10 ms·
What Luddites can teach us about resisting an automated future
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CamperBob2 3y agoThey can teach us that it's (literally) stupid to try. That's an important lesson.
- kennywinker 3y agoSounds like someone didn't read the article. The actual story of the Luddites is super interesting, and they were fairly successful at staving off automation of their professions, until the state violently intervened - including executing some of the organizers.
- Legend2440 3y agoThat was the right move from the state - especially since the luddites started the violence. Automation has made our lives so much easier and the common man so much wealthier. Imagine if we were still weaving our clothes by hand because master weavers in the 1800s were scared of losing their jobs.
- kennywinker 3y agoSmashing machines that threaten a large group of people's way of life isn't violence that I care about. Why do you care about it? Do you put yourself more in the position of the machine-owner than the machine operator? > Imagine if we were still weaving our clothes by hand because master weavers in the 1800s were scared of losing their jobs. Seems like that might have been a win-win-win. We would have high quality clothing. Weavers would have a high quality of life. Fast fashion, and it's unquantifiably massive environmental impact, wouldn't exist. Where's the downside?
- rmah 3y agoWhile I certainly don't condone the way the English state put down the Luddites, if it had not, it's quite possible that England would not have led the way in industrialization. And that spurred other nations to push too or be left behind. England changed radically during the 1800's as they pushed the industrial envelope.
- arcticbull 3y agoThis is a bit of a misconception. The Luddites were not anti-technology, they were a workers rights movement. Many of them were machine operators who smashed machines to protest for better working conditions, pay, and apprenticeships. > Despite their modern reputation, the original Luddites were neither opposed to technology nor inept at using it. Many were highly skilled machine operators in the textile industry. Nor was the technology they attacked particularly new. Moreover, the idea of smashing machines as a form of industrial protest did not begin or end with them. [edit] > One technology the Luddites commonly attacked was the stocking frame, a knitting machine first developed more than 200 years earlier by an Englishman named William Lee. I'm surprised this article continues to play into these misconceptions. [1] The government violently quashed a labor movement that chose to protest by breaking machines, not an anti-technology movement. Wasn't the first time, and certainly wasn't the last. [1] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/what-the-luddites-really-fought-against-264412/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/what-the-luddites-rea...
- CamperBob2 3y agoFrom a parent post: they were fairly successful at staving off automation of their professions From your post: The Luddites were not anti-technology Both of these statements can't be true. Which one (if either) is correct?
- namaria 3y agoYou're conflating technology usage with automation in the service of the owning class, which are not the same thing.
- huytersd 3y agoIt sounds like you’re confirming the parents point.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kennywinker 3y agoThat progress is inevitable? Idk, if progress was inevitable, why did organizers have to be executed to make progress happen?
- CamperBob2 3y agoProgress is most certainly not "inevitable." It takes intelligence, creativity, and hard work to bring about. Sometimes people try to stop it for selfish reasons. Usually those people can be persuaded to back down peacefully, but sometimes they can't. In those cases, force is necessary. That's what government is for. The trick, of course, is to come up with a government that can be trusted to put down Luddite uprisings and the like without going full Soviet with progressive-sounding concepts like central planning, gulags, and collective farms. It all comes down to the problem of defining just what "progress" means. But in general, when a society can feed, clothe, and shelter more people with fewer resources, that's a good indication that things are moving in the right direction. And that's where technology comes in. Maybe there's a better way forward, but the Luddites were sure as fuck not going to find it.
- kennywinker 3y ago> But in general, when a society can feed, clothe, and shelter more people with fewer resources, that's a good indication that things are moving in the right direction. What does it mean when the a society CAN feed clothe and shelter everyone with ease, but chooses not to in favour of enriching a handful of people? Because that’s the world we live in, and it’s the one the luddites tried to prevent.
- CamperBob2 3y agoI don't need to read an article to tell me that it's stupid to stand in the way of human progress. Maybe you do. If so, other sites beckon. And as others have noted, it's well understood that the Luddites initiated the violence. That makes them the bad guys.
- kennywinker 3y agoInitiated the "violence" by smashing machines that threatened their way of life. That doesn't really fit my definition of violence, sorry.
- Legend2440 3y agoNot only stupid; actively harmful. Luddites are selfish and short-sighted. Imagine if we'd listened to John Henry back in the 1800s - we'd still be wasting our time digging ditches by hand. We'd never be able to build the wonders of the modern world, and we'd all be worse off as a result.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoNo, that could certainly be your takeaway, but that would tell us that you didn't actually pay attention while reviewing history and learned nothing from it.
- hprotagonist 3y agoUnderstood properly, Luddites are an early precursor to what would become the labor movement later in the century, as well as the broader philosophical school of personalism that congealed around the same timeframe. All together they were (and are) voices dissatisfied with the injustices and dehumanization of both unchecked capitalism and socialism both. A central idea is the basic fact that, quoting William Morris, “Nothing should be made by man's labour which is not worth making, or which must be made by labour degrading to the makers.” Or more simply: people first. There is a surprisingly rich vein of thought that relates here from the Vatican from perhaps 30 years after the Luddites, on to the present day: ... This circumstance constitutes in itself the most eloquent "Gospel of work", showing that the basis for determining the value of human work is not primarily the kind of work being done but the fact that the one who is doing it is a person. The sources of the dignity of work are to be sought primarily in the subjective dimension, not in the objective one. Such a concept practically does away with the very basis of the ancient differentiation of people into classes according to the kind of work done. This does not mean that, from the objective point of view, human work cannot and must not be rated and qualified in any way. It only means that the primary basis of the value of work is Man himself, who is its subject. This leads immediately to a very important conclusion of an ethical nature: however true it may be that man is destined for work and called to it, in the first place work is "for man" and not man "for work". Through this conclusion one rightly comes to recognize the pre-eminence of the subjective meaning of work over the objective one. Given this way of understanding things, and presupposing that different sorts of work that people do can have greater or lesser objective value, let us try nevertheless to show that each sort is judged above all by the measure of the dignity of the subject of work, that is to say the person, the individual who carries it out. On the other hand: independently of the work that every man does, and presupposing that this work constitutes a purpose-at times a very demanding one-of his activity, this purpose does not possess a definitive meaning in itself. In fact, in the final analysis it is always man who is the purpose of the work, whatever work it is that is done by man-even if the common scale of values rates it as the merest "service", as the most monotonous even the most alienating work. (laborem execrens, 1981) Pratchett fans may notice that personalist thinking sounds Weatherwaxian, and you'd be right! "There's no grays, only white that's got grubby. I'm surprised you don't know that. And sin, young man, is when you treat people like things. Including yourself. That's what sin is." Or from MLK: "...to use the terminology of the Jewish philosopher Martin Buber, substitutes an "I it" relationship for an "I thou" relationship and ends up relegating persons to the status of things."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- huytersd 3y agoIf a machine can do something a human can, a human should no longer do it.
- hexator 3y agoIf that results in a net decrease in wellbeing, then no.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoThe problem isn't the machine, it's the economic system that allows some dude to capture and hoard the surplus produced by replacing the human with the machine.
- anon-sre-srm 3y agoThe machine and the operator are a superorganism system. Looking to place blame on one or a nebulous external cause is intellectually and morally dishonest because it denies culpability for specific instances of harm.
- brigadier132 3y agoHumans that want to do something impractical / useless can still do it. People do that all the time. See, boats in bottles, digging tunnels, etc.
- Jibbedeyeah 3y ago[dead]
- _mlbt 3y agoThat's not necessarily true. There is something to be said for hand crafted goods. A machine can make me a TV dinner, but it's not the same as what mom used to make. Besides food, furniture, art, leather goods, hand blown glass, and custom made suits also come to mind as things that are possible to be made by machines, but are nicer when humans make them. We are also at the point where autonomous AI-powered drones can conduct warfare. I'm not quite sure that completely removing humans from war is a good thing either.
- freedrull 3y agohttps://youtu.be/GEaCuk1EhH4?si=BY5L6HKYXXGQ9Tg7&t=401 https://youtu.be/GEaCuk1EhH4?si=BY5L6HKYXXGQ9Tg7&t=401
- GaggiX 3y agoWhen a machine does what a human artist does, some consider it theft, even though creativity is literally reworking past experiences (including vast amounts of copyrighted data). I have yet to understand what makes one theft and the other creativity. I feel that the problem is not "theft" but the fear of being replaceable in the workforce.
- twojobsoneboss 3y agoThe problem is your profession and skill set being (roughly) your only means to a livelihood
- GaggiX 3y agoI still don't understand why one should be considered theft and the other creativity, unless you're just agreeing with me.
- twojobsoneboss 3y agoWas mainly agreeing to your final point, no comment on the first :)
- triceratops 3y ago> When a machine does what a human artist does Because a machine is doing it. It's an unfair competition. Enforce that the machine can only work 8h/day, pays taxes, rent, student loans, has to spend 20 years training, can't be owned by humans...I think there would be fewer complaints. > I feel that the problem is not "theft" but the fear of being replaceable in the workforce. Sure that too. If you paid artists regardless of whether they do the job or a machine does it, they'd fear it less. Not zero fear because most people want their work to be useful and have a point, not just pick up a paycheck. But also generally artists know other artists can learn from their work and they factor that into the price they charge for said work. They never expected machines would learn too - it really changes things.
- chewbacha 3y agoIs the one making money the one making the art? The machine doesn’t make money, the owner of the machine does. Thus the owner is committing something closer to theft than creativity. Especially if the machine was trained on copyrighted art. This is very similar to wage theft.
- anon-sre-srm 3y agoNonviolence is the first step because the Unabomber route doesn't work, no matter how insightful about the long-term shift reducing demand for human labor and falling wages captured by an ever-shrinking few capital owners who will ultimately become trillionaires while millions/billions of people live in favelas or become homeless.
- ImHereToVote 3y agoWhy not?
- ChainOfFools 3y agoSure, numbers matter. One unabomber had little to no lasting effect on the world. A million unabombers would have been a very different story.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- moffkalast 3y ago> We could automate menial jobs so people have time to make art and music but apparently we'd rather automate art and music so people have time for menial jobs > Unexpected item in the bagging area It's almost as if the menial jobs are the hardest ones to automate eh? It's been proven again and again that what's second nature to us is impossibly hard for computers and vice versa. We can't math, we can't remember things reliably, the average person can't do art very well and most of us suck as writers too. The more effort something takes for us to learn the more we appreciate it as a society, but unfortunately those are the easiest pickings for automation because we have already worked out the entire process of learning it logically and not by intuition.
- Legend2440 3y agoThey're not, we've automated tons of menial jobs. Nobody digs ditches or chops down trees by hand anymore. The menial jobs we're left with are just the ones that were hard to automate.
- nonrandomstring 3y ago> Nobody digs ditches or chops down trees by hand anymore. I do. I literally cleared out a drainage ditch and chopped wood for my neighbour last week. I did it to keep fit, feel good and get out of the computer room for a while. You should try it.
- CrzyLngPwd 3y agoSame! The positive benefits of doing manual labour outdoors are immeasurable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- moffkalast 3y agoA person using an excavator to dig a ditch and a feller buncher to chop down trees is not true automation imo, it's just using a bigger stick to do more. The worker is still there doing the job, they're not at home painting a canvas.
- _Algernon_ 3y agoIf this automated future automates the process of dismissing popups as are employed by this site, I'll welcome it. Something like 5 popups, including hijacking the back button. Edit: I know ubo exists. This is more a point about this site throwing rocks in glass houses. AI may be one source of our dystopian future, but it is not the only one. This is pollution of the commons that is the open web just as much as (AI) SEO spam is. Have some self awareness for god's sake.
- MichaelRo 3y ago>> If this automated future automates the process of dismissing popups as are employed by this site, I'll welcome it. Amen to that brother. The level of obnoxiousness of this site is hard to match, even in today's dysfunctional web environment. I'll never open a technologyreview.com page again, they should go fuck themselves and die in flames. I also flagged this post, this sort of crap shouldn't make HN front.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoIt takes two to tango. 1. The site operator makes choices. 2. The web user makes choices. (The so-called "tech" companies try to remove the likelihood/ability of the web user to make choices.) As a web user, I choose a browser that has no Javascript engine. Nor does it auto-load resources. Yet I read the full article and saw no popups. The website operator has provided detailed "alt" descriptions for each image.1 The 1.2 MiB statically-compiled browser I'm using does not come from a so-called "tech" company or any of their business partners (Mozilla == Google business partner). As such, no need for uBO. If one takes a position that no web user should change their choices, then IMHO this detracts from any pleas to website operators to change their choices. Further, if one argues against web users changing their choices, e.g., a commenter suggests that all web users should always auto-load all resources in a web page and run all Javascript, then this only provides more incentive for website operators to include lots of commercially-oriented garbage in their pages. Truthfully, there is no need to use AI to avoid popups. There are simpler solutions. 1. If for some reason I want to look at the cartoons I can download each image with a single keystroke and view them without using any Javascript. To read the "alt" descriptions, text-only, no Javascript, no popups, without a browser: tnftp -o'|grep -o "alt=\".*"\" class"|sed "s/alt=./@/;s/.\{13\}$//;s/"/\"/g"|tr @ \\n|fmt' \ https://www.technologyreview.com/2024/02/28/1088262/luddites-resisting-automated-future-technology/amp/
- nickelpro 3y agoI can't believe this is a full-throated, illustrated, pop-culture defense of luddism. Luddism is a caricature of an ideology, a thing you throw at opponents in debate and they are forced to deny. You're not supposed to adopt it as your real, actual ideology lol. Is this a joke? Guess I'll need to find some clogs, sign me up General Ludd.
- Legend2440 3y agoIt is frustrating and disappointing that neo-luddism is making a comeback. I had hoped people had gotten the message by now that automation improves our lives in uncountable ways.
- testacpwoek 3y ago> Luddism is a caricature of an ideology "Luddites [...] protested against manufacturers who used machines in "a fraudulent and deceitful manner" to replace the skilled labour of workers and drive down wages by producing inferior goods". 1 It's not an ideology and it's not anti-progress. Workers losing their jobs to automation was a problem then and is a problem now and we still haven't figured out a good way to deal with this problem. People are right to be concerned about the effects of automation, people are right to be upset when they lose their jobs, and masses of people losing their jobs is terrible and leads to other socio-economic issues. Dismissing those complaints and ignoring those issues because hey, who cares about people that aren't me, living where I don't, when number must go up, right? is the bad ideology here. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite
- nickelpro 3y agoReplacing manual labor with automation is good, actually. Sewing machines put the weavers out of business yes, but more people get to wear shirts. I'm pro-shirts, anti-weavers. Preventing such replacement is definitionally anti-progress
- testacpwoek 3y ago>Preventing such replacement is definitionally anti-progress You can have automation while also ensuring that people do not lose their livelihoods. It's not anti-progress to say that automation must not come at the expense of the lives of the people it is replacing. This wilful misrepresentation of Luddites was bad then, and it's bad now.
- dale_glass 3y agoWell, not a great start. It says "art theft", but right in the panels before you have "allow unrestricted access". Well, if you allowed it, it surely can't be theft. IMO, a big problem on pressing on the theft and copyright angles is that they're trivially, trivially circumvented. Because there exists the public domain, permissive licensing, and permissions. And once enough permission for enough content has been obtained, that's it. Digital content rarely goes away, we have high quality data already, and if it works fine now, tomorrow it'll surely work better. I believe fighting against AI by means of copyright is a dead-end and short-sighted tactic, because it will unavoidably lead to creating models that are 100% legal anyway. First of all from companies like Meta, Microsoft and Google that are big enough to collect the data. Trying to sabotage it is unlikely to work great either. We're talking about computers here, which excel in the mass processing of data. Any transformation is likely detectable, possible to work around, and won't impact already existing content.
- artninja1988 3y agoCopying data isn't stealing in the first place. There is no argument.
- Legend2440 3y agoIt's kinda weird how HN (and reddit) is extremely pro-piracy... until AI does it. I've seen a D&D subreddit that bans AI art but encourages the use of art taken from google images.
- jprete 3y agoIt's not weird. One of them is piracy to play games, watch movies, and post throwaway memes. The other is for training generative models that directly compete with the creators of the pirated works and drop the value of human creative skills to zero. The actual act of piracy is small compared to attempting to devalue and commodify our most human characteristics and abilities.
- 3y ago
- kkfx 3y agoWell... Luddites teach us that: - a large slice of people oppose ANY change, no matter if positive or (obviously) negative to them; - as a result when changes are needed or at least opportune a large slice of people hinder the change and get defeated by history, so the changes happen and tend to be favoring a small cohort while technically it can favor the entire humanity if implemented sglitly differently - after a LARGE amount of them the happened change change a bit to mitigate favoring few since now most people have understood the good part and instead of opposing something already there and useful they push small corrections Long story short... People MUST reason instead of being reactionary, the historic tool to make this happening was mandatory public schooling, but history prove it's not that efficient and so far we have failed to implement something better... PS I imaging I was unable to read the entire article, even with Firefox Reader most of the content does not appear...
- porphyra 3y agoBig shame that the tragic death caused by the wanton disregard for safety by the swashbuckling Uber ATG (now defunct) continues to damage the safety-focused and incredibly cautious Waymo even today. This comic is one of many that can't distinguish between different self driving car companies and depicts a Waymo despite the caption being about Uber. I for one look forward to when humans no longer need to kill each other with cars. Tens of thousands of people die in car accidents every year and Waymo is demonstrably vastly safer. Of course, non-automobile means of transportation, like trains and buses, are even more welcome in addition to self driving cars.