7 ms·
E-Bikes Overtake Buggies for Some Amish (2021)
- DANmode 3y agoSurprisingly great content. Thanks!
- daemonologist 3y agoI was struck by the number of people pictured wearing high vis but not helmets; I suppose it might partially be because they're riding in places where pedestrians are otherwise very rare so cars are an even greater danger than usual. The article mentions: > At the same time, helmets pose special problems for Amish women. They grow their hair long and keep it wrapped in a bun covered with a cap. For this reason, most bike helmets do not fit Amish women. Mullett said he has talked with some helmet manufacturers and encouraged them to build helmets suitable for Amish women, so far without success. For now, far more men wear helmets than women. Seems to me that if you could make an exception/determination that ebikes were okay, it would make sense to adjust the rules around hairstyle and cap wearing as well. Not really my place to speak though.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoThe Amish aren't really about rejecting technology just to be luddites, but rather to about trying to preserve their traditions and culture. One of the ways they do that is to avoid adopting new things (technologies, processes, etc) until the community leadership agrees to it. There are Amish that have cars, electricity and computers because their communities have determined that those technologies are acceptable in certain situations and allowed them. Seen that way, electric bikes may not be a big change from the regular bikes some communities already allow for transportation. Appearance is a very significant part of Amish culture though, and changing those norms just to fit a technology is exactly what they don't want to do.
- itake 3y agoI wonder if this change is economically driven: if electric vehicles and tools allow Amish to produce more, then their churches benefit from higher tithes.
- bbatha 3y agoTo some degree yes the Amish are most likely to use modern technology in business contexts. On the other hand if economics were the sole factor they’d all have robot tractors and the other multitude of productivity enhancing tools that have been developed for agriculture that have been developed over the last 200 years.
- bruce511 3y agoIt's interesting to me that you pose this question. I would suggest that this says more about the culture you live in than the culture the Amish live in. (No offence intended.) My hypothesis is that you live in a primarily material culture (safe bet, since we mostly all do.) Thus most of your life decisions surround money. What can you afford, how to get more of it, how to spend less of it and so on. Again, z safe bet, since that's true for most of us in general, and is emphasised especially in the US. Most of this is just baked in, so when we look at alternative lifestyles we can assume that they make decisions as we do. That can be a mistake simply because its hard to conceive the way others live. For example it's common for Europeans to get over 30 days paid leave a year. In the US most shift workers get none. In Europe salaried workers work fixed hours, then go home. In the US they stay late, do emails all night, and so on. Neither approach is right or wrong, they're just different. And it's easy to put my motivations on another group, send then see their decisions as crazy.
- itake 3y agoGentrification and inflation are real and they are coming for you if you fall behind. The Amish try to be self-sustaining, but it is extremely hard to not participate in modern society, especially considering healthcare. If Grandma is sick, do you let her die or do you pay $100k for cancer treatments? If you have 7 or 8 kids, then where does the land come from to house them? Europe is a great example of a region that hasn't had a significant technology breakthrough in decades. (I'm less familiar with healthcare tech, but most engineering products have come out of the USA and Asia). The impact is real: the pounds and euro have fallen in value to the dollar.
- hgomersall 3y agoSlight aside, but that was the position of the luddites too.
- jauntywundrkind 3y ago> The Amish aren't really about rejecting technology just to be luddites, but rather to about trying to preserve their traditions and culture. One of the ways they do that is to avoid adopting new things (technologies, processes, etc) until the community leadership agrees to it. Neither feels right to me. The Luddites and Amish share a common thread, which is that of ownership and control and ability to set one's own course. I don't think the Luddites agreed that preserving traditions and culture was what drove them. They wanted mechanization to serve us all, to not be used to control them. They resisted the mechanization of the human spirit. The Amish have their own culture & tradition, but I think again what's afoot here is also in part about control & ownership, at least as much as it is tradition & culture. To call this just tradition & culture ignores & skips over what's really at stake, which is control & ownership. Whether we have the ability to use technology on our own footing, or whether it is an injected force that shapes and molds us. Is tech soft and malleable, or is it hard & unyielding, forcing humanity to change itself?
- kmeisthax 3y agoSmashing looms was their tactic, not their goal. Their actual goal was to own the looms (to the exclusion of the factory owners). The original Parliamentary compromise regarding the introduction of looms was that skilled weavers would get first dibs on using them. A bunch of factory owners said "Fuck that" and just started using them anyway. Parliament not only didn't punish them for breaking the law, they passed even more laws to criminalize machine breaking on pain of death so that the Luddites couldn't protest anymore. Then they made up a story about them irrationally hating machines so they could paint organized labor as regressive. The Amish reject technology that ties them into a centralized society because they think decentralized, off-the-grid living makes you closer to God. The Luddites did not reject technology, they destroyed it as a tactic to bring capital back to the negotiating table. They're closer to the artists naming-and-shaming AI art users: few if any of them are Dunepilled[0] enough to actually want, say, a ban on computer programs that create art. What they want is protection against being economically replaced. [0] We must destroy the machines that think.
- wkat4242 3y agoI couldn't imagine a community 'leadership: telling me what to do and wear :( Of course we in the modern world are also a bit limited in terms of what we can buy but I often make my own pretty extravagant stuff to wear. Not always appreciated by conservatives but I couldn't care less. Ps nobody in the Netherlands wears helmets on bikes and we don't really need to. But I guess collisions with cars are more common in areas where bikes are less common. I've fallen many times but I always had my arm protecting my head in reflex even though it happened so fast I didn't even realise. The thing is that we don't view bikes as an exercise or sports thing you gear up for but just a convenience thing you grab for the 500m run to the shop. Besides having to put it on you'd be stuck having to carry it as well. And bikes are kinda the king of the road in Holland anyway. If you get hit by a car it's automatically their fault so they're really careful.
- TomK32 3y agoNeither high viz nor helmets help if the motorists are not driving their car as they should https://twitter.com/SurreyRoadCops/status/1454919907964035077 https://twitter.com/SurreyRoadCops/status/145491990796403507... https://www.bournemouthecho.co.uk/news/18206596.pictured-police-car-wrecked-bus-crash-upton-bypass/ https://www.bournemouthecho.co.uk/news/18206596.pictured-pol... https://thelincolnite.co.uk/2021/08/stoned-lorry-driver-crushed-police-car-and-seriously-injured-officers-in-a1-crash/ https://thelincolnite.co.uk/2021/08/stoned-lorry-driver-crus... https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cn0qy743j0do https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cn0qy743j0do
- _ZeD_ 3y agowhy should they wear helmets?
- tfourb 3y agoTo avoid death or serious injury in case of an accident.
- romafirst3 3y agoBy that logic everyone in a car should wear a helmet in case of an accident. Head trauma is a real danger in car accidents. Wearing a helmet in your car will help with any head trauma. Why don't car drivers wear a helmet?
- defrost 3y agoBecause car drivers, unlike ebike riders and buggy drivers, are surrounded by a metal cage built to some level of crash protection standard. Car drivers also largely wear seat belts that prevent them being thrown through the air and impacting trees, kerbs, etc. It's kind of obvious really.
- dxdm 3y agoYou're probably aware of other cases where people wear helmets, for example on construction sites and while riding motorbikes or indeed bicycles. A lot of people riding cars wear seatbelts. I don't understand what's supposed to be so baffling about wearing helmets in this case, as well.
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoBicycle helmets are virtually useless when involved in a multi-vehicle collision (e.g. a cyclist and a car driver). They are typically tested IIRC for speeds of up to 12mph onto a static surface from a height of 2m or so. The forces involved when colliding with a motorised vehicle are orders of magnitude greater. https://www.cycleplan.co.uk/cycle-savvy/what-are-the-cycle-helmet-safety-standards/ https://www.cycleplan.co.uk/cycle-savvy/what-are-the-cycle-h...
- throwaway892238 3y agoThe high vis is paramount. The helmet... well, I just don't know how much good it would do if you get clipped by an F-150 going 60mph
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoHi-Viz is only useful if the driver(s) are actually looking and paying attention. There's plenty of examples of drivers hitting static objects that are festooned with hi-viz colouring and reflectives. Bicycle helmet safety standards are generally for speeds up to 12mph and/or a static drop from 2m onto a hard surface. They are specifically not designed to withstand the forces/accelerations involved in a multi-vehicle collision. (One of my bug-bears is when people point to a destroyed bicycle helmet and claim that it saved their life. Helmets are designed to compress and are particularly weak when subjected to tensile/shear forces. If a helmet splits in two, then it most likely wasn't being effective)
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoHelmets are for when they fall awkwardly; in practice, this rarely happens (disclaimer: I live in a bike friendly country). High-vis is for other traffic to see them. Motorcyclists often have both.
- cardinalfang 3y agoAn airbag helmet full of electronics would allow traditional dress, but I don't know enough theology to make the decision.
- usrusr 3y agoThe only company that made them has gone bankrupt, so there's that. They were successful in Copenhagen, where helmet-wearing is not quite as exotic as in the Netherlands, but apparently one city is not enough.
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoI half-considered getting one of those (I'm in the UK), but the initial cost was expensive and they were single-use as in they needed to go back to the manufacturer to be reset after being triggered which was an additional cost. https://www.hovding.com/ https://www.hovding.com/
- usrusr 3y agoI'd be dead scared of false positives riding in one. That might be harmless at a speed slightly above pedestrian, but my speed range does not end there.
- euroderf 3y agoCould I, as a consumer of said helmet, have performed a non-destructive test ?
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoI don't believe so - once they were triggered they'd need to be factory reset.
- euroderf 3y agoAnd so my only alternative is to place my utmost and final faith in the product.
- bcta1 3y agoSlightly off topic, but I’m surprised that helmet manufacturers haven’t made more helmets for other people whose practices make wearing traditional helmets challenging (like Sikh men with turbans).
- sandspar 3y agoIt's easy to laugh at these groups' apparent selective interpretations of their rules. But at the same time I realize that they are intelligent people, who no doubt reasoned this through to a degree that I can't even fathom. I don't know if this means that I'm right or they're right, whether a gut reaction of "haha that's obvious bullshit" should be listened to or whether that feeling should be ignored when it contradicts the experts' opinions.
- solumunus 3y agoRight about what?
- sandspar 3y agoThanks for pointing this out. "Right" is the wrong word. I think I would have been better to say something like, "whether I'm simply ignorant or whether they're deceiving themselves."
- solatic 3y agoI grew up with Orthodox Judaism and wrote my Bar Mitzva speech on Jewish law governing the usage of electricity on Shabbat. It was a surprising endeavor through "well this was only valid back when vacuum tubes were used" and turned into "the rabbis who wrote the original responsa wrote absolute responsa, and now we respect their decisions". Now, the Orthodox community makes it a point of pride that they "disconnect" on Shabbat, in spite of the fact that it is not part of the list of the 39 Labors that are forbidden on Shabbat, and in spite of other parts of Jewish law about not introducing new restrictions over time. When discussing religious matters - even when there's supposed to be some kind of logic involved, really, underneath, these are emotional decisions. Today it is simply a part of how a community defines itself. A local community makes these decisions together, or not at all, or individual members leave. I imagine Amish communities are similar.
- sircastor 3y agoAs a tangent, I learned a few years ago that my oven has a Sabbath mode, intended to help observant folks keep the sabbath. It’s an interesting feature and I wonder how it started being implemented in appliances.
- looping8 3y agoPerhaps it is because it is a USA thing, but I do not understand the limits they talk about in the article. These Amish cannot use electricity... but they can use solar power? Why is regular electricity in their faith worse than the same energy harnessed via solar power? What is the difference from their point of view?
- 486sx33 3y agoIt’s the wires, the devil comes through the wires … or something to do with the physical connection at least
- cortesoft 3y agoI think the key thing to remember is that they aren't trying to find loopholes or focused on the letter of the law with these decisions. The rules they have are for practical reasons (whether you agree or disagree with them). It isn't as important to them whether it is perfectly consistent with the letter of the law as whether it fits with the purpose of the rule in the first place.
- spiderice 3y agoWhich is what? Not being dependent on an electrical grid?
- hervature 3y agoI think you are more or less correct with regards to electricity but the rule applies more broadly to technology. Obviously, the Amish use wheels and other tools. The problem for them (and which I think a great many people would agree) is when technology ceases to serve us and we (society) become indentured to the technology. Consider all these "phone-free" movements, limited screen time, and social media detoxes. In this light, the Amish seem very much enlightened that they take many years to deliberate whether a technology is an overall positive or detriment. Going back to the use of electricity. I think probably a huge part of a grid that works at nighttime is that it definitely changes society in the sense that nightlife is all of a sudden possible. You can debate whether or not it's a positive impact to society but the impact is inarguable. People will fall on different sides of that debate.
- mosselman 3y agoOfftopic: The scrolling on this page is super annoying. There is probably some javascript library interfering with it.
- jack_riminton 3y ago"Some people are commuting eight to 10 miles, some only one or two miles, but they jump on their bike and go. With a traditional bike, that would never have been considered" As a European this struck me as odd. 8 - 10 miles on an ordinary bike is considered a pretty normal bike commute. Especially as Ohio is pretty flat right?
- derwiki 3y agoI grew up near an Ohio Amish Country (Sugarcreek) which was south of where the glacier came in the last ice age, and can attest that it’s fairly hilly.
- eternauta3k 3y agoAre you thinking km? I would think riding 20 miles = 32km daily is more of a bike enthusiast thing, at least in Germany.
- derkades 3y agoAlso in NL I feel like 10km (one way) is already more than most people are willing to cycle daily.
- wkat4242 3y agoYeah totally. The supermarket would never be more than 1 or 2 km away.
- reubenmorais 3y agoThe EU Commission says [0] 3km is the average bike trip length in most European countries. They reference this other EU funded study [1] on replacing short car trips with walking and cycling, which says: > The willingness to cycle over longer distances differs between countries, but in general we should not expect people to use a bike for transport on distances longer than 3-5 km. Both are from before the e-bike boom. A 2019 Dutch study [2] says the average e-bike commute trip is ~8.5km, which indicates a rough doubling of the conventional bike range from 3-5km to 6-8km. Notably, commutes are significantly longer than all other ride types in the Dutch study, even with e-bikes. [0] https://road-safety.transport.ec.europa.eu/eu-road-safety-policy/priorities/safe-road-use/cyclists/walking-and-cycling-transport-modes_en https://road-safety.transport.ec.europa.eu/eu-road-safety-po... [1] https://safety.fhwa.dot.gov/ped_bike/docs/walcyng.pdf https://safety.fhwa.dot.gov/ped_bike/docs/walcyng.pdf [2] https://sci-hub.wf/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trd.2019.102202 https://sci-hub.wf/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trd.2019.102202
- lettergram 3y agoThis really isn’t that surprising, each Amish community has its own rules and almost all adopt/reject rules based on how it impacts their church and relationship with god. For instance many Amish drive around trucks for work. But they’ll have rules limiting it to picking up supplies, many even have cell phones. That said, other communities reject all forms of modern “comforts”. Medicine, cars, electricity, manufactured foods, etc. The Amish community is pretty large, hundreds of thousands. It’s not surprising some would adopt e-scooters. My favorite amish interaction was asking why one had a wagon full of maybe 20 containers cheese balls. Apparently, it was allowed and their entire community loved them, but it was a 20 mile ride to town so they buy in bulk (this community usually rejected almost everything, so kind of surprising)
- hansonpeter 3y ago[dead]
- throwaway892238 3y agoThe scary part of this to me is biking on country roads, especially with 55mph speed limits that big pick-ups regularly blow past. I live in a rural town, and I would be terrified to bring a bike outside slower town roads.
- arketyp 3y agoIt's easy to ridicule the Amish for their lifestyle and their roundabout solutions to the restrictions ordained by their faith, similar to some orthodox Jewish traditions. But I think there is also something honest about it. No one can lead a 100% rational life; indeed it is not obvious that would even be desirable, that it makes sense or is even possible. Effective altruism is a good example on how mislead such a notion can become. Of course one can argue about what constitutes rationality, adopt a more balanced consequentialism and avoid some of the more absurd conclusions. Anyway, I find something sympathetic about just facing some impracticalities head on.
- fleventynine 3y agoThe more I learn about how fragile our modern IT infrastructure and economy is, it seems the Amish are building a more robust society. Maybe they'll inherit the earth after our horrendously complex web of dependencies is destroyed by war or by accident. I hope most Amish communities can avoid the following: 1. Off-grid solar systems that eventually shutdown if they lose network connectivity. 2. Tractors and other agricultural equipment connected to the internet, likely susceptible to remote security vulnerabilities that could threaten the harvest. 3. Complex supply chains that require cloud services and network connectivity to function.
- lantry 3y agoThat's pretty much the plot of The Long Tommorrow (which is a great read) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Long_Tomorrow_(novel) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Long_Tomorrow_(novel)
- fennecbutt 3y agoPretty sure you're romanticising the Amish and that they're increasingly reliant on modern society.
- fleventynine 3y agoYes, but they're in a better position than most of us, and they would be wise to reconsider their ongoing dependencies on networked infrastructure and modern supply chains for anything life-critical. It's ok to rely on an off grid solar system or an electric truck as long as you disconnect them from the Internet and maintain a cache of replacement parts.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 3y agoWhat I found interesting was the jump (in Lancaster County, at least) directly from push scooters to e-bikes. Like, presumably there was a reason why regular manual bicycles weren't allowed. But e-bikes came along, and then they decided they were ok. I get that these sorts of determinations aren't a science, and they do their best to evaluate technology based on the impact to their community, culture, and values, but it surprised me to learn that some communities that are adopting e-bikes largely limited themselves to push scooters before that. Unless I misunderstood that part of the article (or the article just got it wrong).
- usrusr 3y agoI think (just from reading the article) that bikes had been allowed there the whole time, but that the geography and the distribution of settlements pushed rides just above the threshold of attractivity. One implication of this interpretation is that even before ebikes, it would have been entirely possible (even if extremely unlikely) for someone to go ahead and explore the limits in lifestyle compatibility of lycra, Japanese/Italian groupsets and narrow tires, discover that those would have a huge impact on the practicability threshold on cycling and caused a conversion from buggies to bikes without electricity. (the difference between a proper go-fast-bike and a lowly "comfortable" commuter are huge, it's not only the fitness. Most roadbike enthusiasts have the distance threshold they consider acceptable on a "slow bike" just as low as Joe Average, if they do a longer cycling commute it's on a bike that's closer to the ones they use to go three digit miles in a day than to the common commuter bike)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- qwerty456127 3y agoI feel sad about this. Amish communities seemed like a stronghold of never-changing, perfectly off-grid and durably viable (also fairly humane) way of life with clear values which wouldn't fluctuate chaotically as they do in modern cities, making a remarkably sustainable society. The first bell rang when they started using modern kitchen appliances although powered with compressed air instead of electricity. Now they embrace electricity and electronics. Even from the points of so few, it still seems reasonable to extrapolate and predict Amish communities will turn very different in a century or so. Perhaps they will start using smartphones the day everyone else will forget about these in favour of AR/VR goggles.
- Loughla 3y agoThe Amish are just like the rest of us. There are some more conservative communities that don't use these things, and some that do. For example, the population of Amish near me all have smart phones and solar panels. An hour away they don't even use compressed air power for their tools. Different sects.
- qwerty456127 3y agoVery nice to know. I didn't. Thank you.
- medstrom 3y agoI can also understand adopting the e-bike. It doesn't look at all like a slippery slope that will lead to an automobile lifestyle--at least for the rest of the world, it has the effect of making car sales less likely, not more. The e-bike is a symbol of degrowth, the way forward for future cities. Why shouldn't the Amish help wave that flag?
- qwerty456127 3y agoBy the way (your mention of the "automobile lifestyle" guided me to this question), are they always small villages or dwelling within towns built by "normal" people? I wonder if they occasionally build their own towns and if they design them differently because of lack of automobiles.