3 ms·
Personally, I do not find that long names, brackets and general verbosity helps _me_ with "readability". The less concise it looks the less likely I am to read
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
Personally, I do not find that long names, brackets and general verbosity helps _me_ with "readability". The less concise it looks the less likely I am to read it. And if there is too much to read, I will definitely not read it. Just because someone has entertained themselves by writing lots of verbose code does not mean I want to read it. Skimming it and searching through numerous directories of source code files is not the same thing as actually reading each file from beginning to end.
As it happens, I find terse languages, and "code golf", as more approachable and thus readbale. It is lower volume, more concise and compact. Generally, I can read all of it. I use an ASCII-based array language that uses brackets: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K_(programming_language) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K_(programming_language)
I am not sure why I prefer writing less code as opposed to writing more code. Maybe I just dislike typing. In any case, I am thankful these languages exist. For both reading and writing.
To insinuate that no one takes array languages seriously would of course be wrong, as one can see from the above Wikipedia page.
The question I have is why anyone who prefers popular verbose languages would care about the discussion of unpopular array languages on HN. Why even bother to comment and complain. If array languages are incomprehensible and unpopular, then why pay any attention to them. Appeals for verbosity over terseness do not seem to be working for the vast majority of Javascript I see in webpages from the larger so-called "tech" companies running the most popular websites.
Array languages are very easy to avoid. Imagine trying to avoid Python. Not easy (speaking from experience).
Telling array language authors to make their languages more verbose is like telling Bob Dylan to play what people want to hear and only then will he have a "tiny chance of being heard and taken seriously".
(Also wondering if commenter meant braces not brackets.)
- tomcam 3y ago> Personally, I do not find that long names, brackets and general verbosity helps _me_ with "readability". Thank you, 1vuio0pswjnm7
- NooneAtAll3 3y ago> Personally, I do not find that long names, brackets and general verbosity helps _me_ with "readability". The less concise it looks the less likely I am to read it. And if there is too much to read, I will definitely not read it. in some sense it is a "thesaurus vs ancient egyptian" argument I can totally understand that it would be infinitely nicer to build Stargate and go fight Goa'uld or inherit knowldge of the galaxy-spanning Asgard - but it's the events of "Yes, Minister" that actually do happen in our, real, world > As it happens, I find terse languages, and "code golf", as more approachable and thus readbale. It is lower volume, more concise and compact. Generally, I can read all of it. I use an ASCII-based array language that uses brackets: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K_(programming_language) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K_(programming_language) "A case of MUMPS" (https://thedailywtf.com/articles/A_Case_of_the_MUMPS https://thedailywtf.com/articles/A_Case_of_the_MUMPS) is on The Daily WTF. "WTF" is exactly the default behaviour of people encountering these codegolf-ed langs > The question I have is why anyone who prefers popular verbose languages would care about the discussion of unpopular array languages on HN. Why even bother to comment and complain. you're the seller, I'm the buyer array enthusiasts advertise their product, listing advantages - we reply with "my problems with it are this, this and this. How can you fix it?". Yes I'm interested. No, I don't agree that my concerns are empty. > (Also wondering if commenter meant braces not brackets.) technically, I meant parenthesis. But nowadays, and especially in programming world, all 3 are synonyms and you just add [curly/round/square] in front brackets are just easiest of the 3 for me to recall
- jimbokun 3y agoDylan did play what many people wanted to hear. He was an incredibly successful and popular artist.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoBob Dylan played what people wanted to hear. True or false. https://pitchfork.com/thepitch/855-dylan-goes-electric-newport-seeger-dylan-and-the-night-that-split-the-sixties/ https://pitchfork.com/thepitch/855-dylan-goes-electric-newpo... "In 1965 Dylan was only 24 years old, but he had already gone through a lot of changes and been criticized and attacked for each of them. His first performances as a teenage rock'n'roller were met with laughter and jeers. When he turned to folk music, the high school girlfriend who had shared his early passions was troubled, asking why he'd given up "the hard blues stuff." When he turned from singing traditional folk songs to writing his own material, old supporters accused him of becoming "melodramatic and maudlin"-one, stumbling across a typescript of "The Times They Are a-Changin", demanded, "What is this shit?" When he turned from sharp topical lyrics to introspective poetic explorations, followers who had hailed him as the voice of a generation lamented that he was abandoning his true path and "wasting our precious time." When he added an electric band, he was booed around the world by anguished devotees, one famously shouting "Judas!"" https://www.mojo4music.com/articles/stories/robbie-robertson-interviewed/ https://www.mojo4music.com/articles/stories/robbie-robertson... "We got booed all over North America, Australia, Europe, and people were saying this isn't working and we kept on and Bob didn't budge. We got to a place where we would listen to these tapes and say, "You know what? They're wrong. And we're right." Eight years later, we do a tour, the [1974] Dylan/Band tour, we play the same way, same intensity and everybody says, "Wow, that was amazing." The world came around - we didn't change a note. The obvious thing we learned - that everybody learned - was there was a new way of songwriting. There was a much more colourful, descriptive, humorous, outrageous thrill ride of wordplay. We hadn't seen this before - this was breaking some big rules. I remember saying to Bob one time, "Maybe there's too many verses in this" (laughs), and he said, "There probably are, but that's what I was thinking about when I wrote it." His spirit was on fire, and he was knocking down the boundaries that had been built up around music. It excited me to be part of this revolution." https://www.nytimes.com/1998/10/11/arts/music-when-dylan-s-genius-burned-brightest.html https://www.nytimes.com/1998/10/11/arts/music-when-dylan-s-g... "BUT Dylan was too smart and too stubborn to let hidebound listeners prevent him from making the best music of his career. The hecklers were wrong about the music, as most of them would probably admit now." https://ultimateclassicrock.com/bob-dylan-goes-electric-newport/ https://ultimateclassicrock.com/bob-dylan-goes-electric-newp... "The New York Times' Robert Shelton, whose 1961 review of a Dylan concert is considered to have launched Dylan's career, wrote, "The young audience's displeasure was manifested at the end of most of the numbers, by booing and shouts of `we want the old Dylan.' The young star plowed valiantly on, with the sort of coolness he has rarely displayed on stage." Calling the crowd "rude," "immature" and "noisy young boors," [Dylan] couldn't help note the positive reaction given to "Like a Rolling Stone," which by now was a hit. "Evidently the hostility extends only toward things with which they aren't familiar," he sneered. [Hostility toward things with which they arent't familiar. Like HN commenters' hostility toward array languages.] This song-and-dance with his audience continued over the course of the next year." http://www.goldminemag.com:80/article/bob-dylan-gets-religion-in-the-gospel-years-part-3 http://www.goldminemag.com:80/article/bob-dylan-gets-religio... "The show opened with as excitedly noisy a crowd as Dylan had ever faced, 2,300 souls jammed in, and all with their own loudly exclaimed wish list of favorite Dylan songs and expectations. Fourteen years earlier, you could imagine the 1965 Newport Folk Festival buzzing with similar anticipation and excitement ... and reacting with similar bemusement as the show took shape. Only it was not the sacrilegious explosion of electricity that left the audience reeling in its seats. As he led the band through a 19-song set, Dylan did not play a single song that predated his religious conversion. Even the encore was uncharted territory. "Blessed Is The Name Of The Lord" and "Pressing On" were both new songs, and though the former rocked and the latter soothed, the crowd was in no mood to be impressed. Afterwards, Dylan congratulated himself on not playing a single song he'd ever performed onstage in the past, and when the subject of his fans' expectations was broached, he simply shrugged. "Oh, yeah, that's right. They want the old stuff." Pittsburgh's KDKA TV station even filmed the fans' exodus, with one disgruntled ticket-holder snapping to the cameraman, "He stinks. He's the worst. He's bad. It's a waste." Dylan's audience was furious. Shocked. Cheated. It was Newport all over again, or maybe the Manchester Free Trade Hall, later on in that so-controversial 1965 tour, when the bootlegger's tape was suddenly interrupted by a bellow of "Judas!""