5 ms·
A 'cowboy ski town' where high earners can't afford a home faces housing battle
- recursivedoubts 3y agoI'm in a mountain ski town, same dynamic. If you want housing prices to come down for real you are gonna have to pop The Everything Bubble. Moderately not insane interest rates haven't done that yet. Maybe this time it's different.
- Manuel_D 3y agoInterest rates aren't the issue. Many of these are all cash buyers as per the article. The issue is supply and demand. Building lots more housing in ski towns is what will bring prices down.
- dog_boxer72 3y agoThe issue is wealth inequality - DINK households with 2 six figure incomes massively dwarf what’s possible for a regular American family (one breadwinner, 2.4 kids) - they’re the top 5% which isn’t Elon Musk territory, but as a group it’s distorting housing way more than a tiny amount of billionaires would Fwiw I don’t think there’s anything inherently “wrong” with it, the market is a brutal mistress
- Manuel_D 3y agoAnd ultimately, the only way to let the regular American family buy a house is to build more houses. A desirable location, low density, and low cost. You get to pick two.
- recursivedoubts 3y agoThat cash came from somewhere, and that somewhere is inflated asset values, and those asset values are from comically low interest rates for a decade.
- Manuel_D 3y agoNo, real value goes up. There isn't a fixed pie of value that never changes. The houses are expensive, because a lot of people want them and there aren't enough to satisfy demand.
- recursivedoubts 3y agoWhen everything is expensive that isn't value going up, that's the value of money going down. That's not to say that there aren't shifts in preferences that cause relative valuation changes as well, obviously covid/remote work changed the situation wrt housing to an extent. But that shift is also superimposed on top of The Everything Bubble caused by a decade+ of negative real rates, which has dramatically inflated asssets relative to incomes, concentrating wealth and allowing second-home buyers, investors, etc to buy up these smaller towns. Let's watch and see if the market ever comes down and, if it does, if mountain town housing prices also come down. That will confirm or disprove my theory.
- Manuel_D 3y agoEven without inflation, the real value of assets increases. Economies are not zero sum. The mountain town prices aren't going to come down until more houses are built (or other scenarios, like climate change reducing snowfall and closing the ski resort).
- recursivedoubts 3y agoI don't know why you keep focusing on zero-sum here. My claim is that a large component of mountain-town value increases is driven by second home, investor and semi-retirement of wealthy people driven by cheap credit and, now, by the asset gains of that cheap credit. There has been an inflationary expansion, the early receivers of that inflation (myself included) then can put that money into mountain towns. That doesn't mean that there aren't other factors, just that I believe it to be the major one. There are others, such as people fleeing chaos in the large western cities, remote work, etc. And, as you say, we can expect some increase in the land value of these places over time as well. If the market ever crashes and mountain west towns stay relatively expensive, I will be shown to be wrong. We'll see.
- qazxcvbnmlp 3y agoI’m also in a mountain ski town (same one as you after some profile snooping). Housing prices aren’t going to come down for a while, it’s gone from a happy little remote town to a nice-place-to-be.
- bradgranath 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jmclnx 3y agoThat seems to be a place that can be very prone to bubbles. Yes housing costs are very high almost everywhere, and rent even worse. But Steamboat seems to only survive on the Tourism Industry. I think a place like Steamboat will have a big crash some day, so best people stay clear, which is happening. If I lived there and owned a house, I would sell and move elsewhere, especially if fully paid off. $1 million can help you a lot.
- ghaff 3y agoAnecdotally, I've heard from friends that sort of thing happens with some regularity. A (especially second home) ski condo is one of the most optional large assets you can imagine and even more so if it's really inflated in price. (A lot of people probably also grow out of this sort of thing over time.) As an aside, a second home is something that's never appealed to me. Neither the effort, the expense, nor the ties to a specific location seem like great tradeoffs for most people.
- derefr 3y agoSo, something I don't get: why would a home have any value at all, if it's located somewhere with no service economy, no schools, no hospitals, no firefighters, no sanitation workers, etc (because none of the people powering those services can afford to live there)? People living there wouldn't be able to: get groceries, get a haircut, see a movie, get prescriptions filled, eat out or go out for drinks, visit (maintained) parks, use (maintained) sporting areas like baseball diamonds or tennis courts... etc. At that point — other than maybe having electricity and running water — isn't living in a home there effectively the same as squatting in an abandoned home in a depopulated area?
- FredPret 3y agoYou can still winter there for a short stretch
- karaterobot 3y agoI don't see where in the article they say there aren't schools, hospitals, etc. in town. I think the idea is that people who have jobs there but can't afford to buy homes would have to commute in from neighboring communities—sometimes a long way.
- Shog9 3y agoYep. If you drive around through any of these towns, upon leaving in any direction you'll encounter a mobile home park down the road just a ways, tucked into a valley or next to a railroad, somewhere the views aren't as valuable and the roads aren't as good. Inexpensive manufactured housing or RVs on tiny lots (that still cost too much to rent for what you get). That's where you'll live if you work most jobs in the town, if you're lucky; otherwise, you'll commute a lot further - potentially over dangerous mountain roads in icy conditions. Better hope I70 stays open...
- Manuel_D 3y agoServices like sanitation still exist, they're staffed by people who live out of town. Like much of San Francisco's services. Houses are expensive because the desire to live near a good skiing mountain is high. That, and the potential to rent it out.
- TulliusCicero 3y ago> dividing communities over how to rein in housing costs. Have they tried letting people, y'know, make more housing? Almost invariably, the answer is no. > When it comes to building more housing, residents have mounted opposition to some efforts over concerns about everything from traffic congestion to wildlife migration patterns. ...and there it is. > “Yes, we need affordable housing, no question,” Engelken said. “It needs to be smaller to start with” Jesus Christ. "Yes we need more housing, but how about not that much more housing? Does that work?" NIMBY mentality in the US is a disease.
- FredPret 3y agoWe have the same problem here in Canada. There should be a higher-level authority deciding how much municipalities should zone since housing is now a national problem.
- thefaux 3y agoEveryone has a bit of NIMBY in them. I don't think it's a useful or constructive pejorative at this point. No doubt we need more housing, but not every growth plan is a good one and perhaps we'd get closer if we stopped the name calling.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoNo. A huge part of the problem is that people act like it's just normal to fight new housing in a housing crisis, that you're simply entitled to stop people from building houses in the city where you live. Obviously not every development is good -- I don't want to be tearing up delicate wetlands for condos -- but if the problem is just "there'll be more traffic" or "we need more infrastructure", then we need to be asking how to support more people, not if we should support more people. Normalizing NIMBYism is what got us into this situation into the first place.
- Shog9 3y agoThis. It didn't start with the pandemic or WFH - in the two decades I spent in Colorado, I heard similar stories from just about everyone I met who lived (or more often, used to live) in the various ski towns. I loved living in Colorado, but during the pandemic took the opportunity to sell and move out - it was clear to me that things weren't going to get better any time soon. And for folks talking about a "crash" or "correction" - that happened to some extent after 2008; it mostly just resulted in big investors snapping up a lot of property at a discount and holding onto it until they could sell at a profit - didn't really help at all for the most housing-constrained areas.
- chizhik-pyzhik 3y ago1. Desirable place has a lot of people that want to live there. 2. Residents refuse to change zoning laws, so very little new housing can be built. 3. Demand exceeds supply, so the prices go up. State governments need to pass laws forcing cities to allow housing, or this will continue to just get worse and worse.
- taberiand 3y agoIs more people living in that area beneficial to society?
- Manuel_D 3y agoLower housing cost is generally beneficial to society. Making activities like skiing less exclusive and more accessible is also a benefit. One could argue that skiing doesn't directly benefit society. But by that logic there's not much benefit to art, entertainment, parks, and essentially anything other than food, housing, and healthcare.
- Petersipoi 3y agoSki resorts are already way overcrowded, despite the insane lift prices. How is making it more accessible going to help anything? It's already at maximum capacity.
- throwitaway222 3y agoBuild more mountains, duh! /s
- Manuel_D 3y agoIf they really were at maximum capacity, then ticket sales would drop. But that's not happening.
- Petersipoi 3y ago
- johnrob 3y agoAny area that wealthy people are attracted to pretty much has this problem now. It’s the same exact story playing out in each locale. The core issue is important so on one hand I’m happy to see press coverage, but on the other it’s literally the same article that I’ve now read over 100 times. Will we ever do anything about it??
- paulddraper 3y agoNothing to be done
- arjvik 3y agoWhat's a good ski town to retire in?
- dboreham 3y agoBozeman?
- ghaff 3y agoAlthough it has it's downsides, Salt Lake City? There are a bunch of smaller ski towns but I'm not sure most of them would really appeal to me long-term.
- mynameisnoone 3y agoIf you can tolerate a state run by Mormons, SLC is chill and active. I'd sooner live in Denver. I went through Colorado Springs but it had California-like homeless issues.
- ghaff 3y agoI think I would too (or Boulder). But SLC is very close to probably better world-class skiing.
- viraptor 3y agoFew of them. As you get older, if you want good medical care, you likely want to see the same doctor at a well equipped facility. Ski towns can rarely provide those (mostly rotating staff, just essentials, potentially costly air transport if you need to get something non-trivial)
- corford 3y agoSomeone should familiarise the local residents with Gary Stevenson's work: https://youtube.com/@garyseconomics https://youtube.com/@garyseconomics (https://twitter.com/garyseconomics https://twitter.com/garyseconomics)
- tiffanyh 3y agoYellowstone This is a storyline in Yellowstone TV show. That ski destinations price out locals, due to million dollar vacation homes & tourists. You see this happen at Telluride, Aspen, Jackson Hole, etc.
- marklubi 3y agoWould hardly call Steamboat a ‘cowboy ski town’. They’ve had speed limit signs listed in both MPH and KPH since the mid 90’s.
- Octokiddie 3y agoThis kind of gross imbalance is self-correcting. Those who have been through a few of these cycles know the warning signs. Those who don't get an expensive lesson at the school of hard knocks.
- listenallyall 3y agoThe article fails to even mention the IKON pass effect, which (along with Epic Pass) has massively boosted ski-town demand specifically, on top of the Covid phenomenon that increased desirability of all kinds of resort and recreational areas. By offering unlimited skiing at Steamboat and dozens of additional resorts, IKON (and Epic) has increased frequency of ski trips which in turn increases demand for lodging, which benefits Alterra and Vail because they own the most desirable real estate assets. The pricing-out of average people from ski towns was slowly happening for decades, but it accelerated greatly in the past few years.
- yawgmoth 3y agoThis is why I am against folks in San Francisco making more than folks in Ann Arbor for the same job. When the pandemic hit, high earners moved in and drove costs up in our local market. We lose twice.
- mynameisnoone 3y agoAll high income earners beyond a certain amount (on a graduated scale) should be required to found a new city and pay much higher taxes. Also needed: UBI because around a hundred million Americans are being shut out and left behind.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoSite not responding. https://web.archive.org/web/20240303131135if_/https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/economics/cowboy-ski-town-high-earners-cant-afford-home-faces-housing-battle-rcna140429 https://web.archive.org/web/20240303131135if_/https://www.nb...
- mynameisnoone 3y agoIt's the SF effect that creates expensive hipster ghettos of dumb money chasing stupid money. Just move anywhere else with good climate, low pollution, good walkability/short commutes, relatively low risks, and access to major medical.
- uslic001 3y agoI have been going to Steamboat since 1981. I had a friend who bought a townhome there in the late 1980's for 400K. He sold it in the early 90's for a small profit. Now that townhome is worth 4 million. I have two friend from college that still live in the area but can't afford to live in Steamboat. They live 30 minutes away but the cost of living is still very high.
- angmarsbane 3y agoWhy isn’t the solution to reduce the demand for select housing stock, stating that it can only be sold or rented to people who have an on-site job in the town?