'll go and add it.
- yitchelle 3y agoI noticed that redwoodworld.co.uk had saplings for sale. Very intriguing.
- Lio 3y agoYes I agree. I love Giant Sequoias and have fantasised many times about purchasing a sapling to guerilla plant in my local woods. I've never quite found the perfect spot to do it though.
- secondcoming 3y agoIf you'd like more of a challenge, I bought seeds from here: https://superlativetrees.com/ https://superlativetrees.com/
- secondcoming 3y agoI purchased some Giant Sequoia seeds last year and only germinated them this year. Only two survived but I’ve no idea if they’re doing well. If they do survive my plan is to plant them somewhere in the Scottish highlands. I also have some Coastal Redwood and Dawn Redwood seeds but none of those germinated. I think I kept them in storage for too long. I might give them another shot.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoI read about guerilla gardening recently and childishly thought it would be funny to plant Giant Sequoia saplings here and there.
- indoordin0saur 3y agoDawn Redwoods prefer hot humid summers and cold winters, like you'd see in NE Asia or the East Coast of the US.
- treprinum 3y agoNow re-forest the whole Scottish Highlands please...
- pvaldes 3y agoEven better
- throwway120385 3y agoThe haggis requires very specific ecological conditions for its eggs to mature.
- jjgreen 3y agoSo adorable when they hatch ...
- wizzwizz4 3y agoI thought haggis were mammals. Don't they give birth to live young?
- fransje26 3y agoI read that if you harvest the eggs at just the right time, they contain the purest, smoothest, cask-strength, single-malt you can imagine. The peatiness varies according to the region of harvest.
- arethuza 3y agoThat's the goal of Trees For Life: https://treesforlife.org.uk/ https://treesforlife.org.uk/
- pjc50 3y agoSomewhat disputed as to whether this is a good idea, but there's definitely plans to expand non-plantation "natural" forest for the ecosystem benefits. Main problem is the deer.
- therealdrag0 3y ago
- openrisk 3y agoThe introduction of non-native tree species is not without its own controversies as these may support very different biodiversity landscapes. In central Europe there is, e.g., a debate about the role and future of the Douglas fir, which was also introduced from North America centuries ago: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/ffgc.2022.844580/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/ffgc.2022.84458...
- indoordin0saur 3y agoI remember walking around Switzerland a few summers ago and was surprised to see that most of the tallest trees in the towns and parks were non-native American trees.
- fransje26 3y agoBut I've also seen a few studies that were concluding that the Douglas fir had a (much?) more positive effect on top soil and humus creation than the European spruces, firs and pines that are also used in fast-growth forests (and that are often not indigenous either), with better nutrient composition. Their acidifying potential was also significantly lower. An example I could find: https://www.agriculturejournals.cz/pdfs/jfs/2013/09/02.pdf https://www.agriculturejournals.cz/pdfs/jfs/2013/09/02.pdf
- tetris11 3y agoIt's the UK, it's fine, it's not like its going to suddenly import hundreds of green tropical parakeets or anything...
- Aromasin 3y agoFor those out of the loop, this comment is a tongue-in-cheek jab at the fact there are 1000's of parakeet across the parks of London. Noisy buggers.
- nuc1e0n 3y agoIs the timber they produce good quality for building with? I might like to invest in sequoia farms for carbon capture credits then timber later on.
- simonsarris 3y agoThe wood is somewhat brittle. When they felled lots of them in the US 100 years ago, the loggers found to their great disappointment little use for the resulting wood, and turned most of the giant trees into... matchsticks, and that sort of scrap thing. Possibly the trees can be harvested more delicately today, though.
- bcrosby95 3y agoThey cut down trees that were 10+ feet wide to make matchsticks? That makes the whole affair even more disappointing.
- asadotzler 3y agono, mostly shingles. still sad but not matchsticks, they cut 24-18 foot sections of these 10-30 foot diameter trees that almost all fell fully intact and hauled them to nearby mills that cut them down to boards and posts and shingles and built Pacific coast cities with them.
- api_or_ipa 3y agoFiddlesticks. Redwoods are a fabulous building material. If you’re in the Bay Area, go check your houses joists. Quite a number of old houses here are made of redwood. AFAIK it makes a great wood for joists and structures because it it’s resistant to pests. My nearly 100 year old house’s joists are in fantastic condition. Big, beautiful beams, nearly completely clear and free from knots. The reason it’s rarely used today is because we’ve cut down all the good trees and it’s wildly uneconomical to grow compared to cheaper woods.
- bink 3y ago
- SubiculumCode 3y agoI once took a biology class from a guy who researched giant sequoias. Giant sequoia cones are serotinous, which means that fire on the forest floor causes them to dry out, which opens and releases their seeds. Without fire, the seed won't reach the earth.
- daveslash 3y ago"There are an estimated half a million -->redwoods<-- in the UK and more are being planted, partly due to their public appeal. In the wild, they are endangered with fewer than 80,000 -->giant sequoias<-- remaining in their native California range." (arrows mine) Giant Sequoias (Sequoiadendron giganteum) and Coast Redwoods (Sequoia sempervirens) are two different trees! Note: It seems that my California nomenclature uses "Redwood" to refer specifically to Coast Redwoods, whereas other regions use "Redwood" to refer to all 3 species of Sequoioideae (Coast Redwood, Giant Sequoia, and Dawn Redwoods"). Also, funnily enough, Coast Redwoods are of the genius "Sequoia", whereas Giant Sequoia are of the genus "Sequoiadendron" I've long been aware of a thriving population of S. Sempervirens (Coast Redwoods)[1] and a non-zero population of S. Giganteum, but such a thriving population of S. Giganteum is new to me. The article focuses specifically on S. giganteum, but the references to "redwoods" throw me off.... I'm sure it's accurate, but I'm going to have to read the source paper. For those in Southern California, there's a grove of Giant Sequoia's on Mount San Jacinto that were planted in the 70's by the Forest Service. [2] [1] https://www.redwoodworld.co.uk/locations.htm https://www.redwoodworld.co.uk/locations.htm [2] https://gizmodo.com/these-sequoia-trees-are-thriving-175-miles-south-of-the-1579409426 https://gizmodo.com/these-sequoia-trees-are-thriving-175-mil...
- pvaldes 3y ago> Coast Redwoods are of the genius "Seqoia", on the genus Sequoia
- daveslash 3y agoTypo on my part. Fixed. Thank you. Take my upvote.
- ndonnellan 3y agoPortland, OR (NW Oregon in general) also has a lot of planted Giant Sequoias! So it may not be strictly true that they are super picky. I imagine as climate warms, the PNW will become a better spot for Sequoias. Unfortunately at the cost of trees that like it cooler and wetter e.g. Western Red Cedars. I would plant one, but their trunks get huge quickly, and I see a lot of busted sidewalks around here due to that. https://www.portland.gov/trees/sequoiadendron-giganteum https://www.portland.gov/trees/sequoiadendron-giganteum
- dhosek 3y agoI remember going to Kings Canyon/Sequoia National Park back in the '00s and when we got to the altitude where the sequoia groves existed and I caught a glance of one off to the side, I was so transfixed by how amazing it looked I almost drove off the road.
- bilsbie 3y agoInvasive species?
- gerdesj 3y agoNo. They require deliberate planting and a lot of initial care.
- indoordin0saur 3y agoRelated question I've always had: does anyone know why trees on the west coast of the US and Canada grow so tall? You'll find the tallest species of fir (douglas fir or if you're being pedantic the grand fir), pine (sugar pine), hemlock (western hemlock) and cedar (western red cedar) as well as the redwood species. Other places with similar climate grow tall trees but nearly so high. Is it something about the climate or are forests here just full of highly evolved specimens involved in an arms race?
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoThere's a couple factors. A big one is that the North American Pacific coast was just one the last places to get significant settlement, so we didn't cut down all the big trees like we did elsewhere. Appalachia, for instance, used to have its share of giant trees. But those trees are still dwarfed by the sequoias. The West Coast's wet-dry spells lead to more forest fires, presenting another evolutionary pressure on tree height. Tall trees put their canopies far enough away from the flames that fires can sweep through the undergrowth without ever reaching them. There's also the fact that we have one of the most mild climates in the world: wild temperature fluctuations cause difficulties in getting water up tall trunks. Finally, there's the fog that keeps the canopies moist.
- asadotzler 3y agoRe: fog We've got two recent studies from around here (Santa Cruz mountains) showing that some of our coast redwoods get as much as 30% of their total water from fog. Perhaps relevant to these baby forests in the UK, I suspect that permanently depriving a younger coast redwood of the consistent fog would primarily compromise its photosynthesizing power limiting food production and stunting its growth. One other thing I've been thinking about but have no data for is a 30% reduction in water would likely also compromise the secondary metabolism that produces tannin and certain resins that can act as a sort of adhesive among fibrous cells and serve to reinforce the tree's wood from fracturing under wind stress or hits from falling neighbors. One of the redwood's keys to longevity is the wood's structure and makeup, both of which are influenced by those that secondary metabolism. Depriving an established tree of 30% of its total water consumption would likely lead to immediate crown thinning and might cause enough hydraulic system failure to result in something like apical tip die-back. That would not only lead to a serious loss in growth capability for all but those already near the height limits because they can pack on more total mass adding height and girth than girth alone. Loss of the terminal bud would also open the tip to rot which could eventually hollow out much of the tree. This is not uncommon among mature coast redwoods and the numbers of these hollow giants we find belie the true frequency as the hollowing weakens some of them enough so that wind or fire can more easily take them out. (Note: if you're not familiar with trees, don't worry. they are not made unhappy by the the hollowing. they live on their outsides and the insides are long dead.) We're seeing the die back here on the east side of the range where the trees redwoods that survived along valleys and creeks down into the foothills and even some into the flats have all lost the top 10% or so most likely from the droughts of the last 50 years. The upper parts of the eastern side and most of the west get the coastal fog to water them and the ones down lower on the east side do not in times of drought and we've had 20 of the last 50 years in moderate or severe drought.
- physicsguy 3y agoAt Chatsworth House not far from where I live there's a 'pinetum' (which was a word I'd never heard before) which has quite a few redwoods planted in Victorian times.
- cushpush 3y agoHaving done a research report on redwoods years ago during summer language school, I learned that giant trees once covered all of North America and Europe.
- asadotzler 3y agowhere Jurassic trees prospered, redwoods were abound. They're some of the last from that era.
- jimnotgym 3y agoOn the subject of giant imported trees liking the UK, the tallest trees in the UK are a group of Douglas Firs in Wales, near Betws-Y-Coed https://www.monumentaltrees.com/en/heightrecords/gbr/ https://www.monumentaltrees.com/en/heightrecords/gbr/ I don't recall being in Betws when it wasn't raining, if that helps explain it.
- axxl 3y agoFunnily enough my one trip there was absolutely gorgeous weather with no rain.
- jimnotgym 3y agoIt is a very pretty area, well worth a trip. You can watch salmon jump if you time your trip well
- asadotzler 3y agoI live in a mixed coast redwood forest where the mixed part is a smattering of Doug firs and a dappling of bigleaf maples, tanoaks, and California bay laurels along the creeks and ravines. It's mostly redwoods though, including several large apex groves with walking distance. My two exceptionally big trees are 250 feet tall, and one is a redwood and the other a Doug fir. The redwood is 7 feet diameter and straight as a pole while the Doug fir has four large bends has had a stable 20 degree lean for at least 70 years. It's just shy of 6 foot diameter at breast height. Over the 15 years we've been here about 50 large trees (200' plus) have come down within hearing distance and probably 10 within scare us distance. (these trees weigh as much as a locomotive and would do to your home and you inside what you might imagine a locomotive falling from a couple hundred feet might when do. And at 200+ feet tall, hard to get distance from them, we certainly don't with multiple 200+ beasts within a baseball's throw. My sampling is that 80% of the trees that have come down in the forest around us are Doug firs. They've got a more substantial tap root but they lack the interlocking wide spread of shallow roots that let the redwoods support each other in the high winds that take out trees on our mountain sides when the ground goes from too dry to too wet and vice versa. Also, when a Doug fir comes down, perhaps 20% of the time it's a break where redwoods are all uprooted. Doug firs snap when redwoods can lean and bend. I wonder if this is one of the mechanisms by which redwoods attain apex status like the many unspoiled groves around here where Doug firs are rare. Our tiny piece of the redwood forest is all new growth since the mow that started in the 1840s and exploded in the 1860s mostly calming by the 1920s and a trickle by the 1990s. That makes most of the trees in the 100,000 or so acres of surrounding redwoods 100 to 200 years old. They reside in half a dozen 5,000 to 20,000 acre forests in public and private preserves and a few thousand acres in private use, including logging. Each of the preserved forest sections contain multiple groves left uncut in the era of the timber barons and these groves, two good ones within a mile of me include many of the tallest trees in the world. In my hikes I've realized that the big ones are almost all pretty "hard to get" and that's probably why they survived. Logging in the 1800s was animal and steam powered and moving these chonky trees, even cut into 50 and even 100 ton sections was a big challenge for the horse/mule/oxen (probably 75%) and steamdogs (maybe~25%) that hauled them uphill (downhill included water and water+steam in the mix). The mills were all close by on streams, one famous mill and terminus of a significant 19th century cross mountain road, the eastern leg which still bears his name and is a major artery on the peninsula is about 1,000 feet from the edge of our property. They cut those giants all down to shingles in mills on this side of the mountain in two waves and dragged them up and over to the bay to redwood city and palo alto where the shingles were barged up to build and glorify San Francisco. Take note if you're ever driving around and admiring the turn of the century architecture in the Bay Area, all those shingles are redwood. To me much of looks like the display of so many elephant tusks or other trophies of human extermination efforts. In San Francisco lies this once great forest of the last remnants of of Jurassic trees. (I believe Monkey puzzle trees are less restricted and older and ginkgos are even older and even more widespread. Those trees are our OGs and we should care for them.) Our plot is small, just a few acres, but it's surrounded by tens of thousands of acres of state and local parks on all sides. We've got about 100 coast redwoods and a dozen large Douglas firs along with the other local trees that gird the two year round streams that border our property on three sides. My big tree is 255 feet tall at last measure and precisely 7 foot DBH. That one lives on the creek and his girth is the evidence. Most of my trees are 3-4 foot diameter with maybe 20 in the 4 and 5 foot ranges. The second cut here was in the 19-teens. The first was 1868 and in the teens they made a second harvest and attempts at a few subdivisions for summer getaways and fishing camps (my creek was the best trout fishing in the state before the clear cutting decimated the streams) so my half a dozen chunky ones should be about 150 years old. Certain characteristics of two of them including the largest one, make me think they were there, perhaps not large enough to cut in that first round and spared by local resident harvesters in the second round so they might have a hundred or even two hundred more years on them than the other several in the same size range but with less "patina".
- johnea 3y agorapidly growing 8-) That's funny! I once received a gift: Grow Your Own Giant Sequoia It was a little pot with soil, and a (allegedly) sequoia seed Just plant it and wait 200 years 8-)
- zabzonk 3y agoIn Edinburgh Botanic Gardens. Beautiful for other species too.
- Wistar 3y agoRelatedly: "The Extraordinary Lives Of Coast Redwoods." "A mature redwood adds, on average, a ton of wood to its mass every year." https://www.noemamag.com/the-extraordinary-lives-of-coast-redwoods/ https://www.noemamag.com/the-extraordinary-lives-of-coast-re...
- huytersd 3y agoThey live for a thousand years but will never be able to reproduce in the uk?
- m463 3y agoyou can buy them at jonsteen: https://www.jonsteen.com/ https://www.jonsteen.com/ (unfortunately two I bought dried out and died on my watch, so will not buy another)