8 ms·
The Berkeley Software Distribution
- pjmlp 3y agoAnd this is why UNIX took over the server world, and C widespread everywhere, had it been a commercial product sold by AT&T at a similar price tag as VMS, MVS and others, history would have been quite different than the one portrayed on the article.
- Animats 3y agoFord Aerospace was one of the first commercial sites of BSD Unix. The licensing was complicated. We had to buy Unix 32V from AT&T first. That transaction got on the path for major corporate documents. AT&T and Ford Motor had a cross-licensing agreement. Eventually, I got a no-cost license agreement embossed with the corporate seals of both the Ford Motor Company and the American Telephone and Telegraph Corporation. Made a copy and taped it onto a VAX. Then I drove up to Berkeley from Palo Alto and Bill Joy gave me a BSD tape. BSD didn't have networking at that point. We bought 3COM's UNET.[1] That was TCP/IP, written by Greg Shaw. $7,300 for a first CPU. $4,300 for each additional CPU. It didn't use "sockets"; you opened a connection by opening a pseudo-device. UNET itself was in user space, talking to the other end of those pseudo-devices. Once we got that going, we had it on VAX machines, some PDP-11 machines, and some Zilog Z8000 machines. (The Zilog Z8000 was roughly similar to a PDP-11) All of which, along with some other weird machines including a Symbolics LISP machine, eventually interoperated. We had some of Dave Mills' Fuzzballs as routers [2], and a long-haul link to another Ford location that connected to the ARPANET. Links included 10Mb/s Ethernet, a DEC device called a DMC that used triaxial coax cables, and serial lines running SLIP. A dedicated 9600 baud serial synchronous line to Detroit was a big expense. My work in congestion control came from making all this play well together. These early TCP/IP implementations did not play well with others. Network interoperability is assumed now, but it was a new, strange idea back then, in an era when each major computer maker had their own networking protocols. UNET as delivered was intended to talk only to other UNET nodes. I had to write UDP and ICMP, and do a major rewrite on TCP. When BSD got networking, it was initially intended to talk only over Ethernet, to other BSD implementations. When 4.3BSD came out, it would only talk to some other implementations during alternate 4 hour intervals. I had to fix the sequence number arithmetic, which wrapped incorrectly. And finally, it all worked. For a few years, it was said of the TCP/IP Internet that it took "too many PhDs per packet." One day, on the Stanford campus, I saw a big guy with a tool belt carrying an Ethernet bridge (a sizable box in those days) under his arm, and thought, this is finally a working technology. [1] https://archive.org/details/bitsavers_3Com3ComUN_1019199/page/n15/mode/2up?view=theater https://archive.org/details/bitsavers_3Com3ComUN_1019199/pag... [2] https://eecs.engin.umich.edu/stories/remembering-alum-david-mills-who-brought-the-internet-into-perfect-time https://eecs.engin.umich.edu/stories/remembering-alum-david-...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hcfman 3y agoBeautiful bit of history. I remember quite a lot of it being old. Nice work by the author. Without people taking the time to write things like this up history gets lost. Years ago I build one of the first local search engines for the Netherlands called Search.NL. I am indebted to the writer of the only page that refers to this history any more here: https://www.eindhovenfotos.nl/1/ilse.nl.html#news1-y8 https://www.eindhovenfotos.nl/1/ilse.nl.html#news1-y8
- tingletech 3y ago> The first copy we know to make it out of Berkeley was to Tom Ferrin at UCSF on the 9th of March in 1978. The license was signed on the 13th, the media was an 800 bpi tape, and on the tape was the “Unix Pascal system” and the “Ex text editor.” UCSF and UCB (as well as all the UC campuses and enterprises) are technically the same legal entity, incorporated by article 9 section 9 of the California constitution. Strange that they signed a license, when I worked for the regents we called them MOUs if it was a "contract" with another part of ourselves. When I started working for UCSD and found out we were licensing BSDi for some boxes I was sort of confused, like why don't we get that for free?
- alberth 3y ago> MOUs MOU = Memo of Understanding? (Which are typically non-binding but formalized acknowledgement of intent)
- tingletech 3y agoyes, we were told we could not contract with ourselves, so we had to do memorandums of understanding when we had revenue or other agreements between units. We also had a policy to follow state law (which does not apply to UC unless UC is specifically mentioned in the law).
- actionfromafar 3y agoIs UC federal land or something?!
- fredoralive 3y agoAs noted above, the University of California is given special status by a section of California constitution, so it has special status through that. It's presumably clauses like that fact it's governed by the Regents "...subject only to such legislative control as may be necessary to insure the security of its funds and compliance with the terms of the endowments of the university..." that mean it isn't normally affected by new laws. (https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CONS§ionNum=SEC.%209.&article=IX https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...)
- retrac 3y agoThere's an alternate universe, almost identical to our own, where BSD 4.4 was released slightly earlier, its legal status was not ambiguous, it got ported to the 386 in '90, Linus never bothered to write Linux, and every machine from smartphone to server runs some version of BSD.
- panick21_ 3y agoThere is an alternative universe where Scott G. McNealy has a backbone and doesn't stop participating in BSD development. Sun almost up-streamed NeWS, and they did a ton of other stuff that should have continue to go into BSD. Driven by Sun as the primary BSD advocate, BSD would have dominated being both open and with a powerful backer. Sun really had the largest unix mind-share and most application were targeted at Sun workstations. Eventually this resulted in the Unix wars because lots of people were afraid of Sun/AT&T. Sun could have avoid that and simply made itself and BSD the standard. If that standard was open, there wouldn't have formed a powerful alliance against them. AT&T would still have tried but non-open alliance lead by AT&T wouldn't work out well. But because of a bunch of lawyers and eventually one bad quarter, Sun went full out proprietary and joined itself to AT&T.
- jeff_vader 3y agoAnd we're all happy CVS users.
- panick21_ 3y agoUnlikely. Sun had NSElite in the 80s. BitKeeper and Teamware were available in the 90s. Somebody would make an open source version at some point.
- jmcqk6 3y agoI'm not an expert, but I'm pretty sure there is no universe where that is true.
- drewg123 3y agoWe'd all be happy perforce users :) (For a long time, before git and subversion, even though the official freebsd repo was in CVS, a lot of development happened in perforce)
- drewg123 3y agoKirk McKusick gives a great ~45min talk called the history of BSD at conferences. There are essentially 3 versions (one about the lawsuit, one about the TCP wars with BBN, and one about the early history), and he asks the audience to vote on which version they want to hear. Search for Kirk McKusick history of BSD on YouTube, or come to a BSD conference to hear it. And I'd recommend coming to a conference, just so you can talk to Kirk. He's one of the most down to earth, friendly and just generally nice luminaries I've ever talked to in person.
- panick21_ 3y agoBuying those lectures from him is quite a journey. The most difficult internet sale I have ever made. Very manual process. But I wanted to make sure he gets some money, even if the talks are mostly online anyway.
- microtherion 3y agoYes, I have fond memories of the one or two times I heard him as well. One bit I remember from his presentation was his parable of BSD as the building of a road, with Bill Joy (IIRC) hacking a path through the jungle with a machete, someone else driving a bulldozer along that path, somebody pouring asphalt, somebody adding streetlights, and finally somebody (I seem to recall it was Sam Leffler) painting the streetlights.
- steve1977 3y agoI’ve actually bought a recording of these talks something like 20 years ago. It was either on DVD or maybe even VHS.
- drewg123 3y agoOh! I forgot he still sells those. Its now offered as a downloadable video file as well. See https://www.mckusick.com/history/videoorderform.html https://www.mckusick.com/history/videoorderform.html
- gentle 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TomMasz 3y agoI recall the brouhaha that erupted around Sun's move from a BSD foundation to System V. I've always felt it was a downgrade.
- panick21_ 3y agoThis was the moment many former Sun people identify as the 'death of original Sun'. Sun wanted to make SMP work, so Solaris was a huge amount of work and was incredibly buggy for a long time. Sun effectively lost a huge amount of time going threw this transition and it took years to be back to the same amount of stability. Bryan Cantril talkes about this in LISA11 - Fork Yeah! The Rise and Development of illumos [1] But not everybody agree, if you read 'Sunburst: The Ascent of Sun Microsystems' that was written in 1991, they are very pro the AT&T deal and explicitly call out the BSD people as 'anti-Standard' and thus anti-Sun. The real difference there is the argument about what a Standard is. Their approach is basically Unix belongs to AT&T and therefore they are the standard. While the (in my opinion) more correct argument was that BSD/Sun had the most software and they were the defacto standard and being more open, continuing be the standard was what Sun should have done. Another incredibly important battle was over X vs NeWS. NeWS was arguably technically superior. There is a nice talk by James Gosling about it [2]. It still had technical problems but it would have been a great base to build off. But because some companies, lead by Dec made X open(ish) and many embraced it, X became 'the standard' and thus many at Sun basically said 'Well X is the standard, so therefore we have to switch to X'. Instead of saying, lets make NeWS open and try to be the Standard. The Sun transition also hurt their costumers. In "LIFE UNDER THE SUN: My 20-Year Journey at Sun Microsystems" David Yen mentions costumers bitterly complaining about it. They made the transition very, very aggressively basically telling costumers to STFU. David Yen loved the aggressive approach because he was selling massive SMP servers that need Solaris. SMP servers where clearly where Sun saw the future. If Sun had embraced BSD, open sourced NeWS and made the SMP transition in the open, Unix might have gone into the 90s being an unstable juggernaut. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4zG0uecYSMA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4zG0uecYSMA
- freeremote 3y agoI was a Solaris admin in those days. No one was impressed with the changes. I still, even after all these years, recall the BSD command differences. For whatever reason, I still sometimes enter a random BSDism command on the Linux command line and then say, "Ooops, wrong command. I cannot believe I did that." Especially since I've run Debian stable for the better part of 20 years on and off with attempts to like other distros like Fedora or Arch. Still working in IT closing in on 60 years of age. Still love being a sysadmin. Still love writing shell scripts and automating things.
- Taniwha 3y agoOne minor niggle here: NFS was released by Sun in '89 (used internally before that), couldn't have been released in 4.2 in '84
- williamDafoe 3y agoThe sword of damacles explanation of BSDi's ending is utter bullshit in this article. BSDi knew they were in direct competition with RedHat in the late 1990s. The President, Rob Kolstad, ran a very lean operation with only about 20 employees. Red Hat managed to IPO and was heavily capitalized. Some BSDi employees and one in particular, argued for an IPO and the particular guy from MIT guaranteed that with an IPO everyone would be rich in one year. The palace revolt worked, the MIT guy took over, Rob Kolstad was deposed, and the MIT guy bankrupted the company in just 1 year (record time). The pieces were sold off to Wind River, which was later absorbed into VxWorks, which finally cancelled development a few years later, and that was the end of BSD/OS or BSDi.
- brlcad 3y agoI have the sources to "JHU UNIX" which were a direct fork of one of the earliest BSD's, though I don't recall hearing which. They were recovered off data tapes (and are still in an arcane raw binary format) from the late 70's / very early 80's.
- mprovost 3y agoCool! It might be worth getting in touch with Diomidis Spinellis who runs the Unix History Repository and see if they're interested in adding them. https://github.com/dspinellis/unix-history-repo https://github.com/dspinellis/unix-history-repo