6 ms·
100 Years of Rent Control in Sweden
- michaelje 3y ago>> critics argue that it reduces the supply of rental apartments and creates housing shortages I don’t follow the logic. It doesn’t destroy the property or take it out of supply, it just means someone might not purchase it specifically to rent it out. Which in turn means less demand buying houses overall, which means more opportunities for people to buy (if they want?)
- graeme 3y agoThis analysis only works if you assume the supply is fixed. If you increase the returns to building ownership then people will build more buildings. Which lowers prices. Capping supply by decreasing the returns leads to less supply, other things equal.
- emmacharp 3y agoWon't lower prices reduce returns to building ownership?
- Jensson 3y agoYes, that is supply and demand. Supply will expand until it is no longer profitable to expand supply.
- emmacharp 3y agoBut for supply to expand, prices must go up, right? They can't go down. That is what I'm trying to understand, since a lot of people here imply that "increase in supply will lower prices".
- sethammons 3y agoIt is called The Law of Supply and Demand. I'm sure there are zounds of articles or videos on it. In the model, the price of a unit will change as you adjust either supply or demand. If there is lots of demand and little supply, the price is high. If there is lots of supply, the demand cannot force the price higher. Assuming the seller wants to sell, they have to compete with other sellers. The more units for sell, the less negotiating power they have because someone more desperate can sell cheaper.
- emmacharp 3y agoI understand supply and demand... but it's a really basic theory. My point is: prices will have to increases for supply to increase as well. Saying that increasing supply will keep prices low makes no sense if right now prices are too low for private interests to build more housing. Supply won't keep prices "low" and certainly not lower than they are now. How would that work? How would they make profit?
- jayski 3y agoIt doesn't destroy the property or take it out of supply. But it also strongly disincentivizes potential investors in building new rental properties. Which makes perfect sense,if you inherited 5million euro would you spend it building rent controlled apartments or put into stocks&bonds?
- dehrmann 3y agoOr in a US scenario, would you rather build rentals in Texas or California?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoCalifornia. It’s the world’s fifth largest economy. I will take some regulatory risk over volatility in Texas. California vacancy rates speak for themselves, there is voracious demand for housing there vs Texas. Texas also has the nation’s 7th highest property tax rate. https://austin.culturemap.com/news/real-estate/texas-property-tax-rate-highest/ https://austin.culturemap.com/news/real-estate/texas-propert...
- jajko 3y ago[flagged]
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIn my experience, it is crucial to avoid human nature, and instead, simply evaluate the math. It either works or it doesn’t, no emotion. Emotion destroys risk adjusted returns, and is harmful to preserving capital.
- jajko 3y agoIf you don't evaluate emotions too, you are missing most of human reality in your equations, like it or not. Stuff will not go as expected.
- 3y ago
- neom 3y agoIn Toronto, as it has been explained to me by some banker types, in 2006 they introduced some pretty strong rent control, and developers just switched from building rentals to building condos, now Toronto has no rental units and a zillion condos that not many people can afford to buy or rent.^ Friend of mine lives in a condo and over half the units in his floor are now managed airbnbs. ^ Couple this situation with no restrictions (in fact encouragement) on foreign buyers for many many years, and you have condos sitting empty, condos rented out for amounts nobody can afford, and condos turning into airbnbs for rich tourists. From what I gather, both Toronto and Vancouver are a real mess because of this.
- voisin 3y ago> friend of mine lives in a condo and over half the units in his floor are now managed airbnbs This should change with the new Anti-AirBNB(Short term rental) rules at municipal, provincial, and federal (CRA) levels.
- infotainment 3y ago…and it ends up being a cascade of new regulations to try and address the unforeseen consequences of the previous regulation. Eventually you end up like San Francisco where no new housing ever gets built ever again and prices are sky-high because of it.
- redserk 3y agoBut go too far in the other direction of not regulating enough, you also end up in the exact same spot.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoDo we? How does that work?
- omnimus 3y ago
- colonwqbang 3y ago1. Few new rentals are built, because it's not profitable 2. Existing rentals are converted to condominiums, because that is more profitable If you can afford to buy a condominium, great. If not, there is always the public housing company. I hope you're not in a hurry though because the typical waiting time to get a rental in Stockholm is 7-11 years. https://bostad.stockholm.se/english/ https://bostad.stockholm.se/english/
- paulddraper 3y agoI refer you to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39655144 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39655144 > there's a queue for rentals, so you register that you want to rent in Stockholm, and then you get put on a list, and then wait two years for it to be your turn Price capping any good -- housing, fuel, food -- by definition produces a shortage. A shortage is when there is more demand than supply at the market price. And artificially lowering the market price increases the amount demanded and reduces the amount supplied.
- tonoto 3y agoI believe that the queue hasn't been as short as "two years" in a couple of decades.
- owisd 3y agoIt only creates a shortage in a world where you have the x-shaped supply and demand curve from econ 101, which doesn’t apply here because the shortage already exists because of zoning/planning laws limiting the construction of new housing. If there wasn’t an existing shortage then no-one would be calling for rent controls. Rent controls just change who the winners and losers are as a result of a given shortage, in Stockholm’s case, existing residents are the winners and new residents are the losers. Existing residents who benefit get to vote to maintain the status quo in municipal elections whereas the people that can’t move there because of rent controls don’t, hence the system is self-sustaining.
- Jensson 3y ago> If there wasn’t an existing shortage then no-one would be calling for rent controls False, rent controls isn't about shortage it is about land lords raising rents for people who already live there and since it is so much work to move people will stay and pay overpriced rent. Then that rent control easily leads to the shortage and extremely high prices for new entrants, but that was never the original goal.
- sethammons 3y agoEdit: wow, flagged for quoting the end of the post. Flagged for quoting or flagged because someone disagreed? tl;dr: rent control bad. > The status of the housing market today is that: - 93% of swedes live in municipalities with a housing shortage, - the share of rental apartments is on a continuous decline (in Stockholm it went from 54% to 36% in the last 30 years), - there are long waiting times for first-hand contracts, - there is a substantial black market and - compared to the condominium market, the rental market is more segregated.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dang 3y agoComments that don't do more than quote from, or summarize, the article, are considered low-quality here. HN threads are supposed to be for curious conversation. That can certainly include quotes from the article, no problem there, but comemnts should be adding something of their own to the conversation and not just be summaries.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fragmede 3y agoThere are a bunch of other details about the Stockholm housing market that I think are relevant. I information is dated, as I did not end up moving there, but circa 2017, condos cost m around $300k, but were not expected to appreciate significantly, unlike the US housing market, so it wouldn't be an investment the same way a condo in SF would be. The other thing is that there's a queue for rentals, so you register that you want to rent in Stockholm, and then you get put on a list, and then wait two years for it to be your turn. which leads to the black market mentioned in the post - if you know somebody, you can skip the line. of course if you buy a place you don't have to wait in line, the rich get to buy their way in. so it's not just about price fixing, but also accessibility to find them in the first place. it's not the same free for all to just jump on craiglist and everyone rushes to apply at the showing.
- 58028641 3y agoRent control just rewards people who are lucky enough to get locked in lower rates. The best way to make rent affordable is to increase supply, then the price will fall.
- emmacharp 3y agoWon't falling prices disincentivize building by lowering possible profits?
- noahtallen 3y agoThere’s a limit to how much price can fall when buildings and land are investments. A house which appreciates underneath tenants will get sold, the new owner will have a higher mortgage payment, and rent will necessarily be higher.
- sapiogram 3y agoHousing isn't bitcoin, it's possible to make more of it. And that's the point: Rent control often ends up disincentivizes construction, making it worse for tenants in the long run.
- mistrial9 3y agorent is an economic version of serfdom. The martial winners and their tax collecting partners run the entire market. Practically zero long term successful people in society are renters, perhaps their children at a young age or other temporary versions. In the modern post-2007 world, capital in massive amounts is travelling to every corner of the West, and also capital from other systems into the West, to own, not rent. The reason to own is to capture the value increase in the market - renters get none of that. Established theories about economic adjustment of rent prices are like tales of why the dogs nose is cold, or why it rains after a certain holiday. Many modern accepted economic theories are repeatedly disproved. Economic theory is half marketing and alcohol IMO. wave from the Coastal West USA
- 3y ago
- tuatoru 3y agoThe older I get, the more libertarian. A landowner should be allowed to build whatever they want[1], irrespective of the objections of neighbors. Viewshafts, sunlight blocking, neighborhood "character", convenants on building attributes like size or materials? Nonsense. 1. Subject to physiological and environmental safeguards like water supply and waste disposal for inhabitants, temperature, humidity and air healthiness, fire and earthquake safety, noise pollution, stormwater management.
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y ago"whatever they want" and then you add an asterisk. Give it a few years, as you get older and more libertarian your asterisk will get smaller and smaller.
- jamesrr39 3y agoSounds great... as long as you are the one doing the building or are living in an area not so densely populated that there is decent distance between houses. Hard to imagine people living in houses in a typical urban area would be happy with such a system, given that neighbours could just build whatever they want near to your house, without any consideration to your wishes. As always, there is a compromise to be found, and so we have planning systems.
- INTPenis 3y agoYou're talking about handing over power to the market, or to the biggest players in the market. We've already seen that it doesn't work, time and time again, to rely on a benevolent billionaire to take care of the workers. Government regulation is absolutely necessary to protect the majority of people.
- permo-w 3y agobesides being older and presumably more likely to own land - based on what logic does this make sense?
- omnimus 3y agoand presumambly more rich then when they were 20 and needed to scrape by and live with others
- jamesrr39 3y agoA few things to note: - it is quite common to sub-let ("andrahandsuthyring"/"renting in second-hand") where you rent from another renter (who in turn has the "first hand" contract with the landlord). This is legal and is quite different from other countries where it is common to see "no sub-letting" on every single rental contract you will ever see. So you do not have to sit in this queue (the queue is for first hand contracts) to live in Stockholm as a renter; but you may end up moving fairly often as second hand contracts are very often time limited. - the quote "93% of swedes live in municipalities with a housing shortage" sounds bad, but what does this exactly mean - how bad are the shortages in each municipality, why is there a shortage, what is the divide of rural vs city municipality shortages. Also, a sizeable chunk of the population lives in Stockholm/Gothenburg/Malmö that are likely some of the key municipalities in this number, so it's likely that much less than 93% of municipalities suffer from a housing shortage. - the rent that a landlord can ask for depends on many things, including the "modernness" of the apartment (both in terms of e.g. putting in a new floor, and in terms of appliances). This has the downside that the landlord may decide to modernise the apartment and now you have to pay (a bit) more rent without having a say in the matter. On the other hand it means that landlords have an incentive to keep the apartments in decent condition and not just let things get old and not bother replacing them. You could see this as a positive or negative, depending on your point of view and financial situation. The article says that the rental market in "Sweden is a big mess", but this of course is quite a generalisation and simplification; and how to tackle housing supply and demand in many (all?) countries is a complex and difficult issue. Regarding demand for accommodation outstripping supply in Stockholm & Gothenburg, this is pretty common to other major cities, pretty much everywhere around the globe. Does rent control help or hinder? The article doesn't compare to other countries going through similar conditions that tried other methods, so it's hard to tell. Some ideas for improving housing supply/demand situation: - Building more (duh!). For individuals with some spare land there is a class of house called an "Attefallshus" you can build up to 30m2 and rent out if you wish. - Better public transport late into the night out into suburbs and to nearby towns. Bike paths and affordable electric bikes/scooters to make living not in the centre and still enjoying the amenities possible. - Investment in/encouraging private sector investment in smaller towns and cities, so the spread of demand for housing due to work is more spread across the country. - Encouraging working remote or hybrid schedules, so employees feel they can live further out.
- emmacharp 3y agoRent control, as flawed as it may be, aims to solve a real socioeconomic problem: people being driven out of their homes and neighbourhoods by rapidly rising costs. Proponents of a free market solution to this problem point out the disincentive effect it has on building new rental housing by depressing possible profits. Getting rid of the price control should encourage building and thus, by increasing supply, keep rental prices low... BUT. Won't profits be kept low then, perpetuating the disincentive to build? I mean, If depressed profit opportunities are the problem, housing cost must rise for them to become enticing. So, as I understand it a free housing market, all other things being equal, cannot provide a solution to the "people being driven out of their homes" problem. But, please, enlighten me if I'm mistaken.
- rakkhi 3y agoAll you need to understand: if rent control or price ceilings worked, why not apply it to clothes or food? I mean food should affordable to all right? This is the problem that we don't teach basic Austrian economics in high school.
- emmacharp 3y agoGoods are not all equals. Housing is not Food. And you did not address the problem. Or maybe you don't think it is a problem. PS: I'm well versed in Austrian economics. But theory, hypotheticals and thought experiments don't represent every real, empirical issue.
- scoofy 3y ago>Rent control, as flawed as it may be, aims to solve a real socioeconomic problem: that I was here first. FTFY. It really boils down to that. Is it a hardship? Sure, but really insidious way that rent controls hurt society is stealing from future generations to benefit folks in the present who already are being given a sweet heart deal. It does so by creating incentives to block any redevelopment. The problem with rent control is that, where it is in effect, it is the primary cause of the exact problem it is trying to solve (but only for incumbents). If we really cared about people's stability, we could simply create a system where maximum rent increases are limited, but the percentage increase goes up every year. E.g. max rent increase year 1: 1%. Year 2: 2%. Year 3: 4%, Year 4: 8%... etc. If the rent ever doesn't double, the percentage increases start over. You get prevention against wild changes in rent, and you've got about a decade before seeing potentially dramatic rent increases, but rents can still get back to market levels given enough time.
- somewhereoutth 3y agoWorth bearing in mind that housing markets are not so much driven by supply and demand, but by propensity to pay by the people who want to live or own property there. SF is expensive because tech salaries are really high. London is expensive because that is where funny money wants to park itself. Lisbon is expensive because tourists can pay a much higher fee per night than locals (because a tourist will only pay that fee for say 2 weeks of the year).
- scoofy 3y ago> - there are long waiting times for first-hand contracts, Lol... yes. Given that Stockholm has 15 year waitlists I think that you could say that the "waiting times" can now be measured in literal lifetimes. If you wanted to spend your 20's in Stockholm... best we can do is get you there in your late 30s, when you settle down. From: https://qz.com/264418/why-its-nearly-impossible-to-rent-an-apartment-in-stockholm https://qz.com/264418/why-its-nearly-impossible-to-rent-an-a... >There are two main factors underlying this phenomenon. First, the city wait list for a new apartment is now 15 years on average, or 7.7 years in the Greater Stockholm region. Second, Stockholmers live alone. Very alone. In fact, Sweden has the lowest number of persons per household in the OECD, with just 1.99 persons per household, compared to the OECD average of 2.63. And in Stockholm, that numbers is 2.1, almost the lowest for any capital in the world, while the average household size comes in at 41 sq m, on par with other countries.