7 ms·
Meta Has Had Enough of Australia's Link Tax Shakedown; Will Not Renew Any Deals
- xvector 3y agoFinally, at least one company has the balls to stand up to the ridiculous rent seeking from Australia, France, Canada. Hope Google follows.
- manuelabeledo 3y agoLet's say that all websites decide that they deserve a payout if they are linked by Facebook. Who would be hurt the most?
- givemeethekeys 3y agoLet's say, I share a link to a website that wants to get paid on my Facebook. Meta won't crawl it, since they don't want to pay. So, the link will show up, but without a preview. Any one who clicks on the link will visit the website first, potentially removing them from Facebook for a little while. Alternatively, Meta may decide the demote links without previews. Both of these scenarios reduce active users, and time spent by users on the website. Fewer engagement minutes means fewer opportunities to show them ads. On the other hand, those users will end up seeing more ads on the news website.
- yashg 3y agoOr Meta can simply stop parsing such links and not even show a hyperlink. If users want to visit the link, they have to copy it manually and paste it in address bar. Funny thing, many users don't even know they can paste links in address bar. They use Google as address bar. I have seen people type the whole domain name including the TLD in Google to get to websites. Now imagine Google also stops redirecting to such links that demand payment for sending them traffic.
- givemeethekeys 3y agoMight be possible for browsers to recognize words that look like links to get around that.
- ByQuyzzy 3y agoNobody uses Facebook any more for news, X.com is where news breaks. So this makes sense.
- paddez 3y agoResearch* shows that Twitter only accounts for a fraction of traffic that Facebook/Meta directs to News media. * https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/journalism-media-and-technology-trends-and-predictions-2024 https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/journalism-media-...
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoBut if you go by feels instead of data, Twitter is winning. That's what's important in 2020s discourse.
- ByQuyzzy 3y ago>Reuters has investigated their business and discovered, through very well endowed "research," that Twitter isn't news. I never said that people click THROUGH to news sites from Twitter. But just that, that's where they get their news.
- shiroiushi 3y agoI thought people got their news from TikTok these days. (Or should I call it "news"?)
- justinclift 3y agoDunno if I buy that personally. I don't use X/Twitter at all any more (lost interest prior to Elon buying it), and I only see it pop up in links on HN. Now that Nitter.net has gone away (to see replies on X/Twitter), I don't even bother clicking on the Twitter stories any more.
- simonblack 3y agoHmm. I don't use FaceBook or X. The 'news' that appears on FaceBook or X isn't.
- ambichook 3y agohonestly, i think that the whole situation was ridiculous to begin with. i'm as much for regulation as the next gal (probably even more so than most people on HN judging by the comments i've read in the last few weeks since i started visiting on the regular) but in this case the government was just trying to offload it's own responsibility to the tech giants instead of actually supporting local news services
- wkat4242 3y agoIt seems to be a common problem everywhere though. News services all over the world are increasingly paywalling their content. There's discussions about AI scraping it for free. The approach Australia took was somewhat unique though other countries proposed it too. But the problem does exist everywhere. I don't think paywalls are the solution either though. I'm not going to sign up for a subscription if I find an article linked on HN and can't read it. That's just nuts. Who invests in a whole news platform because of one or a handful of articles?
- Barrin92 3y agoI think paywalls are completely fine. It's the most normal business model there is. I want to read a newspaper, I buy a copy. That's literally how it has worked hundreds of years. Most sites let you peek or give you X articles for free, that's basically the equivalent of opening a paper and taking a look before buying it. Sure if someone links to something that's behind a paywall and I don't have access I can't participate, but that's just normal. If I'm not willing to buy a book or a movie or a netflix subscription I can't participate in a discussion about it. Probably means it wasn't valuable enough for me. Money is a good and transparent indicator of what's worth your time. Technically I think news sites would stand to benefit from making micro-transactions much easier, so that I can just shoot them 50 cents with a single click but that's about the only issue with it.
- stkdump 3y agoIsn't there a fundamental difference between buying a copy of a newspaper/magazine vs buying a subscription? I would love to be able to pay a few bucks once and be able to read a number of articles for that. But that's not how it works.
- im3w1l 3y agoReminds me of the politician's syllogism: [news is dying so] We must do something. This is something. Therefore we must do it.
- aussieguy1234 3y agoThe mainstream media are angry that modern AdTech (Google, Facebook) has taken most of the advertising revenue that used to be their main source of income. They often consider Facebook and Google to be their main competitors, even more so than other media companies. But seriously, why don't they just drop their opengraph tags, if they don't want to show their headlines/subheadings for free? It's not like they are being forced to add these to their pages, so they should not be charging for it.
- satvikpendem 3y ago> But seriously, why don't they just drop their opengraph tags, if they don't want to show their headlines/subheadings for free? It's not like they are being forced to add these to their pages, so they should not be charging for it. They know why, because most of their traffic comes from these platforms. They want to have their cake and eat it too.
- rhelz 3y agoWe can certainly debate whether or not its a good idea for facebook to actually pay for the content they use to attract readers (and therefore advertisers). However, the problem those laws are trying to solve are real problems, which have very real negative consequences for our society. viz, The internet has nuked all previous media business models. It is no longer profitable to print news. The only way media companies can make a profit today is to engage in either right wing (Fox, Newsmax) or left-wing (MSNBC, Rachal Maddow) commentary. Its hard to get this point across, because most people alive today don't even remember what news used to be like. Before a newspaper would publish an article, they would have extensive fact checkers rake the article over the coals, to ensure that no known falsehoods would be printed. But when the internet came, all the money newspapers used to make from classified ads went to craigslist, and all the money they made from advertising went to google and facebook. The result is that news is progressively less fact-checked, edited etc, which makes it less valuable, which makes people even less likely to pay for it... etc etc a vicious cycle which sucks money from good players and gives it to bad players. Now children in florida are dying from Measles because the media tells them that vaccines are toxic. We have the absurdity of people claiming that masks are completely ineffective at stopping an airborne illness spread by coughing. People believing that you can cut taxes and increase spending, without blowing up the deficit. Where do all these nutty ideas come from? They come from media companies who have found out that telling people what they want to hear is more profitable than what they need to hear. So what, exactly, is your proposal to fix that problem? Its gotten far worse since the advent of LLMs--misinformation can be generated on an industrial, indeed, an internet scale. How can you make money giving people bitter-tasting medicine rather than sugar candy?
- xvector 3y ago> Before a newspaper would publish an article, they would have extensive fact checkers rake the article over the coals, to ensure that no known falsehoods would be printed. What? The news media has literally started wars due to not fact checking and prioritizing profits. See the origins of "yellow journalism" and the Spanish-American war. It has always been sensational and politicized.
- wkat4242 3y ago
- PickledHotdog 3y agoThose few days where Facebook blocked news org posts was absolute bliss. The platform is better without them.
- exodust 3y ago> "it’s nearly impossible to get good reporting on this stuff because all the major media sites are biased in that they are recipients of these payoffs." True. Even the ABC public broadcaster gets paid by Meta and Google. Enough cash to create "60 regional jobs".[1] Nevermind regional journalism is something ABC should be funding anyway, without handouts from commercial operators. Then you have outlets like The Conversation. They may or may not receive payment from Meta (they don't disclose, nobody wants to disclose). I'm guessing they do receive something, judging by their often bland articles.[2][3] And they shut down all "conversation", they don't allow commenting on stories any more. Why increase engagement when you're getting free money? [1] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-03-02/facebook-google-news-media-deal-media-pay-meta/103534342 [2] Conversation article: "New research sheds light on the reasons why many people dislike sport" [3] Conversation article: "Why do I need to get up during the night to wee? Is this normal?"
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoAustralian news coverage of this from last week: Meta won't renew commercial deals with Australian news media https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-03-01/meta-won-t-renew-deal-with-australian-news-media/103533874 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-03-01/meta-won-t-renew-deal...
- xs83 3y agoYeah I think this was ridiculous, the news sites get money from being unreadable due to advertising, Meta, Twitter etc drive new people to those pages. Its a dying medium that deserves to die IMO
- sara44444444 3y ago[dead]