3 ms·
For all of the examples on Wikipedia, it seems like there was some confounding extra variable that was missed. I wonder if anybody knows of a case where it just
by bee_rider 3y ago
For all of the examples on Wikipedia, it seems like there was some confounding extra variable that was missed. I wonder if anybody knows of a case where it just sort of happened randomly, with no big underlying cause?
Or maybe I’m thinking of it wrong and this is impossible.
- eadler 3y agoIt can happen any time there is a mix shift in the underlying quantity of the subgroups. It's just that random changes in quantities are not likely to be studied or reported. It's easy to generate manually though.
- DonsDiscountGas 3y agoIn order for it to count as Simpsons paradox I think there would need to be a confounding variable. It's certainly possible for it to appear spuriously, and for something to look like a confounder when it isn't, but there would need to be some type of subgroup.
- Kalium 3y agoThe classic example of admissions does not have a missing confounding variable. It's a case of aggregation at the wrong level.