4 ms·
Is it more economical to carry all that weight in fuel versus having stopovers? Or is this a tradeoff of time versus climate, where time won?
by amelius 3y ago
Is it more economical to carry all that weight in fuel versus having stopovers?
Or is this a tradeoff of time versus climate, where time won?
- MR4D 3y agoRefueling is very wasteful - that's why so many flights are direct today - because it's much cheaper.
- ghaff 3y agoI'm sure that's true although I don't know how the numbers pencil out. That said, people also much prefer non-stop flights because of time, hassle, and reduced likelihood of something going wrong.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cycomanic 3y agoThat's not quite true AFAIK at least a couple of years ago the super long routes (18+h) were served in business class only because not enough customers wanted to do such a long flight in economy.
- ghaff 3y agoThat's mostly not true as far as I've seen because most trans-pacific flyers are not willing/able to spend thousands of additional $ to fly in business class.
- papertokyo 3y agoAnother factor besides comfort is that they can extend the flight time 1-2 hours by having fewer passengers and bags onboard, which of course means premium seats like SQ23/24. Qantas is planning to launch 18–21 hour routes in 2026 with economy class, using modified A350-1000 with an extra fuel tank in the hold.
- throwaway2037 3y agoAre you talking about "Project Sunrise"? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kangaroo_Route#Project_Sunrise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kangaroo_Route#Project_Sunrise
- lucasban 3y agoThe Singapore Airlines Singapore to New York flight is 19 hours and only has premium economy and business. I have to make this trip fairly often and I prefer to take the direct flight as it’s simpler, faster and I have to pay extra for leg room either way. That said, if I had the means I would take business each time, because 19 hours in even the nicest economy seat can be tough.
- SoftTalker 3y agoIt's also riskier to do fuel stops en route. Most accidents happen on takeoff or landing.
- FireBeyond 3y agoAccidents, and maintenance - much maintenance is predicated on cycle times, i.e. how many take offs and landings (and others are based on operational hours).
- Ekaros 3y agoDepends on distance, cargo is best way to look at the ranges. As they optimize for cost per nautical mile. Not passenger demand or comfort or speed. At certain point refuelling saves in cost.
- bombcar 3y agoThat becomes the main issue, the Concorde as it was had 26,400 gallons <=> 95,680 kgs of fuel, and would need more than double that (likely) to do the flight in one go (bar major improvements to efficiency, and counting that more weight at takeoff needs more weight of fuel to fly that extra weight). A quick search says about 40 minutes to refuel a jet, so a stopover is going to add at least an hour, probably more because they have to come out of supersonic, etc.
- amelius 3y agoAnd how are these numbers in subsonic flights? A flight from London to Singapore. How much fuel would it need without stops, versus how much fuel in the least-fuel case (but more-stops case)?
- izacus 3y agoOne thing to take into account is that landing and taking off is very wasteful with fuel - jet engines use significantly more fuel when running in dense air and that doesn't include increased power for climbing. I'm sure there's someone who can plug in numbers into a flight planner here, I'm interested in actual numbers.
- amanda99 3y agoOK, sure, I plugged this into a sim flight planner (http://onlineflightplanner.org/ http://onlineflightplanner.org/). This is on a Dreamliner. Heathrow - Changi: 63933 kgs Heathrow - Tehran: 26957 kgs Tehran - Changi: 39580 kgs So at least based on this it's not too much of a difference, only 4% more with a stop. (Tehran looked to be roughly in the middle on the flight plan between London and Singapore.)
- izacus 3y agoInteresting, I'd expect it to be a larger difference considering how much the carriers avoid stopovers. Maybe the fees and organization of refueling tips the balance?