9 ms·
My Clients, the Liars
- defrost 3y agoOriginal: YASSINE MESKHOUT DEC 5, 2023 posted to: https://jessesingal.substack.com/p/my-clients-the-liars https://jessesingal.substack.com/p/my-clients-the-liars https://archive.md/c4SRO https://archive.md/c4SRO Other HN discussion of Yassine Meskhout's writing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33462658 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33462658
- account-5 3y agoThat was an excellent read.
- avmich 3y agoIt's kind of a pity the parallel construction used by some services can't be revealed just as easily.
- andrewflnr 3y agoI recommend also reading the post titled "Eleven Magic Words", linked through the text "they haven't". OP is interesting and kind of funny, but the linked article affected me... pretty deeply, in a weird way.
- yobert 3y agoThat Eleven Magic Words article got me totally hooked on his writing. I found it very powerful too. There's so much of our society that I know nothing about, and he sheds so much light on it. I feel like he tells you the truth.
- richdougherty 3y agohttp://ymeskhout.substack.com/p/eleven-magic-words-unlocked http://ymeskhout.substack.com/p/eleven-magic-words-unlocked
- 93po 3y agoI found this a little disappointing after so much build up. It's good writing but there was no payoff as to why those words had the impact they did and the reason was effectively just a random choice by a judge
- matthewdgreen 3y agoThat’s the entire point of the piece.
- shermantanktop 3y agoExactly. The machinery of justice is decorated with all kinds of indicators of objectivity and wisdom: precedent, settled law, sentencing guidelines, burdens of proof, law schools filled with eminent scholars. And yet someone has a bad day, or a change of heart, or ate a tasty taco for lunch, or just fell in love, and lives are ruined or saved.
- DANmode 3y ago> Every morning I wonder whether that day has Eleven Magic Words and, if it does, whether I’ll be able to figure them out. And every day that potential scares the shit out of me.
- n3rv 3y agoHello DANmode, I'm trying to touch base from a few months back about a post you replied to about a start-up ISP. I have updated my contact info if you still want to chat.
- morphle 3y agoI'm trying to contact you about a post you replied to about a start-up ISP from a few months back. You can contact me at morphle73 at gmail dot com.
- DANmode 3y ago
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoI find this persons attitude disgusting. They should not be a public defender.
- roenxi 3y agoYes and no. His attitude is a bit unprofessional, but he appears to be putting in an honest attempt at securing the best outcome for his clients. I'm guessing, but it seems reasonable that once criminals start lying there isn't a productive direction to take the conversation.
- yobert 3y agoHow should a public defender behave? He's doing what his job is supposed to be.
- tetris11 3y agoHe should understand the position his clients are in, where one small admission could lead to an entire sentence pinned on them. While he might not like it because it makes his job difficult, he should nonetheless understand it and at least pretend to sympathize on some level.
- croes 3y agoHis attitude doesn't matter if he gets the results
- mft_ 3y agoWhy?
- account-5 3y agoTheir attitude is the result of being a public defender. The result of the people they are trying to defend. They are trying to do the best they can for their client, despite their client. They're allowed to voice their frustration, and even mock the ridiculousness of their clients actions.
- 3y ago
- richrichie 3y agoClearly, this lawyer has not heard of Saul Goodman.
- marmakoide 3y agoThe whole read made me reframe Better Call Saul as a documentary.
- intellectronica 3y ago[flagged]
- spondylosaurus 3y agoThe thing he wrote about Israel-Gaza that devolved into a tirade against American liberals seemed kind of tone-deaf against a backdrop of 30,000 civilian deaths. But also: > it makes me wonder why they want to invest so much of their time and effort in publishing things that are unkind, superficial, and not contributing anything meaningful. Nearly all of the time, money. The outrage machine pays. Looks like OP's associated with Singal, who's the king of stoking various social panics to get eyeballs on his work. Same as the Miles-Cheong playbook. It's the intellectual equivalent of churning out "<X> reacts to <Y>!" videos on YouTube for ad revenue.
- intellectronica 3y ago> The outrage machine pays Thanks for pointing this out. I was assuming the author is publishing this stuff because he just likes sharing his opinions with the world. If there are more concrete incentives that's even worse.
- spondylosaurus 3y agoOh yeah, at one point Glenn Greenwald was making an estimated ~100k per month on Substack.[1] Pretty sure Graham Linehan has raked in some serious cash doing the same. And then of course it's concerning that so many people are willing to throw that much money at wannabe pudits whose insights often boil down to "trans people are scary and bad." (That's still the focus of Linehan's newsletter, apparently! In all these years he's never come up with anything else to say!) [1] https://www.mediaite.com/online/guess-how-much-glenn-greenwald-is-estimated-to-rake-in-each-year-from-substack/ https://www.mediaite.com/online/guess-how-much-glenn-greenwa...
- cuulu 3y ago[flagged]
- pjerem 3y ago> Part of my clients’ clammed-up demeanors rests on a deluded notion that I won’t fight as hard for their cases unless I am infatuated by their innocence. I mean, isn’t it very human ? How to help the client avoid this thinking ? Even more so when you are defending people who have no knowledge of how the system even functions ?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 0xDEADFED5 3y agoisn't the entire premise of this article flawed? the feigned indignity at their clients lying...when it's pretty much required for them to receive any semblance of effective defense: There is a kernel of an exception that is almost not worth mentioning. The Rules of Professional Conduct 3.3 obligates me with the duty of candor. I am not allowed to present evidence that I “know” is false, which encompasses witness testimony. Some jurisdictions make exceptions to this rule for defendants testifying in their criminal trial (correctly, IMO) but not all. So assuming that a client truthfully confesses to me, assuming we go to trial, assuming they decide to testify, and assuming I “know” they’re going to lie, then yes, this could indeed spawn a very awkward situation where I’m forced to withdraw in the middle of proceedings.
- account-5 3y agoI'm curious how a lawyer not being allowed to present as truth known falsehoods at trial is stopping an effective defense? Wouldn't the lawyer knowingly be committing perjury if they lied in court?
- bryanrasmussen 3y agothey said it also applies to defendants testifying, so if question is And then you shot her, correct?! Answer: No I did not shoot her! I never did that. And your lawyer knows it is a lie that you indeed did shoot her, it could be problematic at that point, depending on some jurisdiction. I guess it depends if you think an effective defense should allow the guilty to go free?
- quickthrower2 3y agoEffective defence would allow the guilty to go free. (although “guilty” is a jury verdict so that is impossible but I presume you mean would be found guilty had more evidence prevailed). You can’t have an advocate that draws arbitrary lines at which they are not on your side advocating for you, what would those be? Say someone says to their lawyer they shot the person but really they are covering for their wife even to mthe lawyer. The lawyer then hears them say in court they didn’t shoot (the truth) but the lawyer just knows they are saying something different now to what they said before. It could be that.
- ildjarn 3y ago“Chicanery” nice reference!
- RecycledEle 3y ago[flagged]
- RecycledEle 3y ago[flagged]
- loloquwowndueo 3y agoPlease be sure to post a link or a pdf so we can follow along the complaint’s progress! Yay!
- PhasmaFelis 3y agoWhat exactly is a "disbursement complaint"? Your comment is the #6 result in a Google search, so it's not exactly common, and the other results aren't terribly informative.
- tylerchurch 3y agoLikely a typo for "disbarment".
- PhasmaFelis 3y agoYeah, that makes sense. I suspect the author doesn't have much to worry about, legally speaking, from someone who doesn't know the difference between disbursement and disbarment.
- RecycledEle 3y agoI apologize for my spellchecker and lack of proofreading.
- fallingknife 3y agoWhy would that be his job? If his client had actually touched the gun that would be the opposite of his job because it would produce strong evidence against his client.
- SebFender 3y agoAs House said "People lie".
- Pwntheon 3y agoI believe a more accurate quote is "Everyone lies".
- ProllyInfamous 3y ago"Humans are bullshit generators" — Alan Kay
- narag 3y agoI have some good friends that are lawyers and used to work as public defenders, not sure if they still do. Their experience was not exactly like the author's. Their clients lied to them, yes. But they were very competent, knew every loophole and detail of the legal machinery, having experienced all of it before and shared their knowledge with like-minded individuals while in jail. They were afraid their lawyers weren't up to the task.
- kikimora 3y agoIn my country public attorneys 100% work with police to convict you, not to protect you.
- compumetrika 3y agoBy happenstance I just ran across this by the same author somewhere: https://ymeskhout.substack.com/p/death-of-a-client https://ymeskhout.substack.com/p/death-of-a-client
- tekla 3y agoLying to your lawyer is one of the worst things you can possibly do. If anyone finds out it fucks up EVERYTHING
- D-Coder 3y agoWise old saying: "Three people you should never lie to: your doctor, your accountant, and your attorney."
- rayiner 3y agoIf you catch a public defender in a candid moment, you’ll get a lot of stories like this. What makes the criminal justice system so difficult is that the overwhelming majority of the people that it targets are guilty of what they’re accused of, and scumbags on top of that. When you face that day in and day out, it’s difficult to make yourself keep your eyes open for the innocent ones. I remember an ACLU email in my inbox about the Juwan Wickware case: https://www.aclu.org/news/criminal-law-reform/only-america-16-year-old-locked-rest-his-life https://www.aclu.org/news/criminal-law-reform/only-america-1.... It was trying to drum up outrage about a young man who attacked a pizza delivery driver as part of a coordinated robbery. One of the members of Wickware’s party ended up killing the driver in front of his wife and kids (who were in the car). When I dug up details about the case, I thought “you’d think they’d have picked a more sympathetic case to make their point.” But the fact is that those are few and far between.
- LeftHandPath 3y agoI remember reading about how the TSA was very unsuccessful in catching errors, because they faced a large number of true negatives day in and day out. The alarms barely ever went off, and when they did, it was usually a false positive. The natural human tendency in that situation is to optimize / reduce energy expenditure by letting your guard down and paying less attention. In security, "covert tests" that replicate rare events (like attempting to sneak a gun through a checkpoint) more frequently, seem to increase the chances of success in detecting real threats [0]. If only we could do the same for our legal system. [0]: https://www.cmu.edu/news/stories/archives/2013/november/nov4_reducingscreeningmistakes.html https://www.cmu.edu/news/stories/archives/2013/november/nov4...
- rayiner 3y agoExcept imagine the situation if you faced true positives every day. Working in a court made me do a 180 on my views of the criminal system. We would see the pre-sentence reports, and most of these guys had been engaged in criminal activity since late adolescence. I remember one case where a guy committed crimes in a tri-state area. He ultimately wouldn’t even be prosecuted for most of them after the feds got him.
- unstatusthequo 3y agoAs a lawyer, but not criminal one, none of this surprises me. Some amount of your job is protecting clients from their own misconceptions and things they have convinced themselves of. Those who say this guy is a scum or should be in jail do not have much of a concept of the justice system and what it means to zealous represent a client. Without the truth, you can’t see you blind spots—in fact, your client is making them. To both their and your detriment. I personally love how the writer handled the fingerprints. It allows an immediate inflection point of “let me do the thinking and handle strategy, and stop lying, or find another lawyer.” But, some clients won’t, and those are the ones that end up with an imperfect defense by virtue of them thinking they are being clever or whatever.
- poulsbohemian 3y agoWhen I was in software, my employers lied about their priorities, about what compensation they were willing to extend, about my promotion prospects, etc. When I moved in to consulting, my clients lied to me about their budget, about their requirements, about their goals, about their decision making process. When I moved into real estate, I found the old phrase "buyers are liars" exists for a reason - people don't want to tell you their real budget, they sign an agreement that you are their real estate agent and then you see them at an open house with another agent... I can't help but reflect on all the media on romantic relationships, where so often the root problem is an inability to tell the other person what you really want and need. It's all fascinating stuff because like this author states up front - whoever it might be often would be in a more competitive or better negotiating position if they would just be honest.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoIncentives are almost never totally aligned. Think about it from the other angle. Why as a buyer would I think that you have my rather than your best interest at heart?
- poulsbohemian 3y agoBecause if I don't - or you don't believe I do - then you should fire me and find someone who understands the word "fiduciary."
- metalcrow 3y agoPlenty of people will claim to! But the issue is that you can never be sure, so you want to take extra precautions.
- poulsbohemian 3y agoI mean... bankers, lawyers, doctors, stockbrokers, heck even my kid's school teachers... we're surrounded by people we have to trust at some level are doing their job and seeking to do their best by us. Being overly skeptical does us little good.
- YeGoblynQueenne 3y ago>> Marcel spent our entire first meeting proselytizing his innocence to me. Pedant's corner: proselytizing doesn't mean preaching. It means someone is trying to convert you to their religion. This: "Marcel spent our entire first meeting trying to convert me to his religion his innocence to me." Doesn't parse.
- cxr 3y agoK. By that rule, "Paul was proselytizing to me" doesn't parse, either. ("Paul was trying to convert me to his religion to me.")
- YeGoblynQueenne 3y agoThat's right. "Prosyletise" is the wrong verb to use in that phrase. I think the author wanted to say something like "preaching".
- aspenmayer 3y agoI think a better word choice would be "proclaiming."
- galdosdi 3y agoA pedant's corner deserves a devil's advocate's corner facing it: A little outrageous (in a fun way) but perfectly reasonable choice in making the writing more vivid. It implies that Marcel's theory of innocence is like a religion. That might be an intentional implication whose subtlety escaped you, if the author intended that. Or it could be that the author didn't intend that and just misused the word. I would give the author some benefit of doubt here based on their command of language displayed. "Marcel spent our entire first meeting trying to convert me over to his religion-like faith in his own innocence" Would be a much more appropriate way to render it than the intentionally obtuse way you chose I think I felt strongly enough to comment here simply because I really enjoy seeing fun usages of language like this so I hate to see them smeared as all being accidental screwups, and the only good writing to be really literal writing. (at the same time it is entirely possible this case is unintentional)
- gumby 3y agoI thought this interesting article would be about consultants. The hard part of consulting (not management consulting like McKinsey or KPMG, I mean legitimate technical consulting) is figuring out what the customer actually wants and then finding a way to describe what you plan to do that satisfies what they claim is their need in a way they will understand and be glad for.
- advisedwang 3y agoMaybe I'm just not getting the authors writing style or humour, but it sounds like he doesn't do a good job explaining how the judicial system works to his clients and has the utmost disdain for them.