5 ms·
The Europeans may be out to lunch, but at least they're living a decent life while they're eating. It takes huge balls to look at the US right now -- banks in
by timr 18y ago
The Europeans may be out to lunch, but at least they're living a decent life while they're eating.
It takes huge balls to look at the US right now -- banks in collapse, citizens teetering on the edge of bankruptcy -- and claim that we're a model for the right way of doing things. The French may not work 60-hour weeks, but at least they have the good sense to make the most of the time they've been granted on the planet. What do most Americans live for? Buying cheap crap at WalMart? Buying better crap than the guy next door?
I could care less that the "best" web2.0 companies are based in the US, when those companies are laying people off right now. Their former employees will have to enter the worst job market in nearly 30 years, without health care to protect them if they get sick, or basic social programs to keep their children from going hungry. I think that's an awful, brutal, unfair system, and I'd gladly trade a little bit of "competitiveness" for a bit more compassion.
- davidw 18y agoAs an American living in Europe, I think there are things to be learned on both sides. I completely agree with things like health care, or things to protect people to some degree if they lose their jobs. What doesn't work in "Europe" (please not, however, that there are different systems within Europe) are some of the rigid labor laws, and the high barrier to entry for people wishing to create new companies. ... a little bit later ... I wrote something about it myself, as it's a topic that's quite important to me: http://journal.dedasys.com/2008/12/13/startups-and-work-europe-vs-the-us http://journal.dedasys.com/2008/12/13/startups-and-work-euro...
- doodyhead 18y agoTo address entrepreneurship in Europe misses the point. What Mike Arrington fails to realize is he's only talking about France. When it comes to work ethic, different European countries are world's apart. You can't take countries like France, Germany, the UK and Ireland and blithely treat them as one entity. Behaviors and attitudes to work and to start-ups differ vastly from one country to another.
- xiaoma 18y agoThe same could be said of NYC, San Francisco and Detroit.
- taylan 18y agoAs a US-educated entrepreneur based in Europe, I disagree. Their entrepreneurial culture is what's going to save the Americans, since they have the means to innovate their way out of this meltdown; be it through web 2.0 or greentech. Generous welfare state that we have in Europe presumes presence of a stable economy generating enough surplus wealth to sustain it. If we get outcompeted, it'll be the first thing to go unfortunately. We need to figure out a way to combine best of both worlds.
- axod 18y agoThe next big bubble = greentech.
- taylan 18y agoBubbles are a great way to build infrastructure: http://www.slate.com/id/2165929/nav/tap1/ http://www.slate.com/id/2165929/nav/tap1/ Build a smart energy grid during boom, and it will spawn a great deal of innovation during bust.
- donw 18y agoI'm probably horribly naïve, and quite possibly stupid, but I think the solution is actually pretty simple. Welfare, and all other aid programs, should be available to absolutely anyone, regardless of income. But none of these aid programs should result in the aid-ee receiving any form of currency. For example, welfare should provide spartan clothing, housing, nutritious food, and that's it. No food stamps, no cash disbursal, but a safe and humane environment that can help people to get back on their feet. For those who don't want to get up and work, that's fine too, but comforts like being able to get coffee at Starbucks, or a big-screen TV, or a nice bottle of wine, aren't going to be provided by the government. If you want luxury, work for it.
- barrkel 18y agoIt should include sufficient resources to raise children effectively. Underinvestment in poor children, especially at a very young age, is probably the biggest opportunity cost in almost all countries in the world.
- corentin 18y ago> The French may not work 60-hour weeks, but at least they have the good sense to make the most of the time they've been granted on the planet. France is the number one country in the world for antidepressant drugs consumption...
- davidw 18y agoIs that because people are actually depressed, or because it's easy and cheap to get the pills? Interestingly (well, in a grim sort of way), according to this, the suicide rate is pretty high in France, one of the highest in western Europe: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_ra... That's surprising to me, I would have thought France would show up somewhere between places like Italy and Spain (which have low rates despite being relatively a bit poorer), and more northerly, gray places like Germany. Belgium is quite high up there too.
- herval 18y agoit's not cheaper than america... and it requires a prescription, as well
- timr 18y agoI don't know how much you should read into that list, given that Zimbabwe, Iran, Armenia and Uzbekistan are listed as having significantly lower suicide rates than most industrialized nations. It's pretty clear that the statistics are less than reliable.
- xiaoma 18y agoThis list might be a bit easier to scan: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_OECD_countries_by_suicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_OECD_countries_by_suici...
- johnyzee 18y agoThe French are famous for extensive consumption of medicine in general.
- corentin 18y ago> I think that's an awful, brutal, unfair system, and I'd gladly trade a little bit of "competitiveness" for a bit more compassion. As I see in your profile that one of your goal is to live outside the US, let me tell you that I'll gladly trade my French passport for your US passport. In France, you'll have as much compassion, fairness, equality and socialism as you want (and probably even more!) edit: to be honest, you are on the right track to experience this brilliant social system in the US...
- davidw 18y agoLiving abroad is a great eye opener: you see the good and bad in another system and way of doing things, and you get some perspective on your own country, too.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- donw 18y agoI think that it's often also a great way to realize that Things Back Home are nowhere near as bad as you thought they were, and that The Other Place isn't necessarily paradise, no matter how much you may like their culture/food/women/men.
- davidw 18y agoWell, I'm married to one of the women from The Other Place, so yeah, I'd definitely have to give them the edge:-)
- pg 18y agoYour argument is indistinguishable from the arguments people used to make in the 1970s about how life was better in the Soviet Union than the US. Sure, their GNP per capita was lower, but they had more leisure time; their lives were not merely devoted to piling up possessions; society had more compassion. The actual fact, in hindsight, is that life in the Soviet Union was pretty grim for the average person. It was only good for the guys who ran everything. And that is pretty much the case in France, though on a smaller scale. Once you leave the big tourist areas, France is pretty grubby. The median French citizen does not live some kind of charmed, stylish life in his ample free time. Nor is he so high-minded that he is above buying cheap crap. Everyday life in France for the average person is much like it is for the average person in the US, just a little poorer.
- timr 18y agoI'm not only talking about France -- that was just the immediate target, as the country that Arrington visited. Even in Germany they have very different attitudes toward work and social services than we do, yet still support an industrial and entrepreneurial culture (and still make fun of the French for being lazy). Framing this as a choice between US capitalism and French socialism (or Soviet communism) is a false dichotomy.
- pg 18y agoOk, substitute Europe for France. The median for France is almost certainly above the median for all of Europe.
- ivankirigin 18y agoMedian wage in Portugal is below the US poverty line.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- timr 18y ago
- time_management 18y agoHonestly, I think that it'd be a lot better for American entrepreneurs for the US to learn from the European model. Small businesses will benefit enormously from universal healthcare, for example. More vacation wouldn't hurt either. I'm going to go out on a limb and assert that productivity is probably maximized, per hour, at 9-10 weeks' vacation, and in gross, at 4-5. It makes sense for the most ambitious 1% to work 50+ hour weeks, during the highest-energy decade of their life... but it doesn't make sense for everyone to be working that much.
- etal 18y agoLately it's been bothering me more that we're expected to get our health care plans through our employers. The proportion of Americans who hold traditional full-time, salaried positions at medium-to-large companies is far from 100%. A health care plan is something everyone needs; a job is something much more flexible that we do to earn (notably inconsistent amounts of) money. Moving toward either socialized medicine or the libertarian/free-market model would be better for entrepreneurship -- relying on a paternalistic employer for access to essential services isn't even a local optimum.
- jbjohns 18y agoUniversal health care I'm not so sold on, but the possible options aren't just (1) universal health care and (2) the incredibly awful system the U.S. has. I'm an American living in Switzerland, for example, and here it is simply the law that you must have insurance. And since the government is guaranteeing income for insurance companies there are controls on how much money the insurance companies are allowed to make (from time to time they even have to send checks to their customers because they made to much money!). Since their profits are capped there is no incentive for shady practices like telling every person who claims "no" knowing full well that around 50% wont know enough to push it further as you see done in the US, South Africa, etc.
- jerf 18y ago"banks in collapse, citizens teetering on the edge of bankruptcy" - have you not been reading the news from Europe? Have you not noticed the way the word "global" is prepended to the word "recession"? Europeans had about four days of gloating while we stumbled. Then the gloating stopped because it turned out that many of their banks were even more leveraged than ours, despite their supposedly-superior regulation regime, and their bill came due too. For all that you hear people bitching about the US, in relative terms it's actually not doing so bad. (I'd prefer that we'd all be growing in absolute terms, but the whole "Europe is better than the US argument" is intrinsically relative, so I'm just agreeing to your terms and following through.) You want to talk about how much better the European system is, then explain why this is happening there and not here: http://www.oxfordpress.com/hp/content/shared/news/world/stories/11/NATFRANCE1108a_5REP.html http://www.oxfordpress.com/hp/content/shared/news/world/stor... And notice the scale! This is not an isolated riot in one block of Paris. Nor is this the first time. The European-style social system is unsustainable, and to their credit they are beginning to recognize this and beginning the hard task of scaling back their promises, but they face challenges from all those who were promised and do not want to give it up. I have found it highly ironic (and very sad) that as Europe wakes up to the failures of, for instance, socialized healthcare, the US seems primed to go charging into that pit of despair more than ever.
- timr 18y ago"You want to talk about how much better the European system is, then explain why [the French immigrant riots are] happening there and not here....and notice the scale! This is not an isolated riot in one block of Paris. Nor is this the first time." 1) It's early. If we keep up with the immigrant-baiting in this country, we'll get there. Just last year, we had huge protests in the major cities because of the way that we treat immigrants. Did you not notice? 2) We've been doing the violent social protest thing for quite a while: the Watts riots in 65, the LA riots in 1992, looting after Hurricane Katrina, the Benton Harbor riots in 2003...and many, many others. Here's a nice list: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_riots#1990s_-_2000 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_riots#1990s_-_2000 (for fun, count how many times France appears in the list, relative to the US!) We have a long, illustrious history of making minority groups so angry that they erupt into violence, so if anything, France is late to the party. 3) For the most part, the European banks were not more leveraged than US banks, with certain critical exceptions. That said, most of the world's banks make significant investments in US debt-backed assets, so it's pretty hard for an economic downturn in this country to avoid affecting other industrialized nations. The bank argument is a straw man.
- jamesbritt 18y ago"What do most Americans live for? Buying cheap crap at WalMart? Buying better crap than the guy next door?" That doesn't describe any Americans I know. On what do you base this claim? How do you know what most Americans live for?
- guruz 18y agoit describes the european cliche of the US. That is all what counts in internet discussions ;)