7 ms·
Shields up: New ideas might make active shielding viable
- pfdietz 3y agoOr, just make the vehicle being sent to Mars sufficiently large. Shielding mass needed goes as r^2; vehicle mass and volume as r^3. Just storing the cargo and propellant on the outside of the vehicle and the crew in the center should suffice for a sufficiently large vehicle.
- WJW 3y agoOf course, cost goes up linearly with mass and thus cubed with `r`. Mars missions are expensive enough as it is without making the launch vehicle much bigger than required for the mission.
- hiddencost 3y agoManufacture in space.
- pfdietz 3y agoIf going to Mars is worth doing, it's worth doing at scale. Considerations of "it's too expensive" mean one should work to make it cheaper, typically by reducing launch cost. It looks like we'll have launch costs of a < $10/lb to LEO before anyone seriously goes to Mars. Just say no to flags-and-footprints (and SLS); say yes to large scale Mars activities.
- irjustin 3y ago> If going to Mars is worth doing, it's worth doing at scale This has too much chicken-egg problem built into it.
- ben_w 3y agoFortunately, Musk has a specific goal of "dying on Mars, just not on impact", and might be rich enough to make it happen.
- ramon156 3y agoIf that's how they made decisions NASA would already be broke in the first 3 years
- pfdietz 3y agoNASA isn't leading this parade anymore.
- posix86 3y agoI guess that's where politics comes into play. The reason NASA etc. are trying to push costs down isn't necessairily because it wouldn't be worth it if it was more expensive, it's just that projects that are cheaper have a higher chance of getting funded. Also, the value of going to Mars is still highly speculative. Once we reach it with low-cost, smaller missions, it's going to be less speculative, and the risk/reward profile of sending huge spacecrafts will make them more viable.
- myrmidon 3y ago> If going to Mars is worth doing, it's worth doing at scale I don't think this is true. If the main value is getting credit for putting the first human there, and doing a few experiments on soil samples or somesuch, then it definitely wouldn't be worth scaling things up, the same way its not worth doing missions to the deep sea, Antarctica or the Moon at scale...
- 3y ago
- AYBABTME 3y agoWhich is why minimizing the mass portion budgeted toward shielding makes sense. If you're going to send 10 smaller ships or 1 large one, you better send the 1 large one.
- yetihehe 3y agoBut one 10x large ship is 10^2 more expensive.
- ben_w 3y ago10x radius is (10^2)x mass, I'm fairly sure they were suggesting 10x mass.
- Asraelite 3y agoYou mean 10^3? I don't know where the previous commenter got 10^2 from.
- ben_w 3y agoShielding is only ever needed on the surface, not the volume, and has a fixed thickness for any given quality, hence ^2 not ^3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square–cube_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square–cube_law
- ethbr1 3y agoUnless you source the mass from something that's already orbiting, like the moon. Since we're mostly talking water, any moon water doesn't have to pay the rocket tax to launch from Earth surface. And for a recurring trip, it'd make way more sense to keep a larger transit ship continually in either orbit or transit, with smaller barebones Earth/Mars cargo/crew transfer craft at either end.
- PaulHoule 3y agoIt is hard to pencil out lunar materials being cheap, except maybe for use on the moon. If we're at the point where we are capable of in-situ utilization we probably have some kind of Starship-class rocket. The worst part of the "rocket tax" is not that you have to burn a lot of fuel or screw around with stages and refueling, but rather that you (1) throw the rocket away after one use or (2) it is a Great American Boondoggle like the Space Shuttle. I do like the picture though of a lunar mass driver that sends up regolith, metal, or something like that to a catcher at, say, the L1 point.
- Asraelite 3y agoA better option would be near-Earth asteroids. These require significantly less fuel to get to than the Moon and many are rich in ice. If you got really really lucky, you could even find one with an orbit similar to the Hohmann transfer path required to get to Mars and visit the asteroid en route. That way you don't even need to expend much fuel to transport the water to Mars; it's almost free. For a return trip you could use Phobos and Deimos for material. They are also extremely easy to land on.
- ben_w 3y ago"Sufficiently large" is very large indeed. And that's why an Aldrin cycler is a good idea. (I assume Musk will announce one that looks like a famous 80s Sci Fi thing soon after Starship actually manages a round trip to Mars).
- bjelkeman-again 3y agoAldrin cycler: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_cycler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_cycler
- pfdietz 3y agoIf we can get down to $10/lb, then for the price of a single SLS launch we can put the mass of a battleship into space. People need to stop thinking small.
- ben_w 3y agoFWIW, my idea of a perfectly reasonable piece of space infrastructure in the multi-planet era has a mass of around 10^11 kilograms. Fortunately, the infrastructure itself can bootstrap in a way that reduced the launch costs to, it is claimed, 9 kWh/kg: https://web.archive.org/web/20120306175303/http://www.paulbirch.net/OrbitalRings-II.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20120306175303/http://www.paulbi...
- WJW 3y agoNote: this is only for charged particles such as happen in solar flares, and only in space. Your personal shield against bullets and the like is still impossible, sadly.
- adrianN 3y agoA few tons of superconductors work very well against bullets.
- Terr_ 3y agoThat's true even without power at room temperature. :P
- willis936 3y agoWho's making a 600 T magnet that weighs only a few tons? https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/115011/how-much-power-would-it-take-to-stop-a-bullet-with-a-magnet#115014 https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/115011/how-much-...
- hobofan 3y agoI think at that point you probably have to worry about the effect such a strong magnet will have on the brain and nervous system, so probably not the best fit for personal protection.
- skhr0680 3y agoI’m no rocket scientist, but I feel that statement holds true for bullets too
- bee_rider 3y agoThe bullets are the problem they are trying to use the shield to solve. If the shield also kills the user, that sort of renders the whole thing moot, right? Not to agree with the actual idea that the magnet is necessarily dangerous, haven’t looked that up…
- hiddencost 3y agoThe end is very funny. Mars trip costs 1200 mSv, NASA cap is 1000. Should we just send old men to Mars? Oops, they dropped the cap to 600, we need this tech now.
- grapescheesee 3y agoWhat is the non governement standard/target going to be set at? Do private companies need to adhere to the 'new' NASA limit?
- marcosdumay 3y agoRegulations will appear. There are already regulations about radiation exposure that will be immediately extended into space travel if no regulatory body acts quickly enough. A short search gave me this number, apparently for the US: > 20 mSv a year, averaged over defined periods of 5 years with no single year >50 mSv This basically prohibits paid-for space labor.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoSurely in such unusual circumstances any limits must be set as part of a cost benefit analysis from the point of view of the person concerned. One person might be rationally willing to risk higher exposure in the pursuit of knowledge.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> Mars trip costs 1200 mSv, NASA cap is 1000 The NASA cap is a specific lifetime radiation dose; the Mars trip cost is an estimate of some kind, but they don't specify the duration of the mission. Is 1200 mSv the estimate for the outbound journey, or for both legs, or for both legs plus a 1-year stay on a Mars base? I'm 68, and I've already had cancer; I probably match the "old man" criterion. But I won't be volunteering to travel through a hostile environment, to visit - a hostile environment. For pity's sake, use robots.
- kwhitefoot 3y ago> use robots. Why not use people who are willing to take the risk?
- ooterness 3y agoNeat concepts, but these aren't going to fly any time soon. Quotes from the article: "Take these solenoid designs. Your spaceship basically becomes an MRI tube." "At the end of the day, though, we are still talking about using a roughly 40-ton shield to protect a module that weighs maybe 8 tons. It doesn’t add up. No space agency is currently considering putting a magnetic shield on a rocket because today we don’t have a good solution."
- was_a_dev 3y agoDid you miss the final section on the electrostatic shield?
- ooterness 3y agoYou mean the one that only exists in a simulation?
- mrcsd 3y ago> Based on their simulations, Fry and Madzunkov built small-scale models of their electrostatic shields and tested them in a particle beam at Brookhaven National Laboratory with good results—they showed that the ASPP software was fairly accurate in its predictions. “We are at the stage where we need to start looking at building larger demonstrators. Stojan and I proposed putting a device on a lunar surface as a technology demonstration for the plasma mitigation method. Sometimes, you’ve just got to focus on applications that perhaps you don’t want to do first,” said Fry. It is only a small scale model, but your comment really doesn't warrant such certainty about simulation only.
- denton-scratch 3y agoDoesn't sound very "viable" to me. From my reading, they are claiming that (a) magnetic shielding is impracticable for weight reasons; and (b) heavy electrostatic shielding can't currently achieve even half the protection required for a Mars mission. TFA is unclear about what they mean by a "Mars mission". The amount of exposure an astronaut would face would depend on the duration of the mission, and a (say) two-day holiday on Mars doesn't make a lot of sense, if the one-way trip takes several months. I think TFA's most-useful observation is a throwaway: "but you could probably get away with just picking old men for the job." Yes - just choose astronauts that aren't expected to live very long anyway. As a bonus, that makes it less important to figure out how to get them back. I suspect my slip is probably showing: I'm very much a sceptic of long-distance manned space travel. It's definitely a job for robots.
- ben_w 3y ago> TFA is unclear about what they mean by a "Mars mission". The amount of exposure an astronaut would face would depend on the duration of the mission, and a (say) two-day holiday on Mars doesn't make a lot of sense, if the one-way trip takes several months. Usually[0] such calculations are based on orbital windows, so approximately 15 months round trip time for a short stay and 34-month trip if you're trying to minimise fuel requirements. To get down to just 8 months would require on-orbit staging, which is basically putting supply caches in orbit, but even that's talking about 2 weeks on the ground. But what matters is the time spent in space, not on the ground — once you're on the surface of Mars, things get a lot easier, as you've got a planet between you and the sun half the time, plenty of terrain to hide behind if you need to be out of line-of-sight, about 17g/cm^2 of atmosphere[1] between you and the sun even when it's at zenith, and the possibility of digging a hole to hide in. [0] exception: someone is proposing a fancy new engine, perhaps a fusion torch drive or something. [1] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=2.5x10%5E16+kg+%2F+area+mars https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=2.5x10%5E16+kg+%2F+area...
- denton-scratch 3y ago> once you're on the surface of Mars, things get a lot easier Yes, thanks for pointing that out to me. But TFA notes that (a) the Earth's atmosphere, and (b) the Earth's magnetic field, contribute nearly all of our shielding from both solar and cosmic radiation. Living in a cave on Mars might shield you from solar flares; but it will provide quite limited protection from gamma rays. Mars has a much weaker magnetic field than Earth (Wikipedia says there's no evidence of any magnetic field at all).
- transfire 3y agoI think the take away is that the progress has been surprisingly good and, if it continues, the next generation of designs after the ones we currently have might be viable.
- h2odragon 3y agooo just in time to save the planet form all the satellite debris: https://spaceweatherarchive.com/2024/02/01/will-satellite-megaconstellations-weaken-earths-magnetic-field/ https://spaceweatherarchive.com/2024/02/01/will-satellite-me...
- Perz1val 3y agoWhat if we make the shielding once, put it in orbit and "borrow" it for each ride. Launching it from surface is expensive, between planets not so much. Even better, ship it in parts on the small reusable rockets that we already have. It's about time we start making stuff in space, welding a metal box seems like a good first project (also no shielding gas required)
- zzzeek 3y agoat last a great example of positive cooperation between Earth and Romulans
- simne 3y agoNice try, but unfortunately article have few factual mistakes and bias. First, Earth shield is not just magnetic, but it is complex, magnetic + 100km of thin atmosphere, where most secondary particles just decay with time. Calculations said, for comparable shield, need approx 6 meters of just water. Sure, it is lot of weight, so other calculations said, interstellar ship (or even martial ship) could use tanks with liquid hydrogen as shield, as they should be huge (for martian ship they should be thousands of metric tons, for interstellar, magnitudes more). Second, very long text, but not said clear, that after cancellation of Shuttles, AMS-02 was modified, to use permanent magnet instead of superconductor.
- rapjr9 3y agoHow about a shield against bugs? Maybe an electrostatic charge? Every homeowner would buy one.