16 ms·
The Best Essay
- herdst 3y agoPaul’s blog looking a bit different!
- windowshopping 3y agohow?
- gnicholas 3y agoLooks the same on desktop, but very different on mobile.
- nedbat 3y agoI don't know if it looks different, or what it looks different from. To me, it looks like it was designed in 1999 (which it may have been).
- woopwoop 3y agoThis is not the greatest essay in the world. No, This is just a tribute.
- pjmorris 3y agoTenacious reference.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- saltyoutburst 3y agoHe asked us, "Be you angels?" And we said nay. We are but men, write!
- badcppdev 3y agoUnashamed to admit my first action on the comment page was to Ctrl-F for 'tribute'
- paulpauper 3y agoThe hardest part of writing is it's hard to predict how it will be received. You cannot 'focus group' writing, unlike other mediums of information. Disney can predict with a high degree of certainty that its superhero movies will do well, as there is a large, built-in market for those movies, and they tend to be conceived on the same creative blueprint or foundation. Even its 'duds' are still profitable. But this is not possible with writing, especially not internet writing. What is the market for short-form contrarian non-fiction? Who knows. It's hit or miss, mostly miss
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> Disney can predict with a high degree of certainty that its superhero movies will do well, as there is a large, built-in market for those movies, and they tend to be conceived on the same creative blueprint or foundation. Even its 'duds' are still profitable. Google something like "Marvel superhero fatigue". It seems that either the movie quality is decreasing or the audience is becoming more and more bored by these movies.
- arcanemachiner 3y ago"Customers are like roaches. You spray 'em and you spray 'em and they become immune after a while." - David Lubars
- paulpauper 3y agoDisney never lost money on a superhero film though afik
- throwawaymaroon 3y ago[dead]
- criddell 3y agoIs it important to predict how it will be received? If you are trying to tailor your work for your audience, then you are on your way to being yet another content farm and when’s the last time any of those published something great? I know Paul does have some trusted readers that he shares early drafts with. Maybe he uses those readers as his focus group?
- cool-RR 3y agoFirst sentence reminded me of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_lK4cX5xGiQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_lK4cX5xGiQ
- BobbyVsTheDevil 3y agoSpeaking of tributes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_lK4cX5xGiQ#t=217 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_lK4cX5xGiQ#t=217 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PoAGasPLh30#t=213 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PoAGasPLh30#t=213
- mistermann 3y ago> One thing I like in an initial question is outrageousness. I love questions that seem naughty in some way — for example, by seeming counterintuitive or overambitious or heterodox. Ideally all three. I believe it is possible/likely that the best essay in the world could not be realized as such (thus, it wouldn't/couldn't be the best essay in the world), because most people couldn't even get by one of these let alone all three...and, there's likely to be many other hurdles one would have to make it over.
- cubefox 3y agoYeah. Imagine writing Darwin's essay on evolution in the 15th century. People wouldn't have been merely outraged, they would have killed him right away. And also today some possible essays may contain true and important insights, while being too taboo to not be immediately dismissed by society.
- mistermann 3y agoThe dominant ideology of the era tends to impose its beliefs on the masses, perhaps some day humans can wake up from the dream.
- dpc94 3y agoReally liked this quote. “While breadth comes from reading and talking and seeing, depth comes from doing. The way to really learn about some domain is to have to solve problems in it”
- gmd63 3y agoMuch of the restricted depth of this nature is a consequence of deliberate obfuscation or neglect by the people who are involved in the doing, such as trade secrets, or simply choosing not to write about or share the actual things that impact their craft. You can easily accumulate depth of knowledge from reading in areas that are well documented.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThere isn’t a need to read anything beyond introductory materials to acquire depth, if your competent enough. In fact that’s what I would consider the critical dividing line between a regular genius and a bonafide super-genius. Someone who almost supernaturally acquires expertise/intuition/depth/etc. with very little visible effort.
- rnewme 3y agoWhat does being competent enough mean? Do you have an example of bonafide super-genius?
- aerophilic 3y agoStory from a friend who once was offered the first PhD in Computer Science. He once mentored a guy who was so ridiculously good at writing programs, that he wrote out (once) a 5 foot stack of punch cards (back when that was how you would code), to create a program that was needed by the company for some purpose. It worked, flawlessly, the FIRST time. This was his MO. Once, he wrote a program for an internal client, and it got shipped. They ran the program and ran into a problem. My friend told him to debug it for them… he replied “I don’t know how”. Up to that point in his life, He had never had to debug a single piece of software… My friend helped him debug the program: Turns out, the problem was not an issue with his code, the customer had given him the wrong spec for a critical interface… and that was the only reason it had not worked the first time. There are truly people that qualify. The only note I will make is that generally if you are a super genius in one dimension, you likely have something you are absolutely terrible at in another. Hopefully it is in a dimension that either doesn’t matter, or you have enough complementary people around you to mitigate it.
- timeagain 3y ago> The best essay would be on the most important topic you could tell people something surprising about. The premise is wrong (or at least not obviously right) IMO, so I have a hard time taking any of the rest of it seriously. Could the best essay not be the most emotionally moving? The best when heard aloud? The most convincing call to action? The most accurate? The highest grossing? Driving the most engagement? What about the topic (any topic) that you could tell the /most interesting surprise/ about? If Paul Graham didn’t run this company he certainly would not make it to the front page for his lazy philosophy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- clooper 3y agoHemingway once said just write the truest sentence you can think of and I think he was right. Good writing and good essays are truthful in a way that wouldn't be expected from commercial and marketing copy. But to write truthfully one must know what is true and this is surprisingly hard.
- Nevermark 3y ago> No essay is true, or complete, including this on - Gödel, a bastard and a cynic, having a bad essay day after attempting to out drink Hemingway, yet somehow expressing a surprising deep truth
- clooper 3y agoYou might also be interested in Tarski's work about the undefinability of truth.
- geor9e 3y agoAnyone can nitpick anyone by listing whatabouts they didn't intend. Whatabout this OTHER sense of the word "best". It's in the dictionary. You didn't address it, therfore you're a lazy man of straw. The only defense to that type of attack is to write everything in a way that never chooses any one path, spends all it's time mounting a defense to every whatabout, vaguely floating over eggshells, immune to attack. Who wants to read something like that? Or, you can trust the reader to try to understand the context. The context is a man who calls himself an essayist, has about a hundred essays spanning a decade, all in a very distinct style, where most folks reading them are fans of the prior ones. The context is the Paul Graham Essay sense of the word essay. It's not discussing emotional, spoken, money grossing essays. And to help the reader not get hung up on those whatabouts, he even explicitly spelled what sense of best he is talking about.
- RheingoldRiver 3y ago> It probably wouldn't be about this year's lipstick colors. Instead, the best movie [0] is about this. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vL-KQij0I8I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vL-KQij0I8I
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwawaymaroon 3y ago[dead]
- superb-owl 3y ago> Writing about the best essay implies there is such a thing, which pseudo-intellectuals will dismiss as reductive, though it follows necessarily from the possibility of one essay being better than another. Not to be a pseudo-intellectual, but this confuses partial orderings and total orderings. It makes for a fun discussion, but I hope Paul would agree that there's obviously no "best essay", real or hypothetical.
- shmageggy 3y agoNot to mention that "best" is subjective, so there is no single ordering, but "How to write Paul Graham's favourite essay" wouldn't get as many clicks on HN (ironic for a site with anti-clickbait rules).
- cristoperb 3y agoEven worse, it mistakes the possibility of partial ordering to imply an actual total ordering.
- hackerlight 3y agoPaul has been putting me off lately. Everyone that disagrees with him is a "pseudo-intellectual" or some other hinted-at bad or incomplete person. The guy loves the smell of his own farts and isn't the towering intellectual or writer than he congratulates himself as.
- barrkel 3y agoI found your comment by searching for "it follows necessarily from the possibility of one essay being better than another" because it stood out as a fallacy.
- voidhorse 3y agoNot surprised that pg proves once again that he is little more than a narrow-minded capitalist, who doesn't actually understand anything about culture, the humanities, literature, or what it is people actually value in those spaces. His writing is consistently flat, uninspired, and egotistical. He's ok at writing clear prose and this plus his success in relation to YC has made him popular among technical people that also embrace capitalism. Anyone outside of this little cult realizes that pg says very little of value, particularly when he decides to comment on subjects outside of his capitalistic and technical wheelhouses. I have not read a single pg essay that touches on culture, ethics, or general epistemology that has given me anything other than a complete groan of a reaction and astonishment that this is the sort of thinking that passes the "high-quality" bar for the average technologist. pg can try as hard as he can to write the "best essay". He will never convince this reader since he occupies a completely different world and basically isn't even capable of speaking to this audience in the first place. ...just to lengthen this comment more than is due, the quote is astonishing. I mean, how arrogant do you have to be to claim that the past hundreds of years of literary development, in which the notion of "best essay" is considered at best completely relative and at worst nonsense, must be wrong and that anyone who thinks otherwise must just be a "pseudo intellectual" (read: someone who disagrees with paul graham). He's really high on his own supply.
- gizmo 3y ago> Writing about the best essay implies there is such a thing, which pseudo-intellectuals will dismiss as reductive, though it follows necessarily from the possibility of one essay being better than another. What is the best car? Some cars are real stinkers. It's not hard to find cars that are better than Zastava Yugo in every way. For most cars you can find other cars that are in the same class, but just better. Clearly, a comparison between cars can be made. Car reviewers make this their job. But from the existence of bad and mediocre cars it doesn't follow that there is such a thing as a "best car". How large is your family? Do you want to tow a boat? Do you like to go fast on curvy roads? Do you care more about acceleration or range? How tall are your rear passengers? There are good essays and there are bad essays. Some essays, perhaps, can be considered the very best in their category. But you can't rank order essays across categories, just like you can't argue that a Ford F150 is objectively better or worse than a Mazda Miata. (And if this makes me a small-minded pseudo-intellectual so be it.)
- joshuamorton 3y agoOr formalized, a partial ordering over some set doesn't imply a total ordering or a maximum value.
- plemer 3y agoBeautifully put
- pvg 3y agoyou can't argue that a Ford F150 is objectively better Perhaps if you limit yourself to a hidebound traditionalist view of the form but this topic has been explored by the Moving Picture Essay https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oMDcIApBtL8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oMDcIApBtL8
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoThis is one of the weirdest insults I have heard in a long time.
- libraryofbabel 3y agoIsn’t it pretty strange to write about what makes a great essay without mentioning a single actual essay except Charles Darwin’s natural selection paper from 1844?
- y1n0 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mvdtnz 3y ago[flagged]
- maximinus_thrax 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoOf course you can—plenty of comments are doing it all the time, including in this thread. What's not ok is to post cheap one-liner putdowns about anybody. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- noqc 3y agoSomehow a 233 page manuscript is not what I think of when I think of "essay".
- pedalpete 3y ago> The best possible essay at any given time would usually be one describing the most important scientific or technological discovery To a hammer, everything is a nail. I love technology and science, but that doesn't mean that is what makes the best essay. Relationships are key to our survival, so I suggest personal relations could be just as good an essay as anything scientific - yes, I'm suggesting that social science isn't really a science. This also then leads to timelessness. The essay on natural selection is timeless. It wouldn't be written today, but it is still a viewport into the discovery, and of the time, and the knowledge is still valid. Maybe I am misunderstanding the point about timelessness. > The other reason the initial question matters is that you usually feel somewhat obliged to stick to it. I also disagree with this comment. I'm currently writing a talk I've been asked to present, and in the process of my writing and researching, I've discovered a whole new and better question. I find the point of a good question is that it can lead to better questions. I do feel that PG is suggesting this as well, but maybe this one sentence just stuck out to me.
- mckn1ght 3y ago> Relationships are key to our survival, so I suggest personal relations could be just as good an essay as anything scientific Some of my favorite books are old literature that describe relationship dynamics I still see playing out between people today. Swann’s Way, The Brothers Karamazov, even Canterbury Tales… I think it was Vonnegut that wrote that the best books are the ones that tell you what you already know [but maybe you didn’t know you knew till you read it]. That’s something like surprise, and yet something like the opposite.
- graycat 3y ago> I'm suggesting that social science isn't really a science. In reality and practice, no effort at science is 100% "really a science". But for "social science": (1) It can be a goal to have some of social science be real science. (2) My wife's Ph.D. was in social science, and her dissertation was real science. The work started with a real question, in social science, gathered some real data, analyzed the data statistically, and came to some real conclusions. The conclusions were "new, correct, and significant". Some science? Yup.
- deleted 3y ago
- quickthrower2 3y agoGood essay! Shame he doesn’t talk about taboo. Taboo subjects could make for great essays but it takes a lot of guts to write about them. Anything from collapse of your life, work, prison or death threats may ensue. Breaking taboos move society forward though. Keep an eye on “exceptions to free speech”.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- senderista 3y agoHe talks plenty about taboos elsewhere (e.g. "What You Can't Say").
- tptacek 3y ago"It probably wouldn't be about this year's lipstick colors." Why not? "Death of a Pig" didn't convey any new scientific ideas, and might not even have been surprising in any kind of intellectual way. You could title this piece "Great Essays" and it would be entirely defensible. But Graham gave himself a higher goal here, and I don't think he's really presented a recipe for writing the Best essay. Look what he's up against: Baldwin, Didion, Oliver Sacks; it's easier to come up with examples of great essays that don't set out to develop surprising new ideas, and that probably didn't start out with a mischievous look in the author's eyes. I'm not saying this isn't good advice for developing great essays, just that it's advice that narrows the solution space a bit much.
- gizmo 3y agoWhen he mentioned lipstick and evolution right after I figured he was going to remark on the obvious connection later in the essay, but no.
- skylurk 3y agoWhen the GP mentioned lipstick and pigs, I thought they were going somewhere too.
- kashyapc 3y agoExcellent point on "Death of a pig" by E.B White. It's the perfect example of a timeless essay, without a "big scientific idea". For others unaware of it, that essay was written in 1948[1], go read it in full. It starts like this: "I spent several days and nights in mid-September with an ailing pig and I feel driven to account for this stretch of time, more particularly since the pig died at last, and I lived, and things might easily have gone the other way round and none left to do the accounting." [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20240227003736/https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1948/01/death-pig/309203/ https://web.archive.org/web/20240227003736/https://www.theat...
- tptacek 3y agoI want to be careful not to pummel a straw man, because it's sort of clear that Graham doesn't believe the Best essay must come from an exploration of science or of exciting new ideas (though most of the advice he gives is for that kind of essay). If I have a concern, I think it's about the chemistry his writing has with this community, how threads here will bleach it down to a game of prog-rock writing, trying to somehow outdo Darwin.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tomphoolery 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ericb 3y agoI can't shake the feeling that this is one is AI generated.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoHard not to contrast Graham's > If caring about it is one of the criteria for a good initial question, then the optimal question varies from person to person. with another submission posted some 15 minutes later [0] noting J. R. Ackerley’s ability to make anything compelling through the sheer weight of care The "best essay" for an author is certainly cantered on their care. Yet I feel in the current nonchalant, urbane and cynical climate if the audience sense any sniff of "care", it is to be savaged. Unless it tickles something sentimental or ironic, care is despised and dismissed as weakness that "doesn't make a living" or is some wonky "ideology". But then people would call me cynical for saying that :) [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39663046 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39663046
- nirmel 3y agoI wrote hundreds of essays based on content from my hobby of performing offensive standup comedy. I put this all in a filterable website www.urrong.com and self-published it in an illustrated book, Correct Me If You're Wrong (https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09FRR76YK https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09FRR76YK), the full PDF is here, free: https://www.dropbox.com/s/1ujpr5klpwtmxve/book%20-%20DRAFT.pdf?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/1ujpr5klpwtmxve/book%20-%20DRAFT.p.... I'm a YC alum. Over.
- Sn0wCoder 3y agoThanks for leaving the link to the PDF and web site. Already had some fun playing with the site and think I will give the book a shot.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoI enjoy helping others to think outside the box. You have done quite well in placing your own perception onto two dimensional paper. Thanks for inspiring my own out-of-box interpretations.
- noqc 3y agoThis sounds like how I would write when I was on adderall. I mean, what the hell is this statement? "I love questions that seem naughty in some way — for example, by seeming counterintuitive or overambitious or heterodox. Ideally all three. This essay is an example. Writing about the best essay implies there is such a thing, which pseudo-intellectuals will dismiss as reductive, though it follows necessarily from the possibility of one essay being better than another." That's not what "follows necessarily" means Mr. Graham. Are these pseudo-intellectual spectres literally just you strawmanning your own counterfactual? I can't imagine you actually listening to anyone you would call a pseudo-intellectual.
- James_K 3y ago[dead]
- tikhonj 3y agoThat quote is also just factually wrong because we can have partial orders, or even just have a lot of totally different essays that happen to be equally good.
- noqc 3y agoHonestly, nothing makes me want to write essays like reading Paul Graham. Someone needs to argue with him, since it's clear he's not going to do it.
- calf 3y agoI admired Paul Graham's blog posts.. when I was an impressionable college sophomore. Then I guess after I went to grad school and actually read a lot and tried to do some science and research. I find this kind of popular writing superficial, flawed, inefficient, and even conceited. That's just my subjective experience. But it seems some young people in tech just lap it up, he functions as a kind of thought leader for the industry.
- yellow_lead 3y ago
- richrichie 3y agoIt is not enough to ask novel questions. Trick is to ask questions that do not offend the delicate sensibilities of the overlords of public discourse. This has been a challenge since time immemorial. Darwin was not exactly feted then.
- FreakLegion 3y agoInteresting to see Sam Altman thanked. It's the first time since July 2020, 29 essays ago, and this is also Graham's first essay since the hullabaloo at OpenAI.
- technotony 3y agoI wondered that too. A subtle endorsement of Sama perhaps. A way of saying there's no bad blood there despite what the press was saying about his 'firing' from YC. Sama did a great job running YC, and certainly made PG a boatload of money. Also seeing the success at OpenAi, hard to argue Sama didn't make the right call to leave and focus on it, could hardly have done that plus keep running YC. (my guess at what happened is Sama started openai on the side and gradually it became more and more of his focus until there was a conversation about whether he should focus exclusively on it, which they mutually decided should happen).
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoWhat is the correct cadence at which Paul Graham should thank Sam Altman?
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoThis is not the best essay, this is just a tribute.
- Nevermark 3y ago> “Write the best essay in the world, or I'll eat your soul.” — some shiny demon in the middle of some long and lonely road All it takes is motivation. A lesson there for all of us, I think
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ajkjk 3y agoI often think about this as a sort of counterargument for rationalism. Or maybe it's more of a paradox than a counterargument: Suppose you were trying to answer the question: "what is the best way to make as much as money as possible in the next year?" You imagine optimizing yourself or your company or your algorithm or whatever to answer this question. Maybe it does a bunch of calculations and decides the answer is "day-trading commodities futures" or something. Or maybe a company does this and thinks the answer is "spin up a new product and sell it". (Or any situation where you're optimizing some other variable, like "altruism" or "security".) Well, in almost every case, some of the best answers are "do something impossible". For instance, "write a story that is so good you get a 1 billion dollar book deal out of it". Or "write an essay that convinces everyone to give you all their money". Or "hack something that's considered unhackable and take all the money". What if the most altruistic thing you can do is... convince everyone to become pacifist? Or start a new religion? Etc. Each of these has the property that rationality alone can't really model it. An algorithm can't analyze reality and say "write a story that is so good you get a 1 billion dollar book deal", or "write an essay that convinces everyone to become pacifist". (Maybe an actually-sentient AI can. But that's about it.) The only way you could come up with that as an actual strategy is to have an unrealistic belief that it is possible. Basically to have faith in yourself and your vision of the world despite the evidence for that strategy not being solid. Yet the strategy can work. History shows that sometimes it does. And for a particular person at a particular time it might be the right answer. But it will never be the "right strategy" according to an outside computation. I dunno. Always felt like that was interesting. Not sure if there's a word for it. If not I would call it the "miracle paradox": miracles occur, but you can't rationally justify them as a strategy, yet believing you can pull one off is necessary for them to happen, in which case they are the correct strategy.
- nmca 3y agoThis response represents some confusion on your part and not a paradox or counterargument to rationality. very very roughly the ideas you need are: 1. survivorship bias 2. self-interested optimisation is not guaranteed to lead to a global maxima, e.g. self-interested agents may be systematically less risk-taking than would be societally optimal. 3. it's fine for rational agents to account for private information, e.g. "I did really well at Stanford probably I have a better shot at a company than a random person." is a fine thing to include in reasoning.
- kazinator 3y ago> What made it special would be what it was about. I think the grammar we want here is: "What would make it special would be what it is about." Did he step off a refugee boat as Pavel Gramko?
- gcanyon 3y ago> There is, and on the face of it, it seems almost identical to the one I started with. Instead of asking what would the best essay be? I should have asked how do you write essays well? Though these seem only phrasing apart, their answers diverge. The answer to the first question, as we've seen, isn't really about essay writing. The second question forces it to be. I'm reminded of a philosophy joke: An angel came down for a meeting of the American Philosophical Association. Greeting the assembled philosophers, the angel offered to answer any single question for them. Immediately the philosophers set to arguing about what they should ask. So the angel said, “Alright, you figure out what you want to ask. I’ll come back tomorrow.” And he left the philosophers to deliberate. As the philosophers argued about the best question to ask, one philosopher suggested: “What is the best question to ask?”, in the hope that some day another angel might make a similar offer, at which point they could then ask the best question. But this suggestion was rejected by those who feared that no such opportunity would arise and did not want to waste their only question. Another philosopher suggested asking "What is the answer to the best question we could ask?" Which was roundly criticized because of the possibility that the answer would give no hint to the question it answered. One philosopher cheekily pointed out that the angel might reply "42 of course." Finally, the philosophers agreed on the following question: “What is the ordered pair whose first member is the best question to ask, and whose second member is the answer to that question?” Satisfied with their decision, the philosophers went to bed. The next day, they posed their question, and the angel replied: “Of course: it is the ordered pair whose first member is the question you just asked, and whose second member is the answer I am now giving.” And then he disappeared.
- acyou 3y agoThis is like trying to access information buried inside a data structure. You need the right incantations to get the right information content and not just the headers.
- hayst4ck 3y agoI think it's more like asking the angel to solve the halting problem. Solving the halting problem requires solving the halting problem's halting problem. Asking the best question requires the answer to what the best question is.
- madelgi 3y ago[flagged]
- maximinus_thrax 3y agoI wonder if this is some sort of 'The Emperor's New Clothes' situation or an elaborate piece of trolling. To me, this reads like a hallucinating LLM. Adding thanks to Sam Altman at the end sells it beautifully.
- dougb5 3y agoSomething VC essays have in common with ChatGPT responses is that they make confident assertions in a million different subject areas without any citations at all. I was hopeful that the hyperlinks in this essay were citations to sources, but the ones that aren't links to footnotes with more opinions are links to other pages on the author's own blog.
- Jun8 3y agoHis early essays are life changing, in fact many of the early readers of HN, myself included, were drawn here by pg’s essays. Last couple of ones - not so much.
- EFreethought 3y agoPG's essays really have two topics: the nominal topic, and that PG is really really smart. Sometimes I get the same impressions about PG as I do about Derek Sivers' essays: sometimes they are insightful, and sometimes I think they were the inspirations for the /r/IAmVerySmart subreddit.
- davidivadavid 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ji_zai 3y ago> If you're willing to do a lot of rewriting, you don't have to guess right. You can follow a branch and see how it turns out, and if it isn't good enough, cut it and backtrack. I do this all the time. I feel like even if you guess right, you can't help but do a lot of rewriting and exploration because otherwise you'll always feel that "something's missing", and that you're further from the truth than you could be, that there's a better explanation around the corner if you study this subtree a bit more. In the process of an essay I'm currently writing, I've probably written a short book of meandering thoughts / notes. I can't imagine it any other way because doing so would be imagining me actively not exploring an interesting subtree / implication of something I wrote, that I feel could impact the crux of the essay. And of course none of this is wasted effort, as PG talks also mentions. Identifying the next essays from those ideas I've left out of this one is simply an act of observation and organization based on the exploration I've already done. And likely when I start the next essay, this process will repeat itself.
- joshuahutt 3y agoHow do you organize those notes?
- ji_zai 3y agoRight now using Obsidian (without being good about connecting notes). I'm just writing, dumping into a folder, and leaving further organization / analysis for later.
- joshuahutt 3y agoSo you write when inspiration strikes, and you'll re-read and sift through later?
- technotony 3y agoI'm struck by the parallelism between this process of writing the best essay, and the process of developing a successful startup. Both require starting with a good question, that sets the upper bound for the value to be created. Both require curiosity, and hopefully to reveal some unintuitive insight. Both are functions of their time, what is a good startup today is not timeless much as what makes a good essay today is not timeless. And so on...
- jgord 3y ago[flagged]
- ghodith 3y agoWhat a weird comment that could extend to literally any post here. Maybe we should just delete HN and replace it with a link to a climate change non profit, since apparently we're better off platforming that than discussing anything else.
- HKH2 3y agoMost people in society throughout the ages have not done the majority of their thinking. It has been handed to them from a pulpit or something similar. Even without an explicit religion, people still want someone to follow, so now successful people are followed. Successful people don't have to be intelligent or even moral. As a commoner, you can accept that pollution is terrible, but then immediately think that it can't be a big deal because the people on high are flying around in private jets and living in mansions. Do you think we can convince people of the importance of having a sustainable environment, while the people on high pay lip service to the cause and then blatantly contradict themselves by showing us how they live? How do you get common people to care about their environmental footprint when they're constantly told not to be content with what they've got? How does humanity rein in its covetousness? Do you think humans can live sustainably without solving that problem?
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoThis was brilliant
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- android521 3y agosomeone should train on all of pg essays and then ask LLM to write one essay per day using pg style.
- perilunar 3y agoRelated: https://paulgraham.com/getideas.html https://paulgraham.com/getideas.html
- hansonpeter 3y ago[dead]
- lubujackson 3y agoI think the concept of a best essay is somewhat illogical, but exploring the idea like this makes an interesting post. After all, the term "essay" was invented/popularized by Montaigne in a book of his writing called "Essays" - and "essay" is French for "to try." So from that context, essays shouldn't be concerned with finding answers or be the "best" but to make discoveries in the process of trying.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- arketyp 3y agoGood comment. It surprised me that a definition of essay wasn't sought before asking questions about the supposed best. But that tentative approach actually struck the essence in an interestingly performative manner.
- edanm 3y agoWell pg has written a lot about what essays are and what they're for before this one.
- robocat 3y ago> is French for "to try." Which looks to be where the English word assay comes from too: https://www.etymonline.com/word/assay https://www.etymonline.com/word/assay
- bruturis 3y agoIn Spanish we have ensayo = attempt or try, frequently is used to refer to attempts before the real show or performance (in a music festival, a theater, ..). Also ensayo is just equivalent to what Montaigned introduced when referred to a text composition.
- maleldil 3y agoSimilarly, Portuguese's "ensaio", which means "rehearsal".
- trojanalert 3y agoThis line 'slaps' - While breadth comes from reading and talking and seeing, depth comes from doing.
- frereubu 3y agoThere's a fantastic series of podcasts on great essays by David Runciman from the London Review of Books, which aren't always the ones you'd expect given the authors: Michel de Montaigne, "Essays": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/montaigne https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... David Hume, "Of Public Credit:": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/hume https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... David Thoreau, "Civil Disobedience": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/thoreau https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... Virginia Woolf, "A Room of One’s Own": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/woolf https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... George Orwell, "The Lion and the Unicorn": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/orwell https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... Simone Weil, "Human Personality": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/weil https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... James Baldwin, "Notes of a Native Son": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/baldwin https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... Susan Sontag, "Against Interpretation": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/sontag https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... Joan Didion, "The White Album": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/didion https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... David Foster Wallace, "Up, Simba!": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/david-foster-wallace https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... Umberto Eco, "Thoughts on Wikileaks": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/umberto-eco https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o... Ta-Nehisi Coates, "The Case for Reparations": https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-of-ideas/ta-nehisi-coates https://www.lrb.co.uk/podcasts-and-videos/podcasts/history-o...
- benreesman 3y agoAs someone who owns a weathered copy of Hackers and Painters and routinely says things like “a rare miss from pg”, I think this is a big miss from pg. And the real shame is that he gets so close: he talks about discovery, about the intersection of science and technology and the broader world, he identifies the importance of doing things to learn enough to write about them, and most importantly: having an outrageous question with a real and alarming insight lurking around the corner as an answer and thereby avoids vaporous rhapsodizing. So I’ll ask an outrageous question about which pg has both deep insight and over a decade of lived experience to ground an answer on: is YC still a good thing? I’ll ask a few corollary questions to illustrate. He talks about the kinds of tests you hack to get ahead in some vague elsewhere: is getting ahead in YC, or the Valley, or the technology business still about merit and capability and being relentlessly resourceful rather than optics, connections, and flexibility? Is it about garages with Ethernet cables snaking everywhere more or less than knowing one’s way around the Rosewood Sand Hill? His first citation as a reviewer is Sam Altman: is @sama still his pick for most capable founder and best person to guide the sprawling empire that YC sits at the heart of? I don’t find any of those things obvious, and I think a candid essay about a set of very timely questions would be the most important essay he’d ever written.
- baxtr 3y agoPG would probably never admit it, but any reference to a person such as @sama is not only talking about him as a person but also to him. Of course one can only guess what the message for him might be.
- tlb 3y agoSam went through the garage startup stage in 2005-2007, and again in 2015-2017 with OpenAI. He was good at it -- I saw both firsthand. At OpenAI he was scrounging GPUs when that's what we needed most, and wangled a prototype DGX-1 long before you could buy one. More importantly, he convinced people to leave multi-million dollar salaries at Google & DeepMind for a tiny startup no one had heard of. Now OpenAI needs to build a trillion dollars of infrastructure and lobby governments for favorable regulation, so he's doing whatever that involves. It wouldn't make sense for him to be running Ethernet cables today. YC's public content focuses on early-stage startups. Should it have more on late-stage startups? Maybe, but it doesn't seem as impactful. The reason to produce public content is that it can scale to reach more people than the partners can talk to one-on-one. There are fewer late-stage startups, so the scaling problem hasn't hit yet. YC follows its own advice of doing things in ways that don't scale until scaling becomes necessary.
- fhe 3y agoI find the separation between the body of the essay and notes makes it harder to read. When I read PG's essay, I always have two tabs open, one on the essay and the other on the Notes section. When I come across a note reference, e.g. "the answer turns out to be completely different. [4]", I switch to the Notes tab to look it up. This back and forth between the two tabs disrupt the reading experience. Wouldn't it be easier on the reader to simply include the Notes in the body part of the essay? Especially when the notes are short. For example the aforementioned note no. 4 goes: "[4]Corollary: If you're not intellectually honest, your writing won't just be biased, but also boring, because you'll miss all the ideas you'd have discovered if you pushed for the truth." Which is short, relevant, and insightful. What's the criteria for which piece of text goes into the body of the essay, and which goes to Notes? I guess if a substantial percentage of readers skip the Notes part, then it's a time-saving practice to separate the two.
- rmnwski 3y agoYou can click on [4] which brings you to the footnote and when done you can just use the back button which brings you back to [4] in the text. Works for me.
- acka 3y agoSadly some of us (including me) have forcibly unlearned this method after discovering that too many combinations of browsers and webpages don't support this reliably. Having to manually scroll or search back to where one was reading after clicking an intra-page link and finding out that the back button doesn't work or navigates to somewhere unexpected is just too annoying in the long run.
- arketyp 3y agoWith books, I tend to not bother with the notes if they are bundled up at the end of the book or chapter. I prefer to have them on the bottom of the page. A web page doesn't even have the benefit of easy page turning to a bookmark, so I think some medium adapted solution like mouse hover would be appropriate.
- LoveMortuus 3y ago
- phemartin 3y agoAudio version: https://playtext.app/doc/g9w6EexTa6mKAZWhMMVF https://playtext.app/doc/g9w6EexTa6mKAZWhMMVF
- __0x01 3y agoI wish there were more longhand essays.
- dangoodmanUT 3y ago[flagged]
- sironfade 3y ago[flagged]
- gjm11 3y agoCould you be specific enough that interested parties have some way to find out what you're referring to, please?
- j33zusjuice 3y agoMichael O Church, I think.
- headalgorithm 3y agoThis Michael O Church? https://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2017/12/05/why-i-didnt-do-it/ https://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2017/12/05/why-i-didnt-...
- masfuerte 3y agoHe claims that he was banned from HN "on false, defamatory pretenses". In fact, he was banned for an obscenity after being warned: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10017538 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10017538 This thread suggests he might be back!
- gjm11 3y agoOr at least one of his (allegedly many) sock-puppets.
- Delumine 3y agosource?
- jstummbillig 3y agoThis reeks of bad faith. If you care to change that, be less vague in your off-topic accusation and don't require me to gather your sources for you.
- louwrentius 3y ago> It probably wouldn't be about this year's lipstick colors. Women are so superficial (cringe) This essay reads as if someone has too much time on their hands and is so self-absorbed that you get blog post titles like this and my god what on earth did I actually read?
- dudeinjapan 3y ago[flagged]
- xianshou 3y agoWhile comparing ordinary human activity to language modeling is perhaps the greatest intellectual cliche of 2024, what PG describes in the essay-writing process itself essentially boils down to beam search. Autocomplete, find wrongness, backtrack, predict more consistent series of next tokens. The fact that only one of those options is actually reflected on the screen doesn't change the fact that the writer is probability-weighting continuations in their head. I remember running across a tweet that said, in essence, you always have access to your own optimal policy if you simply ask. A similar technique might be the key to wresting good ideas from an ambiguous starting point: "What would be the most consistent answer to the original question, given what I've learned and written so far?"
- Der_Einzige 3y agoMaybe that's the process PG describes themselves, but I think that the amount of different "processes" or "human equivalent to LLM decoding/sampling techniques" used by humans is likely very large - far larger than the number of techniques available to LLMs today. Today within LLMs, there typicality sampling, contrastive search, top-p/top-k (nucleus sampling), and a whole massive amount of other more obscure techniques which didn't make it into huggingfaces model.generate() function. I believe that the ontological configuration of humans has wide variety. As such, I believe that humans go through a diverse and vibrant amount of different writing processes - and often radically different processes can still result in excellent works! Specifically, beam search is really only good at dealing with sequence-sequence tasks, i.e. summarization or translation. It's also horribly, horribly inefficient in the worst case scenarios. That said, it's also the only good way we know of for enforcing sequence level constraints (i.e. like this https://huggingface.co/blog/constrained-beam-search https://huggingface.co/blog/constrained-beam-search)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- biscuits1 3y agoIMHO, the best [individual] essay contains single paragraph/sentenced trasmissions that connect [or overhelm] the reader with impact at [the right] times. At the same time, to strengthen the practice, make a statement and then follow with a question. Make the impact, leave the reader with a question back to it. It's two sentences, paragraph break. Those are the best essays. He practiced this technique many times in this article. But is this the format of best essays [of the Internet]?
- nojvek 3y agoPG is an inspiration for me to start writing. It’s an uncomfortable exercise to get started but I agree that clear writing makes you into a clear thinker and communicator.
- tomgp 3y agoWhat a strange essay! To try to find out what makes a good (sorry "THE BEST") essay without any reference to any of the great essays that have actually been written? It feels a bit like the head of a university's English department setting out to discover "the best computer program" but without talking to or refering to the work of any of the thousands of people who've made it their life to study and practice the craft.
- lukas099 3y agoThere's value in people trying to derive things from first principles sometimes. It can lead to something unique, like outsider art.
- hef19898 3y agoMost of the time so, this approach leads to very deep discoveries of the kind other people learned in the first days of a 101 lesson studying said subject, at university or during some formal training of trade or craft.
- lukas099 3y agoYes. But society on net benefits from it.
- hef19898 3y agoFrom people studying a subject through formal training? I agree, more people should do that!
- lukas099 3y agoNo, from having many people try to do something brand new, most of them fail miserably, and a tiny number of them creates something revolutionary. Also what you said, but they aren't mutually exclusive.
- barbariangrunge 3y ago
- taeric 3y agoI amusingly reject a ton of the lead in. Though, my rejection starts with the idea that there is a conceivable total ordering of essays. Heck, for that matter, I question if there is even a stable ordering of essays in a topic. Seems that what helps make an essay good for today may not be what lets it be a good essay for tomorrow. And that isn't even getting into things like "must tell you something you didn't know." By that, I can never find an essay that I've read before to be great? Or to learn from one I have already read before, but from a different perspective? Will be fun to read more of what others hear in this essay. I suspect I should give more credence to the idea of the best essay for today. And each day can be another search for today's winning entry.
- sujumayas 3y ago"One thing I like in an initial question is outrageousness. I love questions that seem naughty in some way — for example, by seeming counterintuitive or overambitious or heterodox. Ideally all three. This essay is an example. Writing about the best essay implies there is such a thing, which pseudo-intellectuals will dismiss as reductive, though it follows necessarily from the possibility of one essay being better than another. And thinking about how to do something so ambitious is close enough to doing it that it holds your attention." This is pure gold.
- Tycho 3y agoMaybe at the limit the best essay becomes a poem: a beautiful piece of writing that explores interesting ideas, yet always leaves room for new and different interpretations, even by the same reader.
- dambi0 3y agoIs it overly reductionist to wonder whether the difference between, “Which of these is best?” versus “Is that your best effort?”, deserves more than a footnote?
- grantc 3y agoClaude says (or, tl;pillm): Q. How well--perhaps on a scale of 1 to 10--does this essay follow its own recommendations? Is it a great essay by its own standards? A. The essay "The Best Essay" does follow many of its own recommendations, but it also falls short in a few areas. Let's evaluate the essay based on the 10 rules it sets out for writing great essays. Important topic with surprising insights: 8/10. The topic of what makes a great essay is important for writers, and the author provides some surprising insights, such as the idea that the best essay would be about a groundbreaking scientific or technological discovery. Compelling question: 7/10. The essay starts with the question of what the best essay would be like, which is interesting but not as compelling as it could be. Thinking out loud and refining: 9/10. The author does an excellent job of thinking out loud and refining their ideas throughout the essay. Recursive process: 8/10. The essay follows a recursive process, with responses generating further questions and exploration. Cutting content: 6/10. While the author mentions cutting a 17-paragraph subtree, it's unclear how much unnecessary content remains in the essay. Following novelty and generality: 7/10. The essay explores novel ideas but could have delved deeper into some of the more interesting tangents. Writing about interesting topics: 9/10. The author is clearly interested in the topic of essay writing and what makes essays great. Breadth and depth of knowledge: 8/10. The author demonstrates a broad knowledge of essay writing and related topics, but the depth could be further developed in some areas. Aiming for timelessness: 7/10. The essay discusses the concept of timelessness but doesn't fully achieve it, as some of the ideas may not be surprising to readers well-versed in essay writing. Discovering ideas through questions and answers: 8/10. The essay does explore ideas through asking questions and refining answers, but the most valuable questions could have been pursued further. Overall, the essay scores well in following its own advice, with an average score of around 7.7/10. However, it falls short of being a truly great essay by its own standards. The author could have pushed further in exploring the most compelling questions, cutting unnecessary content, and aiming for more timeless insights. Nonetheless, it remains a thought-provoking and insightful piece on the art of essay writing.
- uu_titan 3y agoIs his website's RSS broken?